boston.com Arts and Entertainment your connection to The Boston Globe
BOOK REVIEW

Lessons from the Civil War and the Dalai Lama

The Go Point: When It’s Time to Decide — Knowing What to Do and When to Do It
by Michael Useem
Crown Business, 288 pages, $25.

Five "go points" preceded a major turning point in the Civil War remembered as Pickett's Charge, maintains Michael Useem, a management professor at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School.

In his new book, "The Go Point," Useem defines a go point as "that decisive moment when the essential information has been gathered, the pros and cons are weighed, and the time has come to get off the fence."

He uses General Robert E. Lee's decision at Gettysburg to send General George Pickett and 13,000 to 15,000 troops in a doomed assault on Union troops to illustrate factors that figure into sound decision-making.

Useem took 33 mid-career managers from Bristol-Myers Squibb, Deutsche Bank, NASA, and other American and international organizations to the scene of the Battle of Gettysburg, something he had done previously with MBA students.

The purpose of the visit to Gettysburg was not just to rehash history. Useem makes it clear that the visitors were not Civil War buffs.

"As they gazed across the now sacred ground of the battlefield, our mid-career managers and MBA students were reminded of the importance of seeing ahead, of thinking strategically, of appreciating the full picture before reaching big decisions," Useem writes.

The five go points that led to the Pickett's Charge decision, Useem says, were:

  • The decision by the Confederate leadership, at Lee's prodding, to take the war to the North and try to force a political accommodation with the Union.

  • President Lincoln's decision to make General George Meade the commander of the Army of the Potomac, replacing General Joseph Hooker.

  • Confederate General Richard Ewell's failure to attack Cemetery Hill and Culp's Hill when they were still vulnerable, depriving Lee's army of a chance to outflank the Union forces. Ewell did not act because Lee's order left him too much discretion and because he was not prepared for that level of decision-making.

  • Union brigade commander Strong Vincent's decision to take his 1,500-man brigade to Little Round Top and defend that vital high point, although he had not been ordered to do so.

  • Meade's decision to confer with his nine top generals on whether to maintain their positions and defend or to attack, and if to attack, when -- contrasted with Lee's decision to attack the Union center, made without seeking the advice of General James Longstreet and others who opposed the attack.

    From his analysis, Useem fashions a template for seeing ahead. It stresses taking the strategic initiative, making sure key decision-makers look forward, appreciating the capabilities of others for making decisions, building a capacity in others for making discretionary decisions, and consulting with others when making major decisions.

    "The Go Point" contains scores of other stories and anecdotes of people who have made crucial, sometimes agonizing, choices. Among these is one very prominent spiritual leader.

    Useem tells the story of how the Dalai Lama reached his go-from-Tibet point after he consulted an oracle, and the man told him: "Leave; leave tonight."

  • SEARCH THE ARCHIVES
     
    Today (free)
    Yesterday (free)
    Past 30 days
    Last 12 months
     Advanced search / Historic Archives