< Back to front page Text size +

Mistrial declared in 2007 Boston murder case

September 22, 2009 02:32 PM

Video by John R. Ellement

A Suffolk Superior Court jury told a judge today that they were hopelessly deadlocked, leading the judge to order new trials for two Boston men accused of shooting an innocent bystander on a Roxbury street in 2007.

Antwan Carter, 20, and Daniel Pinckney Jr., 21, were being tried for first-degree murder in the shooting of Cedirick Steele on March 14, 2007, as Steele stood near the intersection of Centre Street and Highland Avenue.

Prosecutors contend Steele was shot solely because the defendants wanted to shoot someone in that neighborhood and that Steele was not involved in any gang activity as the two defendants allegedly were.

In a note sent to Superior Court Judge Linda Giles today, jurors said they had reached verdicts on all the counts against the two men -- but the decisions were not unanimous as required by law.

The jurors held one more vote -- to decide if they could still try to reach unanimity -- and that fell on a 11-1 count. From the bench, Giles told jurors they should not feel ashamed that they were unable to decide the case.

She said that 11 of the 12 jurors deliberated for seven days -- a juror was removed and a new juror added last Friday -- totaling 40 hours.

In a statement, Suffolk District Attorney Daniel F. Conley's office said both men will be retried. The attorneys had agreed to meet Oct. 20 to set a new trial date. Before the jury began deliberations, Giles found Carter not guilty of a charge of witness intimidation, a charge that rested heavily on tape recordings and letters Carter made while awaiting trial that were seized by authorities through a search warrant.

Some relatives of Steele and the defendants had a brief shouting match in the hallway after the mistrial was declared, but Boston police and court officers separated them without any further difficulties.

E-mail this article

Invalid email address
Invalid email address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

On the beat

Reporter Milton J. Valencia is covering the federal appeals court ruling striking down the Defense of Marriage Act.
Milton J. Valencia
TALK TO US
breakingnews@globe.com | Twitter | 617-929-3100
loading video... (please wait a moment)
archives

LOCAL BLOGS

BOSTON AREA

Universal Hub

A collection of writing from hundreds of Boston-area bloggers.

The Chinatown Blog

Stories and events related to Boston's Chinatown and the Asian American community in Massachusetts

CommonWealth Magazine

Politics, ideas, and civic life in Massachusetts

Red Mass Group

News and commentary about Massachusetts and beyond

Blue Mass Group

Politics in Massachusetts and around the nation

Boston 1775

History, analysis, and unabashed gossip about the start of the American Revolution.
COLLEGE NEWSPAPER SITES

The Berkeley Beacon

The weekly student newspaper at Emerson College

The Daily Collegian

The student newspaper of UMass-Amherst.

The Daily Free Press

The independent student newspaper at Boston University

The Harvard Crimson

The nation's oldest continuously published daily college newspaper.

The Heights

The independent student newspaper of Boston College

The Huntington News

The independent student newspaper of Northeastern University

The Suffolk Journal

Suffolk University's student-run newspaper

The Tech

MIT's oldest and largest newspaper

The Tufts Daily

The independent student newspaper of Tufts University