Re: What a headache for Colts!
posted at 7/27/2011 11:37 PM EDT
In Response to Re: What a headache for Colts!
[QUOTE]In Response to Re: What a headache for Colts! : glen, so why with all of these stats that you believe makes Brady better do you think Manning has won all these MVP's and 1st and 2nd team all pro designations while Brady hasn't?
Posted by UD6[/QUOTE]
Actually, I had said (in the past), 1 and 1a, I also said who cares which is which, then a bunch of Indy fans, like you, said that Manning blows away Brady. So, I saw some stats (over the past year) that changed my mind that proved that what Brady did was more impressive. However, every Indy fan will look at these and still say that Brady has had a better defense and thats why he has won more. BUT, over the past 10 years, but both had a defense that was better 5 times.
Now you bring up the all pro, Brady has had it 2 times, should had a 3rd one in 2003, but was robbed. What Brady did in 2003 was basically dismissed (should had been MVP and 1st team all pro) and a lesser Manning (shared MVP with McNair, could have accepted just McNair because he was injured all year) got the awards. You can look at the numbers and then compare the offenses.
It all comes down to people like you. You say Manning has done all these things, which come up 2nd to what Brady has done, but you dismiss it. You cannot deny the numbers, you just choose not to admit they exsist.
I can admit Manning is a great QB, a 1st balot HOF'er, but real fans will always see him as 2nd best. I am not saying this because I am a Pats fan, because of one of my past jobs, I had done a lot of traveling, and I have ran into many football fans, about 70+% of them said that I was lucky to have the best QB in the NFL playing on the Pats.
So, tell me, what makes Manning so much better than Brady? You can use your opinion, but also give me some numbers. I gave you some, and you tried to dismiss them....what a shocker. Or, will you dismiss this?
1 more thing, Favre has won the MVP 3 times, is he better than Brady too?