Who is the most overrated player of all time?

  1. You have chosen to ignore posts from p-mike. Show p-mike's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    I'm inclined to say Brett Favre simply because he won't go away, and everyone ignores his true legend -- which is throwing interceptions better and more frequently than any quarterback in the complete history of ever -- in favor of some perceived "gunslinger" mentality that is a fiction concocted entirely inside the not inconsiderable skull of John Madden.






     
  2. You have chosen to ignore posts from apdynasty23. Show apdynasty23's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    I, too, say Favre. I think what built up his hype was his story: country boy, blinded by the lights, addiction, overcoming addiction, father dies and he plays a brilliant game, wife diagnosed with cancer, tough kid, never takes a play off, running around like a kid, instead of wearing suits and ties he wears Wrangler's. I mean really, not even the suits could come up with such an iconic marketing machine.

    I think people love him because they can relate to him.

    On the field, he's COMPLETE hit/miss and some of his most ugly misses have been in the most crucial games. See last year against the Saints and 2007 against the Giants.

    I would say, though, that Peyton is in the top 3 somewhere. He's a great regular season QB and he's broken almost every record there is but to me, the NFL is not a league for stat nerds (as Colin Cowherd always says), it's about legacy, rings, January/February football. When you look at his career in that light, he's failed to meet expectations. He has one ring against a team that had ZERO offense and a complete joke of a QB. In the most critical playoff games, he's thrown crucial picks and what adds to it is he, his owner, GM, and sometimes coach, almost ALWAYS blamed someone else. Put Polian on the competition committee and I'd say that's helped swing some balance in favor of Peyton.
     
  3. This post has been removed.

     
  4. You have chosen to ignore posts from HRK103. Show HRK103's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    Ryan Leaf, scouts and GMs were debating between him and Peyton Manning as who they should draft #1 overall.
     
  5. You have chosen to ignore posts from shenanigan. Show shenanigan's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    I know this is older than 20 years but it has to be Joe Namath.  The guy is a household name to this day but was more like a Trent Dilfer than a Joe Montana. 

    Going for modern players- Reggie Bush has been riding college hype for a while now while essentially being a Kevin Faulk... except Faulk is better.


     
  6. You have chosen to ignore posts from digger0862. Show digger0862's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    You guys are crazy in my opinion. Marino was amazing. So he didn't win a super bowl. It's a team game. Having a defense helps.

    Favre won a super bowl. I don't think you can overrate him just because he was a gunslinger. He had one of his best years at age 40.

    I remember Fouts being awesome in air-Coryell's offense. One player cannot win a super bowl.

    Michael Vick, Jeff George, Roy Williams (Safety), Reggie Bush now these guys were(are) overrated.
     
  7. You have chosen to ignore posts from shenanigan. Show shenanigan's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    In Response to Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?:
    You guys are crazy in my opinion. Marino was amazing. So he didn't win a super bowl. It's a team game. Having a defense helps. Favre won a super bowl. I don't think you can overrate him just because he was a gunslinger. He had one of his best years at age 40. I remember Fouts being awesome in air-Coryell's offense. One player cannot win a super bowl. Michael Vick, Jeff George, Roy Williams (Safety), Reggie Bush now these guys were(are) overrated.
    Posted by digger0862

    I can second Michael Vick.  Even pre dogfighting scandal he was on every commercial without accomplishing jack.  ESPN love to wow us with his incredible feets of running for 100 yards in a game while ignoring the fact that he threw for 75 yards and an interception.  Guy produces 175 yards total and he's a Pro Bowler, meanwhile every mediocre QB in the NFL can throw for 250-300 yards a game. 
     
  8. You have chosen to ignore posts from ewhite1065. Show ewhite1065's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    In my opinion Brett Favre. I have always thought so. Love Dan Marino though. I still think he's the best QB I've ever seen. Definitely wasn't his fault they didn't win Superbowls.
     
  9. You have chosen to ignore posts from ewhite1065. Show ewhite1065's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    In Response to Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?:
    Almost anyone from USC? Dan Fouts? this guy had a gun. He orchestrated the Stragic Air Command with one of the best WR/TE groups of all time. No SB but tons of W's. Marino should never be mentioned on this thread either
    Posted by Sam-Adams


    10-4 on USC and don't forget about Notre Dame. Rick Mirer and Ron Powlus. Unbelievably overrated out of college.
     
  10. You have chosen to ignore posts from ONE-TIME. Show ONE-TIME's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    Hey to each his own , but I cant take anyone serious that says Favre or Marino is/was overrated. And the answers you give are really kind of dumb , sorry , but they are. Marino's overrated because he never won a championship , really? So is Cris Carter overrated , of coarse not he's one of the top 10 WRs of all time. Is Moss-man overrated , obviously not! Is it Randy's fault Anderson choked on pri ck and missed a gimmie 39 yard FG? Or that his entire O-line and D-line collapsed in the biggest game of their careers? The guy averages more yards and TD's per year than Rice , but because he's never won it all , by your logic hes overrated. That thought process makes no sense at all. Ive always said and still believe that to an extent winning is overrated. I mean sit down and think about how many things need to come together for a team to win it all. Injuries , schedule , teammates , coaches , I wouldnt have enough time to list them all. Some of you may say these are excuses , but there real.
     
  11. You have chosen to ignore posts from Mungomunro. Show Mungomunro's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

     Darrelle Revis.

       Even with Ryan's pass rush happy front 7 Revis still needs safety help on most plays.

     He's a weak tackler and a cancer in the locker room.

     I think the Jets will let him walk and not skip a beat.
     
     
  12. You have chosen to ignore posts from 49Patriots. Show 49Patriots's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    Peyton Manning. I'm not saying Peyton isn't a great player, if I started a list of my top ten QBs in the history of the NFL Peyton would be in the top 5. What I mean is that the Colts win, it was Peyton. When the Colts lose, It was everybody else's fault. 
     
  13. You have chosen to ignore posts from timesrtough. Show timesrtough's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    HEY DOES ANYONE REMEMBER A JIM KELLEY?  4 SUPER BOWLS  O WINS BUT GREAT QB  GREAT PERSON  GREAT TEAM PLAYER  OK MOST OVERRATED IS SHANNON SHARP. SORRY BUT DAN MARINO,JIM KELLEY,JOHN ELWAY, AND SOME GUY PATRIOTS GOT WAS THE BEST QB DRAFT EVER AND ALL THREE WERE GREAT QB'S EXCEPT THAT GUY WE GOT AND SHANNON SHARP OVERRATED
     
  14. You have chosen to ignore posts from p-mike. Show p-mike's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    I'm seeing a lot of "this guy can't be over-rated because he did this, that and the other thing" responses, which I think misses the point of the thread. When I think of guys who are over-rated, I don't think of the players, I think of the fans and the media. Who, after all, is doing this "rating" we're talking about? It's easy enough to say that guys like Manning or Favre can't be over-rated because they've been on some very good teams and stumbled upon a little hardware despite themselves, but when everything you see and hear about a player is designed to convince you that he walks on water -- and his play continually shows you that he lives primarily to squander most of his opportunities . . .   well . . .  that's over-rated.

    Put this question on a forum in another city and watch how many people say "Tom Brady."





     
  15. You have chosen to ignore posts from kickwax. Show kickwax's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    I'm going with Jim McMahon.   Yes he was the QB on one of the greatest teams of all time,  but did you want him on your team?  I'd clearly take Marino or Favre over him for QBing my team, hell its almost a toss up as to whether I would prefer Tony Eason to him.

    I gave serious thought to Keyshawn Johnson.
     
  16. You have chosen to ignore posts from 123meg. Show 123meg's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    Favre, Kelly is second
     
  17. You have chosen to ignore posts from carawaydj. Show carawaydj's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    I'm with the camp that says picking Marino, Favre, or Peyton borders on being stoned. Hmmm....   Jim McMahon is a good choice.  He was overrated, but I don't know if it rises to the level "of all time".  Frankly, there have been a ton of overrated payers in the NFL.  Too many to choose from.  They are usually just some average player benefiting from a particular scheme or fellow player that makes them look better than they are.

    So given the quantity of candidates, I'll stick with a Patriot as my choice.  I'm going with Brian Holloway.  I think he went to 3 Pro-Bowls yet was purely average.  He is the epitome of the player who benefited from a fellow player.  In this case, playing next to the great John Hannah had its rewards.
     
  18. This post has been removed.

     
  19. You have chosen to ignore posts from TampaPete. Show TampaPete's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    Franco Harris has to be it.  I never saw him make a good run, yet everyone raved about him.  His whole career was based on the Immaculate Reception.  I can think of dozens of better runners.

    Chris Carter has the numbers, but I never saw him make a play that impressed me.  Watch a couple of Randy Moss games and you will see a catch that only Moss makes.

    If you think Joe Namath was overrated you never saw him play.  He used to routinely make the Pats look like amateurs.  He is the only person to ever make the Jets winners. You might as well say that Mickey Mantle was overrated. 

    People are wrong about Marino.  I can't think of a single QB who got the ball off and avoided sacks the way he could.  He also was the only QB to beat the Bears in 1985.  He put up 38 points against a D that allowed only 10.7 points per game in its other 15 games and is considered to be one of the best defenses of all time.

    Nobody overrated McMahon more than he himself.
     
  20. You have chosen to ignore posts from wozzy. Show wozzy's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    Easy...  Emmitt Smith

    Not that he wasn't a talented player because he was, and an all around nice guy but the simple fact is this... he ran behind arguably the greatest offensive line ever.  He used to run through holes as big as a Volkswagon.

    I used to watch him and think "boy if Barry Sanders ran behind that he would have a 3000 yard season."  That there was even discussion back in the day of who was better is laughable looking back on it now.
     
  21. You have chosen to ignore posts from N464Mex-N460A. Show N464Mex-N460A's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    barack obama
     
  22. You have chosen to ignore posts from Jimmy42Jack0. Show Jimmy42Jack0's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    In Response to Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?:
    Easy...  Emmitt Smith Not that he wasn't a talented player because he was, and an all around nice guy but the simple fact is this... he ran behind arguably the greatest offensive line ever.  He used to run through holes as big as a Volkswagon. I used to watch him and think "boy if Barry Sanders ran behind that he would have a 3000 yard season."  That there was even discussion back in the day of who was better is laughable looking back on it now.
    Posted by wozzy

    IMO, this is the correct answer...and no, not just because im a canes fan who thinks the gaytors arent very talented :-)
     
  23. You have chosen to ignore posts from ewhite1065. Show ewhite1065's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    I'd still defend my choice of Favre. Being over rated doesn't mean you're a bad QB.
    Brett Favre is possibly the most Revered QB in the last 20 years yet if you take a look at his history in Big games he forces the dumbest passes for ints that I have ever seen. I don't have an axe to grind with Favre or the Pack but I can tell you I do business with people from out there that are huge fans and when Favre was still there his last 4 to 5 years the fans were really turning sour on him because of that said tendency. He has been elevated to living legend status and although he's good he just isn't that good.
     
  24. You have chosen to ignore posts from themightypatriotz. Show themightypatriotz's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    Joe Montana
     
  25. You have chosen to ignore posts from HRK103. Show HRK103's posts

    Re: Who is the most overrated player of all time?

    I defend my choice of Ryan Leaf. All the hype prior to the draft that year was who's better Leaf or Manning?  who will be #1 overall.... well how dat work for ya San Diego? 
     
Sections
Shortcuts