|
Does your organization suffer from under-management?
By Bruce Tulgan, 10/24/2005
E-Mail This Article
In recent years, under-management has become my principal focus and concern. It is the latest turn in the research I've conducted on the front lines of the workplace since 1993.
"Under-management" is not a household word, like its opposite, the dreaded "micro-management," but it should be because under-management is far more damaging than micro-management and far more common.
Under-management is the cause hiding behind so many problems. So many problems can be traced back to one or more leaders who are failing to take charge on a day to day basis; failing to tell people every step of the way what to do and how to do it; failing to monitor and measure performance constantly; failing to correct failure quickly and reward success even more quickly. Under-management is so widespread, it is epidemic. Its impact, especially in today's changing workplace, makes micro-management look like a molehill.
A shocking proportion of leaders and managers are unable or unwilling to manage their employees effectively on a day-to-day basis. In on our research, we've learned that leaders under-manage for seven reasons:
-
They don't want to micro-manage, so they fail to give enough direction and guidance.
-
They don't want to monitor and measure performance closely, so they let small problems fester and grow.
-
They don't want to single out individuals for special treatment because others might think it's unfair, so they are not as flexible and generous as they could be.
-
They think you have to be a jerk to be a strong manager, so they fall into "false nice guy" syndrome providing no direction and enforcing no standards.
-
They are afraid to confront the people they lead and transform their relationships with them, so they are unable to take charge.
-
They don't study and practice proven techniques, so they remain stuck in bad management habits.
-
They are confounded by all the factors beyond their control (red tape, corporate culture, uncooperative senior management, limited resources), so they never focus on what they can control, which is themselves and their guts and their skill and how they spend their time.
Under-management creates a downward spiral:
-
The manager is not informed about who is doing what, when, where, how, and why. That means employees find less connection between their efforts and the credit they receive.
-
The under-manager is unable to help employees identify and meet resource needs; anticipate and avoid problems; plan the achievement of goals step by step; utilize obvious short-cuts; and learn on the job. '
-
The under-manager is not in a position to decide how much responsibility to delegate to one employee as opposed to another; what expectations are reasonable for each employee; which employees are overworked and which ones have extra time.
-
Problems occur and resources are squandered; thus fixing and salvage attempts must be made.
-
Low performers hide out undiscovered, mediocre performers never improve, and high performers get frustrated and start planning their exits.
And the downward spiral continues. The irony is that under-managers spend lots of time managing, but they spend all of their management time putting out fires, chasing after problems, closing the barn door after the horses have run off. That's why I spend a lot of time convincing managers that, in fact, they don't have time NOT to hold every employee's hand every day.
I tell them: "You simply must take charge and start 'bossing people around.' Why? The confrontations will get easier and easier because management conversations won't be special occasions: That means you'll get good at having these conversations. Your employees will get good at it. Everybody will do a better job with your guidance. Fewer problems will occur and when they do, they'll be dealt with quickly and effectively. Everything will improve when management conversations become standard operating procedure, every day, and every step of the way. But THAT---making management conversations standard operating procedure---is the hard part."
Shouldn't managers be trying to empower their employees? If you want to empower people, especially nowadays, then you simply must define the terrain on which they have power. That terrain consists of effectively delegated goals, with clear guidelines, and concrete deadlines. Let people know exactly what is expected of them and exactly what they can expect in return. This is the most effective single thing that managers actually do. They are hands-on and they are transactional. I coined the acronym H.O.T. (Hands- On and Transactional) Management to describe this approach.
The real trick to being a HOT Manager is in figuring out, with each person and each instance of delegation, the following: How large should the goals be? How far out should the deadlines be? How many guidelines are necessary with each goal? Consistently articulating with every direct report the appropriate standards and expectations ---what to do and how to do it--- is the hard work of leading, managing, and supervising. Within clearly articulated parameters, a direct report has power. Limited power? Yes. But it also has the great virtue of being real power.
I know that managing people in the real world is very, very difficult and there are no easy solutions. I know that most managers are under a tremendous amount of pressure. There are so many factors out of their control. Managers have too much to do and too little time to manage. If you push employees nowadays, many of them will push right back. Employees are high maintenance. It's a whole lot easier to be hands-off and stay out of the way unless something goes wrong. I know there are lots of very good reasons why managers are too soft. That's precisely why I spend 100 plus days a year helping managers see soft, hands-off, under-management in themselves; persuading them to change, to embrace being strong, highly engaged leaders; and teaching them to focus once again on the hard part of managing, the basics. And then I ask them the key question: "Are you ready to get HOT?"
Bruce Tulgan is the founder of RainmakerThinking Inc., a research and consulting firm specializing in younger workers and the changing workplace. He is a frequent speaker at industry gatherings and the author of several books, including, most recently, HOT Management. Tulgan can be reached at brucet@rainmakerthinking.com.
|  |  |  |
More from NEHRA
Ethics
09/08/2008
Our HR experts answer your employer-related questions, including advice on dealing with romantic, inter-office relationships.
NEHRA - The Voice of HR
08/25/2008
Issues to consider with non-competition agreements NCAs cut both ways for human resource professionals. They can help us maintain our own workforce. But they also can impede our efforts to expand our workforce.
Employment Law and Immigration Law
08/11/2008
Our expert explores where the blame for high employee turnover rates is being placed — and what can be done to fix the problem.
The blame game: Passing the buck on employee turnover
07/28/2008
Our expert explores where the blame for high employee turnover rates is being placed — and what can be done to fix the problem.
Creating a culture of employee engagement
06/23/2008
Check out our experts' tips on how to best engage employees and tackle one of today's most important business issues.
Benefits and Compensation
06/02/2008
Our HR experts answer your employer-related questions, including ways to ease employees' financial stresses and how to deal with attendance problems.
Many organizations optimistic despite state of the economy
05/27/2008
A new survey conducted by NEHRA reveals a majority of area firms are expecting little change in budgets, staffing and financial results in 2008.
Workforce development
05/05/2008
Our HR experts answer your employer-related questions, including advice on implementing peer review systems and effective training programs.
Getting on board with onboarding
04/28/2008
Does every employee have to go through this rite of passage or can companies do something to smoothly assimilate new employees into the organization?
Leveraging 360-degree assessments... pre-hire
03/24/2008
Given the finite time that work visas are valid and the very lengthy green card process, it is important that an employer timely assess the need for this process.
Finding the best talent single greatest recruiting challenge, survey says
02/25/2008
Finding the best talent is the single biggest challenge facing the region's human resource professionals in today's market.
Leveraging 360-degree assessments... pre-hire
01/24/2008
To truly understand a candidate's potential to succeed, employers must understand the candidate's past job performance.
Five ways to keep your employees focused through the holidays
11/26/2007
Here is a secret that many of your employees don't want you to know about. On the fourth Thursday of every November, your employees unofficially begin their holiday hiatus.
Employee retention programs lacking at most New England firms
10/29/2007
A new survey by the Northeast Human Resources Association shows that nearly three out of four area firms still lack a specific program.
Leading leaders
9/24/2007
Why HR professionals need to help leaders motivate employees, communicate vision, and move the company in one direction.
'I don't want to get anyone in trouble, but...'
8/27/2007
Why do people keep workplace issues to themselves? Why do HR professionals hear unvoiced complaints for the first time when it's too late to work toward a solution, particularly as employees depart?
Aging workforce a challenge for most firms in the region
7/23/2007
Firms in New England will soon be facing a critical workplace shortage as the baby boomer generation retirement looms. So say the results of a new survey by the NEHRA.
Managing millennials
6/11/2007
My experiences are not those of colleagues even 5-7 years younger than I. To help other managers avoid cross-generational gaffes, here are my tips for managing this generation.
HR's role in managing
office diversity, more
5/14/2007
Our HR experts answer your work-related questions, including how to deal with issues affecting diversity in the workplace.
From diversity to inclusion
4/30/2007
In the last few years, the focus of efforts in companies across the land has shifted from diversity to a focus on inclusion. This sea change has happened without fanfare and almost without notice.
Crisis management a priority for most local firms, NEHRA survey says
4/16/2007
Managing a crisis is serious business for firms in New England and the northeast. So say the results of a new survey by the Northeast Human Resources Association (NEHRA).
It's the year 2010...do you know where your workers are?
2/12/2007
Try to visualize what your workplace will look like in the year 2010. If you envision a sea of cubicles filled with motivated employees, you are in for a huge awakening.
Recruitment value proposition: what is it and how do I get me one?
12/18/2006
If you're reading this you probably already know that your recruitment strategy is failing. Yet you continue to use the same approach despite disappointing results.
Job training and development remain a priority for area businesses, NEHRA survey says
11/13/2006
According to a recent sampling of the Northeast Human Resources Association's (NEHRA) 4,000 members, job training and development remain an organizational priority for a majority of the region's employers.
Becoming a Great Place to Work: the story of Wegmans
10/23/2006
An exclusive preview of the keynote speech at this year's annual NEHRA HR convention.
More from NEHRA archives
|  |