< Back to Front Page Text size +

Big labor targets undecided retirees

Posted by Foon Rhee, deputy national political editor October 20, 2008 10:58 AM

One of the most important groups backing Democrat Barack Obama said today it is beginning its final pre-election push, targeting union swing voters with a mailer on healthcare and Social Security.

The AFL-CIO said it is sending the missive to nearly 500,000 retirees in nine battleground states -- Colorado, Florida, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin -- and pouring more resources into traditionally Republican states such as Indiana and North Carolina "in an effort to push Obama over the top."

The mailer says Republican John McCain would privatize Social Security, tax health benefits, and cut $1 trillion from Medicare. But independent analyses have concluded all those assertions are misleading or overstated.

While McCain wants to allow private savings accounts, he is not calling for the wholesale privatization of Social Security. While he would tax the value of health coverage provided by employers, he would offset that with a new tax credit of $2,500 for individuals and $5,000 for families. And the $1 trillion figure is a guesstimate put out by a partisan group; McCain insists that he would not cut Medicare benefits to pay for his healthcare proposals.

Earlier in the three-week effort, the AFL-CIO sent mailers to gun owners and veterans. "In states like Ohio, retirees represent a significant number of the remaining undecideds," the federation said in a statement. "While our numbers have improved dramatically in recent weeks across the board including with seniors and gun owners as we're reaching more voters with personal contact, we feel there's still room to improve with these hard-to-reach voters, especially in rural communities and exurbs. We're canvassing nightly through the labor program and Working America, and will be visiting many of these voters at the door in the next week. We're also running daily phone banks to undecideds to discuss health care and other issues, reaching hundreds of thousands of swing voters every day. If these hard to reach union voters move to Obama in the final days it could eliminate any potential path to victory for McCain."

  • CommentComment
  • EmailEmail
.

What if you were to look at the McCain health care proposal as an extension of Republican Philosophy, and addressing the need for increased profit margins of the Health Care Insurance Industry, specifically from the point of view of the small business owner who provides group insurance?

If you look at the current state of Health Care Group Coverage for small businesses (that are not self-insured), you will note that the rates paid for Group Coverage are less than rates that are paid for individual coverage plans. You will also note that the Health Care Group Plans offered small business are usually more comprehensive than those offered to individuals (usually because a business advisor will help a small business owner choose a Health Care Plan, while the individual has only himself as an advisor).

What has happened over the past decade or more is that “Underground” Health Care Coverage is being provided by American Small Business owners to friends, relatives, and others who have fallen outside of the system. The Insurance Industry wants to put a stop to this practice.

Here’s how it works (I personally know of several instances.):

• A business owner has a Group Health Insurance Plan, and has say his 45 employees signed up.
• Let’s say his brother, cousin, uncle, and his best friend from college are all self-employed and in need of health care insurance.
• The monthly rates and health plans that the business owner has are much better than any that can be found by the individuals who are out shopping, and they need the coverage for their families.
• The business owner, as someone who cares about the welfare of his community, tells these family and friends that he will put them on his Group Health Insurance Plan if they pay him the monthly rate, and he rolls it up to the Insurance payment.
• So every one benefits, the brother, cousin, uncle, and his best friend all now have lesser expensive, good Group Health Insurance, and the Group Health Insurance plan has grown from 45 (who are paid employees) to 60 (15 people pay the owner for the benefits).
• But, the Insurance Company is profiting less per person because these friends and family who don’t individually qualify for Group Health Insurance are paying a lesser rate than they would if the shooped for individual plans, and the Insurance Industry has no way to monitor if the “employees” in the Plan, and the same as employees who receive paychecks.

Under the McCain Plan the Insurance Industry would in effect be provided with a monitoring system that would ensure that the only persons that would be covered by Employer Based Group Health Insurance Plans would be persons paying income taxes from the business entity that provides the Group Health Insurance, as the tax monies would go directly from the IRS to the Insurance entity.

This plan would probably pop a lot of people out of Group Health Insurance, and into the Individual Health Insurance, which of course provides greater short term profit for the Insurance Industry.

The McCain Health Care plan is not about taxing benefits, and giving tax rebates. That is the smoke screen of the plan.

It seems that the McCain Health Care Plan is set to achieve two specific goals:

1. To set up an Employment Verification system for the Health Care Insurance Industry so that only employees paying taxes from a specific company can be part of that company’s employer based Group Health Insurance.
2. To de-regulate the Health Care Insurance Industry to create maximum profits over the short term, so that the Tax Payers can pony up the monies to rescue that Industry in about 10 years

Posted by lj9283 October 20, 08 12:34 PM
.

SO they want their jackbooted thugs telling you how to vote. Unions have outlived their usefulness and are there to make the union upper echelon powerful and rich. Like politicians, they have their own benefits especially made for them. My dad, a die-hard union loyalist, told me before he died at the age of 83 that the unions have outlived their usefulness. Unions should not take your money and use it to support things and people that are against my wishes. Keep unions out of politics.

Posted by Ozark_Sunshine October 20, 08 11:56 PM
.

Some Quick Facts
1)The Socialism is not helping our kids education or trying to keep our citizens a live(improve healthcare) with our taxes. The socialism is Sending our tax money to Arabian Deserts or any other part of word that cost many Americans life and Creates terrorist heaven countries.
If that money was just given to any people in needs in USA , these people would have put back that money in the market, and we would never have Economic` problem now.

2) Obama affiliation with a well respected professor were criticized harshly but, Mccain being on a real terrorist organization board that killed thousands of people in south America is very normal???

3)Palins life are all full of lies and dishonest behaviors comparing to Obamas .They (Mr/mrs Palin) were member of a party that was trying to split USA by taking away Alaska, and surprisingly that never was unpatriotic but Obama belonging black church was very unpatriotic.?

4)Success in Iraq that Mccain is talking about it is a total lie, our tax money that we don’t want to spend for our kids education and our citizens life is handed to Insurgents (the cute name for terrorists who killed most of our troops) in Iraq.
Now we are paying over 50,000 terrorists(insurgents) regular salary of around $500 a month , so that way they will not attack our troops? That is the success Mccain is talking about in Iraq now.

5) The voter fraud story about ACORN was made by GOP , so while media and Democrats pay attention ACORN Republican can do all the frauds they can. They are really good at that, remember last two elections.
I’m shocked how Media, and Democrats are drawn to these republican made stories, such as Joe the PureLier, Ayers, and Acorn etc

Posted by Fred October 21, 08 02:20 AM
add your comment *(If you put a URL in your comment, it must be relevant )
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About Political Intelligence

Reports from Boston Globe reporters and editors about the transition to the new administration and other national political happenings.

Send your comments to masspolitics@globe.com

News from the Washington Bureau

Shifting Afghan loyalties test US bid for permanent gains

WARDAK PROVINCE, Afghanistan - During the day, US soldiers and their Afghan allies set up checkpoints here along Highway One, halting traffic for hours to search for explosives and evidence of Taliban connections. (Globe Staff, 12 a.m.)

Sotomayor hearing has cordial start, followed by political push-and-pull

WASHINGTON - There was a feeling of good will when Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor entered a filled-to-capacity Senate hearing room yesterday: the loud buzz of conversation fell to a hush, and she grinned at relatives sitting in the crowd as she took her seat at the witness table. (Globe Staff, 12 a.m.)

In Sotomayor hearings, GOP seeking to send message to Obama

WASHINGTON - When hearings begin today on the nomination of Sonia Sotomayor to the US Supreme Court, Republicans on the Senate committee plan to portray her as apart from the mainstream on racial issues - a strategy intended to send a message to President Obama in deciding future nominations: Think twice before picking a liberal. (Globe Staff, 7/13/09)

Democrats, Obama disagree on F-22 spending

WASHINGTON - From the economic recovery plan to healthcare reform and creating clean-energy jobs, Representative Paul Hodes has been among President Obama’s staunchest supporters in Congress. (Globe Staff, 7/12/09)

Mass. health overhaul offers lessons for US program

WASHINGTON - A fear that employers will drop private coverage and dump their workers onto federally subsidized health plans is a major concern among lawmakers crafting healthcare legislation on Capitol Hill, leading House Democrats to propose stiff financial penalties for businesses that don’t contribute to employee premiums. (Globe Staff, 7/10/09)

Liberian’s war-crimes testimony may shed light on Plymouth jailbreak

WASHINGTON - It has been a mystery for more than two decades how Charles G. Taylor, Liberia’s former president, broke out of Plymouth County Correctional Facility in 1985, starting a journey that ultimately made him one of Africa’s most notorious strongmen. (Globe Staff, 7/10/09)

In health bill, billions for parks, paths

WASHINGTON - Sweeping healthcare legislation working its way through Congress is more than an effort to provide insurance to millions of Americans without coverage. Tucked within is a provision that could provide billions of dollars for walking paths, streetlights, jungle gyms, and even farmers’ markets. (Globe Staff, 7/9/09)
Reporter's notebook

To a young reporter, McNamara was a plain-spoken observer of US affairs

WASHINGTON - To a reporter fresh out of college hired to cover the Pentagon for a little-known newsletter, Robert S. McNamara was nearly a mythical figure. (Globe Staff, 7/7/09)

More female veterans are winding up homeless

WASHINGTON - The number of female service members who have become homeless after leaving the military has jumped dramatically in recent years, according to new government estimates, presenting the Veterans Administration with a challenge as it struggles to accommodate the hundreds of thousands of returning veterans from Iraq and Afghanistan. (Globe Staff, 7/5/09)

Healthcare overhaul could limit tax breaks on benefits

WASHINGTON - For the secretaries and environmental engineers, game wardens and van drivers who work for the state of New Hampshire, surgery is free, even at Boston’s top teaching hospitals if it’s necessary. So are MRIs, CT scans, and X-rays. (Globe Staff, 7/4/09)
archives