< Back to Front Page Text size +

Why We Should Quit Starving Amtrak

Posted by David Beard, Boston.com Staff May 19, 2008 11:44 PM

Derrick Jackson has a ringing commentary in Tuesday's Globe about Amtrak, the Bush administration's punching bag for the past eight years -- and now, with gas nearing $4 a gallon, a sudden ridership success story.

Beginning with a Barack Obama photo-op with an Amtrak worker who feared a layoff, Jackson concludes Obama must "get on board for the rail service America needs for a green economy, less urban congestion, and a more civilized future. ... Nothing would symbolize a break from this past more than a whistlestop tour in the presidential campaign, to promote trains themselves.''

The Times's Paul Krugman is having similar thoughts, writing from Berlin that Americans may have to start living like Europeans -- driving fuel-efficient cars, and driving a lot less.

That's hard in the United States, though, where people associate high-density living with high crime, and only 5 percent of Americans regularly take public transit to work.

"It’s hard to justify transit systems unless there’s sufficient population density,'' Krugman writes, "yet it’s hard to persuade people to live in denser neighborhoods unless they come with the advantage of transit access.''

What do you think? When was the last time you took public transit? Is it even an option for you where you live, or given your job or family duties?

  • CommentComment
  • EmailEmail
5 comments so far...
  1. I take the bus to work whenever I can't walk (i.e. carrying too much stuff that day). And I'm an avid train rider. If we can take the train on our annual vacation, we do. The problem is, out here in the west, there are thousands of square miles not approached by any passenger train. If you go online at Amtrak and ask how to get from Albuquerque to Missoula, it will tell you that you can't get there from here. We need a lot more trains running out here. The rails are there, but Amtrak is not.

    Posted by Roadbum May 20, 08 12:05 PM
  1. People are overly skeptical about Mass Transit.
    I live in Los Angeles, and I use mass transit daily,
    sometimes I drive - but only once in 3 weeks, that's all!
    There is too much propaganda towards car usage,
    along with peer pressure, which definitely plays an adverse effect in using mass transit.
    So - I disagree that mass transit is only for "poor or disabled", and I disagree that urban cities are associated with "high crime".
    People should try to change their mentality,
    and try mass transit. It's safe, efficient, and convenient in most cities.

    Posted by Alek F May 20, 08 12:52 PM
  1. I could not agree more. After having lived in Europe and depended completely on public transportation, it continues to baffle me how trains are not developed more throughout the US. They would be an easier, cheaper, safer, and smarter way to travel to decently distant cities (i.e. those 5 hrs away) as opposed to driving. I personally use the public transport here every day and I never plan on driving to work. But I do agree that people won't use it unless they have to but when is enough? When gas is $10 a gallon? We need to improve our systems so people feel motivated to use them.

    Posted by Abby May 20, 08 04:43 PM
  1. I live in a major northeast city right now and take inter-city and intra-city transit because I have no car. I am moving soon to the west coast and can't wait to have a car again. I never get a seat on the intra-city transit, and the cars are full of smelly, sneezing, coughing people. Sure there are smelly, sneezing, and coughing people all over society in public spaces, but I can walk away and avoid them elseware. I can't when I'm stuck on a train for 10-500 minutes (depending on where I am going). Amtrak will also force you to sit next to people you don't want to (because they are coughing, sneezing, smelly, loud, etc). At least when I am driving myself, I can relax.

    Posted by Mark May 22, 08 09:07 AM
  1. I also live in a major northeast city and I have never had a problem with using public transit. I have encouraged several of my coworkers and client to take advantage of using the cities bus system. There may be people on board who are not groomed the best, however there are also many people who use public transit who are just a well off as a CEO of a major corporation. This idea continues the notion that public transit is only for the poor and sickly and that is simply not true. Public transit is an asset for any city, town village who has it and we need to start treating it that way. It is time that we start leaving our private cars at home and using transit, including Amtrak. Just a thought, but Airlines also carry people who don’t have a lot of money. If you are “stuck” sitting next to someone you don’t like, then try to engage with the person. Who knows, you maybe able make that person’s day. It is possible to relax anywhere; all it takes is a little practice. Public transportation at the moment is the best solution to high oil prices. Will you be apart of bringing prices down, or apart of prices continuing to go up?

    Posted by Joel May 26, 08 11:41 AM
add your comment
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About the green blog Helping Boston live a greener, more environmentally friendly life.

contributors

Bennie DiNardo is the Boston Globe's deputy managing editor/multimedia
Beth Daley covers environmental issues for the Globe
Christine Chinlund is deputy health/science editor for the Globe.
David Beard is editor of Boston.com
Eric Bauer is site architect of Boston.com
Gideon Gil is the Globe's Health/Science editor
Glenn Yoder produces Boston.com's Lifestyle pages
Ron Agrella is Boston.com's features editor
Erin Ailworth covers energy and the business of the environment for the Globe.
Michael Prager is a Boston-area writer and blogger with a focus on green issues.
Bina Venkataraman covers environmental issues for the Globe.
Christopher Reidy covers business for the Globe.
archives

browse this blog

by category
  • Alternative Energy/Transportation
  • Environment and Health
  • Flora and Fauna
  • Greener Homes
  • Living Green
  • Wild Weather
;