boston.com your connection to The Boston Globe

Rumsfeld rejects coverup allegations in Tillman death

Ex-Pentagon brass deny responsibility in delay of news

WASHINGTON -- Former defense secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld and other former Pentagon brass yesterday denied any coverup and rejected personal responsibility for the military's bungled response to Army Ranger Pat Tillman's friendly-fire death in Afghanistan.

"I know that I would not engage in a coverup," Rumsfeld told a House committee. "I know that no one in the White House suggested such a thing to me. I know that the gentlemen sitting next to me are men of enormous integrity and would not participate in something like that."

It was Rumsfeld's first public appearance on Capitol Hill since President Bush replaced him with Robert M. Gates late last year. He reiterated previous testimony to investigators that he did not have early knowledge that Tillman was cut down on April 22, 2004, by fellow Rangers -- not by enemy militia, as was initially claimed.

The truth was kept from the public and Tillman's family for weeks, until May 29, 2004. Tillman's mother, Mary, his brother, Kevin, and other family members watched silently from the back row at yesterday's hearing before the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee. Afterward they left without commenting.

Retired General Richard Myers, former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said that he learned of the likelihood of friendly fire toward the end of April 2004, not long after Tillman's death on April 22, but that it wasn't his responsibility to inform the White House or the Tillman family.

"I don't think there's any regulation that would require me to do anything," said Myers. He blamed the Army. "This is the responsibility of the United States Army, not of the office of the chairman, so I regret that the Army did not do their duty here and follow their own policy," Myers said.

Rumsfeld and Myers both said they could not remember precisely how or when they learned of Tillman's death or that it might be friendly fire. Rumsfeld said he did not recall discussing the Tillman issue with the White House until the fratricide became public.

At the White House, presidential spokesman Tony Snow said the administration stands by Rumsfeld's comment that there was no coverup of how Tillman died. "I'm certainly not going to contradict Secretary Rumsfeld," Snow said.

"It is deeply regrettable that this sort of thing happened, and you try to make sure that it doesn't happen at any time," he added.

Tillman's death received worldwide attention because he had walked away from a huge contract with the National Football League's Arizona Cardinals to enlist in the Army after Sept. 11, 2001.

Representative Henry Waxman, Democrat of California and the committee chairman, aired his frustration at the repeated denials of responsibility from the four witnesses: Rumsfeld; Myers; retired General John P. Abizaid, the former commander of the US Central Command; and retired General Bryan Douglas Brown, former commander of US Special Operations Command.

"You've all admitted that the system failed. The public should have known, the family should have known earlier, whoever was responsible," Waxman said as the hearing ended. "None of you feel you personally were responsible, but the system itself didn't work."

" 'The system didn't work, errors were made' -- that's too passive. Somebody should be responsible, and we're trying to figure that out," Waxman said.

Greeting Rumsfeld as he entered the hearing room were two activists who held signs reading "war criminal." "Are you not ashamed?" one said. Rumsfeld did not react.

For the most part, Rumsfeld was measured in his testimony.

Representative Dennis Kucinich, Democrat of Ohio, demanded to know whether there was a White House and Defense Department strategy to manage news media portrayals of the war and other events.

"Well, if there was, it wasn't very good," Rumsfeld remarked.

"Well, you know, maybe it was very good," Kucinich objected loudly. "Because you actually covered up the Tillman case for a while, you covered up the Jessica Lynch case, you covered up Abu Ghraib, so something was working for you. Was there a strategy to do it, Mr. Rumsfeld?"

"Congressman, the implication that 'you covered up' -- that's just false, you have nothing to base that on, you have not a scrap of evidence or a piece of paper or a witness that would attest to that," Rumsfeld replied hotly. "I have not been involved in any coverup whatsoever."

The congressional inquiry occurred a day after the Army laid most of the blame for the response to Tillman's death on Philip Kensinger, a retired three-star general who led Army special operations forces after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks.

The Army censured Kensinger for "a failure of leadership" and accused him of lying to investigators probing the aftermath of Tillman's death. A review panel of four-star generals will decide if Kensinger's rank should be reduced.

SEARCH THE ARCHIVES