THIS STORY HAS BEEN FORMATTED FOR EASY PRINTING
NORTHERN IRELAND PEACE PROCESS: A FIGHT GOES ON

Argument against BC subpoena doesn’t hold up

September 1, 2011

E-mail this article

Invalid E-mail address
Invalid E-mail address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

Text size +

RE “FISHING in BC’s archives’’ (Op-ed, Aug. 23): Ed Moloney and Anthony McIntyre have every right to protest on ethical grounds against efforts by the British to subpoena Boston College to hand over part of its archives. These archives - a project that both men administered on behalf of the college - contain potentially incriminating taped evidence by Irish Republican Army volunteers about unresolved killings during the Irish conflict.

But for Moloney and McIntyre to claim that the release of the material “could be immensely destructive to the peace process in Northern Ireland’’ and that the subpoena appears aimed at damaging Gerry Adams and Sinn Fein’s “remarkable electoral comeback in the general election in the Republic of Ireland’’ is rank hypocrisy.

This claim is undermined by Moloney’s having published a book based on the testimony of one of the project participants, the late IRA volunteer Brendan Hughes, the thrust of which was to damage Adams, according to many respected historians, reviewers, and commentators.

In fact, Moloney is contradicting himself, because his mantra was to berate other Irish journalists for putting the peace process before their duty. He accused journalists of not challenging Adams and Sinn Fein over their shortcomings and alleged links with the IRA regardless of what effect their reporting would have on the fledgling power-sharing institutions.

Nor is it believable for either Moloney or McIntyre or some at Boston College to claim that their lives would be in danger from the IRA were these archives to be released. Moloney never balked at that prospect when he published his book, and McIntyre has often goaded Adams and the republican leadership for having sold out.

Danny Morrison
Belfast
The writer is a former member of the IRA .