Arts and Entertainment your connection to The Boston Globe

'Modigliani' is a portrait of the artist as a cliched madman

Movies about famous artists have their broad-brush-stroke cliches -- the railing against bourgeois convention, the paint-splattered studios, the binge drinking, the womanizing, the madness, the genius -- but I've never seen a movie that embraces all of the above with such ludicrous middlebrow abandon as ''Modigliani." Mick Davis's film about the early-20th-century painter is an epic folly: a biopic that chooses stereotype over fact every chance it gets.

Amadeo Modigliani (played by Andy Garcia) was one of the more eccentric figures in the post-World War I Paris art scene, both in painting style and personal behavior. An Italian-born Jew, he worked in various media (including sculpture) before settling on the approach he remains known for: elongated oil portraits of women with serenely empty almond eyes. He was also a hard-core drinker, a drug addict, and a man who routinely had violent public scenes with his mistresses, including Jeanne Hebuterne (Elsa Zylberstein), the young art student who bore him a daughter.

There's enough melodrama there for several movies, but Davis stuffs it all into a sack labeled ''Modigliani vs. Picasso." By all accounts the two painters had a complicated relationship, but ''Modigliani" amps it up to the level of a professional wrestling smackdown, with the smug, corpulent Picasso (Omid Djalili) taunting the less successful artist into fits of cafe-society fury.

Djalili, a British-Iranian stand-up comedian who bears a resemblance to Alfred Molina, is simply miscast, but at least he has company. At 36, Zylberstein in no way suggests the 20-year-old Hebuterne, and as art dealer Leopold Zborowski, Louis Hilyer is lost beneath his fake beard. ''Modigliani" gives in to the shallow temptation to play spot-the-historical-figure: Look, there's Diego Rivera (Dan Astilean)! Jean Cocteau (Peter Capaldi)! Gertrude Stein (Miriam Margolyes)! As for Garcia, he manfully wraps his wracked purr around dialogue like ''Call me Modi. . . . Now I will paint you, and if I'm lucky, someday I will paint your eyes." It's a losing battle.

Art historians and members of the gaffe squad will find one howler after another: Edith Piaf sang ''La Vie en Rose" in 1946, not 1919; Modigliani died of tubercular meningitis, not from injuries sustained in a beating; how can Jeanne be nine months pregnant and have a 6-month-old child? The bigger crime, though, is Davis's kowtowing to the passe romantic myth of the divine madman-artist. Yes, Amadeo Modigliani was a walking disaster who created beautiful paintings, but there has to be more connecting the two than the boulevard sentiments here.

Ty Burr can be reached at

Today (free)
Yesterday (free)
Past 30 days
Last 12 months
 Advanced search / Historic Archives