Moooom, Who do you love best? (You, of course)

Posted by Erica Noonan, Globe West May 11, 2009 07:12 AM

In the afterglow of this Mother's Day, it is fitting to remember my own Nana, Doris Noonan, who raised four kids in Watertown in the 1950s and 60s with little fuss or support.

When they were small, her kids regularly came to her with the age-old question, "Mom, which of us do you love the best?"

Instead of feeding them that "I love you all the same" b.s., Nana took each of her kids aside and whispered, "I love YOU the best."

"But you must never tell your brothers and sisters YOU are my favorite because it would hurt their feelings," she would whisper to them. "Do you promise?"

Each child would dash away to play, smug and joyful, holding their secret with pride.

According to family legend, it was only after Nana died that the four very grown siblings -- sharing whiskey and warm memories after her funeral -- actually figured out the scheme.

They had all grown up believing they were their mother's favorite child. And even today, each of them still believes it to be true.

Nana was a genius, if you ask me.

Any Mother's Day memories of your own to share with us? Leave a comment or email me at enoonan@globe.com

  • CommentComment
  • EmailEmail
2 comments so far...
  1. My grandma did this too! 6 kids!

    Posted by catherine May 11, 09 01:43 PM
  1. I'm touched by the story, but I choose not lie to my children - when asked that question, I always answer that I love them both, I will always love them both and you cannot measure love so the question of who do I love more makes no sense to me.

    To everyone their own.

    Please note that I did not call a different opinion b. s. either, but again - some people are quicker than others in labeling a different opinion as b. s. Still, it is nice to quickly learn how much you respect other people's opinions and answers, Erica.... I have to give you props for honesty here.

    Posted by HBX May 11, 09 01:49 PM
add your comment
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

about the author

Erica Noonan is chief of the Globe West bureau. Before joining the Globe in 2000, she worked for the Associated Press in Boston. Raised in Wellesley, she has a master's degree in political communication from Emerson College and a BA in political science from Trinity University in San Antonio. She lives in Natick with two energetic preschoolers: Dennis, 4, and Lila, 2.

Contact Erica