In response to mbeaulieu07's comment:
In response to bredbru's comment:
In response to Homecheese's comment:
I think the BCS should look like this:
1. Notre Dame
2. Alabama - lost to Texas A+M (#8)
3. Georgia- lost to South Carolina (#9)
4. Florida- lost to Georgia (#5)
5. Oregon- lost to Stanford (#13)
6. Kansas St. -lost to Baylor (not ranked)
wasnt stanfor 18 going into that game?
thanks for weighing in home.
in a poll (if i had a vote) i would have lsu 1 right now. poll is best team on the field right now.
I don't know how you can make a case for LSU as the #1 team when they lost to the (2) best teams that they've played (Bama/Florida).
mb, a poll of best team in the country is not based on how manuy losses. the sf giants didnt win the most games in teh regualr season, it didnt mean they wer not the best team at the time of teh playoffs. i am all for a playoff. decide it on the field. barring that a better system would be the one the ncaa basketball uses to determine the top 64. the current one perople get votes based on the tradition of their team, politics, and money. siince everyone does not play the same teams nor a playoff, the # of lossees should not determine the best teams for the nc. louisville was undefeated a minute ago, does that mean if they finsihed that way and nd had 1 loss, that louisville should be in the title game and nd shouldnt?
at the moment i "voted" i saw them as the best team. if they were voted #1, i dont think anyone woudl have a legit complaint unless they played the same teams in the same locations all year and did better. or they beat them in a playoff. if every other level of college and high school football can play a playoff, ncaacfb can take the corruption and money out of it and have a playoff.
thanks for the college football discussion / debate.
see you at the nc game.