Local Search Site Search
Home Delivery
  • Today's Globe
  • News
  • Your Town
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • A&E
  • Things To Do
  • Travel
  • Cars
  • Jobs
  • Real Estate
  • Weekly Ads
 
< Back to front page Text size – +
U.S. health policy

Anatomy of Another ACA Lie

Print | Comments () Posted by John McDonough  April 5, 2012 01:40 PM
  • Tweet
  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.

E-mail this article

Invalid email address
Invalid email address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

Lots of folks ask me why I think the Affordable Care Act/ObamaCare is so unpopular. I first assert that it's not as unpopular as popularly characterized (see Kaiser Family Foundation monthly tracking polls) and then I refer to the deliberate and false claims about the law being widely circulated around the nation, particularly aimed at senior citizens. I wrote about one particular falsehood last month. Now, my newfound pals at the GE Retirees Association yesterday sent me another they have been receiving in their email inboxes:

Subject: Medicare Premiums ---FYI
MEDICARE
Look clearly at the 2014 rate compared to the 2013 rate.

For those of you who are on Medicare, read the following. It's short, but important and you probably haven't heard about it in the Mainstream News:

"The per person Medicare Insurance Premium will increase from the present Monthly Fee of $96.40, rising to:

$104.20 in 2012

$120.20 in 2013

And

$247.00 in 2014."

These are Provisions incorporated in the Obamacare Legislation, purposely delayed so as not to confuse the 2012 Re-Election Campaigns. Send this to all Seniors that you know, so they will know who's throwing them under the bus.

Peggy Riehle
Internal Representative
Network Contracting
205-220-6778

Blue Cross Blue Shield.jpg

Could I verify or contradict the message, my GE Retiree friends wanted to know. Didn't sound right to me, so I did some investigating. My contacts in the Obama Administration and the U.S. Senate said it's a viral email lie that has been going around for more than one year now. Independently, FactCheck.org did their own investigation last year of these claims, and here is their conclusion:

This widely circulating message is similar to a falsehood-filled screed that went around last year, urging "retribution" against members of Congress in the 2010 midterm elections. This message makes somewhat different accusations -- also false -- and urges voters to "remember" in November 2012. ...

It claims that "those of you who are on Medicare" can thank "Obamacare" for increases in the per-person monthly Medicare premium -- "to a wonderful $247.00 in 2014." This is also false. The basic premium for Medicare Part B (which covers physician services) was indeed $96.40 in 2009. But the other numbers are all wrong. It was $110.50 last year, for example, and not $104.20 as claimed. And it is $115.40 this year, not $120.20 as claimed.

Actually, only 27 percent of Medicare beneficiaries are paying the basic rate. The rest -- 73 percent -- are paying less under a "hold harmless" provision triggered by the lack of a cost-of-living increase in Social Security this year or last year. Most are still paying $96.40.

As for the future, nobody can say with precision what the basic Part B premium will be next year or the year after, let alone in 2014. The premium is set each year at a level calculated to pay for 25 percent of the cost of the coverage. Medicare officials do keep close watch on the trends, however.

And when we contacted Medicare's Office of the Actuary, we were given these projections -- the most recent available -- which are current as of the president's budget for fiscal year 2012 issued in mid-February:

Medicare Part B Standard Premium (projected, February 2011)
2012 $108.20
2013 $112.10
2014 $117.10
Source: Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services

I was particularly intrigued because the vital email in question included the insignia of Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama. I called the number in question and it has been disconnected. I contacted the public affairs office of BCBS-Alabama and a lovely woman informed me that the individual in question received the viral email on her home computer, and then inappropriately re-distributed it via her work email with the identifying information. The public affairs office emphasizes the BCBS-Alabama "does not endorse" the message at all, is instituting new rules of conduct for all employees based on this incident and will be holding training sessions for all their associates on the new code in June.  They have been overwhelmed with inquiries regarding the viral message and sincerely wish it would all go away.

The lie, meanwhile, has taken on a life of its own and will not die anytime soon.

And people continue to wonder, why is the ACA so unpopular?

This blog is not written or edited by Boston.com or the Boston Globe.
The author is solely responsible for the content.
  • Tweet
  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.

  • Previous Story
    Republican Voter Fraud
  • Front Page
  • Next Story
    Applause, Applause!

LOG IN TO COMMENT

Sorry, we could not find your e-mail or password.
Please try again, or click here to retrieve your password.
Existing users
*E-mail:
*Password:
*Screen name:
(* fields are required)
Login
Forgot your password?
New users
Please take a minute to register. After you register and pick a screen name, you can publish your comments everywhere on the site. Posting Policy.

Register


TRUSTe Certified Privacy

Your comment is subject to the rules of our Posting Policy
This comment may appear on your public profile. Public Profile FAQ

About the author

John E. McDonough is a professor of practice at the Harvard School of Public Health. He is the author of the book “Inside National Health Reform”, published in 2011 by More »

Recent blog posts

  • Applause, Applause!
  • Anatomy of Another ACA Lie
  • Republican Voter Fraud
  • SCOTUS-ACA Watch: Well, That Was Interesting
  • The Parable of the S. S. Independent Mandate

Blogroll

  • Blue Mass Group
  • CommonHealth -- Reform and Reality
  • The Dish
  • Ezra Klein's Wonkblog
  • Health Affairs blog
  • Health Beat by Maggie Mahar
  • Not Running a Hospital
  • The Health Care Blog
  • Health Care For All
  • Life as a Healthcare CIO
  • The Incidental Economist
  • Shots -- NPR's health blog
  • Just Transparency
  • Community Catalyst

Health search

Find news and information on:
Search our entire health encyclopedia
Powered by the Parse.ly Publisher Platform (P3).

More community voices

The 24-Hour Workday

By

Kara Baskin

  • Let's Stop Milking an Overdone Argument...

Apptitude Test

By Daniel Kline
  • OpenTable: A simple way to make dining reservations

Ask the Pilot

  • US aviation failing? We've screwed ourselves...

Blissfully Inspired

  • Dear Becca and Casey...In-Laws and Exes...

Boston by Beat

  • Upper Crust brings the bar roque

Boston Medical Mysteries

By Dr. Sushrut Jangi
  • The Malady and the Melody: Revealed

Boston Real Estate Now

By

Scott Van Voorhis

  • Selling house your retirement plan?...

Boston Spirit

By

David Zimmerman and Jim Lopata

  • Florida high school senior arrested for lesbian relationship wi...

Bruins Daily

By

Bruins Daily Staff

  • Bruins need to keep killer instinct mentality in Game 3...

Child Caring

By

Barbara Meltz

  • How to explain mom's long-absent mother?...

Child in Mind

By Claudia M. Gold, M.D.
  • To CDC on children's mental health: consider office of homeland attachment security

Chow Down Beantown

By Jacki Morisi and Michelle Zippelli
  • Spring Party Recipe: Prosciutto Wrapped Asparagus

Consumer Alert

By Mitch Lipka
  • Hiring a contractor in Mass. the right way...

Corner Kicks

By

Julian Cardillo

  • No Agudelo or Donovan on latest US roster

Crime & Punishment

By James Alan Fox
  • The Next Target of Terror?

DIY Boston

By Melissa Massello
  • 5 minute DIY: Upcycled T-shirt necklaces

Dollar for Dollar

By Christine Dunn
  • When it comes to money, Mother may not necessarily know best, b...

Economy & Equity

By Barry Bluestone
  • Rebuilding America's middle class

The E Word

By

Peter Post

  • Summer Clothing That Doesn’t Make the Grade As Business Casual

Expertly Engaged

  • Can you afford to attend all the weddings you're invited to this year?

Global Business Hub

  • Reimagining vocational training

Going Deep

  • AFC East top 25, No. 13: Patriots LB Jerod Mayo

Health Stew

By John McDonough
  • How concentrated is Mass. health market? Now you can take a look.

Innovation Economy

  • Departing Zipcar CEO Scott Griffith signs up as CoachUp director

In Practice

By

Dr. Suzanne Koven

  • Angelina Jolie...and Betty Ford

The Job Doc Blog

  • Chat live with Job Doc Elaine Varelas

Less Is More

By Garrett Quinn
  • Is this the best Boston tribute video yet?

Let's Go Out

  • Would you use GPS to find your next date?...

Managing Your Money

  • Eight ways to save $50 per month

MD Mama

By Dr. Claire McCarthy
  • New report says 1 out of 5 children has a mental disorder

Media Remix

  • Sizing up Abercrombie: Bad taste, but not discrimination...

Mortal Matters

By Dr. Lachlan Forrow
  • Reverence for Life, Shared Humanity, and Hope

Nutrition and You!

By Joan Salge Blake
  • Study: An Eating Out Trick to Help You Order Less

Obnoxious Boston Fan

By

Obnoxious Boston Fan

  • Lackey no longer in Red Sox doghouse

Off The Field

By Dave D'Onofrio
  • A local look at SI's highest-earning athlete list

On Deck

By

Craig Forde

  • The Cap on Monday; scores, highlights

On Liberty

By Carol Rose
  • Let's show the world how it's done...

Pack Up

By Melanie Nayer
  • Hottest hotel pools around the world...

Pet Chatter

By

Stephanie St. Martin

  • A Mother's Day without mom...

The Restaurant Hub

  • A sneak peek of Bronwyn's new menu...

She's Game Sports

By Alice Cook
  • Standing O's and Heck No's: Last week's best and worst in the sports world

Short White Coat

By

Dr. Ishani Ganguli

  • On hospital charges and doctors' decisions

State of Play

  • A pilgrim's tale: The joy of conferences and video games that t...

Stats Driven

  • A tale of two Aprils

Straight Up

By Voices From Behind The Bar
  • Service first, cocktails after

Ultra Sound Pregnancy

By Lara Salahi
  • On Mother’s Day, A Letter to the Pregnant Me

Roads and Rails

By Nichole Davis
  • Fresh Pond Parkway frustrations, and a Friday traffic fiasco

Weather Wisdom

By David Epstein
  • Why so many tornadoes in the Midwest
Get updates
My Yahoo
RSS Feed
  • Learn about RSS
archives

Browse this blog

by category
  • Massachusetts
  • Massachusetts health policy
  • Nutrition and Lifestyle
  • U.S. health policy

Inside Boston.com

  • Boston-area commencements
    Boston area commencements
    Check out scenes from graduations around Boston
  • Somerville's PorchFest 2013
    Somerville's PorchFest 2013
    Bands and musicians play from home for the community
  • Top 10 businesses
    Top 10 businesses
    Who in Mass. made the top 10 on the Globe 100
  • Tom and Gisele sightings
    Tom and Gisele sightings
    Last spotted in Boston on graduation weekend
  • Plus...
    • Blogs
    • |
    • Crossword
    • |
    • Comics
    • |
    • Horoscopes
    • |
    • Games
    • |
    • Lottery
    • |
    • Caption contest
    • |
    • Today in history
  • Home
  • |
  • Today's Globe
  • |
  • News
  • |
  • Business
  • |
  • Sports
  • |
  • Lifestyle
  • |
  • A&E
  • |
  • Things to Do
  • |
  • Travel
  • |
  • Cars
  • |
  • Jobs
  • |
  • Real Estate
  • |
  • Local Search
  • Contact Boston.com
  • |
  • Help
  • |
  • Advertise
  • |
  • Work here
  • |
  • Privacy Policy
  • |
  • Your Ad Choices
  • |
  • Terms of Service
  • |
  • |
  • Mobile
  • |
  • RSS feeds
  • |
  • Sitemap
  • Contact The Boston Globe
  • |
  • Subscribe
  • |
  • Manage your subscription
  • |
  • Advertise
  • |
  • Boston Globe Insiders
  • |
  • The Boston Globe Gallery
  • |
  • © NY Times Co.