Re: 5 tool?
posted at 4/25/2012 9:08 PM EDT
Current - CarGo, Hamilton, Tulowitski, L. McCutcheon, Kemp
Current 4.5 - Pedey (foot speed), Ells (arm), Cano (foot speed)
Past - Mays (thru '66), Mantle (thru '62), Aaron, Bobby Bonds, Dawson, Lynn, Yaz, Clemente, Cobb, DiMaggio, Morgan, Yount (in '82), Griffey, Snider, Hornsby, Henderson, Kaline, Brett, Al Simmons, Wagner, Puckett, Winfield, Cool Papa Bell; I'm sure I left a few out
Greatest & Complete 5 Toolers - Mays, then Clemente; both had incredible arms and defensive prowess, and Clemente played in a near impossible park for dingers