Local Search Site Search
Home Delivery
  • Today's Globe
  • News
  • Your Town
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • A&E
  • Things To Do
  • Travel
  • Cars
  • Jobs
  • Real Estate
  • Weekly Ads
 
< Back to front page Text size – +
U.S. health policy

The End of Insurance Companies? Nope.

Print | Comments () Posted by John McDonough  February 26, 2012 08:25 PM
  • Tweet
  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.

E-mail this article

Invalid email address
Invalid email address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

It is well known that the U.S. insurance industry opposed passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA/ObamaCare). Indeed, more than $86 million of the $120 million spent by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce to oppose the law came directly from the coffers of the nation's leading health insurers. So it is fascinating to read an account of recent comments of Mark Bertolini, Aetna's CEO and President, delivered at a health industry conference this past week:

"The system doesn't work, it's broke today," Bertolini told attendees. "The end of insurance companies, the way we've run the business in the past, is here."

Bertolini said an amalgamation of regulatory, demographic and economic factors were driving this change. The Affordable Care Act in particular, with its ban on medical underwriting, has made the traditional health insurance business model untenable in the long term, he said.

Nonetheless, he offered measured praise for the law, even citing the controversial medical loss ratio rules as having a smoothing effect on premium swings. "We got pulled through the crucible against our will and have been reshaped because of it," he said. "For most of what has already been implemented, it has been a pretty good thing."

Moreover, he discounted the prospect that the results of the 2012 presidential election or a Supreme Court decision striking down aspects of the ACA would deter the change. "Reform is not going to stop. It won't go away."

So what will the health insurers look like in the future? Bertolini offered a strong endorsement of the accountable health organization model, positioning health insurers as uniquely suited to usher in an era of coordinated care. "We need to move the system from underwriting risk to managing populations," he said. "We want to have a different relationship with the providers, physicians and the hospitals we do business with."

If implemented as passed, the ACA will mean the end of individual health insurance as it has been known in most parts of the U.S. Medical underwriting, the practice by which health insurers rate and cover you based on their assessment of your medical history and risk, will be a thing of the past, as it is in every other advanced nation.

In a few states, including Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, and Vermont, banning medical underwriting and pre-existing condition exclusions was done back in the 1990s. In these states, reform did not mean the "end of insurance companies." In Massachusetts, our insurance companies are doing fine, even though they spend close to 90 cents of every premium dollar on pure medical costs (the ACA's "medical loss ratio" requires companies to spend at least 80 or 85 cents of every premiums dollar on medical costs).

I find it encouraging that a leading voice in the U.S. insurance industry is working hard to get ready to survive and thrive in the new health insurance world coming in 2014. I know this will anger folks on the left who want to see insurance companies disappear and folks on the right who despise anyone's indication of support for the ACA.

Just as many Americans voice disapproval of the individual mandate, they also voice strong support for eliminating pre-existing condition exclusions and medical underwriting -- failing to understand how these two reforms are inextricably linked.

The industry's leading trade organization, America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP) filed an amicus brief on the upcoming U.S. Supreme Court's arguments on the ACA. The AHIP brief neither supports nor opposes the anti-ACA suit, though argues that eliminating medical underwriting requires an effective individual coverage requirement/mandate.

Perhaps the health reform landscape is getting ready for another significant shift.

This blog is not written or edited by Boston.com or the Boston Globe.
The author is solely responsible for the content.
  • Tweet
  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.

  • Previous Story
    One Number to Remember on Contraception -- 58%
  • Front Page
  • Next Story
    March Madness and Supreme Surprises

LOG IN TO COMMENT

Sorry, we could not find your e-mail or password.
Please try again, or click here to retrieve your password.
Existing users
*E-mail:
*Password:
*Screen name:
(* fields are required)
Login
Forgot your password?
New users
Please take a minute to register. After you register and pick a screen name, you can publish your comments everywhere on the site. Posting Policy.

Register


TRUSTe Certified Privacy

Your comment is subject to the rules of our Posting Policy
This comment may appear on your public profile. Public Profile FAQ

About the author

John E. McDonough is a professor of practice at the Harvard School of Public Health. He is the author of the book “Inside National Health Reform”, published in 2011 by More »

Recent blog posts

  • ACA’s Ban on Lifetime Caps Protects 105 Million Americans
  • March Madness and Supreme Surprises
  • The End of Insurance Companies? Nope.
  • One Number to Remember on Contraception -- 58%
  • Put Up or Shut Up Time -- For or Against the ACA

Blogroll

  • Blue Mass Group
  • CommonHealth -- Reform and Reality
  • The Dish
  • Ezra Klein's Wonkblog
  • Health Affairs blog
  • Health Beat by Maggie Mahar
  • Not Running a Hospital
  • The Health Care Blog
  • Health Care For All
  • Life as a Healthcare CIO
  • The Incidental Economist
  • Shots -- NPR's health blog
  • Just Transparency
  • Community Catalyst

Health search

Find news and information on:
Search our entire health encyclopedia
Powered by the Parse.ly Publisher Platform (P3).

More community voices

The 24-Hour Workday

By

Kara Baskin

  • When the "Other Woman" Is Mom...

Apptitude Test

By Daniel Kline
  • OpenTable: A simple way to make dining reservations

Ask the Pilot

  • US aviation failing? We've screwed ourselves...

Blissfully Inspired

  • Do or Don't: Including your furry friend...

Boston by Beat

  • Flashy end to Boston Calling Day 1

Boston Medical Mysteries

By Dr. Sushrut Jangi
  • The Malady and the Melody: Revealed

Boston Real Estate Now

By

Scott Van Voorhis

  • Trapped in your house?...

Boston Spirit

By

David Zimmerman and Jim Lopata

  • Westboro Baptist Church blames Oklahoma City tornado on former ...

Bruins Daily

By

Bruins Daily Staff

  • No reason to hit the panic button yet...

Child Caring

By

Barbara Meltz

  • How to explain mom's long-absent mother?...

Child in Mind

By Claudia M. Gold, M.D.
  • To CDC on children's mental health: consider office of homeland attachment security

Chow Down Beantown

By Jacki Morisi and Michelle Zippelli
  • 3 Standout Dishes from Barcelona Wine Bar

Consumer Alert

By Mitch Lipka
  • Hiring a contractor in Mass. the right way...

Corner Kicks

By

Julian Cardillo

  • In-game Commentary: Revolution vs Toronto

Crime & Punishment

By James Alan Fox
  • The Next Target of Terror?

DIY Boston

By Melissa Massello
  • Shop One Fund products by local makers

Dollar for Dollar

By Christine Dunn
  • Protect your identity when traveling: Some key tips from Equifa...

Economy & Equity

By Barry Bluestone
  • Rebuilding America's middle class

The E Word

By

Peter Post

  • What Is It About Your Voice That Affects How People Hear You?

Expertly Engaged

  • Target Launches New Bridal Collection

Global Business Hub

  • 3 Ways to Amplify and Accelerate Positive Word-of-Mouth

Going Deep

  • AFC East top 25, No. 8: Bills WR Stevie Johnson

Health Stew

By John McDonough
  • California will keep ACA premiums low – and set a national model

Innovation Economy

  • Boston-Power founder Christina Lampe-Onnerud joins hedge fund firm Bridgewater Associates

In Practice

By

Dr. Suzanne Koven

  • For heart health, avoid angry response to this blog

The Job Doc Blog

  • Trying to explain your job? Don't.

Less Is More

By Garrett Quinn
  • Is this the best Boston tribute video yet?

Let's Go Out

  • Got Game? Expert Tips For Connecting After Dark...

Managing Your Money

  • Which generation is the best at managing and saving money?

MD Mama

By Dr. Claire McCarthy
  • 8 Ways to Give Your Child a Safer Diet

Media Remix

  • Sizing up Abercrombie: Bad taste, but not discrimination...

Mortal Matters

By Dr. Lachlan Forrow
  • Reverence for Life, Shared Humanity, and Hope

Nutrition and You!

By Joan Salge Blake
  • Your Guide To Grilling Fruits and Veggies

Obnoxious Boston Fan

By

Obnoxious Boston Fan

  • Rondo, Joan Rivers on 'Fashion Police' (Video)

Off The Field

By Dave D'Onofrio
  • Rondo hangs with the 'Fashion Police'

On Deck

By

Craig Forde

  • Saturday's pitching matchups, notes

On Liberty

By Carol Rose
  • Targeting teenage rapper smacks of prosecutorial abuse...

Pack Up

By Melanie Nayer
  • New York City spotlight: The most expensive hotels...

Pet Chatter

By

Stephanie St. Martin

  • A Mother's Day without mom...

The Restaurant Hub

  • Pews and brews: Centre Street Sanctuary to open in Jamaica Plai...

She's Game Sports

By Alice Cook
  • Standing O's and Heck No's: Last week's best and worst in the sports world

Short White Coat

By

Dr. Ishani Ganguli

  • Computers vs patients: A day in the life of a modern intern

State of Play

  • A pilgrim's tale: The joy of conferences and video games that t...

Stats Driven

  • A tale of two Aprils

Straight Up

By Voices From Behind The Bar
  • 100 posts and Flour, too

Ultra Sound Pregnancy

By Lara Salahi
  • On Mother’s Day, A Letter to the Pregnant Me

Roads and Rails

By Nichole Davis
  • Fresh Pond Parkway frustrations, and a Friday traffic fiasco

Weather Wisdom

By David Epstein
  • Raw and cold now, but Memorial day looks nearly perfect
Get updates
My Yahoo
RSS Feed
  • Learn about RSS
archives

Browse this blog

by category
  • Massachusetts
  • Massachusetts health policy
  • Nutrition and Lifestyle
  • U.S. health policy

Inside Boston.com

  • N.E.'s best clam shacks
    N.E.'s best clam shacks
    Pay a visit to some of the best seafood joints in the region
  • Best ice cream spots
    Best ice cream spots
    Here are our top picks for the area's top ice cream locales
  • Boston Calling scenes
    Boston Calling scenes
    The indie band Cults takes the stage at City Hall Plaza
  • Spotted in Boston
    Spotted in Boston
    Spotted visits Spoke Wine Bar in Somerville's Davis Square
  • Plus...
    • Blogs
    • |
    • Crossword
    • |
    • Comics
    • |
    • Horoscopes
    • |
    • Games
    • |
    • Lottery
    • |
    • Caption contest
    • |
    • Today in history
  • Home
  • |
  • Today's Globe
  • |
  • News
  • |
  • Business
  • |
  • Sports
  • |
  • Lifestyle
  • |
  • A&E
  • |
  • Things to Do
  • |
  • Travel
  • |
  • Cars
  • |
  • Jobs
  • |
  • Real Estate
  • |
  • Local Search
  • Contact Boston.com
  • |
  • Help
  • |
  • Advertise
  • |
  • Work here
  • |
  • Privacy Policy
  • |
  • Your Ad Choices
  • |
  • Terms of Service
  • |
  • |
  • Mobile
  • |
  • RSS feeds
  • |
  • Sitemap
  • Contact The Boston Globe
  • |
  • Subscribe
  • |
  • Manage your subscription
  • |
  • Advertise
  • |
  • Boston Globe Insiders
  • |
  • The Boston Globe Gallery
  • |
  • © NY Times Co.