540 children have died of swine flu, CDC estimates
By Stephen Smith, Globe Staff
Swine flu has killed at least 540 children nationally since emerging in the United States last April, according to federal estimates released today that provide compelling evidence that the novel virus is causing serious illness among more young people than typical seasonal strains.
The report from the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, based on a sophisticated but not-fully-vetted statistical model, estimated that 8 million children fell ill with the H1N1 virus from April through Oct. 17, resulting in 36,000 hospital stays. Children under the age of 18 accounted for more than one-third of all swine flu cases, the report said.
It is not so much that the swine flu is more lethal than the seasonal strain, specialists said. Instead, the virus found a whole swath of millions of children and young adults who had never been exposed to ancestors of this H1N1 strain and who therefore had no natural immunity. And vaccine only started to become available during the past month.
The CDC report did not break out state estimates, but in the past month, coughing, feverish children have flooded Massachusetts emergency rooms. Since early October, two-thirds of those hospitalized with confirmed cases of swine flu have been 18 or younger, according to data provided today by the state Department of Public Health.
Among all age groups in Massachusetts, visits to doctors offices for flu-like symptoms have reached levels almost twice the peaks of recent flu seasons.
The federal figures are especially striking because seasonal viruses tend to do most of their damage in the elderly. In contrast, swine flu is resulting in more deaths among the young, with the new national estimates concluding that 100 more children have died from the disease than adults 65 and older.
"I do believe the pediatric death toll from this pandemic will be extensive and more than we see from the seasonal flu," Dr. Anne Schuchat, a top flu specialist at the CDC, said during a telephone briefing with reporters from the agency's Atlanta headquarters.
Still, specialists in pediatrics and infectious disease sought to reassure anxious parents who have flocked to doctors' offices and public clinics in an often futile quest for flu shots and spray.
In most children, they said, the H1N1 virus doesn't appear to cause symptoms significantly worse than those produced by run-of-the-mill flu.
"You have to have a lot of respect for influenza, but this particular influenza is no worse than the regular one," said Dr. John Schreiber, a pediatric infectious disease specialist at the Floating Hospital for Children at Tufts Medical Center. "It's that so many people are not immune and are getting sick this year."
Laboratory tests show that as of last week, 144 children nationwide had succumbed to swine flu since April, a figure that eclipses the toll for any year since careful tracking of pediatric deaths began in 2004. In Massachusetts, only one of the 15 swine flu deaths has been recorded in a patient younger than 18.
Disease specialists have long suspected that the official death tally captures only a fraction of the virus' genuine impact, however. Flu testing can be imprecise, and a flu infection can unleash a cascade of heart and lung complications, making it difficult to determine the cause of death.
"In those cases, the immediate cause of death might be called respiratory failure, but what set up that chain of events was the influenza infection," said Dr. Lauren Smith, medical director of the Massachusetts Department of Public Health.
So researchers at the CDC developed a new method to better gauge the damage wrought by H1N1, relying on extrapolations based on meticulously gathered data from 62 counties in 10 states. Independent specialists were still poring over the new formula tonight. The CDC has come under fire for some of its earlier attempts to reflect the true trajectory and impact of influenza.
The new estimates project that a total of 22 million Americans have been infected with the H1N1 virus, causing 98,000 to be hospitalized and 3,900 to die.
Since the dawn of swine flu in Massachusetts, 63 to 65 percent of laboratory confirmed cases have been in children under 18, while the elderly have accounted for only 1 percent.
In past years at Children's Hospital Boston, it was rare to see a mid-autumn case of flu. "It's not a November disease at all in Boston," said Dr. Anne Stack, clinical chief in the hospital's emergency department. "But we are definitely seeing influenza here now, and as a result of that we're seeing an increase in our volume in the emergency department."
At the Massachusetts General Hospital for Children on Wednesday night, seven children suspected of having swine flu lay in the intensive care unit. The sickest children, their lungs invaded by the disease and its companion complications, sometimes have to be put on breathing machines.
While some of the children had existing conditions such as asthma that primed them for problems, others had been perfectly fine until they caught the flu, said medical director Dr. Peter Greenspan.
"And the problem is," he said, "the kids who it hits hard, it hits really hard, and they can go downhill pretty quickly."
Contributors
blogger
Elizabeth Cooney is a former
health reporter for the Worcester Telegram & Gazette, where she also was a
business reporter and an editor. Earlier in her career, she edited medical
books and journals at Little, Brown, and worked for Boston magazine.Boston Globe Health and Science staff:
- Gideon Gil, Health and Science Editor
- Ishani Ganguli, Short White Coat blogger







