Ind. GOP pushes bigger school voucher program
Choice is goal; critics fear harm to public schools
INDIANAPOLIS — Indiana’s Republican leadership is pushing ahead with a proposal that would be the nation’s broadest use of school vouchers, allowing even middle-class families to use taxpayer money to send their children to private schools.
Unlike other systems that are limited to lower-income households, children with special needs, or those in failing schools, this one would be open to a much larger pool of students, including those whose parents earn up to $60,000 a year. And within three years, there would be no limit on the number of children who could enroll.
“The goal is to make sure as many kids as possible get choice,’’ said Robert Enlow, president of the Foundation for Educational Choice, an Indianapolis-based advocacy group pushing for school vouchers.
Students receiving vouchers make up less than 1 percent of school enrollment nationwide, but vouchers have been one of the top priorities among conservatives. Indiana’s Republican-controlled Legislature hopes to deliver soon on its long-sought overhaul of public education now that Democrats who fled the state have returned.
Democrats in the House stayed in Illinois for five weeks to deprive the chamber of a quorum because they did not have enough votes to stop the voucher proposal and others they oppose.
The vouchers are government-issued certificates that can be applied to private tuition, essentially allowing parents to use some of the tax dollars that would normally be sent to public schools at other institutions.
The vouchers do not carry any additional expense for the state because they mainly transfer money between schools. But public-school advocates and many Democrats have long opposed large-scale voucher programs, saying they could siphon tax money from local districts, potentially leading to a steep decline in the quality of education.
“It’s a national agenda,’’ said Senate Minority Leader Vi Simpson, a Democrat from Bloomington. “And I think Indiana is the victim of it.’’
Until now, most voucher programs in the rest of the country have been limited to poor students, those in chronically failing schools, or those with special needs.
Indiana’s system would be significantly larger, offering money to students from middle-class homes and solid school districts. Though Republicans have agreed to some restrictions — to appease both Democrats and skeptics in their own ranks — the program would still be the most expansive in the United States.
“We fund education for a reason — to give individual children the skills they need to compete in life,’’ said Luke Messer, former executive director of the Indiana Republican Party who now heads School Choice Indiana. “If the money follows the child, parents ought to have the right to put their child in whatever opportunity they think would best serve their family.’’
Because the GOP controls both chambers and the governor’s office, some form of the legislation is likely to pass.
Voucher critics have watched the debate with alarm, fearing potential harm to public schools and perceived threats to the separation of church and state.
“It’s a blitzkrieg,’’ said Annie Laurie Gaylor, copresident of Freedom From Religion Foundation based in Madison, Wis. “They’re just like drunk with power. This is what we’re seeing everywhere. They need to be stopped. Nobody campaigned on ‘Let’s rob the public schools and give all the money to parochial schools.’ ’’