Were Logan airport security scanners scrapped because of radiation risks?
I was relieved when I heard the news that Logan airport would be replacing its full body backscatter scanners -- which use small amounts of radiation -- with the millimeter wave scanners that don’t use any radiation. The official reason for replacing the security scanner is because of a failure to fulfill a Congressional mandate, which required the machines to have new software to produce less-revealing images by June of this year. (See the photo above to see a before and after with the new software.)
The software adaptation can’t be developed in time, according to the Transportation Safety Administration, so the $40 million contract will be canceled and the machines returned to their manufacturer. Software adjustments were successfully completed for the millimeter wave scanners, which are already in about half of the nation’s airports, and will eventually replace the backscatter machines.
The reason I’m relieved that backscatter machines are going to be scrapped is because of their potential radiation risks, which radiation health experts expressed concerns about back in 2010 when the full body scanners first came to Logan and 29 other airports.
Four radiation scientists from academic institutions sent a letter of concern to the White House questioning “the extent to which the safety of this scanning device has been adequately demonstrated,” especially for frequent fliers who are going through them on a daily basis. The American Pilots Association told its members to opt for pat downs rather than risk the cumulative dose of radiation.
Cellular damage from radiation exposure accumulates in the body over a lifetime, and excess exposure can alter DNA, giving rise to a variety of cancers.
I went through a few pat-downs myself at Logan airport to avoid any radiation exposure from the machines. I was particularly concerned about the potential for a machine malfunction that could expose me to more radiation than originally intended.
Ann Davis, a TSA spokeswoman, told me in a 2010 interview that the machines were inspected regularly at Logan and elsewhere and that all the radiation surveys that had been conducted at Logan, up to that point in time, “have found radiation emissions to be below the applicable national standard.”
But European Union countries were concerned enough about the radiation risks to ban backscatter machines in 2011; they only use millimeter wave scanners in their airports.
A TSA contractor who spoke with the Washington Post on the condition of anonymity speculated that concerns about radiation risks contributed to the decision to remove the machines from US airports. “I suspect they may have had additional concerns that they’re not talking about,” the person told the Post. “I believe they feel politically uncomfortable going back on their previous statements.”
I suspect he’s right, though TSA officials insist that the radiation safety question wasn’t a factor.Deborah Kotz can be reached at email@example.com. Follow her on Twitter @debkotz2.
May 1, 2013
By Deborah Kotz, Globe Staff The catch-phrase “Boston Strong” has become an emotional rallying cry a …
April 30, 2013
By Deborah Kotz, Globe Staff Wrigley’s launched a caffeinated gum this week called Alert Energy, add …
March 11, 2013
By Deborah Kotz, Globe Staff About 15 percent to 30 percent of people with allergies have allergic r …
March 6, 2013
By Deborah Kotz and Brian MacQuarrie, Globe Staff As Congress debates whether to toughen the nation’ …
March 7, 2013
By Deborah Kotz, Globe Staff No doubt, the biggest appeal of exercise is to build biceps, heart musc …
March 4, 2013
By Deborah Kotz, Globe Staff A survey released today makes the case for exercising to improve sleep …
April 8, 2013
By Deborah Kotz, Globe Staff If you needed another reason to limit your intake of red meat and sugar …
March 29, 2013
By Deborah Kotz, Globe Staff Kids meals at restaurant chains are just as bad as ever, according to a …
Gideon Gil, Health and Science Editor
Elizabeth Comeau, Senior Health Producer