Carp made the team. Softy didn't want to make deal because he make too much, would require to give up too, and would force the Sox to make unneeded roster move. After being wrong on all three Softy has been fairly quiet other than the bashing he does. It is interesting that Softy was so concerned about the 40 man but his favorite player is going to require someone to be move. The inconstancies are at least constant.