Books We Like: Free-Range Kids

Posted by Erica Noonan, Globe West October 8, 2009 08:38 AM

free-range-cover13.jpg

This month's Moms Are Talking About Books We Like selection was written by "The Worst Mom in the World."

Seriously, that's what The Today Show, and The View and bunch of other people called Lenore Skenazy after she made national headlines by allowing her 9-year-old son take a short subway ride by himself in Manhattan.

Amazingly enough, she didn't take all this criticism and bad mommy talk terribly personally, and just published Free-Range Kids: Giving Our Kids the Freedom We Enjoyed Without Going Nuts With Worry.

Free-Range Kids is a thoroughly enjoyable read. Lenore is funny and self-depricating, provacative but not polarizing.

She points out -- accurately -- that kids today are way safer than they have ever been. We parents are way nuttier, which is the bulk of the problem.

Intellectually, I am with Lenore all the way. She makes total sense.

But my gut says otherwise. I was 9 years old when Etan Patz diappeared and 11 when Adam Walsh was murdered. I was 12 when the Tylenol Killer poisoned seven people in Chicago, and 14 when Sarah Pryor vanished taking a walk less than a dozen miles from where I lived.

Every one of those events terrified me and my friends, and our parents, who tended to keep us indoors a lot growing up.

As a hothouse parent, I'm not sure I can raise a free-range kid.

Lenore suggests taking some baby steps for practice: in a couple of years I might let my kids walk down the street alone or roam around in the woods out my sight.

Sure, I'll get to that when they are in high school. Or college. (Or possibly grad school. Or maybe after they are married...)

How about you? What do you think about the Free-Range Kids philosophy? Leave a comment, or send an email to enoonan@globe.com

  • CommentComment
  • Email E-mail

Email this article

Invalid email address
Invalid email address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

6 comments so far...
  1. I'm sorry but being a helicopter parent is as damaging as if you fed your kid McDonald's every day. Some of my friends don't allow their high-school age kids to take the T into Boston. One won't even allow her 16-year-old daughter to take a taxicab. These are the kids who are going to go absolutely berserk when they get to college. If they can figure out how to get there, that is.

    I'm not saying that you should let your first-grader hitchhike to school, but it's okay for your neighbor to give him a ride. Seriously, stop imposing your irrational fears on your kids. It's abuse!

    Posted by just_cos October 14, 09 05:14 PM
  1. My daughter is one and I'm already a free-range parent.

    Other moms shocked in horror recently when I *GASP* let her eat sand. As they all reached out and shrieked "YUCKY" at the top of their lungs, I stepped between them and my daughter, who was making faces and had already figured it out for herself. She didn't need anyone to teach her that lesson and the worst consequence for learning the lesson herself was the possibility for a slightly sandy diaper.

    I've also been shamed for letting my daughter eat dirt, sit in a shopping cart without having wiped it down or put in one of those stupid covers, and for letting her chew on my keys. All of these things actually have the benefit of helping to build her immune system by exposure to everyday bacterias.

    I let her play on her own, and do not feel obligated to be her cruise director for every second of the day. I've been told it's neglectful to be online while she's perfectly happy bouncing in and out of her ball pit because I'm not sitting there actively engaging with her. To them I say you need a life and your child needs some breathing space.

    The author of this article is harming her children, and when they go to college she'll end up in therapy because she has no identity separate from her identity as a mom.

    Posted by C October 16, 09 12:47 PM
  1. People have always marveled at how independent my kids are, and while some of it is personality, I'm convinced that a large part of it is because I have always left them to their own devices to some extent. From the time they were very small, I would have them in a safe location and let them do their own thing. I was of course nearby in case something unthinkable happened, but I didn't play cruise director. I even (gasp) make them work things out themselves, instead of spoon-feeding them a solution. They are allowed to ride their bikes around the neighborhood, as long as they check in at home periodically. Oh yeah, they are 9 and 7.

    Posted by akmom October 17, 09 09:47 AM
  1. I love Lenore's blog and book. I don't let my kids bungee jump naked off the Grand Canyon, and I don't send them into the Combat Zone at 2 am. But I also don't need to walk them into their classroom in 3rd grade, I don't stand over them when they play in the back yard, and I let the ride their bikes (gasp) out of my sight. They are allowed to use jackknives once trained, and my 3rd grader cooked French toast for breakfast all by himself this morning, without killing himself or burning the house down. I don't boil their hands every time they go out in public, and I don't freak if they get their clothes dirty. Let the leash out a little - your kids will amaze you with what they are capable of.


    Posted by BMS October 17, 09 03:28 PM
  1. C: We need to get together. Seriously. Our daughter eats dirt and sand, licks rocks, carries sticks in her mouth like a dog, sits in the mud and plays with worms and slugs...

    And I can't tell you how many parents have given us dirty looks or outright admonishments for it. Ah well.

    Posted by phe October 20, 09 01:59 PM
  1. "Lenore suggests taking some baby steps for practice: in a couple of years I might let my kids walk down the street alone or roam around in the woods out my sight.

    "Sure, I'll get to that when they are in high school. Or college. (Or possibly grad school. Or maybe after they are married...)"

    I know this is an exaggeration, but some people do that to their daughters IRL: it's called keeping them in purdah. How do these daughters get married before being allowed to walk down the street alone? Arranged marriage - the parents don't allow the daughters to meet the son-in-laws before the weddings (and for some reason they still condemn having sex with a stranger, as if marital sex isn't really sex so wedding-night sex with a stranger doesn't count).

    Posted by Leslie October 31, 09 09:13 AM
add your comment
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

about the author

Erica Noonan is chief of the Globe West bureau. Before joining the Globe in 2000, she worked for the Associated Press in Boston. Raised in Wellesley, she has a master's degree in political communication from Emerson College and a BA in political science from Trinity University in San Antonio. She lives in Natick with two energetic preschoolers: Dennis, 4, and Lila, 2.

Contact Erica

get RSS feed


click here to subscribe to
Moms Are Talking About

archives