< Back to Front Page Text size +

Gaffes, tall tales, and deceptions

Posted by Foon Rhee, deputy national political editor May 28, 2008 03:10 PM

Now, there are already dueling and growing gaffe lists for Barack Obama and John McCain.

The Republican National Committee today issued a list of Obama "tall tales:"

1. Mistaking the Nazi concentration camp his uncle helped liberate, saying it was Auschwitz, when it was Buchenwald.
2. Saying that his parents met because of the 1965 Selma civil rights march.
3. Claiming that he became fluent in Indonesian as a child.
4. Putting himself at the center of an anti-asbestos campaign at a Chicago housing complex.
5. Taking credit for passing legislation requiring nuclear energy companies to disclose low-level leaks.
6. Claiming he received a stockholder letter revealing that his blind trust wasn't so blind.

The Democratic National Committee responded with a longer one of McCain's "Top 10 Misstatements and Outright Deceptions:"

1. Doesn't even know who is in charge in Iran.
2. Iraq/Iran, Sunni/Shia: McCain doesn't know the difference.
3. Still thinks Czechoslovakia (which split into two countries in 1993) exists.
4. Wrongly claimed that Baghdad was mostly normal.
5. Called Baghdad market safe.
6. Can't even remember how little he knows about the economy.
7. Falsely claimed he never requested pork.
8. Falsely claimed that tax cuts increased government revenues.
9. Claim to be untainted by special interest money is false.
10. Wrongly claimed he never supported amnesty for illegal immigrants.

14 comments so far...
  1. Wow - the DNC really slam dunked that one (note sarcasm).

    #1 is ridiculous. Of course McCain knows who is in charge of Iran. It was Obama who never refuted the comment that he would meet with Ahmadinejad, who is THE PRESIDENT OF IRAN. Ayatullah Ali Khamenei is the supreme leader...but unfortunately Obama didn't know that, so he continued to support the statement saying that he would meet with Ahmadinejad. Also - Ahmadinejad represents Iran at the U.N. which McCain pointed out at a press conference. It can safely be assumed that the leader Obama is referring to is therefore Ahmadinejad.

    #2 - again...obviously McCain knows the difference. It was a slip of the mouth - saying Sunni instead of Shi-ite or vice-versa. It wasn't a misstatement or a gaffe, because it was immediately corrected in the same sentence.

    #3 - no he doesn't. Even I refer to the two states as Czechoslavakia...knowing full well that it is now Czech and Slovakia. Doesn't mean that he thinks it still exists. They're really reaching here...

    #4 - That's a matter of opinion. If Barack wants to refute it, he should first accept McCain's invitations to visit. Oh wait...he already denied the offer.

    #5 - Again, matter of opinion...not a gaffe.

    #6 - Har har...good one...har har. Where is the gaffe in that?

    #7 - What pork would that be? I'm assuming that this is again, a matter of opinion.

    #8 - A matter of differing opinion between two parties. Ugh - Are they even trying?

    #9 - I could say the same about Obama.

    #10 - He said that the bill wasn't amnesty...and it wasn't.

    That was pathetic.

    Posted by Divided We Fail May 28, 08 03:43 PM
  1. The latest rumor on the Internet is that Obama's uncle was in the Navy and not the Army. I guess it's too much to expect the media to look into this, after all they are probably too busy sharpening their axes for the next go round with Hillary.

    Posted by Fred C Dobbs May 28, 08 05:04 PM
  1. John McCain's immigration bill WAS NOT amnesty. It offered an alternative route to citizenship for qualified immigrants.

    Posted by AH May 28, 08 05:09 PM
  1. Media check the facts. What a laugh. They are mostly ignorant and bias.

    Posted by v racer May 28, 08 05:14 PM
  1. I would take Obama's mis-recollection of the concentration camp his grandmothers brother liberated over Mccain utter cluelessness over Shia/Sunni, Iran/Iraq. This is the sort of colossal clueless mind numbing stupidity and ignorance which got us into Iraq in the first place. Why cant the republicans find someone with functioning neurons. They had Romney, but evidently his cluefulness scared the hell out of the clueless brigade.

    Posted by Roger Helastandt May 28, 08 05:23 PM
  1. Obama #7 - Called his Grandmother a racist

    McCain #11 - He's old and probably wears a diaper.

    Posted by John Leibowitz May 28, 08 05:32 PM
  1. Both lists are pretty lame.

    But the defense of #2 above is funny- the correction about Al-Qaeda in Iran did come quickly... from Joe Lieberman! It was both a mistatement and a gaffe.

    And #8 isn't a matter of opinion; show me the data (hint- you might be able to make a case with the capital gains tax, but for income taxes, forget it).

    Posted by BCC May 28, 08 05:53 PM
  1. How petty... who cares?!

    Posted by Kevin in Houston May 28, 08 06:11 PM
  1. Fred Dobbs, 5:04 pm post:

    On Memorial Day weekend, Obama said that his uncle liberated prisoners at Auschwitz. The Republicans picked him up on that. Turned out it was his great-uncle (grandmother's brother). Someone pointed out that the Russians liberated Auschwitz. Then we were told it was a part of Buchenwald. Then we heard the rumor that his great-uncle was in the Navy instead, (which didn't liberate concentration camps). That rumor is apparently true. I enclose an internet page.

    How's Obama going to explain great uncle Charlie Payne, the "Auschwitz Liberator" having been in the NAVY?

    Did the Navy drive a boat up on shore, like one of those tourist "Duck" contraptions that float and drive?

    (The Navy didn’t liberate concentration camps.)


    Here is the actual link to the information about Obama's white Great Uncle:

    Charles W. Payne, born 1924, enlisted 10Nov42, NAVY, 6293977 Registered, order #12019, Kansas City, Wyandotte Co., Board #4

    http://www.kshs.org/genealogists/militar...

    So it seems Obama's great uncle liberated Buchenwald from his ship in the Pacific.

    The information is correct...here is Obama's family tree link and it shows the same name
    http://genealogy.about.com/od/aframertre...

    This article came from this link:
    http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080528064332AANetsd

    So, how much of what Obama said is true? None of it.

    I do not mean any offense to his great-uncle, who may well have been heroic in what he did in WWII, or to the Navy. I merely want to point out that not one word of what Obama said was true, which is no surprise to me.

    Lightnin'

    Posted by Lightnin May 28, 08 06:26 PM
  1. Niether one of these of these goofballs seems qualified to be our next president.

    I wonder what the job and housing markets are like on some out of the way island in the South Pacific because whichever one gets elected, things are going to get really bad here in the states. Maybe it's time to move.

    Posted by Mike May 28, 08 07:14 PM
  1. Wow, you people are nuts. His great uncle SERVED IN WWII. Respect that and stop trying to put a spin on it. Obama was speaking on memorial day, so why wouldn't he honor hos great uncle? Have some respect and talk about actual issues.

    Posted by sally May 28, 08 07:41 PM
  1. Breaking news at Washington Post: Obama campaign's co-director in Puerto Rico has been exposed as a washington-based lobbyist for the Puerto Rican government. An ethics problem here?

    Or just a reminder of the parable of glass houses, as in if you live in one, don't throw stones.

    Posted by vb May 28, 08 08:12 PM
  1. In my comment #9 above, I now have some reason to believe that it may not be correct, as a Charles T. Payne was in the unit that liberated Ohrdruf, and may possibly be Obama's great-uncle, despite the middle-initlal question. I would delete that entry if I could, at least until I get further clarification.
    That being said, people who served during that time, in that area, know more about war, and people, and service to country, than any of us could imagine, or would want to know. I believe that Mr. Payne would have little use for Obama due to his long association with the racist, anti-American, anti-white "Rev." Wright, and also with William Ayers and his wife, who bombed American government buildings, and said recently that they wish they had done more. Probably Mr. Payne would not speak to Obama, which would be understandable. He probably would not like the fact that Obama could find nothing bad to say about Wright for a long time, but said he was shocked by his grandmother's (Payne's sister's)comments about being afraid of some young black men.

    Lightnin'

    Posted by lightnin May 28, 08 09:46 PM
  1. Obama's gaffes are of a personal nature while McCains' concern real policy issues for the US
    More Gaffes (for McCain)
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEtZlR3zp4c

    The RNC cannot seem to find much from Obama's 12 year elected record
    1. 800+ bills passed in 8 years in IL senate including healthcare reform for 150,000 blue-collar parents
    www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2007/07/29/us/politics/20070730_OBAMA_GRAPHIC.html

    2. His consistency on renewable energy/environment
    ** Jan. 12, 2007: Co-sponsorship with McCain/Lieberman - climate change bill to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by two-thirds by 2050
    ** Jan 17, 2008: Policy approaches to SF Chronicle
    http://cdn.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/object/article?f=/c/a/2008/01/18/MNSNUH7GC.DTL&o=0
    ** Feb 13, 2008 Wisconsin auto-workers, economy speech
    http://wclo.com/podcasts/wclo-news-features/2008/feb/13/obama-janesville/

    3. In 4 yrs US Senate he got real change started with by crossing the isle with Coburn, Lugar, Hagel, McCain
    **the Coburn-Obama Government Transparency Act of 2006 (became law),
    **The Lugar-Obama Nuclear Non-proliferation and Conventional Weapons Threat Reduction Act, (became law),
    **The Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act, passed the Senate,
    **The 2007 Government Ethics Bill, (became law),
    **The Protection Against Excessive Executive Compensation Bill, (In committee), and many more.
    ** Honest Leadership and Open Govt. Act (became law)
    ** joined Chuck Hagel (R-NE) in introducing legislation to reduce risks of nuclear terrorism (partial passage)
    http://andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com/the_daily_dish/2008/04/obamas-outreach.html

    Posted by Young Atheart May 29, 08 06:05 PM
add your comment
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About political intelligence Field reports from Boston Globe reporters and editors covering the 2008 presidential campaign and the national maneuvering of Bay State politicians.

Send your comments to masspolitics@globe.com

archives

browse this blog

by category