Re: ranking the coaches
posted at 1/3/2013 12:00 PM EST
In response to mbeaulieu07's comment:
In response to rkarp's comment:
Payton, Coughlin, McCarthey, Reid
Shanahan, Harbaugh, Harbaugh, Tomlin, Smith
Marvin, Lovie, Fox, Carrol, Rex, Fischer
Kubiak, Garrett, Schiano, Schwartz,
Frazier, Munchack, Rivera, Philbin,
Havent seen enough
A Couple of thoughts on your list:
1. I'd have Coughlin in the top tier.
He is not in BB's class. BB deserves to be in the top tier alone
2. I think Shanahan is extremely overrated.
Why? He has won in Denver and is now winning in Wash
3. If I could have my pick of any coach outside of BB, it'd be Jim Harbaugh.
I like John as a coach as much as Jim
4. I think Leslie Frazier has done a really good job with relatively no WR's and an average to below average QB.
Lets see him do it 2 years in a row before he moves up a tier
5. I think Pete Carroll is the NFL Coach of The Year for the job that he's done in Seattle, with a rookie QB. Love their defense.
Coach can be coach of the year and still not be a great coach