Keating ekes out win against Perry
Democrat William R. Keating claimed a narrow victory last night in the state’s most closely watched congressional race in years, as the Scott Brown-style surge that Republicans were counting on to carry them to victory in the 10th District failed to materialize.
With more than 95 percent of precincts reporting, Keating was maintaining a lead of more than 10,000 votes over Republican Jeffrey D. Perry, in a district that stretches from Quincy to Provincetown and the Islands. Perry, a state representative from Sandwich and a favorite of the Tea Party movement, had been counting on the same energy that buoyed Brown in January, to make him the first Republican to win a House seat in Massachusetts since the 1990s. Brown’s 20-point margin in the district in the special US Senate election in January was seen as priming the district for a seemingly similar independent-minded Republican.
But as the results poured in last night, Keating won or was competitive with Perry in town after town where Brown had scored massive victories. For example, Brown won Cohasset by 26 points in January; Keating claimed it by 2 points. Rockland gave Brown a 31-point margin; Keating won it by 9.
The race has been one of the closest, most expensive, and nastiest in recent Massachusetts political history as Keating, Perry, and three independent candidates vied to replace Representative William D. Delahunt, who announced last spring that he would retire after 14 years.
‘‘I will fight each and every day to earn your trust,’’ Keating said, declaring victory before cheering supporters just before 11 p.m. ‘‘Today I heard the voters, Massachusetts heard you, and America heard you. You put your mark on Washington today and I will fight heart and soul to prove you right.’’
Moments later, Perry appeared in front of a crowd at a resort in Hyannis to concede.
‘‘We offered the people in the 10th District a choice. They made a different choice,’’ Perry said. ‘‘I’m not standing here feeling bad,’’ he added. ‘‘I’m standing here feeling very blessed.’’
Interviews with voters suggested that Perry’s past hung over the race and may have contributed to his defeat. A former police officer in Wareham, Perry’s role in two different illegal strip-searches of teenage girls in the early 1990s by an officer under his command was repeatedly reprised during the campaign.
While Perry was not charged or disciplined in the cases, Keating and his allies launched a barrage of negative ads and mailers that targeted the Republican as untrustworthy. And two weeks before the election, one of the women who had been strip-searched broke her long silence to speak out against Perry, saying he was unfit for office because he did not stop the assault.
‘‘Perry, to me, was in his personal behavior, reprehensible,’’ said 66-year-old Ruth Harrington, while voting for Keating in Hingham. ‘‘I would never vote for a man like that. People say, ‘Well, it happened in the past.’ Would you say that if it were your sister?’’
In Marshfield, John White, 60, a data center technician who was supporting Jill Stein in the governor’s race, said he had cast a ballot for Keating but was mostly voting against Perry.
‘‘It’s more of a vote against Perry, based on who I think he is,’’ he said ‘‘I think the biggest killer was the story going around about the girl getting strip-searched nearby and him doing nothing. That’s a killer for me.’’
Some voters, however, said they were swayed to vote for Perry because of the negative ads.
‘‘It backfired with me,’’ said Dick Low, 63, a doctor in Hingham. ‘‘It was nasty, and you have no idea how to judge how factual it is.’’
And in Marshfield, Ellen Dow, 45, said she had been impressed by Perry’s attitude during the campaign. ‘‘He seems like he’s going to work hard,’’ she said.
Last night Perry’s mother, Millie Perry, bemoaned the effect of the negative ads.
‘‘I think my son ran a clean campaign. I think that’s why he lost,’’ she said.
But at Perry’s election night party the crowds gathering around a pair of TV sets absorbed the growing gap between their candidate and Keating, with the mood growing quieter. Dozens pulled on coats and left the ballroom, as Perry continued to make the rounds, greeting supporters. Younger voters, still on their feet, said they would hold out hope until the end, while older campaign workers sat back in their chairs.
One of the bigger surprises of the night was in Plymouth, where Brown won by 28 percentage points in January. A sprawling community known for having a conservative bent by Massachusetts standards, Plymouth went for Perry by only 163 votes.
The congressional race also featured three independent candidates, who combined attracted more than 10 percent of the total vote. The top vote-getter of the three, Maryanne Lewis, received more than 16,000 votes, or 6 percent of the total.
Hingham voter David Drinkwater, 44, said he voted for Lewis out of disgust with both Perry and Keating.
Asked what he liked about Lewis, Drinkwater said, ‘‘nothing. But I didn’t like Keating’s ads against Perry, and I didn’t like Perry either.’’
It’s unclear, however, how those independents affected the final outcome. Another candidate, former Quincy mayor James A. Sheets, for example, garnered more than 10,000 votes, including many from his city, which otherwise went strongly for Keating.
Alan Wirzbicki can be reached at awirzbicki@globe.com. David Filipov, Jenna Russell, and Sean Murphy contributed reporting.
On the beat

Reporter
Milton J. Valencia is covering the federal appeals court ruling striking down the Defense of Marriage Act. |
|
Recent stories from the MetroDesk


Features

Editor's Choice

A pastor's dream, a church in crisis

Out of pain long past, he forges hope
- Ambitious emissions plan called lagging
- Adrian Walker: Stopped for being black
- Science with a beautiful, and complicated, view
- Chairs bring change of pace to Harvard Yard

From Today's Globe
- Elizabeth Warren acknowledges telling Harvard, Penn of Native American status
- Limitation on child sexual abuse complaints may be extended
- Whitey Bulger cooperated with FBI as early as '50s
- Governor Patrick endorses Elizabeth Warren
- 2 facelotteryfraudcounts

LOCAL BLOGS
Universal Hub
The Chinatown Blog
CommonWealth Magazine
Red Mass Group
Blue Mass Group
Boston 1775
The Berkeley Beacon
The Daily Collegian
The Daily Free Press
The Harvard Crimson
The Heights
The Huntington News
The Suffolk Journal
The Tech
The Tufts Daily







