THIS STORY HAS BEEN FORMATTED FOR EASY PRINTING

VoxOp

October 30, 2009

E-mail this article

Invalid E-mail address
Invalid E-mail address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

  • E-mail|
  • Print|
  • Reprints|
  • |
Text size +

THE PUBLIC OPTION LIVES
“The public plan is being considered once again (as it has been rejected in the past), but as the government-run entity still draws serious opposition, with its installment, an ability for states to ‘opt out’ of the plan is proposed. If the plan is followed through, likely many red states will opt out, which means that the citizens of these states will not have access to this option, and must rely on private insurers. . . . Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi has called the public option the ‘consumer option,’ to make it sound more appealing than it does now, but the opt-out feature will limit consumer choice to some degree.’’

“The Democrats are more like medicine men than health care experts. That the plan wouldn’t take full effect for some years appeals to them. Once people start complaining about rationing and high taxes, many of the Democrats, like medicine men who scoot to the next village before their ‘cures’ are exposed as frauds, will have left office and become health care lobbyists.

“ ‘Bipartisanship’ for President Obama consists of talking with Republicans who already agree with him. But even that bogus definition won’t hold up now that Olympia Snowe has distanced herself from Harry Reid’s plan.’’

GEORGE NEUMAYR
spectator.org

“In all of the excitement about Harry Reid’s inclusion of an opt-out public option in the Senate version of the health care reform bill, one question has been somewhat submerged: ‘Opt out of what exactly?’

“What the public option actually would provide to states that didn’t opt out has been left pretty much to the imagination of each person.’’

JOHN ARAVOSIS
huffingtonpost.com

“Joe Lieberman announced that he would support a filibuster against the health care bill that Harry Reid announced yesterday with the public option with the phony ‘opt-out’ provision. Thus, the 60-vote bluster bursts like a soap bubble. Only the most unprecedented brass would try to pass this on reconciliation, and I think that would require a fine razor, not just to scrape support together but to threaten a few necks.’’

LARRY PERRAULT
texasgopvote.com

AN ATTACK AT MASS. GENERAL
“The police did not release details about the stabbing, nor what the person was being treated for. The police also did not say if the attacker had had a previous history of violence or criminal behavior, which is the most likely predictor of future violence. Bipolar disorder itself is not a predictor of increased criminality or criminal behavior.

“The news story noted two previous unrelated violent criminal incidents within the hospital in the past six years. For a large teaching hospital that helps to treat the city’s indigent population for health care problems, it could be a lot worse.’’

DR. JOHN GROHOL
psychcentral.com

“While this certainly qualifies as a ‘psychiatrist’s worst nightmare,’ it’s not the greatest thing in the world for the nanny-state antigun forces, either. Here we have a private citizen - and what difference does it make what they do for work if they’re not actually on the job at the time - using their lawfully owned and carried firearm in the defense of another. We have an actual, honest-to-goodness defensive gun use where the gun wasn’t taken away from the gun owner, where the wrong people didn’t get shot, where the private citizen stopped a deadly threat with the force necessary.’’

More opinions

Find the latest columns from: