Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
-
Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:30 PM EST
- N464Mex-N460A
- Posts: 899
- First: 8/6/2009
- Last: 11/10/2011
The game was over until the refs give the dolts an assist -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:31 PM EST
- p-mike
- Posts: 4849
- First: 1/21/2010
- Last: 4/23/2013
How does this team live with itself?
I would be embarassed. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:32 PM EST
- NY-PATS-FAN4
- Posts: 3524
- First: 9/17/2009
- Last: 5/8/2013
Makes me wanna vomit. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:34 PM EST
- Indylove
- Posts: 903
- First: 1/12/2009
- Last: 11/20/2010
You'd be calling for it yourself and so would Brady if it happened to him. BTW - they missed on the sack.
A rule is a rule. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:35 PM EST
- wwPATRIOTSww
- Posts: 15
- First: 11/4/2010
- Last: 2/19/2013
what a complete joke!!!! -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:36 PM EST
- p-mike
- Posts: 4849
- First: 1/21/2010
- Last: 4/23/2013
No doggggg, a rule isn't a rule.
It's a judgement call, just like the "unnecessary roughness."
That was obviously incidental contact and in no way a "blow to the head." -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:37 PM EST
- knightsailor
- Posts: 829
- First: 5/27/2005
- Last: 5/12/2011
In Response to Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:The game was over until the refs give the dolts an assist
Posted by sirpinochle
That was pathetic. Philly will get a first down.
Indy should have onside kicked. How dumb was that. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:40 PM EST
- Indylove
- Posts: 903
- First: 1/12/2009
- Last: 11/20/2010
Sorry pmike - usually you are a reasonable thinker, but not here. And yes, Brady would be calling for the same. No one seeks penalties more.
The defender meant to bring his arm down. That he didn't mean to hit manning's head is of no consequence. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:44 PM EST
- TexasPat3
- Posts: 8153
- First: 12/29/2008
- Last: 8/28/2012
In Response to Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:The game was over until the refs give the dolts an assist
Posted by sirpinochle
Unbelievable! I'm watching this game with my friends, and I predicted some sort of penalty call would give the Colts a first down. WHAT A CROC!!!
Roger Goodell MUST GO!!! -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:48 PM EST
- knightsailor
- Posts: 829
- First: 5/27/2005
- Last: 5/12/2011
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:Sorry pmike - usually you are a reasonable thinker, but not here. And yes, Brady would be calling for the same. No one seeks penalties more. The defender meant to bring his arm down. That he didn't mean to hit manning's head is of no consequence.
Posted by Indylove
Someone should pass gas in Mannings face.
Didn't he flop balls on a girl in college? -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:48 PM EST
- N464Mex-N460A
- Posts: 899
- First: 8/6/2009
- Last: 11/10/2011
nice pick!
-
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:51 PM EST
- p-mike
- Posts: 4849
- First: 1/21/2010
- Last: 4/23/2013
Well . . .
The zebras tried and they tried.
But it just wasn't enough this time.
This time. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 7:53 PM EST
- Indylove
- Posts: 903
- First: 1/12/2009
- Last: 11/20/2010
whatever pmike. Leave it to a po'd pats fan whose team chose not to show up today to blame refs for their absolutely reasonable and understandable calls.
I guess you believe the eagles shouldn't have challenged the collie call, either? -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:03 PM EST
- p-mike
- Posts: 4849
- First: 1/21/2010
- Last: 4/23/2013
Challenge what?
The whistle blew, you can't challenge possession in that instance. If the play was allowed to continue to its conclusion, it would have been reviewable, but the officials didn't allow that either. They whistled it dead. Play over. No review.
What are you going to challenge, the official's interpretation of "unnecessary" roughness?
Come on, man. You know better than that.
Pull your head out. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:06 PM EST
- 4Adam13
- Posts: 925
- First: 9/14/2008
- Last: 5/4/2012
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:whatever pmike. Leave it to a po'd pats fan whose team chose not to show up today to blame refs for their absolutely reasonable and understandable calls. I guess you believe the eagles shouldn't have challenged the collie call, either?
Posted by Indylove
leave it to an Indy H0mo to post over 600 times on a Pats forum. Gay Manning Lover -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:07 PM EST
- EnochRoot
- Posts: 4050
- First: 6/10/2008
- Last: 4/13/2013
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:No doggggg, a rule isn't a rule. It's a judgement call, just like the "unnecessary roughness." That was obviously incidental contact and in no way a "blow to the head."
Posted by p-mikeIt isn't a judgment call, unfortunately. Any touching of the QB's helmet is a "blow to the head". Remember Tully Banta Cain in 2006? Kept the Colts drive alive in the AFCCG.Crappy rule, but the call was correct. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:09 PM EST
- EnochRoot
- Posts: 4050
- First: 6/10/2008
- Last: 4/13/2013
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:whatever pmike. Leave it to a po'd pats fan whose team chose not to show up today to blame refs for their absolutely reasonable and understandable calls. I guess you believe the eagles shouldn't have challenged the collie call, either?
Posted by IndyloveI really can't believe you are on a Pats fan board DURING a game being played by your supposedly precious colts. Some fan you are. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:20 PM EST
- Indylove
- Posts: 903
- First: 1/12/2009
- Last: 11/20/2010
I don't think so Pmike. I am sure I've seen coaches challenge passes that were ruled incomplete, but I am no authority. If I am wrong, I'll retract my comment.
I've been looking for the rules all over the web with no luck. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:29 PM EST
- TexasPat3
- Posts: 8153
- First: 12/29/2008
- Last: 8/28/2012
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head? : It isn't a judgment call, unfortunately. Any touching of the QB's helmet is a "blow to the head". Remember Tully Banta Cain in 2006? Kept the Colts drive alive in the AFCCG. Crappy rule, but the call was correct.
Posted by EnochRoot
If that's true, than why was Gary Brackett not flagged on Vick's final run, before the Eagles punted the ball back to Gomer with just seconds remaining? Brackett came down on Vick's hemut with his forearm.
This is simply further proof that Roger Goodell and his minions are ruining the game. Referees have far too much discretion now. It's easy for them to turn a game with a call. Is that what we want...games decided by a referee's thought process and rule interpretations...rather than let the players decide it on the field? -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:31 PM EST
- p-mike
- Posts: 4849
- First: 1/21/2010
- Last: 4/23/2013
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:I don't think so Pmike. I am sure I've seen coaches challenge passes that were ruled incomplete, but I am no authority. If I am wrong, I'll retract my comment. I've been looking for the rules all over the web with no luck.
Posted by Indylove
It's not the same thing as "catch" or "no catch." The reason you can't challenge that particular play is because there was no conclusion. The Eagles had what was ostensibly a live ball, and the play was still going on. When the officials blow it dead at that point, it can't be reviewed for possession because the ball has not been spotted. It's the same as an inadvertent whistle or "down by contact." Once the whistle blows, the play is over.
If you go back and call it a fumble, where do you spot the ball?
It's a moot point in either way. The bogus personal foul would have negated the fumble in any case.
Either that, or I am entirely wrong. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:34 PM EST
- zbellino
- Posts: 8705
- First: 3/20/2006
- Last: 5/14/2013
No, PM. You are entirely right. You cannot challenge a dead play. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 8:41 PM EST
- EnochRoot
- Posts: 4050
- First: 6/10/2008
- Last: 4/13/2013
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head? : If that's true, than why was Gary Brackett flagged on Vick's final run, before the Eagles punted the ball back to Gomer with just seconds remaining? Brackett came down on Vick's hemut with his forearm. This is simply further proof that Roger Goodell and his minions are ruining the game. Referees have far too much discretion now. It's easy for them to turn a game with a call. Is that what we want...games decided by a referee's thought process and rule interpretations...rather than let the players decide it on the field?
Posted by TexasPat3Tex, you have watched this game a long time to know that is the rule. If they didn't call it on Brackett (I am assuming that is what you meant.) then I wouldn't have much difficulty chalking it up to the refs favoring the colts. It was likely simply missed though. The refs were probably watching Peyton on the sideline to see if anything happened to him. -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 9:37 PM EST
- TexasPat3
- Posts: 8153
- First: 12/29/2008
- Last: 8/28/2012
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head? : Tex, you have watched this game a long time to know that is the rule. If they didn't call it on Brackett (I am assuming that is what you meant.) then I wouldn't have much difficulty chalking it up to the refs favoring the colts. It was likely simply missed though. The refs were probably watching Peyton on the sideline to see if anything happened to him.
Posted by EnochRoot
My mistake...I meant to say why wasn't Brackett flagged? Your Peyton distraction theory could explain it...LOL!!!
-
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 9:42 PM EST
- agcsbill
- Posts: 7458
- First: 11/6/2006
- Last: 5/15/2013
Hey, gang... it is only going to get worse! Unless the players adjust their tackling techniques to lead 100% with the shoulders, with the helmet coming no where close to the player, or when approaching the QB keeping their arms at their sides (I guess batted balls will decrease?) we'll see all sorts of flags and fines. One wonders who is driving this penchant for these flags? I think players know the game they are playing is violent and no one should be complaining! -
Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?
posted at 11/7/2010 9:42 PM EST
- TexasPat3
- Posts: 8153
- First: 12/29/2008
- Last: 8/28/2012
In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head?:In Response to Re: Oh My God Blow To Manning's Head? : I really can't believe you are on a Pats fan board DURING a game being played by your supposedly precious colts. Some fan you are.
Posted by EnochRoot
Enoch and All:
The Eagles today, though playing on their home field, were penalized 14 times, for 125 yards.
Indy bias?? What Indy bias?? LOL!!!!