Is his roofing bid fair, and how can he be sure?

This is a summary. To read the whole story subscribe to

Q. My old Victorian house built in 1881 is huge, with an enormous attic and a turret, which I bought in 1975 and had the roof re-shingled. So the roof is 37 years old. A roofer offered to do a new roof for $17,000. Is that fair, or reasonable?

LEE MONDALE, Marblehead

A. Considering the size and intricacies of the roof, including that turret, I think that price may indeed be fair. Because the roof is not seen from the yard, I suggest you get plain shingles with a 30-year or 40-year life expectancy. Don’t bother with fancy shingles because you can’t see them. As a final note, those shingles that lasted 37 years and counting, are remarkable. One thing you can do to see if the offer is fair is to invite two more bids.

Full story for subscribers.

Get the full story with unlimited access to

Just 99 cents for four weeks.