boston.com News your connection to The Boston Globe

Racial profiling is confirmed

Police face new rules on stopping motorists

By Bill Dedman, Globe Correspondent, 5/4/2004

    On city boulevards and rural lanes, whites and women are far more likely to receive written warnings instead of tickets when stopped for identical traffic offenses, according to a Boston Globe study of newly released state records.

 FOLLOW-UPS

8/8/2004
Police plan public meeting

5/9/2004
Chiefs deny racial profiling

5/6/2004
Civil rights advocates laud plan

5/5/2004
Police chiefs decry study

5/4/2004
Racial profiling is confirmed
Northeastern study [PDF]
Report summary
Who got a passing grade?
Police response [MS Word]

2/16/2004
Police flouting 'no fix' law on tickets

1/21/2004
Profiling study cites dozens of locales Charts
Northeastern study [PDF]

1/20/2004
Reilly starts push to end profiling in police stops

1/17/2004
Boston police to get tough on tickets

9/19/2003
Judge: Suspect must stay in jail

9/18/2003
Seeing bias, evidence tossed

8/5/2003
Deeper look at profiling

7/24/2003
Funding urged for study

5/24/2003
Ticketing cited despite curbs

3/5/2003
Romney backs profile tracking
People asked to join task force

1/25/2003
Chief: Glitch caused error

1/8/2003
Task force to review data


 THE SERIES

Day 1:
Race, sex, and age drive ticketing
Minority officers are stricter on minorities
Boston to track all stops by police

Graphics:
Who gets fined for speeding
Minority officers
Most-favored status
One officer's week

Town-by-town:
Ticketing whites vs. minorities
Large departments | All

Ticketing women vs. men
Large departments | All


Day 2:
Punishment varies by town and officer

Graphics:
How tickets raise insurance
Ranking the departments
Littering is worse?

Town-by-town:
Toughest on speeders
Large departments | All
Locals vs. out-of-towners
Large departments | All


Day 3:
Troopers fair, tough in traffic encounters

Graphics:
Frequent ticketers
How fast can you go?


Editorial: Tickets to fix
Op-Ed: Looking deeper
Op-Ed: Study proves nothing
Profiles in prejudice

 ONLINE EXTRAS

Q & A
Secretary of Public Safety Edward A. Flynn, the senior law enforcement official in Massachusetts, spoke with the Globe about this series. Q & A

Detailed report
A closer look at how the Globe analyzed hundreds of thousands of traffic tickets.
Download study
This .PDF document requires Adobe Acrobat

Online chat
Globe reporter Bill Dedman chatted with Boston.com readers about this series.
Read full transcript

 EARLIER REPORTS

In January, the Globe published the first results of its analysis.

Part 1:
Citations reveal disparity
Totals key to computations

Graphics:
Tracking tickets
Searches by race and age

Charts:
Searching minorities more often
Ticketing their own


Part 2:
Police not pressed on race
Tewksbury cop is tops
Fridays worst for tickets
Scope of monitoring reduced

Graphics:
Where race was not recorded

Charts:
Failing to record the race
Searching more cars

Three out of four police departments in Massachusetts have engaged in racial profiling against nonwhite drivers, state Public Safety Secretary Edward A. Flynn is expected to report today.

To monitor police interaction with citizens, Flynn could require officers in as many as 249 departments, including state troopers, to fill out an extra form every time they pull over a motorist, even when they don't write a ticket or a warning.

Four years after the Legislature ordered a test for racial profiling in Massachusetts, police departments will receive their final grades this morning. Flynn is scheduled to release the final report of a state-sponsored study of traffic tickets by Northeastern University's Institute on Race and Justice and to announce what standard he will set for requiring the additional paperwork. Northeastern posted the report on its website last night.

The attorney for the state's police chiefs association predicted that many police officers will respond to Flynn's ruling by "de-policing," doing fewer traffic stops lest they give more ammunition to their critics.

"De-policing is a real possibility," said John M. Collins, general counsel for the Massachusetts Chiefs of Police Association. "When somebody is falsely accused, they're not going to continue to give you the bullets to shoot them with."

The Northeastern study confirms a Boston Globe study of the same traffic tickets last year: Minorities, especially men, are disproportionately ticketed and searched in most communities in the state. And when police officers decide whether to write a ticket or a warning, women are far more likely to get a break.

In applying the state law, police chiefs expected Flynn to be a tough grader, requiring the additional paperwork from police departments that show a disparity on any one of Northeastern's four statistical tests: ticketing resident minorities more than whites, compared with their share of the resident population, as judged by the 2000 Census; ticketing all minorities more than whites, compared with their share of the community's drivers, as estimated by Northeastern; searching minorities more often than whites; and issuing warnings to whites more often than to minorities.

Looking at Northeastern's final report on 341 communities, 92 communities received a passing grade on all tests. The largest community in the state receiving an all-clear was Agawam, a Springfield suburb of 28,000 people.

In the Boston area, the only communities given a clean bill were the northern towns of Boxford, Danvers, Essex, Hamilton, Manchester-by-the-Sea, Middleton, and Newbury; the northwest towns of Acton, Burlington, Carlisle, Concord, Groton, Harvard, North Reading, Reading, Westford, and Winchester; the south towns of Duxbury, Halifax, Hanover, Marshfield, Norwell, Pembroke, and Plympton; and the west towns of Medfield, Norfolk, and Plainville.

The police departments that failed at least one test range from the State Police and Boston Police Department to the tiny Martha's Vineyard community of Aquinnah, with 344 year-round residents, nearly half of them American Indians.

The final grades: 15 police departments failed on all four tests; 42 failed on three tests; 87 failed on two tests; and 105 failed on only one. Not every department was eligible for all four tests because sufficient numbers of searches and written warnings were required for statistical significance.

To identify communities where minorities might be targeted for traffic enforcement, the Northeastern researchers studied 1.6 million traffic citations issued between April 1, 2001, and June 30, 2003.

Police departments can appeal Flynn's decision to Attorney General Thomas F. Reilly, but in a letter to police chiefs his deputy told them not to get their hopes up. Reilly will set aside Flynn's ruling only if a department can prove that the decision was "unsubstantiated by substantial evidence," Stephanie S. Lovell, first assistant attorney general, wrote last month. The most contested part of Northeastern's study has been the test that the most departments failed, a comparison of the minority share of tickets with an estimated driving population of each community. Many police departments complained that the estimate didn't account for high minority populations in a neighboring community, as in Milton, which is between Boston and Randolph, both of which have higher minority populations.

So the police chiefs in eight communities did their own road surveys this spring, counting races by observing faces of drivers in high-traffic areas, and in every case found that the minority share of drivers was higher than Northeastern had estimated, thus lowering the disparity. Those communities are Andover, Dedham, Marion, Milton, Randolph, Shrewsbury, Swampscott, and Watertown. Northeastern noted those communities in its report, but still failed them on that test.

The new form that police officers have to fill out hasn't been designed, but similar forms in other states give researchers several additional pieces of information: the reason for the stop, information about an oral warning, what an officer is looking for in a search, whether any contraband was found in a search, and an exact location, which is written on traffic tickets in Massachusetts now but isn't entered into state computers.

Bill Dedman can be reached at dedman@globe.com or 617-929-2837. See Boston.com for a list of communities and their grades on the report.

SEARCH GLOBE ARCHIVES
 
Globe Archives Today (free)
Yesterday (free)
Past 30 days
Last 12 months
 Advanced search