Re: SERIOUSLY... Is BERNIE WILLIAMS a HALL of FAMER?
posted at 1/10/2013 5:12 PM EST
In response to pinstripezac's comment:
In response to ZILLAGOD's comment:
Hall Of Fame is for tourists.
Real fans of baseball, football, hockey, basketball or Rock 'n' Roll will tell you who was great and who wasn't.
You don't need these amusement park museums if you hnow who's who. These are for the casual observer...and fro someone to make money by exploiting someone else's talent.
Pete Rose was a terrific player, he may be a jerk as a human being , I can't really judge as I don't know him ( althoug I get the impression he is) , but what we know about Carlton Fisk is that he also is a bad example of a human being. One is in the Hall, one isn't. Based on a personal problem in his personal life. Lawrence Taylor is an indisputed NFL Hall Of Famer, not a very nice person, either.
All a matter of someone else's choice....not mine or yours.
can't let that one slide zill
if the subject is baseball
pete rose broke the golden rule
the one posted in every clubhouse
worse than roids or anything fisk did
when it comes to potentially hurting the game
You and I have disagreed on this before.
I respect your opinion however Pete Rose has been banned from the game for life for betting on games while a manager of a MLB team.
I agree with that punishment.
But on the other hand I feel he belongs in the hof for how he played the game and for the records he holds.
How much blood can you extract from one man?
Pete Rose deserves to be in the hall.