< Back to Front Page Text size +

More ad sparring on economy

Posted by Foon Rhee, deputy national political editor September 23, 2008 03:01 PM


Another day in the Wall Street crisis, another pair of dueling TV ads.

Bad-mouthing each other instead of promoting their prescriptions, Barack Obama and John McCain launched ads aimed at what they perceive as the other's vulnerability.

Obama's spot goes after McCain on his ties to Washington lobbyists and corrupt Washington ways.

"Bermuda," the announcer says over an image of an idyllic beach. "It’s more than just a vacation destination for John McCain. McCain went to Bermuda and while he was there pledged to protect tax breaks for American corporations that hide their profits offshore.

"And grateful insurance company executives and their lobbyists who benefit from the tax scheme, gave McCain $50,000," the announcer says as dollar signs are reflected in the shades McCain is shown wearing. "John McCain. He took a vacation, and so much more. And we get more of the same."

McCain's campaign responded by asserting that Obama's Chicago headquarters is provided by an offshore company.

“Barack Obama’s ad cleverly ignores two key facts: his own campaign headquarters is provided by a company based in Bermuda, and is guilty of the very same off-shore benefits he’s attacking. Whether he is opposing additional oil drilling while decrying high gas prices or blasting earmarks despite his requests for a billion dollars in pork barrel spending for his home state, Barack Obama has a stronger record of hypocrisy than he does making change in Washington,” McCain spokesman Tucker Bounds said in a statement.

UPDATE: Democratic vice presidential nominee Joe Biden weighed in on the issue during a campaign stop today in Woodbridge, Va.

He criticized "a disturbing trend lately with John McCain -- claiming the mantle of reform in public but promising business as usual in private."

"Take the example of the most notorious tax loophole that exists in our law today. It’s this offshore deal -- the Bermuda insurance loophole," Biden said. "Now what happens here is that big insurance companies say their headquarters are in Bermuda when in fact they’re in the United States of America, but by doing that they are able under the law to send the money that they earn in America off shore to Bermuda where they don’t pay any taxes on it. Now by the way folks this is no small loop hole these companies are evading between 4 and 7 billion dollars a year in tax liability. 4 to 7. They’re skipping out on billions of dollars of taxes. That money could be going to insure our children who lack health care, to make sure that our veterans as they come back to the VA that the VA is not underfunded, to rebuilding bridges that are crumbling around the nation -- rebuilding our infrastructure."


McCain's spot tries to use the experience card against Obama on the economy, after using it often on foreign policy.

"In crisis, experience matters," the announcer says. "McCain and his Congressional allies led. Tough rules on Wall Street."

"Stop CEO rip-offs," the announcer continues, over an image of Franklin Raines, the former head of Fannie Mae, who the Obama campaign disputes has been advising the candidate. "Protect your savings and pensions."

"Obama and his liberal allies? Mum on the market crisis. Because no one knows what to do," the announcer says, partly quoting Harry Reid, the top Democrat in the US Senate.

"More taxes. No leadership. A risk your family can't afford," the announcer concludes, a twist on Obama's slogan of saying "We can't afford more of the same" about McCain.

The Obama campaign responded to McCain's ad by citing a series of commentaries praising Obama's sober approach to the crisis -- and criticizing McCain's floundering response.

“This ad is laughable. If you believe John McCain, George Bush and the Republicans in Washington have led on reforming Wall Street and restraining CEO pay, I've got a bridge in Alaska to sell you," Obama spokesman Bill Burton said in a statement.

2 comments so far...
  1. McCain thinks that calling for the firing of Cox, and his parroting of Obama''s plan is being proactive.

    With international confidence hanging on a thread last week, both candidates should have had the restraint with their objections and allow Bernanke and Paulson to come out with ONE VOICE from America. Barack Obama, despite having long proposed a plan to avoid this crisis and take us out through commonsense regulation, kept mum so that Paulson and Bernanke could assuage frayed nerves internationally. On the side you have McCain mouthing off, creating all sorts of distractions and problems for the administration. What John McCain did not understand about his actions was that if confidence continued to spiral as a result of his impulsive words, the 700 billion bailout package would not even be enough to solve the problem. it''s a good thing he now finally recognizes the wisdom of Obama''s economic philosophy, but his pattern of being Johnny come lately on a range of issues that have been the hallmarks of Obama''s campaign is becoming a pattern. However, McCain''s impulsive and unpresidential behavior at a time of national crisis raises questions about his commitment to national interest above his own political interests. Now he comes upto say Obama has no plan? So he put the country at risk to score political points last week with his nonsense, and now is trying to make Obama look bad for doing the right thing? ABSURD.

    Posted by andyt September 23, 08 04:37 PM
  1. So, the nation is going broke, banks are failing, jobs are disappearing, and if you ask the media, all the presidential campaigns are worried about is who’s to blame.
    What has McCain contributed to the bailout package? Most people don’t know. But, I do know that he thinks Barack Obama deserves some of the blame for not acting earlier, and for refusing to reschedule the presidential debate to work on a solution for the economic crisis (as, apparently, does FOX News). And Obama? Well, no matter what he plans to do about the economy, at least we know he and the rest of the Democrats think the Republicans are at fault. Democrats are blaming Nancy Pelosi; Bill Clinton is blaming Democrats—but who is finding a solution?
    Sure, there’s been news coverage of what is happening as the government scrambles to find a solution—what legislation has been proposed, and how it will help. But, for the most part, that kind of writing has been short, sparse and unclear. As the government has scrambled to find a solution, the media has scrambled to find a scapegoat. I Googled the campaigns and their positions on the bailout. The first search result? “Campaigns assign bailout blame.” Most of the stories that followed made a similar point.
    Maybe it’s like a University of Virginia business professor I spoke to said—the problem is that so many people don’t understand the financial problem, or the implications of the bailout.
    All people know is that the economy stinks, and maybe for the campaigns, and the media, it’s easier to find someone to blame than to explain the intricacies of a solution.
    I guess that makes sense, but if you ask me it’s a cop-out. It doesn’t really matter how we got IN to this mess—it’s too late to do anything about it now. What matters is who can get us OUT. And the only way we’re going to learn that is if the media starts focusing on what the candidates are doing to help the failing economy, instead of just on who they’re blaming for the problem.

    Posted by Emily October 2, 08 01:23 PM
add your comment
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About political intelligence Field reports from Boston Globe reporters and editors covering the 2008 presidential campaign and the national maneuvering of Bay State politicians.

Send your comments to masspolitics@globe.com

archives

browse this blog

by category