"> " />
RadioBDC Logo
Steady, as She Goes | The Raconteurs Listen Live
< Back to front page Text size +

Capturing hope and destruction

Posted by Teresa Hanafin  December 9, 2008 10:20 AM

E-mail this article

Invalid E-mail address
Invalid E-mail address

Sending your article

"Darfur (Boys and Tree)" / Photo by Ron Haviv

By Mark Feeney
Globe Staff

WINCHESTER - It's hard for a title to set the bar higher than "Humankind."

Modeled on the landmark 1955 Museum of Modern Art exhibition "The Family of Man," it shares its predecessor's forthright support of the party of humanity and commitment to social uplift. But "Humankind," which runs at the Griffin Museum of Photography through Jan. 11, labors under three severe disadvantages.

"Family" consisted of 500 photographs, "Humankind" has 31. Several hundred photographers contributed to "Family," 11 are in "Humankind." They all belong to the photo collaborative VII, which includes some of today's ablest photojournalists (the best known is James Nachtwey). Even so, with 6.7 billion people making up humankind, that's spreading ability awfully thin.

Most important, the MoMA show took place in a vastly different visual environment. The image glut we now drown in was then only a flood. The photographs in "Family" could introduce as well as redirect and reinforce. Inevitably, the eyes of contemporary viewers are inundated - and jaded - to a degree unthinkable half a century ago.

Perhaps that's why "Humankind" grabs viewers' lapels so tightly. "Rwanda Refugees," "Congo, AIDS Clinic," "Malaria, Peru," "The River Ganges, Pollution" are less descriptive than prosecutorial. With such titles you don't really need to see the pictures. The occasional photograph like "Krumping," "Cheerleaders," or "Ballerina Wendy Whelan" is the frameful of sugar to help the righteousness go down.

"5,400,00 DR Congo (Hope)" / Photo by Marcus Bleasdale

The conceptual thrust of "Humankind" matters less, of course, than the actual images making up the show. Many are spectacular, and some are spectacularly good. Christopher Morris's "North Korea" shows enrobed women arrayed en masse, a totalitarian tableau not quite vivant. Ron Haviv's "Blood and Honey" presents a man and woman in uniform kissing in front of war wreckage from the dissolution of Yugloslavia. A terrific image, it maintains an unnerving balance between affirming life and documenting its destruction.

Unfortunately, that conceptual thrust does its best (or worst) to interpose itself between viewers and image. Before we can be moved, we're preached at. Morris's "Hurricane Katrina" shows a globe, battered yet still brightly colored, against a dark background of bottles, books, and other debris. It's an arresting, startling image. Yet the title turns something the eye can barely comprehend into a neat little package the conscience can cluck over and instantly file away.

Or consider Haviv's "Darfur (Boys and Tree)" (see above). How differently would a viewer see the image if its title were just the parenthetical? Three young African males, shot from in front and below, are outlined against a tree. Its wretchedly bare branches seem to beseech a sky filled with storm clouds. It's a powerful, memorable composition. But the title pigeonholes it. The title tells us how to react.

"Katrina" and "Darfur" have entered that class of terms, like "Holocaust" or "apartheid" or "Ground Zero," that decent people (you know, like you and me) can be assumed to have a reflexive reaction to - as we should. But imagine Mr. Kurtz's dying words in "Heart of Darkness" as "The Congo! The Congo!" instead of "The horror! The horror!" There is a world of difference between the two, morally no less than aesthetically. It's the difference between journalism and art, fact and truth. "Congo" offers a kind of absolution - it's the Belgians' fault. "Horror" lies within us all.

John Wesley Mannion's "State School" juxtaposes decay and renovation. It consists of 10 color photographs, 2 feet by 3 feet, that Mannion took at the now-derelict Pennhurst State School and Hospital, in Pennsylvania.

Chest of drawers
"Chest of drawers" / Photo by John Wesley Mannion
Pre-op sink
"Pre-op sink" / Photo by John Wesley Mannion

Mannion would clean and paint portions of small spaces there. The contrast between the rubbish and peeling paint with the restored bits is disconcerting. It's nowhere near as disconcerting, though, as the contrast between the handsomeness of these pictures, with their rich and subdued colors, and the rotting scenes they document.

The most memorable thing about Jan Cadman Powell's "codedknits," a small set of photographic lithographs, is what inspired them. Fishermen in the Aran Islands, off the coast of Ireland, wear sweaters knit with highly specific patterns so as to make it easier to identify their bodies should they drown.

Powell has created a variety of knitting samples. Some have wondrous names: "Herringbone Blues," "Sirocco Skein," "Wager Welt." Seen on the page, they are dense, gnarly abstractions: reminders of the solidity of earth and warnings against the unforgivingness of water.

Mark Feeney can be reached at mfeeney@globe.com.


Humankind: Images by VII
State School: Images by John Wesley Mannion
Codedknits: Images by Jan Cadman Powell

Through Jan. 11
Griffin Museum of Photography
67 Shore Road, Winchester

  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.


Welcome to your community for New England's amateur photographers. Take pictures ... get published ... win money ... have a blast!
The Color Green
It's the color of hope, envy, regeneration, relaxation, and money -- as well as the theme of the October contest. Make it the focal point of your best photograph.
Upcoming events

Featured Photographer

Featured Photographer: Ben Rifkin
Life and wildlife in Madagascar
For years before I started college, I knew I wanted to spend a semester studying abroad, but I wasn't sure where. By my junior year at Brandeis, I made up my mind to travel somewhere off the beaten path, and, of course, Madagascar is pretty far off the beaten path for someone like me....
An essay about Rebirth Workshops
Now that it's been several months since I returned from a week-long Rebirth Workshop in Mississippi, I'm happy to look back and provide an overview of what we did that made it such an intense experience for me as a photographer....
Photography apps for your phone
Thinking of ditching your separate camera and moving to just using your phone for all your photos? What apps should you go for? Instagram made headlines recently after being bought by Facebook for $1 billion. What does it include, and what else is out there?...