This little boy sounds troubled
My 5- year- old son recently came home from school with a note saying he pushed another student in the stomach, when I asked him about it he completely lied to me. I had to get the real story from his teacher. The next day he came home with something that looked like red marks and dot around his neck and shoulders. He said some story about a chair causing it, then he told my family that my fiancé did it.... I know this cannot be true, I see how they interact and how this upsets my fiancé.
What is the deal? How can I deal with this? I'm afraid of him being taken from us!
From: Brooke, Atlanta
Hi Brooke,
My best guess is that he's acting out to get attention. Your attention. Maybe he doesn't feel like he has enough of your attention -- that you're giving too much attention (in his mind) to your finance. Or maybe he doesn't feel secure about your love for him. How stable is his life? Is his birth dad at all in the picture? Is your fiance living with the two of you? Have there been previous men in your life who perhaps have not lasted? Here's what I'm getting at: "If mom stopped loving X, Y and Z, maybe she'll stop loving me." Maybe he's testing you: Will mom still love me if I'm this bad? What about this bad? With this in mind, I have three suggestions:
1. Don't include your fiance in every activity you do with your son. Do some things every weekend (more often, if possible) with just the two of you, you and your son and make a point of saying, "You know what? Let's just you and me today." That will help him feel more secure about you.
2. Every day, spend some alone time with your son. Five minutes, 10, whatever you can manage. Call it, "Mom and me" time and make a point to shut off all your devices, to give him your total attention. When sees that he can have your undivided attention guaranteed, he may feel less need to act out to get it.
3. You are his parent, not your fiance. Your fiance should not be the boss of your son. He should not discipline him. That's your job. Are your son's aggressive behaviors new since your fiance came on the scene, or at least since he became your fiance? Aggression can be a learned behavior. How do you know what goes on when the two of them are alone, and that your son might not be imitating something he's seen your fiance do?
In the meantime, in school, your son is involved in aggressive behavior. Whether he's the instigator or the victim, he needs coping skills, so I'm glad you've been in touch with the teachers. Don't drop the ball on this; stay in contact with them so you can work together to figure out what's going on with him in his interactions with other kids. Hopefully, that will enable all of you to guide him to socially acceptable behaviors. He may need professional intervention.
Now about the lying. The best way to address this is to let him know how much you value truthfulness: "In our family, we really value telling the truth." At this age, he can understanding that lying is unfair, a kind of cheating.
1. Don't accuse him of doing lying; that will only make him more entrenched. When you think he's lying, tell him, "I'm not sure if you are telling the truth. Let's not talk about this any more right now. That will give you a few minutes to think again about what happened." In other words: give him the benefit of the doubt and the chance to regroup.
2. Don't try to trap him into a lie. If you found evidence he lied, for instance, the teacher gives you a different version, present the facts as you know them: "Mrs. X said she saw you hit Brian. Is it possible you aren't remembering this right? I'm not happy when someone hits another person, but I'm even less happy if someone lies about. Do you want to think about this again?"
3. Don't punish him for lying. All that does is fuel him to become a more clever liar. Instead, he needs to see you as understanding and approachable so he can conclude: "Even if I do something really stupid, my mom might understand. I can tell her the truth." If he starts out with a lie and then recants, reward his courage: "I'm proud of you for telling me the truth. That was a brave thing to do." If the transgression is so severe, or this happens repeatedly, I'm not suggesting you simply let him off the hook, but that you acknowledge the truth-telling.
What behaviors do you model to him? If you lie, even a little, ("No officer, I wasn't speeding....."), change your ways; the role model we present as parents is the single biggest factor in why kids lie.
For you to worry that social services might intervene, makes me wonder if there's more going on here than you've conveyed. If that's so, you need to do more than write in to an advice column. There are places to turn to for help. The school system has psychologists who are good listeners and will guide you if they think your son needs an evaluation. I bet your pediatrician or clergy could also steer you in the right direction. You've taken a first step.
The author is solely responsible for the content.


Why is "fiance" spelled "finance" in this article?
spellcheck manually p 3, please! Is it finance or fiance?
The finance typo had me confused for a bit as I was skimming the answer.
Hmm...I'm not sure how I feel about the implication that this woman is a serial dater. Seems a little unfair to throw that at her just because she's engaged. I'm not saying it's not a possibility and worth considering but I wonder if you would ask that if she were married to the stepfather already. I think the rest of the advice is sound but honestly, the word finance appears a little too often considering this isn't a column about money.
Thanks to all of you eagle-eyed copy-editors who caught my bad spelling. I think I have corrected all the incorrectly-typed fiances. My bad!
I am uncomfortable with the fact you completely discounted that is possible that the fiance could be harming the child. Sadly, it happens even when parents think: "I know this cannot be true, I see how they interact and how this upsets my fiancé."
Please do not gloss over what could in fact be a completely legitimate reason for this child's distress.
Personally, I blame it on autocorrect. (It causes more errors than it corrects.) Although proofreading seems a reasonable expectation. Such errors are, as the responses so far demonstrate, distracting.
Actually, CommonSense, I don't dismiss that possibility at all. I address it directly when I write, in the fourth paragraph, "How do you know what goes on when the two of them are alone, and that your son might not be imitating something he's seen your fiance do?"
He may have no earthly idea where that mark came from, and is just making stuff up to have an answer, either it's what he thinks people want to hear, or it will get attention. Or he was doing something foolish and doesn't want to admit it. "Well, Mom, we were all wearing our backpacks around our necks playing Backpack Warriors and I got tangled up with Bobby."
Kids pick up on the fact that if an adult asks where a scrape, bruise, or ding came from they'd better know. Any kid with an unexplained mark and a non-bio-Dad male in the picture sets off the abuse alarm. May be true, may be paranoia, may be someone covering their behind asking so they can say they did their due diligence even though they're not actually worried.
As for pushing, yes it's wrong, but it does not take a bad example adult in the household pushing the kid for a kid to think it's a good idea on some occasion. Kids push and shove sometimes. Yes, even yours.
This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.
About the author
Barbara F. Meltz is a freelance writer, parenting consultant, and author of "Put Yourself in Their Shoes: Understanding How Your Children See the World." She won several awards for her weekly "Child Caring" column in the Globe, including the 2008 American Psychological Association Print Excellence award. Barbara is available as a speaker for parent groups.
Submit a question for Barbara's Mailbag
Ask Barbara a question
Recent blog posts
The 24-Hour Workday
Kara Baskin
Child in Mind
MD Mama
Repeat C-sections
Boston Moms
Recent blog posts
More community voices
The 24-Hour Workday
Kara Baskin
Apptitude Test
Ask the Pilot
Blissfully Inspired
Boston by Beat
Boston Medical Mysteries
Boston Real Estate Now
Scott Van Voorhis
Boston Spirit
David Zimmerman and Jim Lopata
Bruins Daily
Bruins Daily Staff
Child Caring
Barbara Meltz
Child in Mind
Chow Down Beantown
Consumer Alert
Corner Kicks
Julian Cardillo
Crime & Punishment
DIY Boston
Dollar for Dollar
Economy & Equity
The E Word
Peter Post
Expertly Engaged
Global Business Hub
Going Deep
Health Stew
Innovation Economy
In Practice
Dr. Suzanne Koven
The Job Doc Blog
Less Is More
Let's Go Out
Managing Your Money
MD Mama
Media Remix
Mortal Matters
Nutrition and You!
Obnoxious Boston Fan
Obnoxious Boston Fan
Off The Field
On Deck
Craig Forde
On Liberty
Pack Up
Pet Chatter
Stephanie St. Martin
The Restaurant Hub
Roads and Rails
She's Game Sports
Short White Coat
Dr. Ishani Ganguli
State of Play
Stats Driven
David Sabino
Straight Up
TEDx Beacon Street
Maura Welch
Ultra Sound Pregnancy
Weather Wisdom
RSS feed
click here to subscribe to
Child Caring
archives
browse this blog
by category