Re: Idiot Fans with no Clue, Please Shut Up!
posted at 4/23/2010 12:33 PM EDT
In Response to
Re: Idiot Fans with no Clue, Please Shut Up!:
"I mean, when you think about it, it's the exact same thought process..one camp believes player-x is gonna be a great player because all the mock drafts and "experts" say so, while the others think BB's choice is a great draft pick just because BB said so... " Actually thats not true in my case...I am not saying whatever Bill does is right, what I said is that if you are gonna argue atleast get ur facts straight, and dont cry about getting a a player at a position of need for us .....Nobody knows waht these guys are gonna do....but if you gonna argue who you want,,,dont tell me what the draft experts say about him being small, and then call him a smurf...He is above average height for the positon..if they said small they meant in stature...and everyone crying about Kindle needs to ask why noone else drafted him yet...
Posted by patsfan76
well personally i never made a single comment about his size, which seems about average for the position in my estimation but certainly not small or a "smurf"...my only point was that all of us, whether we like the pick or dont like the pick, dont really have opinions of our own when it comes to these players...our opinions come from either so called "experts" and analysts, or BB himself..
and that being said, for the posters that wish BB wouldve drafted someone else like dez bryant, or hughes, or oldrick etc...we have many people in the "in bill we trust" crowd scolding them for "thinking they're a GM" or that they think "they know better than BB" etc etc...so my point was, the "in bill we trust" crowd is doing the exact same thing basically when they defend it as some kinda brilliant move just because BB told them mccourtney can play...
reality is, after a decade the jury is still out on BB as an evaluator of college talent..he has had a few hits, but many more misses, reaches, and puzzling draft pick trades..the best in the biz at working what he has and coaching them up, there is no denying that, but as much as i hate to admit it he is no bill polian on draft days....and even with 3 super bowls, his draft record does not automatically afford him the right that every single pats fan automatically accepts his picks as "genius"...