< Back to front page Text size +
all entries with the category

Debt

Creditor protection for your 401(k)

Posted by Andrew Chan October 29, 2009 10:40 AM

Are funds in my 401(k) plan protected from creditors if I file personal bankruptcy?

Under the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (a.k.a. the Bankruptcy Reform Act) tax-exempt retirement plan accounts (including qualified plans, traditional IRAs, Roth IRAs, 403(b) plans, 457(b) plans, SEPs, and SIMPLE plans), are protected from an employee's creditors in the event of bankruptcy. With the exception of the Traditional IRA and Roth IRA assets, all of these tax-exempt retirement assets are protected without a dollar limit.

Traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs are protected up to $1 million dollars under the federal law. However, some states may provide additional protection beyond the federal limits. Additionally, the language in the federal law seems to suggest that any funds rolled over from an employer retirement plan are fully protected even if the amount exceeds the $1 million dollar limit.

Keep in mind that there are exceptions to the protection provided under the Bankruptcy Reform Act. Certain liens and debts are not discharged or fully discharged under this law. These include:

• Tax liens,
• Debts for luxury goods/services,
• Cash advances,
• Judgments against you for death or injury caused while intoxicated,
• Domestic support obligations,
• Educational loans,
• Debts incurred to pay taxes, fines and penalties,
• Debts from divorce or separation,
• Homeowner association, condominium, and cooperative fees,
• Fees on prisoners,
• Pension or profit sharing debts, and
• Debts or liens incurred from interference with lawful provision of services.

What the Credit Card Bill of Rights means for consumers

Posted by Andrew Chan May 21, 2009 10:00 AM

Yesterday, Congress passed the Credit Cardholders' Bill of Rights Act of 2009 and sent it to President Obama for his signature. This bill amends the Truth in Lending Act and provides consumers with many reforms to the way credit cards are issued and administered today. According to the bill that was passed, here is a summary from the Library of Congress of what it means to consumers:

FULL ENTRY

Advantages and Disadvantages of being an authorized user

Posted by Andrew Chan April 29, 2009 02:30 PM

My Mom authorized me to be a user of her Master Card when I was in college. I only used it when I traveled one summer. I haven't used the card in 3 years but notice that my mother's credit card shows on my credit report. Am I liable for any balance merely as an authorized user? I didn't even have a job at the time I used it. I was a full-time student. I have asked the credit reporting agency if it can be removed from my credit report as it is my mom's account.

As an authorized user on your mom’s credit card account, you are not legally responsible for payment of the debts incurred on that account. Keep in mind that an “authorized user” is different from a joint account holder. An authorized user’s financial status (i.e., your income, financial assets/liabilities and credit history) is not considered by the creditor for purposes of that account. On the other hand, a joint owner’s financial status is considered by the creditor for the joint account. Joint account owners are responsible for repayment of any debts on a joint account.

FULL ENTRY

What happens to loans when the co-signer dies?

Posted by Cheryl Costa April 7, 2009 09:14 AM

My father died almost a year ago now. He was the cosigner for my student loans and I was told that the loans he co-signed for me were forgiven. However, my account still shows $8000 in loans. Would the loans issued before his death be forgiven? And how do I go about getting loans in the future?

Your dad was only a co-signer on the loans. It appears from your description that you were the primary borrower so you are still responsible for re-paying the loan. (As a co-signer, your dad would only have been responsible for your debt if you were unable or unwilling to pay.) I would check with your loan issuer to be sure but I would assume that you are responsible for the debt.

If you are talking about a PLUS loan that your dad might have taken out for you, it is possible that the loan might be cancelled or discharged because he would have been the primary borrower on that type of loan. Again, you would need to review the promissory note that was signed and contact the loan provider.

For any future loans that you might apply for, you would have to apply using only your income information and hope you get approved. If you are denied a loan based on your own earnings, you may have to find another person willing to co-sign for you. These days, that might be very difficult to do. I always counsel clients to never co-sign for a loan unless they are fully prepared (and able) to pay back the loan in question. Being a co-signer can have all kinds of negative consequences. Many co-signers are not aware that their credit and credit score can be negatively impacted even if the original borrower is dutifully making all required payments. That is because the loan will still show up on the co-signers credit report. If the co-signer is hoping to be approved for a large loan for a mortgage or a car, lenders may deny the loan because the potential outstanding debt level is too high.

Maintaining your credit score becomes even more important during the continuing credit crunch

Posted by Andrew Chan April 3, 2009 02:00 PM

It’s always a good idea to be vigilant about your credit score, but even if borrowing loosens up a bit in 2009, you still need to do everything necessary to keep your credit score high. Fair Isaac, the company that created the FICO score, has been working on a new version of its landmark credit scoring method that might have serious consequences for you if you’re planning on borrowing for a home or establishing any other new credit in 2009. The new version of FICO is going to be particularly focused on your balances, not only on your on-time payment records.

Your top priority under this new system: Get balances down.

Reports say that the new FICO revision will actually allow a bit of lenience on late payments – something that might affect more than a few consumers with the downturn in the economy. Obviously, this won’t mean that someone can chronically pay late, but once or twice won’t make the same impact as in earlier FICO versions.

Yet credit utilization – essentially the amount of credit you’re actually using relative to your credit limit – is a much bigger deal simply because high balances are so prevalent right now. From the lender’s perspective, high balances mixed with a tough economy means a higher risk of default among customers.

So what’s a good target utilization rate for all your revolving credit accounts? No more than 50 percent of your credit limit, and if you can get it significantly lower than that over time, that’s a good plan. So, the lower your credit utilization, the better your score.

FULL ENTRY

How to correct your credit report

Posted by Andrew Chan January 23, 2009 09:30 AM

Just how do you go about correcting your credit information? About two years ago we applied for a car loan and found out that our son's financial info was included in my husband’s credit report. Our son pays his bills so that is not a problem but he does have loans and credit cards that are NOT ours.

We contacted all three credit reporting companies with NO results. We sent detailed corrections with proof of identification with no results. A person from one of the companies when we were discussing the fact that my son and husband have the same first name (but certainly not the same address, social security etc.) said "close enough".

How exactly do you get the wrong information corrected once they have it in their computers? I might also say that this experience has led us to have very little confidence in the privacy and accuracy of these reports.

Unfortunately, correcting your credit report can be a long and frustrating process. While the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) regulates how credit information is collected, maintained and used it does not ensure that the process is as straightforward as it should be.

FULL ENTRY

Responsibility for your debts when you die

Posted by Andrew Chan January 19, 2009 10:30 AM

Is my executor or trustee responsible for my credit line loan at the bank after I die? There are no funds in my estate and no insurance on the loan.

In general, executors and trustees are not personally responsible for the debts and liabilities of the decedent. However, there are a couple of exceptions to this that I will explain in greater detail later in this posting. In terms of the debts and liabilities of an estate, the role of the executor or trustee is to make sure that legitimate debts and claims are paid from the decedent's assets. If the estate does not have enough assets to pay all of the outstanding debts, it is likely that some creditors may not get paid. State laws determine which debts will get paid and in what order. Debts such as funeral expenses, legal fees, and court fees are considered high priority debts and are usually paid off first. Outstanding credit card balances and other similar debts are usually considered a lower priority and are paid after the higher priority debts are paid in full. Debts and loans that are secured by property such as mortgages and car loans are usually the responsibility of those who inherit the property. If the property is sold rather than inherited, the debt associated with that property is usually paid with the proceeds from the sale of the property.

Earlier I mentioned that an executor or trustee is not usually responsible for the debts of the decedent. However, there are exceptions to this. An executor or trustee may be personally responsible for the debts and liabilities of a decedent if he/she is the decedent's surviving spouse or if he/she causes the estate to lose money due to his/her mismanagement or dishonesty.

Depending on the property ownership laws in your state and the type of the debt outstanding, the surviving spouse may be liable for the debts of his/her deceased spouse. For example, debts that were incurred together such as jointly held credit cards may become the sole responsibility of the surviving spouse once one of them dies.

An executor or trustee has an obligation to act in the best interest of the decedent's estate. Therefore, if the executor or trustee causes the estate to lose money due to their dishonesty or mismanagement, the executor or trustee may be held financially responsible for those losses.

Due to the unique nature of each person's financial situation and the differences in state laws, it would be a good idea to consult with an attorney if you have any questions about how your outstanding debts will be paid upon your death.

Knowing your FICO credit score

Posted by Andrew Chan January 8, 2009 10:00 AM

Many experts believe that borrowing will continue to be tight in 2009 unless the government does something to loosen the credit markets at the consumer level. This means that it will be increasingly difficult to get favorable interest rates on consumer loans including mortgages, auto loans, and credit cards unless your credit score is among the highest. According to Fair Isaac, the company that created the FICO credit score, those with a score in the range of 760 - 850 should receive the most favorable interest rates when looking to borrow. During the past year the bottom end of this range has increased by roughly 20 points as credit markets tightened up.

While your FICO score is only one factor used by creditors to make lending decisions, it is used widely by lenders as an indicator of your overall credit history. Understanding your FICO score and it components is critical to improving or maintaining your ability to borrow.

FICO scores range from 300 to 850. In general, the higher your score is the more favorable the interest rates available to you when you apply for a loan or for credit. An example from Fair Isaac illustrates the significant difference in the average interest rates available to those with a FICO score in the 760 - 850 range versus those with score in the 500 - 579 range. The average interest rate as of Nov. 24, 2008 for a $300,000 dollar, 30-year fixed mortgage in Massachusetts is 5.652 percent for those with a score in 760 - 850 range compared to 9.931 percent for those with a score in the 500 - 579 range. This difference in interest rates means higher monthly payments of $885 dollars for those with a FICO score between 500 and 579.

FULL ENTRY

Death of a co-signer

Posted by Andrew Chan January 3, 2009 04:00 PM

My elderly grandfather is a cosigner for my $25,000 student loan and I am worried about how this might affect his modest estate after he dies. I plan on paying off the loan when the time comes and I assume I will not be in default when he dies. But what if I default after he dies? How long after his death are my grandfather and his estate on the hook? I don't want my mom, uncles and aunts to be burdened with the specter of this cosigned loan.

Good question! Unfortunately, there is not a single universal answer to this. Similar to when a borrower dies, it generally depends on the type of loan or loan program, the guarantor or lender, and the specific terms of the loan. As the economy tightens and lending standards increase, borrowers are increasingly turning to other options to improve the chances of successfully securing a loan. One option has been to seek someone to co-sign the loan. Often this means asking a family member, a relative or a close friend to assist. Although a co-signer may not have primary responsibility for the repayment of the loan, their obligations (or their estate’s obligations) may continue after death.

FULL ENTRY

Settling with your credit card company

Posted by Andrew Chan December 15, 2008 10:30 AM

I am planning to borrow some money from a family member for little or no interest. I would like to use it to pay off three of my credit cards totaling $15,000 dollars. What would be the best way to get these companies to lower the total amount owed so I can pay them off for less?

If you are having difficulty meeting your credit card obligations, one option may be to try to negotiate a settlement with the credit card companies directly. Credit card companies may be willing to provide you with various forms of relief including reducing your interest rate, reducing your monthly payments, waiving late payment fees, reducing the total amount that you owe, or extending your payment period.

If you decide to contact them to negotiate some form of relief, you should contact them as soon as you suspect that you will have difficulty making your payments. Let them know if you have experienced any financial hardships (such as a job loss or a medical emergency) that may have contributed to your inability to make timely or full payments. Also, discuss the things that you are trying to do to remedy the situation. These steps may give you a better chance of successfully negotiating a settlement with them.

FULL ENTRY

Early withdrawals from your IRA can be costly

Posted by Andrew Chan November 14, 2008 10:05 AM

I have $15,000 in credit card debt. I have $40,000 in a Rollover IRA. I have a 1 year old and a 3 year old that are both in daycare so my weekly expenses are high. I charge on my credit card monthly about what I pay for my minimum payment. I was thinking that if I took out $20,000 out of my IRA and paid off my credit card that the money I am spending on my minimum payment I could use for my monthly expenses. I know it is bad to take money out of an IRA but what I am paying in interest on credit cards is going to cost more than taking a hit on taxes by taking out the money out of my IRA. What are your thoughts?

In difficult economic times, one of the more common places that people want to turn to in order to make ends meet is their IRA account. While this may look like an attractive option to get cash, making a non-qualified withdrawal from your IRA before age 59½ can be costly. The federal government and some state governments discourage non-qualified, early withdrawals by imposing steep penalties on these transactions.

FULL ENTRY

My credit card interest rate is soaring. Is there anything I can do?

Posted by Cheryl Costa October 15, 2008 10:55 AM

I have $11,000 in credit card debt and I recently missed two payments. Now my interest rate has soared. Why am I having a hard time getting them to lower my interest rate? I usually pay my bills on time.

I wish I had better news for you but you are probably out of luck. According to a recent study by the Center for American Progress, in the first quarter of 2008, banks charged off 4.7 percent of their credit card loans. This represents a 33 percent increase from the first quarter of 2006.

There is no question that banks are feeling the pinch and they are doing whatever they can to reduce risk and and raise cash. Most often, banks have been systematically lowering cardholder's credit limits and raising fees. And, as you have recently learned, they are increasing interest rates at the very first sign of trouble. One missed payment can send your interest rate to the maximum permitted under the terms of your cardholder agreement. By raising your interest rate, the bank is hoping to scare you into paying down the debt.

You can always try to call the credit card company and plead for a lower rate -- sometimes persistence does pay off. In my opinion, that avenue is always worth a try. If there was a specific reason you missed two payments, try explaining your particular situation. If you have been a lifelong customer with a solid payment history, throw those facts in as well.

At the end of the day, however, you might not have any choice but to accept the higher rate and try to pay off the debt as aggressively as you can. You might have some success moving the balance to another card but even that would be a longshot now that you have missed two payments.

For more information on this topic, check out this interesting post on msnbc.com, it details how a new policy at American Express allows that firm to penalize cardholders based on where they shop and which bank holds their mortgage.

What should I do? Pay down debt or save for retirement?

Posted by Cheryl Costa October 5, 2008 10:00 AM

I have $2,000-$3,000 to either put in a retirement account or use to pay down debt but I am not sure which would be best for me at this time.

I am 65 and work. I intend to retire at 70, but could do so sooner. My debt includes a $68,000 mortgage at 4.78 percent; $9,000 home equity loan at 4.88 percent; credit card loan of $7,500 at 3.99 percent and a second credit card loan of $8,500 at 1.99 percent.

Considering the current state of the financial markets and how close I am to retirement, should I invest the $2,000-$3,000 in an IRA or use it to pay down my debt?

My inclination is to use the extra money to pay down debt or possibly to supplement your emergency fund if your emergency fund is on the low side. None of your debt is at a high rate (which would ordinarily make me want to see the money invested) but you will be retiring soon and it would be nice if you could enter retirement with as little debt as possible.

Right now you have $16,000 in credit card debt. That is quite high. I see that the rates are low, but I have to wonder if these rates carry an "expiration" date. If these rates are fixed, I would leave use your extra money to pay down some of the more expensive debt, like the home equity line. (That being said, you should still be trying to pay down your credit card as aggressively as you can.) You are not living within your means if you carrying that level of credit card debt.

These days, with the market so rocky and the job market looking worse and worse, there is definitely something to be said for having a ready supply of cash. In this blog, I have always been an advocate of having an emergency fund. Generally, I recommend a fund equal to 3 to 6 months of your necessary monthly expenses.

Now, more than ever, this emergency fund is critical. If you are worried about your job and your financial security, build this fund up to 6 months of expenses as quickly as you can. Money in the bank can do a lot to ease a worried mind.


Banks paying you to pay off credit card debt?

Posted by Cheryl Costa September 22, 2008 08:49 AM

These days, if you miss even one payment on your credit card, you could be receiving a call from your bank instead of a letter. That is because more and more people are now defaulting on their credit card debt. A recent article in the Wall Street Journal stated that 4.5 percent of bank credit card accounts are now delinquent.

Banks are so anxious to see balances paid down that some are offering payment incentives. Citibank has been contacting some of its credit card holders and offering to match a percentage of the payments made over the minimum amount due if the cardholder agrees to pay off a percentage of their balances quickly. There is a cap on the match ($550) and the cardholder usually has to agree to at least temporarily stop using their card.

Another bank has realized that cardholders are using caller ID and answering machines to avoid collection calls so they are mailing phone and gift cards to late payers to get them to call back. The trick is that the gift cards are not activated until the account holder contacts the lender.

The point is that if you are struggling with credit card debt, you should contact the bank as soon as you can. Companies are definitely trying harder to work deals that will work for you. Some will offer temporarily lower payments until you catch up on your debt. At the end of the day, the credit card companies want the debt paid off just as quickly as you do.

How can I help my parents prepare for retirement?

Posted by Cheryl Costa September 11, 2008 10:19 AM

I am very concerned about my in-laws' financial situation. They are in their mid- and late-60s, still working, and to my knowledge, have no retirement money saved. The only thing that I see as an asset is their house, which is probably worth over $1 million, though I'm certain they have a number of loans against it.

What financial issues should we anticipate as they get older? In cases like this, will the responsibility of paying for their medical treatment (should it be necessary) or debts fall on us?

This is certainly a very tough situation. It seems to me that your in-laws will almost certainly have to continue working well into their 70s and possibly longer. You (and they) have to hope that their health is good enough to permit that.

I would suggest approaching your parents with your concerns. It is possible that they have some retirement savings that you are not aware of. Tell them that you are concerned about their future financial security and ask them if they think they might need some professional assistance. There are many financial planners who do financial "check-ups" and maybe you could arrange one for your in-laws. Cost for these kinds of meetings would be approximately $500. You won't get a full plan with this type of consulation but the planner can make the "tough calls" about what kind of retirement your in-laws will face if they can't change their habits.

If your in-laws started aggressively saving right away, they could still build a retirement nest egg. They should also probably delay taking Social Security until age 70 so they can receive the largest possible benefit. It might also be necessary for them to sell their home, pay off their loans and move to a less expensive property when they retire. They may even have to relocate to a less expensive area of the country.

You would generally not be legally responsible for any of your parents expenses or debts but you might feel an emotional obligation to help them out if their situation becomes particulary dire. If you think this will be the case, you should adjust your financial plans accordingly.

This is one of the big reasons that financial planners always tell clients to save for their own retirement first. It doesn't do anyone any good if parents direct all of their excess savings to their children's college tuition at the expense of their own retirement.

ABOUT MANAGING YOUR MONEY
Local finance professionals share insights and advice on issues such as budgeting, managing debt, and retirement planning.

About the contributors

Jill Boynton is co-founder of Cornerstone Financial Planning in Newington, N.H. Along with traditional financial planning services, Boynton provides analysis specifically for divorce.
Andrew Chan is the founder of Integrative Financial Advisors in Framingham. He provides comprehensive financial planning advice and investment management services. He has been an adviser for over 12 years and works with clients to integrate all aspects of their finances including investments, retirement, education funding, and tax planning.
Cheryl Costa is a managing director at AFW Wealth Advisors, which has offices in Natick and Purchase, N.Y. She advises clients on investing, education funding, and estate planning. She holds a master’s in business administration from Boston University.
Jamie Downey has been an accountant for more than 14 years. He's a partner at Downey & Co. in Braintree. Prior to joining the firm, he served as a manager in the audit department of accounting firm KPMG.

E-mail your question

Name:
E-mail:
Your question/comment:
archives