< Back to front page Text size +

South Park, Scientology, and Isaac Hayes

Posted by Michael Paulson August 11, 2008 02:36 PM

chef.jpg

Isaac Hayes is being remembered in many ways today, but here at the religion desk, we pause to recall his staunch defense of Scientology, which led him to resign as the voice of Chef (right) on "South Park" to protest an episode that mocked his faith. The "South Park" folks, in return, killed him off, or at least seemed to.

The incident in which Chef is killed (which originally aired on March 22, 2006) is too gruesome for me to post (and it's not funny either, IMHO), but for a taste of what got Hayes so exercised, below is a clip called "Stan Chooses Scientology.''

The Globe's Joseph P. Kahn commented on the Hayes-South Park dust-up in 2006, writing:

"Hayes played Chef on 'South Park' for nine irreverent years, during which the show mocked virtually every religious group under the sun. Nevertheless, he asked to be contractually released Monday, saying, 'Religious beliefs are sacred to people, and at all times should be respected and honored.'"

And in the New York Times, also in 2006, Alessandra Stanley reflected on the relationship between celebrity, Scientology and South Park, writing:

"Isaac Hayes left 'South Park' after an episode of the animated series on Comedy Central savagely mocked his religion, the Church of Scientology, and its most famous follower, Tom Cruise. Earlier this month, Comedy Central pulled a rerun of the offending episode, 'Trapped in the Closet,' after speculation that Mr. Cruise was displeased. Viacom, the parent company of Paramount, is about to release Mr. Cruise's movie, 'Mission: Impossible III.' Oh, and Viacom also owns Comedy Central. It looks like two sides are pretty much even. Yet the creators of 'South Park' didn't make fun of Viacom's pliability on the premiere of the show's 10th season Wednesday night. Instead, Matt Stone and Trey Parker reserved their scorn for Mr. Hayes and the Church of Scientology: the episode was entirely devoted to portraying Mr. Hayes's character, Chef, as the victim of a sinister brainwashing cult."

(BTW, if you visit the South Park web site today, among the top searches, not surprisingly, is Isaac Hayes.)

Email this article

Invalid email address
Invalid email address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

51 comments so far...
  1. The writers of Southpark would write anything that gets a cheap laugh! Comedy has become trash. One day those who condone religious discrimination will be living in their own trash. What comes around goes around.
    Lets pay some respect to Isaac Hayes and his magic that he brought to so many and get this and other "mockery" shows off the air!

    Posted by Ged August 11, 08 05:50 PM
  1. Cheap laugh? Try satirical ingeniousness that helps us laugh about all some of things that are so wrong with this world. For example - Censorship of free speech, terrorism, and Scientology (which could probably go hand in hand with the first two.)
    God rest his soul - if he never joined the cult he would probably still be alive since Scientology forbids any psychiatric treatment (which helps people that have suffered from strokes.)

    Posted by Dave August 11, 08 06:24 PM
  1. "Comedy has become trash."

    Get off his lawn! Nothing's funny unless Ged says it's funny!

    What a maroon.

    Posted by Dan August 11, 08 07:30 PM
  1. Let's simply remember a great artist and man for his accomplishments.

    Posted by Monty August 11, 08 07:38 PM
  1. Isaac Hayes will be remembered.

    By the way, more people have died in psychiatric mental institutions than in all major wars since 1776. Who in their right mind would want to go see one of those charlatans?

    Posted by PepsiJuror August 11, 08 07:48 PM
  1. More people have died in mental institutions than in all major wars since 1776.

    Posted by PepsiJuror August 11, 08 08:09 PM
  1. Hayes didn't have a problem with all the other religions that Parker & Stone ridiculed, so why the double standard with the Scientology episode?

    Posted by elebaud August 11, 08 08:24 PM
  1. Those bigotted internet hackers probably killed him somehow. They just released another You Tubes video promising something big... I bet they used their contacts inside the International Gay Conspiracy, the Psyche's, the Shriners, the Knights Templar, the OTO and Skull and Bones to send an electrical signal causing his treadmill to overload.

    Posted by Herbert August 11, 08 08:32 PM
  1. They make fun of all,to say they finally went to far(scientology) would be saying its ok to rip on everything else(gays,religions,ect..) but how dare you rip on my beliefs!what makes scientology special?all should be fair game.THANKYOU VERY MUCH SOUTH PARK,4 MAKING US ALL LAUGH!which brings us all TOGETHER!I will never quit watching!

    Posted by Rob Postle August 11, 08 08:46 PM
  1. I'd like to say, there are a lot of sockpuppet commenters in this thread, lotsa people with agendas......just saying........

    A fire....you must DIE in it

    Posted by rickglass August 11, 08 09:07 PM
  1. Isaac Hayes didn't quit South Park of his own volition and didn't personally have a problem with the Tom Cruise episode. Scientologists basically forced him to quit, even issuing a BS press release on his behalf.

    http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,401321,00.html

    Posted by David August 11, 08 09:10 PM
  1. It's a damn shame. I Think some of the blame does rest on Scientology . Roger Friedman (a personal friend of Hayes) wrote a very interesting article about the subject of Isaac Hayes and Scientology. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,401321,00.html

    By the way. That number of people who died in psychiatric institutions is complete BS. I always found Scientology's hatred of Psychiatry ironic considering Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard died with a psych drug (Vistaril) in his system. Don't believe me? Just look at his Tox report. http://www.xenu.net/archive/hubbardcoroner/

    Posted by Chester August 11, 08 09:19 PM
  1. Hernbert you are insane.
    (Unfortunatly you can;t take anything for that can you?)
    He wouldn't have had the Stroke if David Miscavige hadn't made him give up his livlihood and then still demands so much money from him.
    The cult is responcible for his Death. Just another skull on their heap.

    Posted by Madame_Guillotine August 11, 08 09:22 PM
  1. Sadly ,whether Isaac was great or not,scientology remains a dangerous cult. The extent to which CO$ controlled Isaac is not up for dispute. It's whether celebrity's are targeted purely to advertise the cult or is it that they are so vulnerable it make them attractive to Cults.
    Co$ do not morn the passing of a Human Being but the loss of revenue.
    Yours truthfully Paul.

    Posted by Paul McGeown August 11, 08 09:25 PM
  1. "The evil men do lives after them, good oft interred with their bones."

    Good bye poor old hypocritical Hayes... Some generations will miss you... others will be glad your gone.

    Posted by tiredofstupidpeople August 11, 08 09:32 PM
  1. I wonder if Ged is a Scientologist bot monitoring any board regarding Mr. Hayes today... They typically don't have a sense of humour....And like to project their "brand of un-humour" onto others....

    Posted by AnnonnyMoose August 11, 08 09:34 PM
  1. Pepsijuror, I'd love to see you back that statistic up. I don't think you can, since there is no possible way that more than 124 million people (the estimated amount of people killed, military and civilian, during the course of World War II) have been killed in any combination of worldwide mental institutions.

    Of course, you, being a member of CCHR/Scientology/WISE, love to spout off that statistic, but can you find proof to back it up? No. Always attack, never defend, that's the L. Ron way.

    At any rate, RIP Isaac; we'll miss your chocolate salty balls.

    Posted by Anonymous August 11, 08 09:35 PM
  1. "More people have died in mental institutions than in all major wars since 1776."

    CITATION NEEDED!


    ("Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.")

    Posted by David Mudkips August 11, 08 09:40 PM
  1. Isaac Hayes was a Scientologist who lived like many other people who consider themselves Christians, good people, and true Americans. People who are Scientologists live with a high ethical standard and support this wonderful world we live in. Its unfortunate that this group called (Anonymou$) are drug abusing, professional protestors, who waste tax payers money because they give nothing to society. I know who you guys are, the loosers who in high school had dandrif, bad breathe, and never got invited to partys or social events. Now you want some attention so you go after the same people that were popular and had everything growing up. Ahhhh, poor internet geeks. get a f#$@&ing life, go shower, brush your teath, buy some new clothes and maybe somebody will like you.

    Posted by Baller August 11, 08 09:50 PM
  1. BREAKING NEWS!!!

    Mr. Hayes died from OT8 overdose!!!

    Posted by lolcocks August 11, 08 10:01 PM
  1. "By the way, more people have died in psychiatric mental institutions than in all major wars since 1776."

    You are a moron, and I cannot wait until your cult crumbles and free practice(in FULL) of Scientology is allowed-- as the Freezoners do.

    Posted by Dio Brando August 11, 08 10:11 PM
  1. His liver probably had enough of his Scientology niacin 4000 mg daily dose. This cult kills!

    Posted by anonymous August 11, 08 10:19 PM
  1. Baller:

    Isaac Hayes was a decent guy both before and after he joined Scientology. The only mistake he made was giving any of his money to the cult.

    I like how you put a dollar sign in Anonymous. Is this meant to suggest that critics of the cult are on the German psychiatrists' payroll? I'm still waiting for my paycheck....

    Posted by Anonymous August 11, 08 10:26 PM
  1. '...Its unfortunate that this group called (Anonymou$) are drug abusing, professional protestors, who waste tax payers money because they give nothing to society. I know who you guys are, the loosers who in high school had dandrif, bad breathe, and never got invited to partys or social events. Now you want some attention so you go after the same people that were popular and had everything growing up. Ahhhh, poor internet geeks. get a f#$@&ing life, go shower, brush your teath, buy some new clothes and maybe somebody will like you.'

    Baller: Replace 'Anonymous' with 'Scientologists' and you have a far more accurate picture of the true nature of the COS. Not that they'll ever tell the public that... C'mon, OSA! Can't you present a more believable accusation than the above quote? I must have seen that EXACT SAME ACCUSATION over a hundred times in various comment sections on blogs, news sites and gossip pages since this whole thing started. Unless you can present SOLID PROOF that Anon is what you claim it to be, than you're just blowing hot air.

    Try to be a little more original with your accusations, OSA. The ones you have right now get old fast. Anonymous is BORED AS HELL. Give us something NEW to work with!

    Posted by A Watcher August 11, 08 10:37 PM
  1. Isaac Hayes was and is the man. South Park is funny if you don't take life that seriously......(sigh) I am conflicted. Celebrity calls to mind that strange dichotomy of existence. Life is a paradox. My opinion is flawed....yet perfect. Necessary but useless. As are we all.....and none of us. Poo poo platter.

    Posted by spankyspiderpants August 11, 08 10:38 PM
  1. Rest in Peace Isaac Hayes. The world has lost a kind-hearted and talented man.

    I would like to correct some falsehoods surrounding his involvement in Scientology and his departure from South Park. In public comments he stated that while he didn't agree with the "Trapped in the Closet" episode of South Park (which lampooned Scientology) he emphasized that he understood South Park makes fun of everybody. On the Opie & Anthony Show he said that he had no problem with the way Matt and Trey handled the Scientology episode. He loved his role as Chef, and did not want to leave South Park, but he faced extreme pressure from Scientology leaders to distance himself from the hit TV show.

    In January 2006 Isaac Hayes suffered a stroke, and in March a statement was issued by the Church of Scientology on his behalf, announcing his resignation from South Park.

    The New York Post reported that the press release announcing he had left South Park was not written by Isaac Hayes. The release was put out by fellow Scientologist Christina "Kumi" Kimball, a fashion executive for designer Craig Taylor.

    He was pushed into leaving South Park because according to Scientology policy, Scientologists must disconnect from anyone considered to be an enemy of Scientology - even close friends and family members may be disconnected.

    Google "Isaac Hayes back stabbed by Scientology" to find out about what happened in 2006.

    Posted by Brian Peters August 11, 08 10:49 PM
  1. And wouldn't you know it the internet bigots show up.

    Posted by Jason August 11, 08 10:55 PM
  1. Never take life, or your role in it, too seriously.

    That should be the mantra for all people on this planet, whatever race, religion or creed they may be.

    Unfortunately, most religions are judged by their public image which is usually the result of some type of celebrity expounding on their beliefs. Most Hollyweird types leave a bit to be desired when you're looking around for role models. And for Christianity or Scientology, or any other religion to depend on today's celebrities to project a good image for them, is a huge mistake on their part.

    Posted by Pete Cline August 11, 08 11:23 PM
  1. Ged you are truly tapt in the head if you believe south park is trash, read between the lines of every episode and you will see the substance of a great show that provokes peoples thinking and addresses issues that need to be addressed.

    As for mr Hayes...

    I will remember Isaac as the jolly old guy who always broke into song, i will remember Isaac as someone who gave us advice to live our lives by. So you see we should be mad at Isaac, we should be mad at that fruity little club for scrambling his brains. and i know that somewhere out their, theres the good part of Isaac thats alive in us all.

    Posted by Ben August 11, 08 11:53 PM
  1. Yes, Jason Scilons are everywhere.
    It is a shame they think themselves above everyone else on earth and use terms like 'raw meat ' and 'Worthy Oriental gentalman" to discribe those outside their faith.

    But please don't hold it against the poor scilons. They have been brainwashed and tricked into believing the only way they will be happy is to give all their money to the cult. That;s why they do all those terrible things to people inside and outside the cult.

    Once the illegality of OSA and RPF and forced abortions in Sea Org, not to mention the falsified tax stuff, they wont be able to hurt any more people.

    No more mentally Ill Scilons killing their families, no more people in their care dying of dehydration with Coakroach bites all over their bodies.

    Posted by Madame Guillotine August 11, 08 11:57 PM
  1. Jason: And wouldn't YOU know it that OSA shows they have no rhetoric other than calling anyone who questions their 'religious practices' a bigot or throw out some other unfounded accusations. Unless you can provide EVIDENCE of bigotry in these questions Jason, then GTFO.

    Posted by A Watcher August 12, 08 12:05 AM
  1. RIP Chef, we'll miss you.

    It's a shame he got mixed up in that crazy cult.

    Posted by Fran August 12, 08 12:21 AM
  1. "More people have died in mental institutions than in all major wars since 1776."

    maybe because for so long people didn't know any better, medical fields have advanced alot over the last 150 years. before then people didn't know you needed a clean room and tools to operate on a person

    Posted by the anti August 12, 08 12:29 AM
  1. Once again scientology comments on this forum show how sad they are. What has the number of people who have died in Psychiatry since 1776 got to do with Isaac Hayes death? Aside from the quote being bogus Isaac wasn't in Psychiatry when he died, he was in Scientology. How about LRH quote "Criminals ALWAYS accuse others of the crimes they commit". One wonders then why Scientologists are throwing this "number of deaths since 1776" accusation against Psychiatry around at a time like this.

    been indoctrine

    Posted by David R August 12, 08 01:52 AM
  1. I think this is the time to remember Isaac. He was an artist who touched a lot of lives. He bridged gaps in music, race, religion and cultures. He was an extremely talented and gently man. He helped blacks, whites, rich and poor, young and old. He was a husband and a father. The world is better for him having been here. Goodbye Isaac Hayes.

    Posted by Gayle August 12, 08 02:49 AM
  1. Isaac Hayes was a good artist and scientologist.
    I agree with his decision to leave "South Park".
    I would have done the same.

    Posted by FrankG August 12, 08 04:33 AM
  1. Issac Hayes was so much more than Chef on South Park or a member of a controversial church. He was Stax Volt! His music defines his greatness. The Theme from Shaft is as great as Gershwins Rhapsody in Blue and Hold on I'm Coming equals anything by the great James Brown.
    Yet people use his passing to make their political points ....So Bostonian!

    Posted by Thomas J Lane August 12, 08 06:36 AM
  1. “Its unfortunate that this group called (Anonymou$) are drug abusing, professional protestors, who waste tax payers money because they give nothing to society. I know who you guys are, the loosers who in high school had dandrif, bad breathe, and never got invited to partys or social events. Now you want some attention so you go after the same people that were popular and had everything growing up. Ahhhh, poor internet geeks. get a f#$@&ing life, go shower, brush your teath, buy some new clothes and maybe somebody will like you.”

    Firstly:
    *protesters
    *losers
    *dandruff
    *breath
    *parties
    *teeth

    And f**k is four letters, not five.

    Now, I love Hubbard’s “always attack, never defend” policy. First we were terrorists (because peaceful protests and internet pranks = terrorism, and it totally harms people) and religious bigots (because pointing out abuses in a corrupt organisation is totally bigotry – we’ve always only protested against abuse like fair game and the RPF; and fraud, like promising OT powers which are never delivered and not telling people you believe in Xenu until they’ve payed enough money and are indoctrinated completely. We have NEVER gone after individuals, or protested against their right t have Scientology religious beliefs).

    Now apparently, we’re being payed to protest, and we smell (Good argument! People who smell bad never have good causes!). Now firstly, I’d like to know where you got the information that we’re payed to protest. Do you have any evidence of this? Even just anecdotal evidence – I want to know where you got this idea.

    Secondly, have you met every single one of us, smelt their breath, looked at their hair, and watched them to see if they got invited to parties or social events? What’s that? No, you haven’t, and it’s impossible to do so anyway because they’re all anonymous and you have no idea who they are?

    And finally, whether we’re smelly and professional or not, this doesn’t have anything to do with our message. The cult of $cientology still practices fair game, they still destroy families, they still have their own abusive re-education camps for members who step out of line. The internet is still full of evidence of all this, and the public still deserves to know about it. The “always attack, never defend” policy always results in Ad Hominem, a logical fallacy – you can say whatever horrible things about us you want, but our point will still stand regardless. Saying we’re horrible people will NOT make the Church of Scientology any less of an abusive, fraudulent, manipulative, criminal, destructive, for-profit CULT.

    Posted by Shamus-shamus August 12, 08 06:44 AM
  1. Poor pro scientologists, don't know what they got themselves into.

    RIP Mr. Hayes.

    www.xenu.net
    www.exscientologykids.com/

    Posted by anonymous August 12, 08 09:21 AM
  1. Rational nonbelievers face a stacked deck all the time. The scientologists and the others in the sham business of religion shouldn't complain. Our constitution says there shall be no religious test to hold office, but religion (along with false patriotism) is a refuge for the scoundrels in politics.

    Posted by Dan Tanner August 12, 08 09:45 AM
  1. Why is this being discussed in a religious blog? Scientology is not a religion but a spoof, invented by a science-fiction writer who was actively interested in child abuse, hypnosis, brain-washing, devil-worship, but above all in making money. He sold it first as a self-improvement scheme. Nothing to do with religion.

    Dear Isaac lived well beyond the average age for a member of this dangerous cult: their appalling treatment of their members would make a more interesting and useful topic.

    Posted by Sam Gregors August 12, 08 09:55 AM
  1. Isaac Hayes would still be alive today if he had received REAL medical treatment for his stroke and subsequent health issues - but the Church of Scientology continues to ilegally practice their own version of psychiatry/medicine, a version that has been proven does nothing to improve the patients health.

    The Church of Scientology International is responsible for Isaac Hayes death and criminal charges should be made.

    Posted by Catastrophe August 12, 08 10:48 AM
  1. The episode in which Chef is killed sent the message that people shouldn't hate Isaac for leaving the show in support of Scientology but that the anger should be directed to those who cornered him into hypocrisy. i.e. The "church".

    They prey on the good in people to separate them from their hard earned money.

    Isaac Hayes was a beautiful man and I have nothing against people believing whatever they want - it is the "church" and not the "faith" that I oppose.

    RIP Isaac, your time is your own now.

    Posted by Who's the man we all miss....chef August 12, 08 11:05 AM
  1. You can see a really cool Isaac Hayes performance in the concert film "Wattstax," about a big free concert they held in South Central Los Angeles in 1972.

    Scientology is a vicious multi-national criminal racket. It is much, much worse than you probably think. What kind of "religion" has an internal prison gulag? What kind of "religion" goes by the credo of "Always attack, never defend"? What kind of "religion" prevents an older gentleman who has had a serious stroke from taking the proper medications, and then advises him to run, unsupervised, on a treadmill, as a way to "sweat out toxins"? Answer: Scientology. Anyone who thinks Scientology is a religion needs to see a Psychiatrist immediately.

    Posted by Dr-Lilly-von-Marcab August 12, 08 11:19 AM
  1. Mister Hayes might have lasted longer outside of a cult that believes that all ailments are created in the mind. Scientologists will tell you that using their "tech" will improve you physically, mentally, and in terms of quality of life. They then tell you that Scientology is the only way to do this. This traps most members of this cult in an unhealthy spiral of hypnotic trances, worthless sauna treatments, overdoses of b vitamins, instead of going to a physician. Real health experts are mistrusted because they can prove without a doubt that Scientology does zero for your health. Scientology was invented not by a holy man, but a science fiction writer. L. Ron Hubbard's concern was not helping people on "the way to happiness," his goal was to make money, make more money, and make others make money to satisfy his greed. It is also interesting to note that LRH had almost no scientific background and moreover had no peer reviewed evidence that his philosophies worked. To be a Scientologist, you must agree to be controlled by LRH's policies. You must follow every directive or risk Scientology punishment, which includes slave labor. In this sense, Isaac Hayes was being a "good Scientologist" by quitting South Park. You will never hear a Scientologist criticising their own religion. They are directed to disconnect immediately from anyone who does criticise (family included). This is obviously a philosophical pyramid scheme, as you have to buy your way up "the bridge to total freedom." Parishioners are directed to sell as many Scientology texts as possible to maximize the take for church management. It is a business. Isaac Hayes was by no means religious; he was just participating in a scam invented by a mentally ill dead person.

    Posted by Inscrutable Eye August 12, 08 03:18 PM
  1. you know this does crack me up

    "Its unfortunate that this group called (Anonymou$) are drug abusing, professional protestors, who waste tax payers money because they give nothing to society"

    i'm sorry but i don't do any drugs

    the other other protest i been to was a war protest last year, and i didn't even know it was going on till i got there

    and i waste tax payer money? isn't scientology sucking up more tax dollars trying to take over the world by not paying them?

    Posted by the anti August 12, 08 10:12 PM
  1. There's an implied fact here which isn't true.

    Issac Hayes did not resign from South Park because of the Scientology episode. He did go to South Park creator Matt Stone to tell him that he was being pressured by Scientology to quit.

    The episode aired in November 2005 - Hayes had a stroke in January 2006, we were told that he wouldn't be returning for health reasons - In March 2006, Scientology offered press releases in Issac's name and a signed letter of resignation.

    But no one interviewed Issac Hayes about it, because he was still recovering from a stroke two months prior and literally could not talk.

    Who quits "in anger" 4 months after an episode aired ?

    Posted by Kate Noelle August 12, 08 11:24 PM
  1. WHY IS THERE SO MANY NEGATIVE COMMENTS IN REGARD TO A PERSON THAT HAS PASS AWAY, WHY CANT YOU BE SENSITIVE TO THE FAMILY.

    Posted by E.F. August 13, 08 10:00 AM
  1. Isaac Hayes We will remember you fondly

    Posted by mike August 13, 08 11:56 PM
  1. @all
    Read the bio on his own website to know soemthing about this great artist.
    http://www.isaachayes.com
    Why listen to peoples which are not knowing him?
    Why listen to people like Friedman which was the first person to "use" the death of Isaac to attack Scientology?
    Why not simply listen his music and honor this man!!
    I love your music Isaac, I don't know you personally and I think all other here knows anything more.
    SHUT UP!! anti,Kate noelle,inscrutable eye, Who's the man we all miss....chef,
    and all other bygots go and find "Lulz" somwhere else not related to a person like Isaac Hayes, which is no longer under us.

    Posted by Marie September 10, 08 12:16 PM
  1. Its real simple what Trey and Matt did was for fun just like they did with any race, war and religion no one had a problem with it, Issac hayes didn't even have a problem with it. Scientology had to have brainwashed the famous actor/guy who wrote the shaft theme, because after they stepped in he changed his statement from being ok with it to being outraged to it. Scientology had a policy called disconnection where pretty much you have to sever ties with people who are deemed a threat to scientology. They don't give a flying f@$* if they are your best freind, co-worker, spouse or family member. They took what was just a joke as a threat and told issac "oh by the way your friends of south park are xenu's servents so you are not aloud to hang out with them anymore." which he did. so why did he die, if he did what they told him to do. The reason was he was not brainwahsted. They killed him because he was gonna leave. otherwise they would have just left him be when he disconnected from south park.

    Posted by Whistleblower November 11, 09 11:03 AM

Blogger

Michael Paulson covers religion for The Boston Globe. He shared in the Pulitzer Prize in 2003, won the Mike Berger, Templeton and Supple awards in 2008, and is a four-time winner of the Wilbur Award.
E-mail mpaulson@globe.com.

views

Harvey_Cox_cow.JPGHarvey Cox, the Hollis professor of divinity at Harvard University, marks his retirement by asserting a little-used right of his professorship -- to graze a cow in Harvard Yard. Photo, by Barry Chin of the Globe staff, taken on Sept. 10, 2009 in Cambridge, Mass.

archives