boston.com Arts and Entertainment your connection to The Boston Globe
BOOK REVIEW

A hopeful view of a vexing world energy situation

Spend much time thinking about the global energy situation today, and it's easy to get profoundly depressed.

Weird changes seem to be rattling the earth's climate, even as 2 billion people in China and India have just begun to start living American-style, fuel-guzzling lives. The unshakeable addiction of the United States to Saudi Arabian oil subsidizes America-hating extremists from Iberia to Islamabad to Indonesia. Electric deregulation has been a costly disappointment in many states, a downright debacle in California. After consumers got a nice break in the 1990s, prices of gasoline and heating fuels seem to have locked into permanently higher levels.

But along comes Vijay V. Vaitheeswaran, energy and environment editor for Britain's The Economist, to assure us in this new book that things are not as bad as they seem, and, if anything, are getting better.

''Can we move beyond today's dirty energy system to one that is cleaner, smarter, and altogether more sustainable? Absolutely," declares Vaitheeswaran. He says the solution lies in three converging trends: energy market deregulation, technological innovations like fuel cells and small-scale local power plants, and a growing worldwide environmental consciousness.

''For the first time in decades, there is reason for hope about the world's energy and environmental future," Vaitheeswaran declares.

What starts off sounding like a well-focused book quickly becomes scattered as it attempts to touch on all three issues. Vaitheeswaran meanders through an account of the California electric fiasco, his interview with pugnacious Exxon Mobil chief executive Lee Raymond, an evening with Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward hosting an energy-policy salon at their Manhattan apartment, a Keystone Kops snafu with a battery-powered car on the freeways of Los Angeles, and visits to a Bombay slum and a Chinese factory town. Attempts are made to tie them into the book's core thesis, but several chapters still feel like extra pages borrowed from the columns of The Economist.

Vaitheeswaran offers a tantalizing peek at a hurricane-ravaged village in Honduras being rebuilt with solar collectors for power generation, plus computers with broadband Internet connections contributed by Microsoft's Bill Gates. It sounds like a perfect example of planet-saving, life-changing power to the people -- not just electricity but a link to the modern e-world. But after less than two pages, the author has skipped on to the Earth Summit II in South Africa, leaving unexplored all the implications that a million solar-paneled, plugged-in villages could have for the Third World.

And the book has no shortage of ''to be sure" qualifiers. ''The transition to clean energy will not happen overnight," for example. Big nuclear power plants ''are being swept aside by the global move toward micropower" -- but many may hang in ''for some time in some parts of the world" because at least they don't add to global carbon dioxide emissions. And then there's the ultimate hedge against any solid prediction: ''Of course, no one knows what the future holds for our planet."

Covering yourself for eternity is tempting, but a bolder, braver voice in several places would have made this book more compelling.

''Power to the People" deserves middling grades for presenting a coherent, cogent theory of why the world is not going to the dogs energy-wise. But as a readable, lively survey of today's world of power by a likeable and smart writer, it stands out.

Peter J. Howe can be reached at howe@globe.com.

SEARCH THE ARCHIVES
 
Today (free)
Yesterday (free)
Past 30 days
Last 12 months
 Advanced search / Historic Archives