On a Pats thread me which I mainly read/post on, me and another poster got into a debate on A Bobby Orr thread.
I know you all are hardcore Bruin fans but try looking objectively. I was told I was beyond comprehension and ridiculous to put Super Mario ahead of The great Bobby Orr on my all time list.
I also went as far as to say possibly when it's all said and done maybe 10 years from Sid could possibly have as decorated a career as that. Not that he will, but it's entirely possible.
Even if you all put your list up and have #4 ahead of #66 please let me know if it's reasonable to say that they be spoken in the same discussion, which I think is absolutely fair.
I did some research and on the HHOF Boards with over a 100 posters I would say my assessement of putting Mario either 1,2, or 3 is definitely not out of line and certainly right around where most had him.
Anywho, sorry for taking up your time but in finishing here is my list.
5. Roy (sorry boys, had to do it based on pure domination)
List your own if you like, critique away, and factor in whatever makes you think makes each player who he is..( ie.. talent, era, longevity, etc....)