With vice-like grip, Japan keeps health costs down - for now
TOKYO - Half a world away from the US health care debate, Japan has a system that costs half as much and often achieves better medical outcomes than its American counterpart. It does so by banning insurance company profits, limiting doctor fees, and accepting shortcomings in care that many well-insured Americans would find intolerable.
The Japanese visit a doctor nearly 14 times a year, more than four times as often as Americans. They can choose any primary care physician or specialist they want, and surveys suggest they are almost always seen on the day they want. All that medical care helps keep the Japanese alive longer than any other people on Earth while fostering one of the world’s lowest infant mortality rates.
Health care in Japan - a hybrid system funded by job-based insurance premiums and taxes - is universal and mandatory and consumes about 8 percent of the nation’s gross domestic product, half as much as in the United States. Unlike in the US system, no one is denied coverage because of a preexisting condition or goes bankrupt because a family member gets sick.
But many health care economists say Japan’s low-cost system is probably not sustainable without significant change. Japan already has the world’s oldest population; by 2050, 40 percent will be 65 or older. The disease mix is becoming more expensive to treat, as rates of cancer, stroke, and Alzheimer’s disease steadily increase. Demand for medical care will triple in the next 25 years, according to a recent analysis by McKinsey & Co., a consulting firm.
Japan has a stagnant economy, with a shortage of young people that hobbles prospects for growth and strangles the capacity of the debt-strapped government to increase health care spending. Without reform, costs are projected to double, reaching current US levels in a decade, according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, or OECD.
For generations, Japan has achieved its successes by maintaining a vise-like grip on costs. After hard bargaining with medical providers every two years, the government sets a price for treatment and drugs - and tolerates no fudging.
As a result, most Japanese doctors make far less money than their U.S. counterparts. Administrative costs are four times lower than they are in the United States, in part because insurance companies do not set rates for treatment or deny claims. By law, they cannot make profits or advertise to attract low-risk, high-profit clients.
To keep costs down, Japan has made tradeoffs in other areas - sometimes to the detriment of patients. Some are merely irritating, such as routine hourlong waits before doctor appointments.
Japanese hospitals experience a “crowding out’’ effect, with space for emergency care and serious medical conditions sometimes overwhelmed by a flood of patients seeking routine treatment, said Naohiro Yashiro, a professor of economics and health-care expert at International Christian University in Tokyo.
“Patients are treated too equally,’’ he said. “Beds are occupied by less-urgent cases, and there are no penalties for those who overuse the system.’’
The government has largely been unable to reduce the length of hospital stays, which are four times as long in Japan as in the United States. Hospital doctors are often overworked and cannot hone specialized life-saving skills, according to recent reports by McKinsey. Statistics show that the Japanese are much less likely to have heart attacks than people in the United States, but that when they do, their chance of dying is twice as high.
Emergency room specialists because of relatively low pay, long hours, and high stress at many hospitals, doctors and health care analysts said. Emergency room service is often spotty; the number of emergency room beds in many hospitals are limited and diagnostic expertise is sometimes lacking. In a highly publicized but not unprecedented incident, a pregnant woman complaining of a severe headache was refused admission last year to seven Tokyo hospitals. She died of an undiagnosed brain hemorrhage after giving birth.
