< Back to Front Page Text size +

Is "Brothers & Sisters" Being Sloppy?

Posted by Matthew Gilbert May 14, 2008 05:44 AM

daveemily.jpg


I just can't get used to the idea of Justin and Rebecca as lovers on "Brothers & Sisters." I wrote about how the gay ceremony went off on Sunday night without much ado, but I didn't want to spoil the big surprise kiss at the end, between the two characters who, until recently, believed they were half-siblings. Now, after seeing that kiss, I wonder if you feel as negatively about it as I do.

This show is about family, obviously, but about the feeling of family as much as the genetic realities. You know, family of choice and all that. In the finale, when Nora finds out that Rebecca isn't technically related to the Walkers, she says what has been the "Brothers & Sisters" point of view all along: "There's more to family than DNA." So it seems especially unfortunate that the writers would then conveniently ignore that notion and throw Justin and Rebecca into each other's arms. For a show that has been pretty careful and deliberate about how it portrays love, the plot twist is kind of sloppy.

1 comments so far...
  1. Given that this show is just a glorified soap opera with above average actors, I don't see this kiss as out of character for the show. Plus it's exactly what the Desperate Housewives watchers wanted! Do you think it is co-incidence that these two shows were timetabled next to each other? Tune in next season as Calista Flockhart's character becomes pregnant by Danny Glover's character...!

    Posted by BBCa May 14, 08 03:20 PM
add your comment
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About viewer discretion What we're watching on TV

Contributors

Matthew Gilbert is the Globe's TV critic.
Joanna Weiss is the Globe's pop culture reporter and critic.
Johnny Diaz is the Globe's local TV news writer.
archives

browse this blog

by category