Analysis: Obama goes beyond generalities on race
By Peter S. Canellos, Globe Staff
PHILADELPHIA -- After a year of speaking of racial reconciliation in mostly hopeful, uplifting terms, Barack Obama today offered a fuller, deeper, and more personal testament to the nation's tormented racial history and how to begin to overcome it.
The speech had greater weight and specificity than his usual stump speech, and made fewer promises as it wrestled with the legacy of his former pastor and his inflammatory rhetoric. It suggested that an Obama administration would be a time of grappling with difficult and sometimes unpleasant issues rather than conjuring great visions.
For some voters, the speech might serve to remove the glow of optimism surrounding Obama's candidacy; but for many others, it could make him a more realistic president.
Like Mitt Romney's address on his Mormon faith last year, Obama's speech was delivered in a presidential setting -- in the very shadow of Independence Hall -- and invoked common values and historic truths; it showcased Obama more as a national teacher, a role that particularly flatters him, rather than simply an eloquent speaker.
As such, it added gravitas to a candidacy that some have found superficial; and it also served to quell the controversy-of-the-moment over Obama's long association with Rev. Jeremiah Wright, the pastor whose statements Obama condemned in no uncertain terms while offering a reasonable explanation for why he's sticking by his church and its former minister.
"I can no more disown him than I can disown the black community," said Obama. "I can no more disown him than I can disown my white grandmother."
Starting with a reference to slavery as the country's original sin, Obama aimed for a Lincolnesque tone. Lincoln is frequently cited as a model of presidential leadership and invoked as a figure of reconciliation. But few have tried to capture Lincoln's almost mournful tone of parsing painful issues, piece by piece, in reference to timeless principles -- speeches that were meant to be printed and passed around rather than delivered on the stump and posted on YouTube.
"For the African-American community, that path [to a more perfect union] means embracing the burdens of our past without becoming victims of our past," Obama said. "It means continuing to insist on a full measure of justice in every aspect of American life. But it also means binding our particular grievances – for better health care, and better schools, and better jobs - to the larger aspirations of all Americans. . .
``In the white community, the path to a more perfect union means acknowledging that what ails the African-American community does not just exist in the minds of black people; that the legacy of discrimination - and current incidents of discrimination, while less overt than in the past - are real and must be addressed.''
Obama provided a coda that tied this ongoing struggle to his politics of hope -- suggesting that the benefit of all this hard work will take the form of unified action on priorities such as health care and housing that challenge all Americans.
But this speech will be remembered as the moment that Obama got a little more down and dirty, and grounded his candidacy in serious mechanics of governance. He tried to take apart the engine and get some grease on his hands rather than just pat the hood.
This wasn't the gauzy vision of diversity draped in tapestry metaphors and colored in rainbow hues: It was a nation confronting its sins and overcoming its deeply held fears and prejudices.
"We have a choice in this country . . .," Obama said. "We can tackle race only as spectacle – as we did in the OJ trial – or in the wake of tragedy . . . We can play Reverend Wright’s sermons on every channel, every day and talk about them from now until the election, and make the only question in this campaign whether or not the American people think that I somehow believe or sympathize with his most offensive words. We can pounce on some gaffe by a Hillary supporter as evidence that she’s playing the race card . . .Or, at this moment, in this election, we can come together and say, “Not this time."
For perhaps the first time in the 2008 campaign, Obama presented a big problem as something to be confronted by average people -- the aggrieved white worker, the black person fuming about injustice -- who are part of his own political constituency. There was no corporation or lobbyist or rival politician in the picture.
The question -- for Obama, as well as his legions of hopeful supporters -- is whether those average Americans will give him the answer he wants.
I did not expect Obama to confront the issues of race in America head-on, but that's exactly what he did, with uncommon honesty, eloquence, and courage. He gave rightwing radio pundits plenty of ammunition (they will cut and paste several statements to disqualify him, especially the lines "I can no more disown him than I can disown the black community," and "I can no more disown him than I can disown my white grandmother"), but even if he loses the nomination he will stand tall. The gut-wrenching honesty of this speech is a rare and possibly unprecedented thing from the lips of an American politician running for office. The entire speech can be seen here:
You nailed it perfectly James. I for one can only hope the country can move forward even if for one election and look at the candidates based on their records, actions and leadership in managing their campaigns, their lives and building their country. I love this country more than I ever thought I would and still I am hoping for a better tomorrow and we need to make this next step where we say enough is enough. We need to elect the best candidate not because someone that he knew said something good or bad but because we know him/her to be good and the best to be President, the best to lead us.
Let's work hard for our campaign, either it be Hillary's or Obama's or McCain's.
May the best candidate win!
Ane
Yes They Will!!
Obama did a great thing today - and I hope that the people of this country will realize that we are in serious trouble and we need to work on important issues like the economy, health care, and this God awful war.
Don't let the racist press - spin the issue - Rev. Wright is not running for President. My Pastor often says things that I don't agree with but often says things that have more meaning for me than the things I don't agree with.
This speech highlights why we need a man like Obama to be our President. Thoughtful, intelligent, inclusive, the best ideas America has to offer for moving forward together as one Nation, under God.
We have an opportunity to do some things now that have not been possible for other Presidents. Our Nation is ready for change in a new and hopeful direction. If we learn to trust each other and learn to work together, we will again become the great nation of hope that we have been in the past.
So now Senator Obama gives a speech and admits that he was in the pews when some of the statements were made. Nice how he changes his tune mid scandal. Reminds me of his five different versions of NAFTA. He gave an interview with FOX News where he stated that had he been in the pews and heard any of these statements, he would have left the church and never gone back. So now he admits it, yet still goes to this church, still supports its value system. I have never been an Obama supporter because I knew there were too many blank lines in his story. He didn't have the experience, he had too many shady connections. I knew about this church last year. I commented on this church in my blog and many others due to its 10 points of vision which gave a non-negotiatable commitment to Africa. I am not against anyone going to church that embraces their own culture. However, I do have a problem when that church excludes others and speaks ill of those who are not of their own kind!!!! I sit here and read the comments of the supporters that feel that what was being said on the pulpit was acceptable although the way it was expressed was unfortunate. Yet, would you feel the same way had David Duke been saying hateful things about you and Africa? Would you be upset if your race was blamed for something like cancer? Would you be upset if we disparaged MLK? Would you be upset if we blamed you for all of the issues that we have had to experience or even the experiences of ancestors many years ago? I think you would. I think you would label us as racist. Yet we can not label this church or the beliefs the same way. We can not say anything negative about you or your candidate without us being hateful bigots! Racism goes both ways and whether you want to accept it or not, your acceptance and justification is a slap in the face of this country in which you have been given so many rights and freedoms. Senator Obama went to and still attends this church. He has been going for 20 years!
Senator Obama has a platform of change and speeches. He has given speeches based on words! He has said we take that as just words. Well, action speaks louder than words. And by remaining a member of this church, condoning the behavior of this pastor, dismissing his hate filled sermon as words out of context is a slap in the American face of all people! This isn't just about being white or black, it is about being American. Senator Obama has proven that he doesn't truly grasp the idea of American pride. His actions show that he believes enough to continue to go to a hate filled racist church! Yeah, racist because it is racist against White America. Sure, there are churches out there that spew hate in the white communities, but let me assure you that most god abiding Americans do not attend those churches. The difference between belief and acknowledgement is that one goes if they believe. The other acknowledges that it exists but do not condone or attend the church! I acknowledge that the churches exist, but I would never go to one because I don't believe in that type of hate! I don't believe that you go to a church for 20 years if you dont believe in the message being given. Whether it was a snippet of a sermon or not, it is the core values of the church that begin the hate. The 10 points of vision of the church sets the basis of the hate in that church. Senator Obama allowed his children to go to this church, he has allowed them to listen to this hate! He has condoned the behavior of the pastors. Sure Rev Wright retired, but Otis Moss III has the same feelings as the previous pastor. He has already stated he would label anyone who is against Rev Wright as racist! So he obviously feels the same way! Senator Obama needs to step down from this nomination if he even thinks that he can begin to heal the gaping wound he has caused. He needs to also consider stepping down from his Senate seat. Racism does not belong on the capitol steps!
I hope america does not pass on this great candidate.
The hypocrisy in the media is unbelievable! we still have former kkk members in the senate and the house.Who voted those people in over and over again?
It's easy to make a huge spectacle out of words spit out by some old, and embittered pastor; but, the white supremacists have had a free ride for ever.Why doesn't the media go after those folks?
Look anywhere in the South you'll see paraphernalia still being sold and racism being espoused.Where's the outrage?
Believe me, iam a 40+ white american man from Iowa but iam going to change my vote from Hillary to Obama. This was the most graceful speech i have ever heard on national Tv.
This speech should put to rest the concern that Obama lacks judgment or maturity. He powerfully demonstrated those traits through his nuanced response to the crisis. He condemned the message without condemning the inspiration for his faith. He addressed the crisis head-on, but rose above it to give us all transcendent themes that can unify people. We need judgment and maturity more than ever in our president; I see more of it in Obama's speech than in any of Clinton's or McCain's words or deeds. Once again, Obama is a unifier, all the more remarkable because he did so around a typically extremely divisive set of issues.
This article seems to plead with the reader to forget this Obama debacle. Must have been written by the Obama camp.
What if it had been a friend of McCain that had said these things? Jesse Jackson and the rest would be all over the media and everyone. Can you imagine how different the reporting would be today with all the Liberal media?
This whole thing is disgusting. Obama should stop making an issue out of being black, and should focus on being an American. He will take us back decades. In England, blacks and whites talk and act the same, and get along great. Until we all act the same, things will never be good, and Obama is fuel on the fire. he has really disappointed me with the way he has handled this.
Has Barack Obama ever given a speech with eight American Flags on the stage? Has Barack Obama every started a speech with a quote from the United States Constitution? Has Barack Obama ever invoked the founding fathers during a speech before?
Or did he merely give us the speech that he thought we needed to hear?
Barack Obama acknowledged black anger and white anger; but how can he then support affirmative action, which answers the black anger, but dismisses the white anger?
The speech didn't address the real issues with Barack Obama on these stories that are coming to light and finally getting long over due coverage. The issue is not his growing list of associates that could cause one to pause and raise an eyebrow but rather it is his avoidance to address hard questions. Senator Obamas usual first response is a charming ambiguous answer. We do not like the fact that we have to count on the media to ask the same set of question 2 or 3 times before we get a answer that is straight forward and not a charming ambiguous response. The first part was good and had substance but then he went to pandering for his support base. He was so busy hitting us with the right words to reaffirm his voting base to make it anything more then a self serving political press release. The ending was incredible selfish and horrible. For him to have the gall to basically say Vote for me or you will be choosing to go down the wrong path was a total self pandering statement
I am sorry to all of those Hillary supporters, but this man (Obama) is what this country needs right now. Black, white or plaid, this man transcends one side over another and is truly, I believe, seriously concerned and interested in bringing glory and respect back to this nation.
Why didn't Mr. Obama give a speech like this at the outset of his campaign? Seems to me he was forced into this due to the negative press he was receiving once his pastor's sermons hit the public airwaves. Also, he contradicted himself in this speech by admitting to being in the church for similar type sermons when just last week he said he was away when these type of diatribes were delivered.
I am so proud of Senator Obama, I am whitej, educated, female and forty and I believe that the American people are ready for a man like Obama to run this country. I feel that he addressed the issues that we all must address and I agree that true change can only happen when we all come together as a nation full of differences and yet reeling from the same difficulties. Senator Obama cannot and will not change the opinion of everyone, there will be many that will fight him because of his color, many who will fight because the changes he speaks of will not benefit them. However, like Obama I believe that the majority of our nation is a nation of fair minded individuals that are our future, and it's a future that demands change. Mr. Obama had my respect before this speech, but that respect has deepened considerably.
Mr. OBOMBA ..... Your continued reference to RACE implies that YOU are a Racist !
Let me enlighten you: I am 78 years old. I was born during depression years. I went to public schools. There were many "unforgettable" black students there too. We ALL had the same teacher... same subjects, and SAME opportunity to LEARN.
When I got into High School... and College ... RACE was not an issue !!
Everyone was subjected to the SAME education. Some were able to grasp the concepts; others, perhaps not as intelligent, were content to sit on their pity pots and continue reaching for handouts.
Some of my most respected Teachers, Bosses, and Associates over the years were people of color ! These are the ones that made something of themselves and stood on their own two feet.
There is NO EXCUSE for Negros ( African-americans?) to feel discriminated upon !!!! We ALL had the same opportunities ! ( Maybe not in YOUR country, but here in USA -- the problem exists with the COLOR only because their whiney asses continue to be lazy and stupid by choice ! --- Get OFF the Crusade for BLACKS... and get down to business about HOW you think you are entitled to be considered for a job you are not qualified for !
Not this time! This time we have a clear, obvious chance to do the right thing. I'm not going to blow it. Are you?
And of course he just couldn't resist trying to pull Clinton into his mess by attempting to portray her as being backed by a bunch of rednecks. This still doesn't explain why he waited 20 years to denounce his pastors offensive remarks (which his pastor has a LONG history of making). The only reason he chose to spoke out was that he was finally outed as a radical, something many people in Chicago have known for a very long time.
he still doesnt get it. The injustices that black people endure every race endures. The fact is that with out slavery all the black people in america that came over as slaves would be in africa. In africa they would be starving, aids ridden or dead. Slavery though wrong is what gave black americans a chance to leave the dark continent and live a life better then 90% of all africans. Even in the poorest black communities they are still leaving better then most Africans.
Its time that black people simply get over themselves. How man other countless races and people groups have been enslaved,killed and tormented. Have they not moved on with there existence. The single greatest hindrance to black culture and success is black people.
The speach made by Obama today was truly a ground breaking event in American political history. All should read his entire transcript and they will that he truly is different and better for America
I am one of the undecided voters who has, for the first time, been following the campaigns of all of the candidates this 2008 election. And out of all of them, I feel that Mr. Obama has the potential to become one of our greatest presidents. Yet, I can't help but feel that some of us white Americans, maybe more than we would like to think, have not gotten to the point where we can interpret our constitution to include people who do not share our background. Its not to say that we are racists, but more, if you will.....tribal.
Oliver Wendell Holmes said it best....The mind of a bigot is like the pupil of the eye. The more light you shine on it, the more it will contract."
Oh pleassssssssssssse. Give me a break. I am now certain to not vote for him in November.
Obama is a hypocrite in this speech as he has been in so many others. His campaign demanded that Hilary repudiate Ferraro but he can't "disown" Wright. And then there's his comments that basically say African-Americans need to expect justice and equality and that whites shouldn't deny discrimination exists. That's fine but how about addressing discrimination and prejudice perpetrated by blacks? How about saying that NONE of it should happen and that black people should quit denying that they discriminate against others? He does America a great disservice by acting as if it's a one way street. How do you unify when the you place the blame all on one side? Comments like those made by Reverend Wright and with such fervor come from a racist person. Two wrongs don't make a right.
Very conniving!
Pfffft. The usual platitudinous and vacuous eloquence.
"This wasn't the gauzy vision of diversity draped in tapestry metaphors and colored in rainbow hues: It was a nation confronting its sins and overcoming its deeply held fears and prejudices."
Wax Poetic all you can. Obama has yet to define a reasonable plan for anything in this campaign. Botht the democratic candidates are hollow at best on all the issues.
I FEEL OBAMA IS NOT AN HONEST PERSON
This has been my hope from the beginning of Mr. Obama's run for president. It is time to heal some of wounds that keep our country from being really free for all race and all color. I am white and far from a young, but I still have hope.
Good speech; good article. This from a supporter of Sen. Clinton.
It is perfectly fine for someone to vote for Sen. Clinton because she is a woman, or for Sen. Obama because of his race. However, it is not acceptible to criticize others for not doing so. And it is better if we choose between them based on our expectations of how they will perform a difficult office.
Let us not lose sight of the fact that these are two competent, decent individuals, either of whom would make us proud as president.
No person should consider voting before watching this clip:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=jc2FCJ7zWEQ
Good speech; good article. This from a supporter of Sen. Clinton.
It is perfectly fine for someone to vote for Sen. Clinton because she is a woman, or for Sen. Obama because of his race. However, it is not acceptible to criticize others for not doing so. And it is better if we choose between them based on our expectations of how they will perform a difficult office.
Let us not lose sight of the fact that these are two competent, decent individuals, either of whom would make us proud as president.
give him a break, I think he did the best he could and it was from his heart. Obama shouldn't be running for President. Yes, because he is Black and Americans aren't ready for a Black President, and because he does not know what he is getting himself into. No one will be able to straighten out Bush's mess. So, why let a Black man take the job and get destroyed during it.
He's to wishy washy. On p. 94-95 [of his first autobiograpy, obama] describes an effective tactic to deal with White people:
"It was usually an effective tactic, another one of those tricks I had learned: People were satisfied so long as you were courteous and smiled and made no sudden moves. They were more than satisfied; they were relieved - such a pleasant surprise to find a well-mannered young black man who didn't seem angry all the time."
Sounds like he practiced his tactic with this speech.
I just wonder if the public would buy this same speach if it had been deliverd by John McCain to explain why he frequented a church for twenty years headed by an admitted mentor who gave racially charged speaches in favor or white America. I think not. Obama's hypocracy speaks volumes. He gave the speech because he got busted. I can not trust him to lead my country.
Yes, I will (give him the answer he wants). Obama was at his most inspiring and best today -- intelligent, compassionate and very real. I love your analysis -- it goes so much deeper than the knee-jerk talking heads who immediately want to focus on this political strategy. That speech was from the heart. He easily could have walked away and let the pastor thing fade. He's still going to win the nomination. He could have let it slide. But he stood up and seized the moment. And that took COURAGE. I'll go to the wall for this guy. He's the first real political leader of my lifetime (I'm 45, not quite old enough to have fully experienced the Kennedy's or ML King). This man would make an AWESOME president.
As an Afrio-American, retired military person. When I went into the Service, they told me I could only be a clerk. Wrong, I became a Para-Legal. The american people don't have to pat themselves on the back. L:et the world that God gave us, judge us as HUMAN. Thank you Father for this day only.
Yes, he took a chose of 20 years listening to Wright. He denied that a few days ago. And when he realized that he was cougth he gave a speach as usual. I am sick of Obama. Done. Yes, he took a chose of 20 years listening to Wright. He denied that a few days ago. And when he realized that he was caught he gave a speech as usual. I am sick of Obama. Done.
I hope this message is posted. We are in the fight of our lives here in America. Lets try to work together. I don't want to spend another generation praying for reconcililiation between race, culture and ethnicity in this great melting pot. But to those who still beleive race matters Black or White. Me and the rest of my true American brothers will rise to the top of the heap of the corporatization and selling off of the American middle class to foriegn nations. While both black and white biggots are left to squable for crumbs off the table of the globilization of the world. You know who your are. Barrack is trying to give a simple message. Unite or Perish America. While haliburton, the Clintons are playing the divide and conquer game which has worked in the past that America could never really afford then. As the babarians draw near to our gates, racist and biggoted eyes are blind. I am black. I love America. Wake up or the next time someone calls out slave they will be pointing at you. No job - Nafta, Unequal Trade with China. No rights - Patriot Act. No nation - failed immigration reform, which causes our country to loose its borders. Good luck America and God bless. You may not get this chance to vote like this again.
THANK YOU , THANK YOU ,THANK YOU Senator Obama
I thought the speech definitely drew the line in the dirt as far as his stance on the past comments of the race and their influences on the election. I believe Mr. Obama should be commended for turning what has been a brief, but recently intense season of racial storms that he has encountered and despite taking the traditional political position of hopefully avoiding media, he completely took this countries current status of one of the most difficult topics, (at least in the race of presidency) and addressed the issues and concerns from numerous perspectives, while simultaneously clarifing his stance in relation to the recently aired comments of his pastor, friend and spiritual inspiration, as well as previous commentary.
I can't say that I know of any better presidential candidate who could show such leadership, to approach such a topic of weight as this.
Only those have dreams could be resonated with a dream. Only those who believes in hope have hope. Only those who love knows how to love. We are all enslaved by our past and our mind. We act only based on what we could.
The result of Obama campaign shall reflect the true sentiment of the Americans. Being an Asian immigrant, I am watching with intense curiosity.
I believe Obama is the man America needs right now. He is afroamerican and white, he knows islam and Christianism. He is the living proof that mixtures work. And very well !.
If Obama wins the Presidence, America will enter finally in the XXI century. And With the US, the whole world. Yes, we need a change. We need to change and he is the onli person who can start a New Age.
It is evident he is honest, brilliant and he doesn t owe anything to anybody. Only to the people. I hope he will win, but, if not, we shall have to remind the old saying: " Every nation gets the President it deserves"...
Regards
Maria San Roman
Beautiful. Conciliatory yet acknowledging this nation's hideous past but yet great potential. Fox Noise or Faux News will try to continue exploiting Rev. Wright's speech; but the nation will stand with Barack.
i think Obama"s speech was great, and right on target. it is about time that we (all) americans regardless of speech, color, ethnicity, or religion stop playing this race and religious game, and vote for the candidate that will bring this great nation of, by, and for the people of this nation back together. And stop pandering to the special interest groups, and corporate america CEO's that is destroying this nation by outsourcing of jobs overseas, and destroying the middle class that made this country so great. Obama is our only hope, so give him a chance to prove it. Also, get those congressmen/women that voted for pork barrel incintives out of congress that they passed last week prior to going on a 2 week vacation (which they seem to always be on).
Not only in this election but others as well, I wonder if race would still be a "key issue" if we didn't keep making it a "key issue"?
It seems that Americans (or perhaps it's just the media) demand that their politicians come out of some kind of prisitine environment, free from all strife and controversy and then everyone wonders why their leaders are phoney and out of touch. Obama sees the truth and speaks the truth. Finally a leader I can believe in! He has my vote!!
Throughout time man has been capturing man , selling man, eating man, making slaves, murder, etc.... Would someone explain why the BLACK man claims the corner stone of slavery , abuse .. most of the slave traders were BLACK...and WHY do we continually have to be opressed by the attitude of the black nation. They have MORE opportunity that I ever did. I am truly sick of all them complaining and crying poor me then add salt to injury they DAMN America. When will the BLACK take responsibility for themselves and quite crying poor me...
Obama is not going to be president. Not because he is BLACK but because he lied.
Truly brilliant! If the country does not embrace this leader, it will deserve who it gets.
I sincerely hope that we can take this as an opportunity to start a dialog, rather than the soundbites of the past, of relinquishing knee-jerk reactions to every perceived slight or inuendo, of trivializing the very real serious issues, and make some sound decisions - regardless of which candidate you choose to support.
In NYC the most diverse city in the world, we DON'T love each other. But we have learned to TOLERATE each other. Especially after being called to the carpet so many times and learning the hard way when when to keep our mouths shut.
But then again...when it comes to the RED SOCKS....%$#^%$#% BOSTON!!!!
I believe just putting that forward is going to affect everyone whether they know it or not. I believe energy is never destroyed, it just changes form. His speech touched a lot of people's minds. It opened some eyes. He's had my vote since he began with a "bottom-up" campaign. Built from community organizers that are locals. I believe with that type of support, even if he gets shafted on electric voting machines, he will not be going away for a very long time.
This was a historic, moving, very personal speech addressing the heartbreaking but very real racial divisions and wounds in this country. Even as a member of the "model minority" myself as an Asian woman, I have experienced the treatment as "other." But I know my experience is really nothing compared to the black experience.
However, white, black, yellow, whatever color, we all share the pain and effects of racism, and Obama's speech was a powerful, honest discussion on this issue that we all sorely needed.
What's remarkable is that even though his candidacy has been so smeared with racism, he chooses not to blame, not to make himself a victim and castigate others, but rather urges to find common grounds to go forward.
Please, my fellow, beloved Americans. Listen to his speech with an open heart, without the lense of partisanship, and let's see how we can make this a better country. You don't have to vote for him, but please at least think about what he's said with an open and honest heart.
It is the finest and most important speech that I have heard in my lifetime (born in 62, I just missed some of JFK's finest moments).
We are fools if we do not select this individual to lead us through the difficult times ahead.
I just watched Obama's speech and it was very powerful and moving. He was respectful of all who have been highlighted in the news recently.
There are no elequent words that he can speak that will erase the TRUTH!!!..He is what he is. You can verbally distance yourself from someone that has influenced yours and your family's lives for 20 years but in no way can you shed the mental input that is now embedded into your mind and heart forever...Hard to believe that anyone regardless of their race will buy Obama's racial speech!!!. More rhetoric!!!!!Why is it we see pictures of his Grandma but none of his white Mother??Dig deep America!!!SOMETHING IS NOT RIGHT WITH THIS PICTURE!!.....At least with Hillary Clinton what you see is what you get!!!. NOT SO HERE!!!....WAKE UP AMERICA...before it is too late...
Type your comment here...
what a powerful speech combining the most controversial aspects of the American narrative with the future promises of the American dream.
This man will be an articulate president, not afraid to deal with the specifics of a philosophical question, whilst understanding the realities of this society.
It is a relief to listen to a speech which goes beyond the prejudices or orations of this or that religious leader. Obama has vision and insight. What is there not to like about this candidate?
There is one overriding reason Barrack Obama should be the Democratic nominee for president. Win or lose in November, he has, and will continue to mobilize a whole new generation of voters and politically active participants. These young, enthusiastic and energetic voters and activists can be the new face and heart of the future Democratic Party. They can transform the party’s image to represent hope and the future, not unlike Obama’s message. And the party can draw on their energy and enthusiasm to build a strong base for the future. If the Democratic Party does not pick Obama as its nominee it may well be squandering an historic opportunity to build a strategic advantage for decades to come.
i love this guy
I was impressed by Senator Obama's courage, integrity and wisdom. He will make a fine president.
Y E S W E C A N ! ! ! M Y G O D Y E S W E C A N ! ! !
By living in Illinois and following his political career, I have gain an insight into this candidate that allows me to believe that Barack Obama is not only the right person for the job, but he will be an excellent president.
He reaches across the races, cultures, and political spectrum with just as much ease as his speeches indicate. I believe it would be a shame to allow someone else's words to be used against him.
If we were all judged by what a religious leader had said, then no one could run for presidency.
I have never been a fan of Obama. In that context, I was not a fan of Lyndon Johnson. Johnson rose to the occassion when the time came to Civil Rights. The right man at the right time.
Perhaps Obama is now the right man at this time. His words were brilliant. Perhaps his actions will follow and he can become a Democat Lincoln.
Well its not hard to for him to add greater weight and specificity than his usual stump speech given that all his previous speeches are short details.
It was a spectacular speech, I only hope the American public appreciates its content. I am 70 yrs. old and hope that we restore our country to its former glory.
To stand up like a true man. A courageous man, a man who understands the pittfalls of trivializing issues and making the election process into a mockery as most journalists and especially the visual media tends to, and confront them.
That is what Senator Obama did today. I can't see how much more "American" one can be? A lapel missing on a jacket? Please let us all grow up as a nation and start dealing with real issues from now on.
Race has been, and is an issue in this country. Let's embrace each and every American. Let us discuss whether we truly want to leave a legacy of perpetual war and distruction to our children and grandchildren or prosperity like the "Greatest Generation" has left us.
Let's leave a house like the one they left us! That is what I am willing to do. I truly do not care what Mr. McCain and Mr. Obama are like in personal life, because it is personal. Nor do I have any desire to see a drinking buddy in the White House, look what happened when that wish became a reality for some of us in the last 8 years? I want a serious and intelligent President instead!.
Becuse I care about where they want to take this country.
If we have no desire to dwell on the fring lunatic clergy Rev. Hagy, who supports Sen. McCain, why do we spend so much time on Rev. Wright who apparently is just as angry as Rev. Hagy? Let's treat candidates not with double standards, but rather even handedly!
I don't want cliche answers wrapped around in religion and stale ideas. I want to leave my children and grandchildren the America I inherited from my elders!
It seems that posterity provides those seminal moments that allow greatness to be great. I hope the American people have the ability to rise above the fray and see the opportunity we have as a society to take a giant leap toward a national and cultural resolution of our own identity.
Thoughtful analysis. It remains to be seen whether America is ready to stop the politics of divisiveness and get together on issues that really matter to all Americans, or if we continue to dwell on 15-second sound bites and embrace Rovian scare tactics. I'm hopeful that a majority of Americans this Fall will choose the former.
I agree
YES WE CAN!!!
I have never been a fan of Obama. In that context, I was not a fan of Lyndon Johnson. Johnson rose to the occassion when the time came to Civil Rights. The right man at the right time.
Perhaps Obama is now the right man at this time. His words were brilliant. Perhaps his actions will follow and he can become a Democat Lincoln.
I'm a white middle class male on the verge of retirement. I know I am no better then my countrymen I am no more insightful. I am not wiser and I have no special perch from which to perceive the truth. I am simply sick of the politics of hate and division. I will be voting for Obama this year for President.
I thought it was a good speech. This "analysis" was pretty flattering as well.
http://www.chml-srucnoc.net
nodding in agreement when his pastor speaks hate on 'white america'
not a chance game over go away
you suck up obama lickers make us sick
Very, very well said. We can only hope that the American people is smart enough to avoid voting for the same politicians and misguided policies that we've permitted for 24 years now.
OBAMA TODAY IN HIS SPEECH, HE FAILED ON CREDIBILITY ISSUE, AND HE ALSO FAILED ON ABILITY TO MAKE GOOD JUDGMENT ISSUE. THE RACIAL DIVISION IS EVIDENCED IN HIS TODAY'S SPEECH, CONTRARY TO HIS WISH, HE FURTHER CONFIRMED THAT RACE BECOMES A ISSUE, OVER 80% OF THE BLACK VOTE FOR HIM ON HIS BET FOR THE PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE OF DEMOCRATIC PARTY , HE OR ANY POLITICIAN IN OUR MODERN HISTORY CAN NOT GET 80% OF THE VOTE TO WIN ELECTION BASED ON THEIR PERFORMANCE, IT ONLY FURTHER ENHANCE THE FACT THAT RACE IS A ISSUE PLAYED A VITAL ROLE IN HIS SO FAR SUCCESSFUL BET OF THAT POSITION. LET US SPEAK TRUTHFULLY, WITHOUT OVER 80% OF THE BLACK SUPPORT, HE CAN NOT WIN THIS RACE.
Discrimination is a fixed idea or belief set in as conditioned mind and expressing itself as hatred to fellow humanbeings. Why ? Can we change the heart of a person who is having discriminative set ideas ? and how ?
Being as "what is " is more important then rather running after "what should be" as an ideal.
No philosophical words can cure this disease of discrimination.
When "what is" is understood by thought itself then it can go near the fact and then that fact has power to change by itself without any pressure, without any effort, without any struggle.
What Senator Obama has said is somrething Intelligent people have always known. We are all Americans.
We are a diverse nation...all colors, all religions and lack thereof,rich, poor,
employed unemployed, Democrats, Republicans, Independents, and those who never vote but always complain.
We should be doing better at respecting our differences and learning to cooperate rather than cause dissention. We should uphold our many cultures that blend us into one nation that is made stronger by understanding and appreciating our similarites and differences.
We've certainly have had enough time to learn this.
Discrimination is a fixed idea or belief set in as conditioned mind and expressing itself as hatred to fellow humanbeings. Why ? Can we change the heart of a person who is having discriminative set ideas ? and how ?
Being as "what is " is more important then rather running after "what should be" as an ideal.
No philosophical words can cure this disease of discrimination.
When "what is" is understood by thought itself then it can go near the fact and then that fact has power to change by itself without any pressure, without any effort, without any struggle.
Is the Boston Globe an Obama supporter? This article would lead one to think so.
My remaining question, and the one all of my friends still have is, why is he only now taking exception to the anti-American views of his Pastor? Was he not listening to him before-for 20+ years? Or was he in agreement with his Pastor's anti-American views and now feels he must distance himself to remain a viable candidate? I am less interested now than before in the kind of "change" Obama had in mind. Further, while I assumed he was pro-American before the speech now I am not sure where his loyalties are.
Who wrote this...Obama's wife?
This was a historic, moving, very personal speech addressing the heartbreaking but very real racial divisions and wounds in this country. Even as a member of the "model minority" myself as an Asian woman, I have experienced the treatment as "other." But I know my experience is really nothing compared to the black experience.
However, white, black, yellow, whatever color, we all share the pain and effects of racism, and Obama's speech was a powerful, honest discussion on this issue that we all sorely needed.
What's remarkable is that even though his candidacy has been so smeared with racism, he chooses not to blame, not to make himself a victim and castigate others, but rather urges to find common grounds to go forward.
Please, my fellow, beloved Americans. Listen to his speech with an open heart, without the lense of partisanship, and let's see how we can make this a better country. You don't have to vote for him, but please at least think about what he's said with an open and honest heart.
I support Barack Obama! He and his wife Michelle are truly inspirational...wise beyond their years! I am grateful we are being presented with this kind of leadership in this 21 century. It's a higher standard of leadership and it's long overdue. I am grateful that the time is now and it is not too late.
The most remarkable speech by a politician in my lifetime...including those by JFK and Reagan. I wonder what on earth could possibly move those who were unmoved by it.
I thought Obama gave a magnificent speech. Only the worst cynic could read or hear the words and not recognize the truth at the heart of it.
The race/gender issues have been fuled by the MSM. Every primary is viewed through a collectivist lens. The American people are broken down into this group and that group. Blue collar, white collar, men, women, women over 50, young people, black men, black women... it goes on and on.
I'm an American citizen.
Reverend Wright doesn't bother me at all. He's no less inflammatory than the Pat Robertsons and Jim Hagee's the Repulicans pay homage to during every Presidential election, and he's a thousand times more intelligent.
I watched Reverend Wright on youtube and he's correct when he blames American foreign policy on the 911 attack. Our CIA and the 911 Commission have drawn the same conclusion. As Ron Paul stated, it's called "blowback".
When he says goddamn America when talking about the War on Drugs, the 3 strike laws and the injustice built into them; again, I have to agree with him. If white men were being incarcerated at the same rate as black men because of the war on drugs, drugs would be legalized by now.
I do disagree with Reverand Wright on the cause; it has nothing to do with black or white and everything to do with "green". I have no doubt if the tables were turned and it was rich black people or rich hispanic people in power; they would make their money the same way. White, black, hispanic, doesn't matter; we all have one thing in common - greed.
As usual the establishment is using divide and conquer to keep the status quo. I
sincerely hope people will say - not this time.
I think Lincoln said "You can fool some of the people some of the time, and some of the people all of the time, but you can't fool all of the people all of the time".
Obama should remember that and get the heck of the presidential race.
We have a need to know Senator Obama from every angle and what he believes when he talks of equality for America. The problem I have with him at this point is the pattern that seems to be: I say one thing during speeches, but my actions and history show something quite different.” Whether it is a NAFTA speech, transparency, but then delays responding to Rezko questions until it becomes an issue, then a uniter until we see whom/what he has been exposed to for 20+ years….wasn’t in the pew..then, well “yes I was”… Geesh! ANd for anyone to say that Clinton +/or Obama is at fault for the direction the Democratic campaign has headed, is ludicrous and short-sighted. America is a melting pot of races, genders, culture, etc. and we each have a personal interest in seeing “ourselves” in our President. With that connection comes passion and emotional investment. Human nature, yes. However, it also must be tempered with information about the candidates (good and bad, without negative “label” attached to said information) so that we can make informed choices, rather than only emotionally-driven ones. After much research, soul-searching and actually listening to what both candidates have to say and what their actual legislative records show, I decided to vote for Hillary. I had to take off the blinders of opinion polls, media spin, mud and excitement and remember what this race is really about: Hiring someone to do the toughest and,arguably, most important job on the planet. Being President of the US isn’t about speeches, promises and what-if’s - it is about who I believe will get up, everyday, and work their butt off for me and every other hardworking American, because they have a track record of that already. That person is Senator Clinton. She has been thru many tribulations, tests, and challenges in her life and like the Energizer Bunny, just keeps going and going. Where she gets the energy and conviction, I wish I knew. Think what each of us could do in our own lives and communities with just an ounce of her strength! She has worked hard and diligently for all Americans, and spent years building strong relationships because she has a passionate vision of what America can be, not just because she’s running for President. Vetted, intelligent, tested and hardworking. Senator Clinton is the right choice for me in ‘08
I think the audacity to confront what is derailing all of us as one nation has been exposed and tackled by Obama. I think we all have commited the sin of racism, and must come forwrad for repentance in our individual way. I turely see a more promising America, whereby we can look beyond race and become the melting pot we are.
Fabulously written. Though I am a supporter of Sen. Obama, I now am interested to see if Americans will become interested in the politics of reality instead of just the politics of politics. The referenced speech is like being in a dark room full of people who have been sitting there for some time and their eyes have comfortably adjusted to the darkness, AND THEN someone comes in and turns on the light; the first and enduring reaction for many will immediately be to turn off the light, but for many of the rest they will endure the temporary discomfort of once again adjusting to the light - the true manner in which they should see. Great article.
So much about so little. Those of us who have marched for MLK and supported heroes like RFK, this guy is truly shameful in his pandering to those traditions and attempting to heave up historical guilt as a diet for todays version of the reckless white slave addict.
This country is divided; it is divided by those like this guy who no more road to travel upon. It is unfathomable to many how the economy, the war, the debt, the education system, the future in general are not discussed and instead have to listen to this drivel. No matter what ones view of the future leader might be, they are in for some extremely difficult times. I would choose experience over rancor.
Remarkable. With this speech, Obama managed to take all the pundits and make their analyses of race in the campaign over the last week look small-minded and disingenuous. What Obama's detractors fail to acknowledge is that his ability to engage difficult issues honestly, courageously, intelligently and transformatively is the hallmark of presidential greatness. This is the man who could bring reconciliation not only to the US, but to the Middle East, Tibet, Sudan, North Korea, Cuba, etc. This is the man who can restore our reputation in the world.
The same international community who can't understand why we elected George W. Bush to two terms will never forgive us if we reject Obama this time.
Did Hussein Obama write this artical by himself? Get real, stop kissing his aszz.... Has he ever mention that OJ was a criminal, a killer, a murderer ? Hussein himself is as racist as his mentor/uncle(Wright). He just happens to be a really good actor.
White male. Age 63 Republican and Conservative
Obama just got my vote. Where do I send him money?
First let me say this, a African AAmerican man as President is fine with me. However, don`t give me someone who speaks of the very thing he speaks against, racsim. Do your own research on his church and what they stand for. It`s nothing more than what white people say about black people. Obama is Muslin and this country will soon discover just how bad the USA will get if he is elected.
Now it seems only Blacks can talk and benefit from race issue. Whites can not even touch that. Is this a reverse racism?
This hasn't quelled anything. Just cause he gets up on some stand and gives a speech It's all okay right? We won't even bother questioning the fact that Mr. Obama was a follower of an America Hater for 20 years. No, just give us a nice sounding speech and it will all be okay.
His speech was profoundly moving and thoughtful. I already feel like I'm watching one of the greatest presidents in history, though I concede that this speech must be backed up by equally courageous policy.
Great speech! Obama is willing to say what is right, even if it isn't pleasant.
Obama should have addressed the effert being done and is on the process,by some scholars and agencies. His speech might be perceived saying as nothing is being done. He should have said I will join those who are head on it, rather than saying it will be terrible if you curtail my candidancy.
The Palestinian problem is not because of radical Islam as he stated, but of occupation. Blaming the weak for your political gains is not sincer politics.
I don't think he addressed the issue. In my opinion the issue is how do you deal with race relations? Is it through millitancy or through discussion and interaction.? He did not present a single method on how to deal with it, except rhetoric.
Regards
It was a great speech that almost changed the subject from the specifics of his relationship with his Pastor Wright to the broader question of racism in America.
As grand as the speech may be, it does not erase the fact that Senator Obama's relationship with this man- the fact that he as belonged to this man's congregation for 20 years and calls him his spiritual adviser- cuts a deep hole into the central message of David Axelrod's brilliantly executed Obama Campaign--Change, Good Judgment, etc.--
I am very disappointed with Senator Obama and his campaign.
Never before has our country needed a candidate to win a election as desperately as we need Senator Obama.
The speech today by Senator Obama was theater. It rings hallow. After 20 years of attending that church, listening to its message of hate and subjecting his children to it as well, is not erased by a 20 minute address. He is just a orator, nothing else.
I was impressed with his speech and respected the fact that he did not turn his back completely on Rev Wright just for political gain. I believe Obama is a man of integrity and vision. His speech did nothing but bolster this opinion of mine.
Peter has captured the essence of the speech as well as the challenge we face as a society.
Lets hope we find it within ourselves to challenge our inner self and overcome the prejudices which we have inherited.
I feel what Obama has said has a lot of truth. He has proven that he can be friendly with people he may not agree or like. He also said that he is ready to sit down with his adversary world leaders rather than ignore. He has the ability to balance and be friendly with his Rev. Wright. many black leaders taken up preachinh rash worlds about the country out of frustration and the very fact of Obama building the bridges between this devide is an indication that he is truly bi-racial and can see and be friendly with adversaries and bring unity. Cheers to Obama..
I have a problem with Him in church for 20yrs and not beliving in him
I was leaning toward him but now i don't know?
It is fine for him to speak about race along soul-searching terms. However, the nuts and bolts of politics and governance and the emotional, spiritual, and transcendental objective of such soul-searching, even for an issue that confronts us all, cannot be put on the same plate. We're all going to get indigestion. To say that good health care coverage and better jobs for Americans are possible if we can all just get along and lay down our racial prejudices is like saying we will have food on the table if we are open-minded.
Obama is overreaching and it is understandable, given the climate that his campaign is in. He should just stick to the nuts and bolts. All this talk about race flies out the window when people these days are so much more concerned with keeping the roof above their heads and putting food on their table.
As an American I am pleased that the Senator confronted the controversy du jour head on and was positive about how we might turn this into a unifying moment. As an educated descendant of those slaves to whom he referred, I am honored that he did not patronize any ethnicity and try to sugar coat the American experience of race relations, but rather is forcing us to realize that whether we choose to become color blind or not, we had better find a way to work together if we are to be AmeriCANs rather than AmeriCAN'ts.
Let's get on with the campaigns and get a can-do president who can harness our fractured American spirit without trying to scare us with notions of terrorists behind every tree and under every rock. There is work to be done and we need to get to it PDQ!!!
Man are we screwed. Obama waves the flag of racial tension. if he gets elected we can expect 4 years of this moronic pile of crap. For about five minutes, he'll talk about optimism. then watch him start talking about angry black men. sheesh.
Excellent. I did not have a chance to see the speech, but I like the coverage that you did on it. I am a white voter and have no intention of changing my mind about voting form Obama. It is time America had and Black President and he is the man to do it.
Thank you. Plain and simple. Thank you ...
I want to understand, but I am having a hard time coming to terms with a person going to a place of worship and listening to such racial hatred from a minister.
Obama was close to this church and minister for years, I could not be associated with any organization with such a "hate message", and I certainly no longer
want a President that stands by this type of message.
Instead of embrasing Obama, now I almost fear him.
so? he's saying ferraro was right? okay for him to denounce ferraro who gave her own assessment of his candidacy but asks understanding for his pastor's inflammatory racism? there is nothing new in obama's speech. the last thing we need is a lecture on race. again, he's putting the blame as if the problem was race. the problem is more about his honesty. so, he covers it up with words. again. now that is a pattern we will see in the white house when he's president.
I am so proud of the speech and what Obama stands for. As a young voter, and as a person who believes that this nation truly needs freedom from typical washington politics, he made me proud today.
Accurate and well -written historically analytical
Good one:
Just like Scoot Helman's article on the Rep votes for Hillary.
WOW... I was so blown away by Obama's speech. I can see a 40 years from now, children in highschool reading this speech, of President Obama, side by side with Abraham Lincolns and Martin Luther Kings.... what a moment we are living in. I am hopeful our country is ready to turn this page now. While Obama is not perfect, no person is. His imperfections, are believeable and understandble to me. If he was too perfect, I would wonder, what is he hinding. It maybe a big strench for our country, but that is what makes a catch, an amazing catch. Like in our recent superbowl, when the Giant's receiver caught the ball using his head to hold it tight to his head, which changed the whole dynamics of the game in the last 2mins of the game. If the average person in our country can reach deep inside themselves to vote for Obama as President, that is the kind of amazing play that will happen in the fall. That is game changing. Our country, throughout history, seems to have been blessed with so many great individuals who arise just in the right time. God Bless American, we are truly a Blessed Nation.
Correction: I believe Obama said, "In the Wako tragedy" not "In the wake of tragedy".
Wow. His words were inspiring. This will go down as the most important speech in this century to date. God bless Barack.
Does Obama take us for fools. He doesn't address the issue and talks with his usual bombast. The fact is he must hold a good deal of resentment against whites, even though his mom was white.
Please imagine if John McCain or even Hillary Clinton had a preacher that denounced blacks and agreed with the KKK. Forget end of story. When will the Obama double standard stop?
I believe the shine is starting to come off the apple. Let talk about real candidates like Hillary and McCain.
Despite our best intentions. Despite our inflated self -image as that of an open, caring and unbigoted populace, it's too soon. The wounds are too deep, the prejudices too ingrained and the unpleasenat experiences are too new for us to elect a black man for president. No matter what we say in public, in our homes we still fear those whom are different.
It will not be the babyboomers who elect a black president. Our children may do so, or, as I expect it will be their children. If it were not the Reverend Wright issue, then we would have rejected him sliently. We now have the reason we were secretly hoping for to assuage our guilt and deny our prejudice.
A wolf in sheep's clothing. No one who knows the law would allow any one to be a mentor with such hatred. Blaming the other guy. No, no, no. You are not Lincoln.
Oh please - not more of the same old tired and worn out rhetoric of the oppressed minor people! When will the people of Obama, come to their collective senses, and leave the victim mentality behind. We all have experienced the phenomonen of being "dumped" upon. Loosing a managerial position to a white female, so the corporation could market their equal opportunity jargon is nothing less than the poor poor oppressed people of Obama. You endorse the actions, behaviors and hate talk, that the Rev. Wright espossed by overtly supporting, being baptised, and married by the man. So please do not even try to tell me that this is a man, Obama, that will bring wide and sweeping change! He is after all, a politician. And just like all other politicians is not to be trusted.
And my answer would be my vote for him... he offers far more than HRC.