ATLANTA -- Women with advanced breast cancer soon may have another treatment option: A novel experimental drug delayed the growth of tumors nearly twice as long as standard chemotherapy did in patients who had stopped responding to Herceptin, doctors reported yesterday.
The experimental drug, Tykerb, worked so well that an international study of it was stopped early, in March, and all participants were offered the drug.
In the study, women who received Tykerb plus the chemotherapy drug Xeloda had no growth of their tumors for an average of 8 1/2 months. That compares with 4 1/2 months for those given only Xeloda, said Dr. Charles Geyer Jr. of Allegheny General Hospital in Pittsburgh.
He led the study and reported the results yesterday at a meeting in Atlanta of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.
Tykerb's manufacturer, British-based
``This is huge," said Dr. Roy Herbst, a cancer specialist at the University of Texas's M.D. Anderson Cancer Center in Houston, who had no role in the study but has consulted for Glaxo in the past.
``The next step will be to use it in patients instead of Herceptin up front," to see whether it is more effective, he said.
Herceptin and Tykerb are members of a new generation of cancer medicines that more precisely target tumors without killing many healthy cells. Herceptin has been an important option for many women with advanced breast cancer, but eventually it stops working and women succumb to the disease.
Tykerb works in a similar yet completely novel way. Like Herceptin, it targets a protein called HER-2/neu, which is made in abnormally large quantities in roughly one-fourth of all breast cancers.
Herceptin blocks the protein on the cell's surface; Tykerb does it inside the cell, and blocks a second abnormal protein, too.
The benefits seemed to come without serious side effects -- at least in this study of 321 women, Geyer said. Diarrhea, mostly mild, and rash were more common in women taking Tykerb.
No patients developed heart failure, but four of the 160 on the drug combination had a modest decrease in pumping power of the main chamber of the heart -- side effects also seen with Herceptin.
Tykerb has one big advantage over Herceptin -- it's a pill instead of an intravenous drug, which should make it cheaper and easier to use, doctors said.
But Dr. Pamela Klein, a vice president at
``Both of them together may be better than either of them alone," said Dr. Julie Gralow, a specialist in breast cancer at the University of Washington and Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center in Seattle.
Breast cancer is the most common major cancer in American women and the second leading cause of cancer deaths in women.
Between 10 and 20 percent of breast cancers are advanced or have already started to spread at the time they are diagnosed. Average survival with this type of cancer is about two years.
Tykerb produced mixed results when tested in 416 patients with advanced kidney cancer. It made no difference in survival or disease progression for the group as a whole, but a subset of patients with high levels of an abnormal protein the drug targets had more time before their tumors started to grow, said study leader Dr. Alain Ravaud, of the University Hospital of Bordeaux, France.