< Back to Front Page Text size +

McCain ad hits Obama on Iran policy

Posted by Foon Rhee, deputy national political editor October 28, 2008 02:56 PM


John McCain, turning his fire on Barack Obama to foreign policy, launched a new TV ad today that says the Democrat doesn't take the Iranian nuclear threat seriously.

The ad seeks to capitalize on Obama's remark in May that Iran is a "tiny" threat compared to the Soviet Union, and in a report in the Israeli newspaper Haaretz today that French President Nicolas Sarkozy is very critical of Obama's positions on Iran.

"Iran, radical Islamic government, known sponsors of terrorism, developing nuclear capabilities to generate power, but threatening to eliminate Israel," the announcer says.

"Obama says Iran is a 'tiny' country, 'doesn't pose a serious threat,' " the announcer continues. "Terrorism, destroying Israel, those aren't "serious threats? Obama -- dangerously unprepared to be president."

Here's the full quote from Obama in May on the campaign trail in Oregon: "Strong countries and strong Presidents talk to their adversaries. That's what Kennedy did with Khrushchev. That's what Reagan did with Gorbachev. That's what Nixon did with Mao. I mean think about it. Iran, Cuba, Venezuela -- these countries are tiny compared to the Soviet Union. They don't pose a serious threat to us the way the Soviet Union posed a threat to us. And yet we were willing to talk to the Soviet Union at the time when they were saying we're going to wipe you off the planet. And ultimately that direct engagement led to a series of measures that helped prevent nuclear war, and over time allowed the kind of opening that brought down the Berlin Wall. Now, that has to be the kind of approach that we take. You know, Iran, they spend one-one hundredth of what we spend on the military. If Iran ever tried to pose a serious threat to us, they wouldn't stand a chance. And we should use that position of strength that we have to be bold enough to go ahead and listen. That doesn't mean we agree with them on everything. We might not compromise on any issues, but at least we should find out other areas of potential common interest, and we can reduce some of the tensions that has caused us so many problems around the world.

Haaretz reported: "Sarkozy has made his criticisms only in closed forums in France. But according to a senior Israeli government source, the reports reaching Israel indicate that Sarkozy views the Democratic candidate's stance on Iran as 'utterly immature' and comprised of 'formulations empty of all content.'

"Obama visited Paris in July, and the Iranian issue was at the heart of his meeting with Sarkozy. At a joint press conference afterward, Obama urged Iran to accept the West's proposal on its nuclear program, saying that Iran was creating a serious situation that endangered both Israel and the West.

"According to the reports reaching Israel, Sarkozy told Obama at that meeting that if the new American president elected in November changed his country's policy toward Iran, that would be 'very problematic.' "

UPDATE: The French government is denying the Haaretz report. "The remarks attributed by the newspaper Haaretz to the President of the French Republic concerning Senator Obama's positions on Iran are groundless. To the contrary, the in-depth discussions between the President of the Republic and Senator Obama on Iran during their meeting in Paris in July demonstrated a broad convergence of views on this issue. President Sarkozy and Senator Obama agree to oppose Iran's development of a military nuclear capability," said the communique issued through the French embassy in Washington, D.C.

  • CommentComment
  • EmailEmail
.

Gawd, McCain is such an angry old cuss. This campaign has really brought out the worst in him and his followers. If there is anything he should have learn from Bush is you can't scare people into submission anymore.

Posted by Sam October 28, 08 03:03 PM
.

What Obama said:
"Iran, Cuba, Venezuela -- these countries are tiny compared to the Soviet Union. They don't pose a serious threat to us the way the Soviet Union posed a threat to us."
McCain ad:
"Obama says Iran is a 'tiny' country, 'doesn't pose a serious threat,' " the announcer continues. "Terrorism, destroying Israel, those aren't "serious threats? Obama -- dangerously unprepared to be president."

This is a indefensible distortion of Obama's words. What a disgrace John McCain has become. That's what happens when Bush personnel run your campaign.

Posted by McBain October 28, 08 03:30 PM
.


God help us if McCain wins. Obama intelegent and well crafted approach to foreign relations is what we need at this time and age. If McCain gets in you can guarentee that the foreign threats to this country will grow and McCains impotent reactions to them will just loss us any chance at security we will have.

If McCains/Palin wins this contest it is up to every God loving American Citizen to oppose them with every legal means nessicary. They are the greatest threat to this nation since 9/11


Posted by McCain is Senile and a Liar October 28, 08 04:10 PM
.

OHMYGOD!!! THEIR ARMY HAS BEARDS!!!!

Posted by Bud October 28, 08 04:17 PM
.

The biggest threat to our nation isn't Iran. It's John McCain.

Posted by enough October 28, 08 04:38 PM
.

Deny, deny. Haaretz is no tabloid, it regards itself as the paper of record for Israel, and is very left-wing. If they say a senior government official told them Sarkosy thinks Obama is clueless on Iran, it means they have a senior government official with trustworthy information. "Formulations empty of all content" sounds like what Obama says on every other subject, so it rings true from that aspect too.

Posted by ivrydov October 28, 08 04:51 PM
.

USSR had hundreds of ICBM's pointed at us. Some only 90 miles away in Cuba or underwater in subs. Iran will be lucky to get 1 nuke. Tiny COMPARED. Obama is too much of a realistic guy for McCain. Futhermore Obama clearly stated Iran WAS a threat to Israel. Israel is not USA even if we support them.

Posted by Nuke Yourself John October 28, 08 05:04 PM
.


Wait, you mean Obama cares more about the treat against the United States of America than a treat against Israel, why how dare he. How dare he compare the threat of a tiny country in the middle east against the U.S. and an a paper in Israel get upset. Aw sorry Israel, but ya, know, Compared to the USSR or even Russia today, the Iranian threat to us is small. Now the threat to you is large of course, cause you are also a tiny nation. Now we support you and will defend you, but don't bitch about it, m'kay.

Posted by James E Stevenson October 28, 08 05:31 PM
.

Obama is 100% correct. Iran is small. They are underfunded. Their antisemitic president is not the head of the armed services and is ill. They are currently getting reamed by the falling price in oil.
It is true that Iran needs to paid attention to, and they have the potential to pose a credible threat, but to be hysterical about Iran is about as intelligent as it was to be hysterical about Iraq, and that is exactly what McCain is goading us into. We need vision and a steady hand, not erratic bluster. We can still run a strong and strategic pro Isreal position without playing into the End Times fantasies of the current Evangelical cabal in the White House (not to mention their protege, Ms Palin).

Our enemies would love to see us get involved in yet another protracted, wrong footed military engagement with no predifined premise or endgame, and John McCain is happy to oblige them .

Posted by Mike October 28, 08 05:56 PM
.

These guys in the video look more like "henchmen" than army men. Give them all yellow jumpsuits with like, a freaky dove insignia on the shoulder and a really cool submarine and a huge telecom link to the UN so they can demand stuff. That would be REALLY scary.

Posted by Dr. Evil October 28, 08 06:07 PM
.

I too believe that Haaretz, a very liberal Israeli paper, did report the truth. It was ambarrassing to Sarkozy because the French may think they will have to deal with Obama now; but I believe when it was said McCain was leading in the polls. Biden himself doesn't think too much about Obama's judgment. He stated that we are sure to have a catastrophe within the first six months of an Obama presidency. I know you immature, naieve, underage, inexperienced, kool aid drinking Obama cult followers believe the messiah can do no wrong and that McCain is evil, but you need to read a little more history and live a few more. years .and

Posted by R. Stern October 28, 08 06:51 PM
.

McCain is baisically George W Bush Jr.

America needs Obama.....He has 2 things that McCain hasn't got
1. a brain that functions normally
2. and the american people behind him

If by any means the USA elect such an uneducated redneck like McCain and Palin - we wil no that the result is fixed and the american people hae been bumped.

Furthermore , i would like to bring up the issue on Iran. America created Usama bin Laden , they trained him, America enforced Saddam Hussein into the Iraqi government, thy also elected george bush.....now you tell me who supports terrorism?

Israel can have nuclear weapons or trhe so called "energy", India can have nuclear weapons, America can have nuclear weapons so why in Gods name should Iran be deprived of it ? Seems to me as if the America government are the BIGGEST HYPOCRYTES on this planet.

Good Luck Obama

Posted by Shabz October 29, 08 12:54 PM
.

it is ludicrous and tedious how America makes up enemies to the Whole universe to justify its domestic policies and break every international law. Was it not America that invaded Iraq based on Iraq nuclear threat to the world ...a Big Lie? Isn’t it America that is still occupying Iraq and opposing a convention to Iraq Government to keep their troops in there? Isn’t it America that just bombard civilians in Syria few days ago claiming she was haunting terrorist? Isn’t it America that is acting as if it is the owner of the whole universe and policing the while world? Isn’t it America that vetoes any resolution against Israel mass killing Palestinian? Who is spreading terror?

Posted by annasttasiaaa October 29, 08 01:00 PM
.

Sarkozy wants the Iranians hammered even more than the USA because Iranian Gas pipeline directly competes with the French nuclear energy program that Sarkozy has been championing. With Russia having some 50% of gas market, the European countries are moving rapidly to nuclear power and France thinks that as a leading manufacturer they can benefit to a tune of billions...they have already captured the market in UK. With Iranian gas pipeline, both Russia's energy monopoly fractures and with the reduced price of gas the urgency to shift to nuclear becomes less. That is why both Russia and France are so keen to put Iran in a box - even better anihilate it. Now dim-wit McCain wants to make capital out of this....how typical of this incurious man

Posted by Coldstream October 29, 08 01:27 PM
.

If the good people of the U.S. rise up and demand that their AIPAC bribed government officials stop their blind and complete support for the Nazi-like and criminal Apartheid Israeli regime the world would be much more safer and just. Wake up people! While the corporate mafia are getting bailed out with OUR money, WE are at the same time obliged by our so called representatives to give free handouts (tens of billions of dollars annually of or taxes) to the immoral Israeli war making regime. This is the injustice that the people of that area see everyday and the pundits wonder why its not winning their hearts and minds. What a joke!

Posted by P Justman October 29, 08 01:42 PM
.

It is funny how you worthless liberals try to flock to every little tid bit of information that comes up about Obama and tries to show who he really is and that he is not good for this country. You try to refute every piece of information that comes out about him because deep down you know he will be a horrible leader and you try to hide it because you do not want people to be able to make an informed decision without having to read a large amount of McCain bashing while they are trying to look into who the candidates really are. Feel free to back your Socialist leader Obama and I wont feel the least bit sorry for you when you realize the monster you have created by putting someone in office that is unfit for leadership. Also, before you talk bad about someone's intelligence or try to refer to them as a "dim-wit" please look into the person's past and try to learn a bit about the person. McCain graduated from annapolis which I doubt he could have done if he were dim-witted. Also, feel free to say whatever you want about me. Bash me all that you want because I do not share your views and show what type of people you truly are by attacking someone because their views are different than yours. It is sad that you have to sit up here and make coments on the already liberal articles written by the liberal media so that you can feel better knowing that people have to read the garbage that you have to say about someone that you do not even know anything about other than what the media tells us.

Posted by Republican October 29, 08 04:25 PM
.

Don't believe McCain's scare tactics. Remember, MCCAIN WAS THE ONE WHO JOKED ABOUT BOMBING IRAN! One of many bills Obama sponsored in Congress was designed to keep track of spent nuclear fuel rods around the world to keep plutonium out of the hands of terrorists. And Obama has stated he will deal with Iran and other countries decisively, but not with the COWBOY DIPLOMACY that McCain would use! John McCain showed a lack of good judgment by choosing Sarah Palin as his running mate; she's clearly unqualified to be vice-president, let alone president if the need arises. And if Americans elect McCain, what's to prevent him from using more poor judgment, possibly at a critical moment? EIGHT YEARS OF COWBOY DIPLOMACY IS ENOUGH. Barack Obama will lead with intelligence, clear vision, even temperament, and decisive action. We need a CHANGE. VOTE BARACK OBAMA!

Posted by Don Stevens October 29, 08 10:09 PM
.

Israel is clearly going to defend itself against the possibility of Iran developing a nuclear weapon. The real question becomes will we be reliable allies in a war against Iran (and possibly Syria). This becomes potentially sticky if the Soviets provide fire power to the Iranians. If we are wimps, the Middle Eastern powers will join together to wipe out Israel altogether. They will pack together if we show weakness. If Obama is president, prepare for the beginning of Armageddon, because by the time our nation comes to Israel's defense, a full blown nuclear melee is probable. WEAKNESS LEADS TO INTERNATIONAL DESTRUCTION.

Posted by Joseph Saebi October 30, 08 12:00 AM
.

I am very new to the USA but I am here legally (lol). I can't believe what is happening here. To turn your backs to the man who almost gave his life to the country and choose who? one who hates the country and all his relationships are dangerous. This can't happen any where else in the world. Is it insane or what? go ahead guys. Put the most anti-american man in the white house at the end this is what your enemies want.

Posted by confused November 2, 08 01:35 AM
add your comment *(If you put a URL in your comment, it must be relevant )
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About Political Intelligence

Reports from Boston Globe reporters and editors about the Obama administration, the Massachusetts congressional delegation, and other national political happenings.

News from the Washington Bureau

Support wanes for curbs on credit-card interest rates

Efforts in Congress to cap credit-card interest rates are faltering because of opposition from Democrats and a lack of specific support from the White House, despite growing consumer outrage over a rush by banks to impose rates as high as 30 percent. (Globe Staff, 11/19/09)

Obama domestic agenda largely a one-party effort

Despite early pleas for bipartisanship, President Obama is forging ahead with his domestic agenda with a largely single-party strategy, unable to corral more than a handful of Republicans on a wide range of major legislation before Congress. (Globe Staff, 11/17/09)

Beirut attack victims’ families face new hurdle

On Veterans Day, Christine Devlin stood in the cold in Westwood for the unveiling of a new memorial to local soldiers lost overseas, including her son Michael, one of the 241 servicemen killed in the bombing of the US Marine barracks in Lebanon in 1983. (Globe Staff, 11/14/09)

Powerful health care groups offer optimism on overhaul

Two leading health care interest groups, representing insurers and big business, struck a more conciliatory, even optimistic tone on the health care overhaul yesterday, emphasizing their support of the overall goal of increasing coverage and containing costs even as they warned that the wrong bill could cause great harm. (Globe Staff, 11/13/09)

FHA runs low on cash, fueling bailout concerns

The Federal Housing Administration, which propped up the collapsing housing market last year, acknowledged yesterday that it has drained its cash reserves to dangerously low levels, heightening concerns that it might need a taxpayer bailout. (Globe Staff, 11/13/09)

Earmarks’ cash flow lifts firms, lobbyists, lawmakers

16 defense-related firms in Massachusetts have secured nearly $30 million in federal funding in next year's defense appropriations bill pending in Congress. The tally offers a lesson in the practice known as congressional earmarking, in which lawmakers direct federal money to specific projects, usually in their districts. (Globe Staff, 11/12/09)

Afghanistan wary of US plan to send more advisers

Afghan officials have begun to push back from the Obama administration's plans to send hundreds of advisers to the country, complaining the Americans are often overpaid, underqualified, and unfamiliar with the culture of the country. (Globe Staff, 11/12/09)

Mass. keeps an eye on US bill’s funding ban

Massachusetts officials are closely monitoring an abortion funding ban in the sweeping health care legislation before Congress to make sure that it does not restrict women’s access to abortion coverage in the state. (Globe Staff, 11/11/09)

Survey raises new doubts on military’s ‘don’t ask’ policy

WASHINGTON - The Obama administration received more research yesterday to help make its case for allowing gays and lesbians to serve openly in the armed forces. (Globe Staff, 11/10/09)

Lieberman’s threat of filibuster looms large

When a recent conversation among Senate centrists turned to insurance company antitrust concerns, Joe Lieberman boasted of his bona fides: As Connecticut attorney general in the 1980s, he sued the industry. (Globe Correspondent, 11/9/09)
archives