< Back to Front Page Text size +

House passes stimulus package

Posted by Foon Rhee, deputy national political editor January 28, 2009 07:11 PM

The House passed an $819 billion economic recovery package, over objections that it includes too much spending that won't quickly boost the economy and that it doesn't include enough projects that would immediately create jobs.

The Associated Press reports that the vote was 244-188, after a Republican alternative, comprised almost entirely of tax cuts, was defeated, 266-170. Democrats control the House with 255 seats to 178 for Republicans.

The package passed without a single Republican vote -- a fact quickly noted by supporters of the measure.

Americans United for Change, a coalition of progressive and labor groups, said in a statement, "While the House of Representatives passed the economic recovery package this evening by a wide margin, scoring a major victory for American workers and families and a beleaguered American economy, they did so without a single Republican vote. Republicans appear to have learned nothing from the message sent to all of our elected officials in the most recent election that it’s time to set partisan games, politics and ideology aside and work for bold solutions to the daunting challenges facing the American people. Rather than address the most severe economic crisis America has faced in a generation, Republicans retreated to the partisan games and failed policies of the past eight years which cost them dearly in the last two elections. In turning their backs on the American people during a time of historic economic crisis to score cheap political points, Republicans in the House at worst may have committed political suicide and best proved their irrelevance to the process."

But Representative John Boehner, the top Republican in the House, tried to make the most of 11 Democrats voting against the package.

“This was a bipartisan rejection of a partisan bill," he said in a statement. "Families and small businesses across America are struggling, and they are counting on their leaders in Washington for ways to strengthen our economy. House Republicans want to work with congressional Democrats on legislation that fulfills the goal set by President Obama: crafting a bipartisan plan focused on job creation. Unfortunately, the trillion dollar government spending bill before the House today was not that plan, and a bipartisan coalition of Members rightfully rejected it. It is time for Capitol Hill Democrats to finally work with Republicans on a job creation package that lets families and small businesses keep more of what they earn and that is supported by the bipartisan majority that the American people expect on an issue so important.”

The package includes about $544 billion in new spending over the next two years and $275 billion in tax cuts for individuals and businesses.

House Republicans complained that bigger tax cuts would be more effective.

But some Democrats and economists say it doesn't include enough infrastructure spending on transportation and other construction projects.

The package needs ten times the infrastructure money to create the construction and factory jobs to stoke the economy, CNBC commentator Jim Cramer said on MSNBC this afternoon.

"One city, Boston, could use all that money," he said.

After the vote, President Obama issued this statement:

“Last year, America lost 2.6 million jobs. On Monday alone, we learned that some of our biggest employers plan to cut another 55,000. This is a wakeup call to Washington that the American people need us to act and act immediately.

That is why I am grateful to the House of Representatives for moving the American Recovery and Reinvestment plan forward today. There are many numbers in this plan. It will double our capacity to generate renewable energy. It will lower the cost of health care by billions and improve its quality. It will modernize thousands of classrooms and send more kids to college. And it will put billions of dollars in immediate tax relief into the pockets of working families.

But out of all these numbers, there is one that matters most to me: this recovery plan will save or create more than three million new jobs over the next few years.

I can also promise that my administration will administer this recovery plan with a level of transparency and accountability never before seen in Washington. Once it is passed, every American will be able to go the website recovery.gov and see how and where their money is being spent.

The plan now moves to the Senate, and I hope that we can continue to strengthen this plan before it gets to my desk. But what we can’t do is drag our feet or allow the same partisan differences to get in our way. We must move swiftly and boldly to put Americans back to work, and that is exactly what this plan begins to do.”

UPDATE: Representative Edward J. Markey, a Malden Democrat, praised the passage of the bill, and said it would provide more than $6 billion for Massachusetts and could save or create nearly 100,000 jobs by the end of this decade.

“Massachusetts has been a leading force in our economy since the Industrial Revolution,” Markey said in a statement. “Our tradition of innovation will continue as we repair and renew our economy with smart, targeted investments in health, energy and technology initiatives. It will put people to work now and build the industries that will engineer long-term economic growth.”

“The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act will start rebuilding our economy immediately by creating or saving millions of jobs. From advanced, plug-in hybrid batteries that will propel our vehicles and automotive industry into the future, to weatherization programs that will save consumers thousands of dollars on energy bills while creating thousands of new jobs, this legislation will modernize our cars, our homes and our workforce.”

  • CommentComment
  • EmailEmail
.

79 Billion for State Fiscal Stabilization Fund ? This is so states do not raise taxes or cut services. However in true liberal fassion Deval et al will screw us before this Stimulus (political speak for screw the people) becomes law,so that they can ignore it and screw us after it becomes law.

Thank a DEMOCRAT

Posted by Lonnie January 28, 09 06:27 PM
.

So there were even some Dems who wouldn't go with this spending plan?

Posted by stink January 28, 09 06:37 PM
.

Thank god there are republicans somewhere...

Posted by Hank Rearden January 28, 09 06:52 PM
.

Maybe the Republicans didn't support it because it was a bad bill full of "pork"...ever think of that...how about some thoughtful debate and compromise. It's unfortunate there's no balance of power anymore.

Posted by Josephine January 28, 09 06:58 PM
.

The Dems are pushing too hard and too fast for thoughtful people to assess the benefits of their plan or to ferret out all the pork. Republicans offered a number of alternatives that have merit, but they were dismissed sumerarily.
Our country needs well planned long range projects, and the resulting jobs will benefit our country as well as the workers.

Posted by WB Jones January 28, 09 07:20 PM
.

We won. Dig it.

Posted by HMill January 28, 09 08:37 PM
.

It's time that Americans unite, again, to renew Camelot hopes of a "last great hope", showing our faith in God. People need jobs, education, and new things, as we used to have. The old self-centered attitudes don't work, as we saw the past decade, so, give the Democrats a chance, and give God the glory; our Country is recovering from a mess! We need three lanes on each side of the interstates, new vehicles that get better gas mileage, a faster Amtrak system across America, all schools with asbestos need to be knocked down and replaced with a new interesting place to learn, and retired people need to have medicare at age 62.

Posted by Paul January 28, 09 10:17 PM
.


$50 million to promote arts.
$335 million to educate people about sexually transmitted diseases.
$15.6 billion in Pell grants for college students.
$6 billion for modernizing college buildings,
$600 million to buy new cars for government workers.
$150 million in repairs to the Smithsonian Institution.

Stimulation indeed, for the people printing money. What
a bunch of goons running the government.

.

Posted by Billw January 28, 09 10:37 PM
.

At first, I was dismayed that not one republican voted for the bill. Then I looked at the spending pie chart. Only 5% for infrastructure? And look at all the give aways in the bill. Maybe, just maybe, the republicans might have a point --- is this bill just one big give away? What ever happened to the idea of putting people to "work"? What ever happened to a stimulus plan based upon improving our infrastructure, our roads and bridges, sewer and water treament plants, our electrical grid? A give away doesn't put anyone to work. Just like the first bailout, the government is going to give our tax money away, and will not obtain any equity in return. In the case of the second bailout, not even any sweat equity. Shame.

Posted by remembermadison January 29, 09 09:27 AM
.

Hey Billy,

"$50 million to promote arts: " yes cause hiring an 1000 art teachers would never create jobs
"$335 million to educate people about sexually transmitted diseases: " Terrible, I mean they would have to hire nurses, technichians(Sp?) and even just plan old desk people.
"$15.6 billion in Pell grants for college students:" Yea cause having more students in our universities would be bad, why?
"$6 billion for modernizing college buildings:" Terrible think of all those construction Jobs......
"$600 million to buy new cars for government workers." Ok this one I agree with, unless the fleet is so old, which is possible.
"$150 million in repairs to the Smithsonian Institution." Again construction jobs are bad, right?

"Stimulation indeed, for the people printing money. What
a bunch of goons running the government."

Yea pork is bad, especially when it creates jobs....?? moron

Posted by James E Stevenson January 29, 09 11:10 AM
.

WAR COSTS - IRAQ + AFGANISTAN
Per Month - $12.3 billion
Per Week - $2.9 billion
Per Day - $410 million
Per Hour - $17 million
Per Minute - $284,722
Per Second - $4,745
Ahhhh ---, whats a few trillion here and there matter anyway?

Posted by remembermadison January 29, 09 04:53 PM
.

Smart move..very smart move by the Republicans.

Any serious objective examination of this bill reveals that it WAS heavy in pork to favored groups and causes, even giving a measly 5% to the infrastructure project ( which would take a LONG time to stimulate the economy) that the President touted.

If Congress wanted to quickly and efficiently stimulate the economy, the obvious method is tax cuts..but that method seem to be anathema to docrinaire Democrats.

This bill WON'T stimulate the economy... certainly not in the quick and dramatic manner that you would expect from such a large sum of money.

It WILL fail..and when it does.. ONLY the Democrats who voted for it will have dirty hands.

Angry taxpayers won't have any problem identifying which party to blame.

It take back what I said about this being smart..

This wasn't smart..It was brilliant.

Posted by tom January 29, 09 06:34 PM
add your comment *(If you put a URL in your comment, it must be relevant )
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About Political Intelligence

Reports from Boston Globe reporters and editors about the Obama administration, the Massachusetts congressional delegation, and other national political happenings.

News from the Washington Bureau

Rail stimulus funds to bypass Northeast

The railroad tracks from Boston to Washington - the busiest rail artery in the nation, and one that also carries America’s only high-speed train, the Acela - have been virtually shut out of $8 billion worth of federal stimulus money set aside for high-speed rail projects because of a strict environmental review required by the Obama administration. (Globe Correspondent, 12/16/09)

Medicare buy-in is latest hurdle for health bill

WASHINGTON - Senate Democratic leaders grappled for a health care deal behind closed doors last night, as a fragile and tentative agreement they announced last week threatened to collapse. (Globe Staff, 12/15/09)

Al Qaeda looking to Yemen as next base

As the United States steps up the hunt for Al Qaeda in Afghanistan and Pakistan, some of the terrorist network’s veteran operatives are leaving the region and flocking to Yemen, where an escalating civil war is turning the nearly lawless Arab nation into an attractive alternative as a base of operations, according to US and foreign government officials. (Globe Staff, 12/12/09)

House Democrats seek $40 billion in defense bill for jobs

Massachusetts Representative Michael E. Capuano and other House Democrats are drafting an amendment to a defense spending bill up for a vote in the coming weeks that would provide $40 billion to create jobs, one of several proposals under development as lawmakers debate a second round of major spending on the economy. (Globe Staff, 12/12/09)

House passes financial overhaul bill

A sharply divided House yesterday passed the most dramatic overhaul of US financial regulations since the Great Depression, voting to establish a new borrower protection agency and give the government sweeping new powers to crack down on the types of Wall Street practices that caused last year’s economic meltdown. (Globe Staff, 12/12/09)

Obama gains popularity in poll of Israelis

WASHINGTON - President Obama is not as unpopular in Israel as has been previously reported, according to a new poll released yesterday by the New America Foundation, a Washington-based think tank. (Globe Staff, 12/10/09)

Both sides dig in as vote nears on Wall St. rules

Republicans went on the attack yesterday as the House opened floor debate on a sweeping package of new rules for Wall Street banks and traders, calling the legislation an unwarranted intrusion by government that will stifle economic recovery and do more harm than good. (Globe Staff, 12/11/09)

Mass. congressmen push for monitoring of aid to Pakistan

Two Massachusetts representatives and witnesses at a House hearing yesterday said more safeguards may be required to make sure $1.5 billion a year in US development aid to Pakistan is not spent inappropriately or skimmed off in corruption. (Globe Staff, 12/9/09)

Senate health bill stalls as costs are weighed

Senator Patrick Leahy told reporters yesterday that he his wife have canceled their plans to spend Christmas at their farmhouse in Vermont, reluctantly concluding that the Senate would probably be stuck in Washington working on its massive health care package right up until the holiday. (Globe Staff, 12/9/09)

House votes to eliminate tax break for venture capitalists

The House voted by a wide margin and along party lines yesterday to eliminate a lucrative tax break for venture capitalists, private equity firms, and hedge funds. The measure moves to the Senate, which in past years has refused to eliminate the break. (Globe Staff, 12/9/09)
archives