< Back to Front Page Text size +

Clinton embellished Bosnia visit

Posted by Foon Rhee, deputy national political editor March 24, 2008 02:08 PM


Now that a video has surfaced and after questions were raised about her account, Hillary Clinton's campaign acknowledged today that she may have misspoken when she described a harrowing visit to Bosnia while first lady.

"I remember landing under sniper fire," she said last week as she sought to burnish her commander-in-chief credentials. "There was supposed to be some kind of a greeting ceremony at the airport, but instead we just ran with our heads down to get into the vehicles to get to our base."

But a CBS report on the 1996 visit -- distributed by Barack Obama's campaign -- shows Clinton greeting soldiers at the base near Tuzla without even wearing a helmet and with daughter Chelsea in tow, almost sans helmet. The CBS correspondent, however, says it is one of the more dangerous places in Bosnia -- too hazardous for the president to tour.

The Clinton camp emphasized that latter point, while conceding she might have embellished the details.

  • CommentComment
  • EmailEmail
.

This You Tube Video on the same topic is a lot funnier:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=It6JN7ALF7Y

Posted by Long Tall Texan March 24, 08 02:21 PM
.

Is it really plausible that any parent, much less a President, would send his child anywhere that was deemed "too dangerous" for him to visit? No. In fact, he had already visited Bosnia three months earlier, as noted by the Washington Post's original debunking of Senator Clinton's claims. And, according to then-AP reporter, now Washington Post correspondent John Pomfret, the Tuzla airport was "one of the safest places in Bosnia" in March 1996, and "firmly under the control" of the 1st Armored Division. Please correct these errors in your coverage.

Posted by Jeanne Heifetz March 24, 08 02:36 PM
.

As an addendum to my earlier comment, the video you are showing is of helicopter landings, where Senator Clinton was explicitly talking about the plane landing at Tuzla (she talks about being taken into the cockpit of the C-17; helicopters don't have cockpits). She also talks about the greeting ceremony being canceled due to danger, but the Acting President of Bosnia is clearly visible on the tarmac, as is the 8-year-old girl who presents her with the poem of peace. I suggest you link to the video of the landing that she actually referred to in her speech last week.

Posted by Jeanne Heifetz March 24, 08 02:45 PM
.

This is the correct video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOsGo_HWP-c

She clearly says getting off the plane, which is clear from this video..

Posted by Matt March 24, 08 02:47 PM
.

First--------it's a true thing. Bill did leave a stain on Monica's dress, and his legacy should be disgusting.

Second------is anyone surprised that Mrs. Clinton lies??????

Posted by my daddy might be bill March 24, 08 03:23 PM
.

I do not understand why the media continually finds fault with Hillary Clinton, yet dimisses Barack Obama's inconsistencies. First he was not present during the Reverend's speeches, then he did hear some comments, then in his speech he did not. After this was brought to light, it makes sense now why his wife would say she wasn't proud to be an american until now. Must have been the sermons she heard for 20 years that influenced her. Interesting how her comment wasn't linked back, if it was Bill Clinton stating this, it would have been a headline! From CNN to the Globe, it is sad that there is such a profound difference in reporting. I understand that the media picks who they support, but such outright favortism is disrespectful. I am also tired of hearing how Obama is winning by a landslide, Hillary is still close with the popular vote, by not acknowledging this aren't you dismissing their votes? There has been consistently two to one support for Obama without equal representation for Clinton. Isn't it the media's job to be sure that all issues are dealt with fairly?

Posted by Karen Young March 24, 08 03:28 PM
.

Poor poor Hillary Clinton, she's always being beat up by the big bad media, is she comfortable and does she needs another pillow.

Posted by Shawn March 24, 08 05:29 PM
.

Poor poor Hillary Clinton, she's always being beat up by the big bad media, is she comfortable and does she needs another pillow.

Posted by Shawn March 24, 08 05:31 PM
.

helicopters don't have cockpits

Huh? I'm an Obama supporter, but this comment is just ignorant.

Posted by JoAnn March 24, 08 06:42 PM
.

Yes, please DO link up to the correct video, which underscores how she more than "embellished" her account of this Bosnia visit. But the important question to me is, why did she choose to lie about this? She didn't just embellish the details: she substantively changed the truth of the situation. And she has repeated this story of the "harrowing" visit quite a number of times. Again, why did she choose to lie? It really wasn't that politically advantageous. And didn't she know there would be footage?

Posted by CommonSense March 24, 08 07:12 PM
.

So Hillary misspoke, whatever! At least the picture proves that she is there. The peacekeeping forces obviously knew that the first lady and her entourage would be visiting, so it was important that they were protected. How do we know that snipers were not around? I agree with Karen Young #6 about the media constantly finding fault with Hillary, while giving Obama a pass with all his inconsistencies. Obama was caught lying about Wright, but I haven't heard any of the media commenting about that at all. The media and the voters know that they have been sold a bag of goods, by the lofty, self grandiosing, Obama, and don't want to admit that they've been had. Obama gives a speech that harks back to the sixties, and encourages America to talk about race. All this is to divert attention away from his crazy talking Minister of twenty years. Obamarites seemed to think Obama was really the black Jesus coming to bring change and unity. People especially young people with not much wisdom, and older ones who were reminiscing about what America used to be, all fell under Obama's mythical spell. Unfortunately it may be quite late when they really discover who the real Obama is. Hillary is like the energizer bunny, and whatever life throws at her, she just keeps on ticking. That is what I call "grace under fire or should I say "sniper shots?"

Posted by Charly March 25, 08 01:08 AM
.

Karen Young, last I checked the media wasn't sweeping the Reverend Wright story under the rug. Kinda sparked a big discussion on race in America. Obama like every politicain walks a tightrope gaining endorsements that aren't politically palatable. I don't see Reverand Wright's influence in anything Obama has said. Seems like Obama is a person of integrity that can listen to someone with an extreme opinion and maintain a moderate opinion. Hillary in this case just lied at time when the current President took the country to war on a lie and over 4,000 service persons have died. Last, the election is based on delegates not the popular vote. The popular vote has given Obama a good lead where every state is split, no winner take all. It's Hillary that's hoping the superdelegates ignore the popular vote and vote for her despite House Speaker's Pelosi's request they fairly represent the voters.

Posted by Chris336 March 25, 08 02:01 AM
.

Give Hill a break. She misspoke, it even happens to our most distinguished leaders. Like when the President said he never had sex with that woman.

Posted by Mary March 25, 08 03:24 AM
.

"mis-spoke" is a polite word for lie. Hillary lied, in a quite baldfaced manner, about this incident on more than one occasion.

She has also "mis-spoken" and/or exaggerated her role in: Irish peace process, Macedonian border re-opening, passage of FMLA (she had nothing to do with it), passage of SCHIP (again, she had nothing to do with it).

Please, reporters, do your job and call her on her serial "mis-speaking" and resume padding.

Posted by Ruth March 25, 08 09:52 AM
.

It seems most likely that Hillary probably had so embellished the facts about this Bosnia visit in her own mind, that she really thought she was telling the truth. She was probably startled to see the video that contradicted her own memory. It does say something interesting about her as a person that she is able to exagerate and embellish events in her own mind to such an extent that she loses sight of reality. Don't we already have someone like that as President now?

Posted by Andrew March 25, 08 10:57 AM
.

NO one should trust "BILLARY" Clinton!

http://osi-speaks.blogspot.com/2008/03/lying-billary-clinton-shows-why-she.html#links

Posted by KYJurisDoctor March 25, 08 11:43 AM
.

Were Senator Clinton's "misspoke" remarks about being under sniper fire, on a teleprompter? No one has asked that question!

Posted by John R Cannon March 25, 08 01:00 PM
.

Helmets were not necessary !. The full panoramic, uncropped, picture clearly shows a nearby Micheael Dukakis in his tank/helmet ready to defend the First Lady !

Posted by Jerrold E. Fink March 25, 08 02:28 PM
.

Why is it an embellishment rather than a deliberate lie intended to advance and support the position that she has been "tested underfire" and is ready to serve from"moment one"?

Posted by howard croft March 25, 08 06:14 PM
.

how do you forget something that never happened?...

if obama was caught in the same lie..he would get drummed out of the race...

The press is giving her a pass.....an hillary has the nerve to say give me a break...

unbelievable

Posted by bj jounson March 25, 08 07:35 PM
.

The Commander-in-Chief Hillary Clinton was in Afghanistan for the last 20 days commanding her valiant forces. It has been said that the President, Bill Clinton, will only send her battle-hardened General to the “most dangerous” war zones. Earlier in the day, General Rodham Clinton landed in a cork-screw manoevre to avoid sniper fire. Later in the late evening, as mortar shells exploded, sniper fire crackled and bullets whizzed, General Clinton rallied her troops and under very heavy fire, she personally led a charge up the hillside and across the river to victory. There were heavy casualties.

Right!

Posted by John Paul Telhomme March 25, 08 10:27 PM
add your comment *(If you put a URL in your comment, it must be relevant )
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About Political Intelligence

Reports from Boston Globe reporters and editors about the transition to the new administration and other national political happenings.

Send your comments to masspolitics@globe.com

News from the Washington Bureau

Democrats, Obama disagree on F-22 spending

WASHINGTON - From the economic recovery plan to healthcare reform and creating clean-energy jobs, Representative Paul Hodes has been among President Obama’s staunchest supporters in Congress. (Globe Staff, 12 a.m.)

Mass. health overhaul offers lessons for US program

WASHINGTON - A fear that employers will drop private coverage and dump their workers onto federally subsidized health plans is a major concern among lawmakers crafting healthcare legislation on Capitol Hill, leading House Democrats to propose stiff financial penalties for businesses that don’t contribute to employee premiums. (Globe Staff, 7/10/09)

Liberian’s war-crimes testimony may shed light on Plymouth jailbreak

WASHINGTON - It has been a mystery for more than two decades how Charles G. Taylor, Liberia’s former president, broke out of Plymouth County Correctional Facility in 1985, starting a journey that ultimately made him one of Africa’s most notorious strongmen. (Globe Staff, 7/10/09)

In health bill, billions for parks, paths

WASHINGTON - Sweeping healthcare legislation working its way through Congress is more than an effort to provide insurance to millions of Americans without coverage. Tucked within is a provision that could provide billions of dollars for walking paths, streetlights, jungle gyms, and even farmers’ markets. (Globe Staff, 7/9/09)
Reporter's notebook

To a young reporter, McNamara was a plain-spoken observer of US affairs

WASHINGTON - To a reporter fresh out of college hired to cover the Pentagon for a little-known newsletter, Robert S. McNamara was nearly a mythical figure. (Globe Staff, 7/7/09)

More female veterans are winding up homeless

WASHINGTON - The number of female service members who have become homeless after leaving the military has jumped dramatically in recent years, according to new government estimates, presenting the Veterans Administration with a challenge as it struggles to accommodate the hundreds of thousands of returning veterans from Iraq and Afghanistan. (Globe Staff, 7/5/09)

Healthcare overhaul could limit tax breaks on benefits

WASHINGTON - For the secretaries and environmental engineers, game wardens and van drivers who work for the state of New Hampshire, surgery is free, even at Boston’s top teaching hospitals if it’s necessary. So are MRIs, CT scans, and X-rays. (Globe Staff, 7/4/09)

Obama confronts skeptics on healthcare, pledges action

ANNANDALE, Va. - President Obama, pledging to overhaul healthcare this year despite divisions in Congress and the public, took on his skeptics directly yesterday, seeking to assure patients that their costs would not increase and that they would not be victims of a “government takeover.’’ (Globe Staff, 7/2/09)

Consumers likely to face increased bank costs

WASHINGTON - An array of government-created insurance agencies - which have long charged bargain-rate premiums to banks, credit unions, and brokerages - are seeking to make up for massive shortfalls in their insurance funds by raising fees and premiums, many of which are likely to be passed on to consumers. (Globe Staff, 7/2/09)

Supreme Court rules in favor of Conn. firefighters

WASHINGTON - A sharply divided US Supreme Court ruled yesterday in favor of a group of white firefighters who accused the city of New Haven of racial discrimination, potentially making it much harder for employers to bring racial balance to the workplace, while handing ammunition to critics of high court nominee Sonia Sotomayor on the eve of her confirmation hearings. (Globe Staff, 6/30/09)
archives