First honest report out of spring training

  1. This post has been removed.

     
  2. You have chosen to ignore posts from tcal2-. Show tcal2-'s posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    Really?

     
  3. You have chosen to ignore posts from southpaw777. Show southpaw777's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    I thought he looked a little round in the waist...What a shame that he cant take being in MLB seriously. I doubt they sign lohse though. Morales and Aceves are being stretched out and maybe RDLR will be available soon...

     
  4. You have chosen to ignore posts from mef429. Show mef429's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to southpaw777's comment:

    I thought he looked a little round in the waist...What a shame that he cant take being in MLB seriously. I doubt they sign lohse though. Morales and Aceves are being stretched out and maybe RDLR will be available soon...




    i don't see them giving up a pick now when they have starter depth they can turn to.

     
  5. You have chosen to ignore posts from mef429. Show mef429's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    i'm eager to see RDLR in action, can't wait for some games to start up and check out how he looks. He could pitch his way into the mix if Farrell disciplines Doobie.

    obviously Ace and Morales are the first options to supplant him.

     
  6. You have chosen to ignore posts from hill55. Show hill55's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    x

     
  7. You have chosen to ignore posts from mef429. Show mef429's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to hill55's comment:

    x




    yeah hill?

    tell us how you really feel.

     
  8. You have chosen to ignore posts from moonslav59. Show moonslav59's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    When I showed skeptisim towards Doubron'ts outlook this year based on what happened in 2011, and how it might expose a weakness of character, I was labelled a "pessimist" and "naysayer".

    I may be wrong, but I think the author of this thread said he was going to Florida to watch all the games, so maye this report was his first hand report.

     
  9. You have chosen to ignore posts from parhunter55. Show parhunter55's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    Sorry folks.  I did not mean to post and run.  I created the OP at work and came home to find a sweaty basement and hot water heater problems.  Not the way I want to spend a Friday night.

    I don't understand why I am a troll for expressing concern over something that the staff is concerned about.

    To selenium, the "first honest report" line is a bit tongue in cheek, but come on.  Everyone who follows baseball knows that every player shows up in the "Best shape of his career," and such.  Rarely is a guy called out for showing up out of shape.  My guess is that if Doubront had not done so in a previous year, he might not have gotten called out this time.  But after Beer and Chicken Gate and the huge disappointments of 2011 and 2012, and with the attempt to make over the team with high quality guys who have good chemistry and work ethics, Doubront's showing up to camp in poor shape made his lack of good judgement stick out all the more.

    As for the injury part of it.  In 2011 Doubront spent time out for injury and his lack of conditioning was blamed post-fact.  In 2013 he is already an injury risk, as reported in the off-season by Finn and Cafardo, I believe (and on Bleacher Report possibly as well).  Any pitcher who increases his innings from one year to the next as much as Doubront did is considered an injury risk by baseball evaluators.

    Lastly, as for attending the Spring Training games...I can only wish.  My info on this came from the Globe writers.

     
  10. You have chosen to ignore posts from moonslav59. Show moonslav59's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    Lastly, as for attending the Spring Training games...I can only wish.  My info on this came from the Globe writers.

    I must have confused you with someone else. Sorry.

     

    (Cue: Pike's attack)

     
  11. You have chosen to ignore posts from georom4. Show georom4's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to moonslav59's comment:

    When I showed skeptisim towards Doubron'ts outlook this year based on what happened in 2011, and how it might expose a weakness of character, I was labelled a "pessimist" and "naysayer".

    I may be wrong, but I think the author of this thread said he was going to Florida to watch all the games, so maye this report was his first hand report.



    this is what i dont understand about this board...you have a guy with a past who has done something similair that shows his lack of conditoning and preperation, and someone writes a post about it and is attacked for making stuff up....

     
  12. You have chosen to ignore posts from Joebreidey. Show Joebreidey's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to georom4's comment:

    In response to moonslav59's comment:

     

    When I showed skeptisim towards Doubron'ts outlook this year based on what happened in 2011, and how it might expose a weakness of character, I was labelled a "pessimist" and "naysayer".

    I may be wrong, but I think the author of this thread said he was going to Florida to watch all the games, so maye this report was his first hand report.

     



    this is what i dont understand about this board...you have a guy with a past who has done something similair that shows his lack of conditoning and preperation, and someone writes a post about it and is attacked for making stuff up....

     



    I was just asking for a picture or 3rd party verification.  I've seen no pictures, and the one article that was posted, did not mention Doubront.  When I'm on jury duty, and the DA says the defendent did it, fine, but show me some evidence.

     
  13. You have chosen to ignore posts from Joebreidey. Show Joebreidey's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to mef429's comment:

    In response to southpaw777's comment:

     

    I thought he looked a little round in the waist...What a shame that he cant take being in MLB seriously. I doubt they sign lohse though. Morales and Aceves are being stretched out and maybe RDLR will be available soon...

     




    i don't see them giving up a pick now when they have starter depth they can turn to.

     



    I haven't seen the pictures, but people are going way overboard.  No doubt that professional athletes should be in good shape.  But for a pitcher, you can still be in good pitching shape and be 10-15 pounds overweight.  I manage to be 15-20 pounds overweight all the time.  Sometimes I am working out seriously and just overeating.  Sometimes I can drop 15 pounds through dieting, but have no conditioning at all.

     
  14. You have chosen to ignore posts from pinstripezac35. Show pinstripezac35's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to parhunter55's comment:

    Sorry folks.  I did not mean to post and run.  I created the OP at work and came home to find a sweaty basement and hot water heater problems.  Not the way I want to spend a Friday night.

    I don't understand why I am a troll for expressing concern over something that the staff is concerned about.

    To selenium, the "first honest report" line is a bit tongue in cheek, but come on.  Everyone who follows baseball knows that every player shows up in the "Best shape of his career," and such.  Rarely is a guy called out for showing up out of shape.  My guess is that if Doubront had not done so in a previous year, he might not have gotten called out this time.  But after Beer and Chicken Gate and the huge disappointments of 2011 and 2012, and with the attempt to make over the team with high quality guys who have good chemistry and work ethics, Doubront's showing up to camp in poor shape made his lack of good judgement stick out all the more.

    As for the injury part of it.  In 2011 Doubront spent time out for injury and his lack of conditioning was blamed post-fact.  In 2013 he is already an injury risk, as reported in the off-season by Finn and Cafardo, I believe (and on Bleacher Report possibly as well).  Any pitcher who increases his innings from one year to the next as much as Doubront did is considered an injury risk by baseball evaluators.

    Lastly, as for attending the Spring Training games...I can only wish.  My info on this came from the Globe writers.

     

     



    I don't understand why I am a troll for expressing concern over something that the staff is concerned about.


    no worries parhunter U were just being piked

    I'm sure many others shared your disappointment

    he wouldn't be the 1st guy with a  mill $ arm and 10 cent brain

    heard he's not expected to throw until Wednesday....

    I have mixed feelings on the subject

     david wells was one of my favs he had a mill $ arm and 2 cent brain



    tony maz said last night people told him

    rubby de was eye popping

     
  15. You have chosen to ignore posts from Ice-Cream. Show Ice-Cream's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

     

    I hope this year's Red Sox team can create a positive and winning environment. 

    Remember the 2004 team?  They had fun, played their a**es off, and won. 

     

     
  16. You have chosen to ignore posts from parhunter55. Show parhunter55's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    Back when I firtst came to this forum, some 7 years ago, you could create a Thread about something you read and discuss the meaning/implications.  Now you end up defending the source, or your intent, or even your right to have an opinion about whatever it is you wanted to discuss.

    Very few posters actually addressed my proposed idea.  And I knew I would be perceived by some as overreacting.  Yes, I know that Morales and Aceves are being stretched out as starters.  And I think the Sox need that kind of depth, with Lackey coming off major surgery and Buchholz not yet ever having been able to pitch a full slate of starts.  And perhaps Morales and Aceves would perform admirably for the #5 and #6 starters on this team.

    But if you want to improve the rotation, you have to get a guy who pushes your #4 or #5 guys down a slot or out of the rotation.  I am not convinced Lohse is as good as his 2012 numbers say he is.  But he is a bona fide starter, the best available on the FA market, and will pitch a full season in all likelihood.  To assume Morales or Aceves could pitch 180-200 innings in 2013 is being too optimistic IMO. 

    If the Sox could turn Salty and Doubront into a young LHH LFer, or a bona fide 1B prospect, or a pirtching prospect a couple of years away from ML ready, wouldn't that be enough to off-set the loss of the 2nd round pick?  Depending on the cost of signing Lohse, I would at least consider signing him and trading Doubront. 

    The fact is, I was calling for trading Doubront long before he showed up to camp in poor shape...but that was when I had hopes the Sox would sign two starters--Haren and one other--making Doubront expendable.  Once again, the idea was to trade him before he got hurt.  Now, trading him would be harder, but it would have the added value of sending a strong message to all the pitchers that keeping in shape and taking your conditioning seriously is required on this team. 

    Let's face it...the Sox pitchers have had a recent record of playing in less than optimal physical condition, and during that same time have sustained an almost unprecedented amount of injuries (whether or not that is related to the lack of conditioning is open to debate).

     
  17. You have chosen to ignore posts from Joebreidey. Show Joebreidey's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to Ice-Cream's comment:

     

    I hope this year's Red Sox team can create a positive and winning environment. 

    Remember the 2004 team?  They had fun, played their a**es off, and won. 

     



    Something that Valentine and some of our fans never understood.  You want to have players that want to be at the ballpark.  You want to have players that want to hang out in the clubhouse after the game.  You don't want to have players being questioned about what the manager said yesterday.  You want to encourage comraderie, not have players seeing how quickly they can get to their cars.

     
  18. You have chosen to ignore posts from Ice-Cream. Show Ice-Cream's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to Joebreidey's comment:

    In response to Ice-Cream's comment:

    I hope this year's Red Sox team can create a positive and winning environment. 

    Remember the 2004 team?  They had fun, played their a**es off, and won. 



    Something that Valentine and some of our fans never understood.  You want to have players that want to be at the ballpark.  You want to have players that want to hang out in the clubhouse after the game.  You don't want to have players being questioned about what the manager said yesterday.  You want to encourage comraderie, not have players seeing how quickly they can get to their cars.



    I agree with you Joebreidey.   :)

    I think Farrell is a manager that the players can trust.  I am not concerned about Farrell's performance when he was managing the Blue Jays. 

     

     
  19. This post has been removed.

     
  20. You have chosen to ignore posts from Joebreidey. Show Joebreidey's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    Back when I firtst came to this forum, some 7 years ago, you could create a Thread about something you read and discuss the meaning/implications.  Now you end up defending the source, or your intent, or even your right to have an opinion about whatever it is you wanted to discuss.

    I just asked to see pictures, or a report from say, Pete Abraham.

    Very few posters actually addressed my proposed idea.  And I knew I would be perceived by some as overreacting.  Yes, I know that Morales and Aceves are being stretched out as starters.  And I think the Sox need that kind of depth, with Lackey coming of major surgery and Buchholz not yet ever having been able to pitch a full slate of starts.  And perhaps Morales and Aceves would perform admirably for the #5 and #6 starters on this team.

    I'm not sure what you want.  Morales and Aceves are probably as good as any two BP guys in BB if you need a #6.

    But if you want to improve the rotation, you have to get a guy who pushes your #4 or #5 guys down a slot or out of the rotation.  I am not convinced Lohse is as good as his 2012 numbers say he is.  But he is a bona fide starter, the best available on the FA market, and will pitch a full season in a likelihood.  To assume Morales or Aceves could pitch 180-200 innings in 2013 is being too optimistic IMO. 

    I agree, in theory, that you get your most leverage from replacing a #5 with a #1, but usually when you have a bad #5, say someone with a > 5.00 ERA.  In this case, I think you'd be replacing someone with maybe a 4.50-4.75 with someone that will have a 4.25-4.50.  I think you really need to improve by a full run to make it worthwhile.

     
  21. You have chosen to ignore posts from parhunter55. Show parhunter55's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    I hope De LaRosa can end up being in the rotation.  I think he has all the tools and desire, whereas Doubront may have all the tools, but apparently lacks the desire (and discipline that accompanies such desire).  But De LaRosa will also not pitch a full slate of starts in 2013. 

    The Sox currently have just two pitchers on the team (Lester and Dempster) who have been able to pitch full seasons in recent years.  They really need a 3rd.  Who do you suggest that to be?  Having passed on other options, I think the Sox should be considering Lohse (even if by all accounts they are denying any such interest).

     
  22. You have chosen to ignore posts from parhunter55. Show parhunter55's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to Joebreidey's comment:

    Back when I firtst came to this forum, some 7 years ago, you could create a Thread about something you read and discuss the meaning/implications.  Now you end up defending the source, or your intent, or even your right to have an opinion about whatever it is you wanted to discuss.

    I just asked to see pictures, or a report from say, Pete Abraham.

    Very few posters actually addressed my proposed idea.  And I knew I would be perceived by some as overreacting.  Yes, I know that Morales and Aceves are being stretched out as starters.  And I think the Sox need that kind of depth, with Lackey coming of major surgery and Buchholz not yet ever having been able to pitch a full slate of starts.  And perhaps Morales and Aceves would perform admirably for the #5 and #6 starters on this team.

    I'm not sure what you want.  Morales and Aceves are probably as good as any two BP guys in BB if you need a #6.

    But if you want to improve the rotation, you have to get a guy who pushes your #4 or #5 guys down a slot or out of the rotation.  I am not convinced Lohse is as good as his 2012 numbers say he is.  But he is a bona fide starter, the best available on the FA market, and will pitch a full season in a likelihood.  To assume Morales or Aceves could pitch 180-200 innings in 2013 is being too optimistic IMO. 

    I agree, in theory, that you get your most leverage from replacing a #5 with a #1, but usually when you have a bad #5, say someone with a > 5.00 ERA.  In this case, I think you'd be replacing someone with maybe a 4.50-4.75 with someone that will have a 4.25-4.50.  I think you really need to improve by a full run to make it worthwhile.




    I respect your opinion.  And I appreciate the response.  My biggest fear right now is that Doubront/Morales/Aceves end up contributing in the 5.00 era range (which is actually quite an improvement over what the Sox got out of their #5 - 7 starters last year).  And my hope would be that Lohse would provide an ERA around 4.00.

     
  23. You have chosen to ignore posts from parhunter55. Show parhunter55's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to Triumph-'s comment:

    In response to parhunter55's comment:

     

    I hope De LaRosa can end up being in the rotation.  I think he has all the tools and desire, whereas Doubront may have all the tools, but apparently lacks the desire (and discipline that accompanies such desire).  But De LaRosa will also not pitch a full slate of starts in 2013. 

    The Sox currently have just two pitchers on the team (Lester and Dempster) who have been able to pitch full seasons in recent years.  They really need a 3rd.  Who do you suggest that to be?  Having passed on other options, I think the Sox should be considering Lohse (even if by all accounts they are denying any such interest).

     




    They are not gonna give up that draft pick.




    My thinking is that if they could trade Doubront as part of a package and get a prospect or two, that 2nd round pick would be less of an issue.  I would not just sing Lohse to replace Doubront.  In fact, I would not sign Lohse unless I already had a deal in place involving Doubront.

     
  24. You have chosen to ignore posts from OutofTownPATS Fan. Show OutofTownPATS Fan's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    In response to SpacemanEephus' comment:

    In response to HelloItsMeAgain1's comment:

     

    In response to SpacemanEephus' comment:

     

    OK, why are we assuming he showed up out of shape?  Because he got hurt?  

     



    Space, you been hitting some of Humboldt county's finest?

     

    read mef's post above.

     



    whether or not i may have hit that humboldt sticky, I read mef's post and found no evidence to the effect of Doubront showing up out of shape.  No quotes from anybody there.  No links to any reports.  and, i cant tell from pictures because, in shape or not, red beans and rice never missed Felix.  I just don't understand why we are jumping to this conclusion.

     


    AROUND THE BASES: How precise is the schedule? The bullpen sessions were set for 10:02 a.m., 10:14 a.m. and 10:26 a.m. … Jon Lester said that he believes in leadership by example. He is showing in his actions hustling from station to station and going full speed though the drills. … Felix Doubront reported in poor shape and the staff isn’t happy about it. He had conditioning problems in 2011, too.

     

    Peter Abraham yesterdays update

     
  25. You have chosen to ignore posts from notin. Show notin's posts

    Re: First honest report out of spring training

    Lohse turns 35 this year and has shown no inidcation he will take a short offer at less than his terms.   If he took a one year or two year deal, things are a little different.  And if the team can get a prospect for Doubront, it goes help replace the draft pick.  However, it does not help with the first round pick, as the team's overall budget for signing picks is drastically reduced by losing the second round money, and that could hamper their ability to sign high-profile clients with lofty demands.

     

    Dealing Doubront is another matter, although what would the Sox realisticaly expect in return?  They really coyuld use a LF, and certanly prospects are always in play.  If they chose to deal him for a LF, what would be a realisitic target worth giving up Doubront for?   There certainly are teams with surplus OF talent that need SPS, and Doubront need not be targetted to a team that hopes to contend, but is there a good match up?  I certainly would not deal him for, say, Carp or Venable, for example...

     
Sections
Shortcuts

Share