< Back to Front Page Text size +

Whitehouse defends Sotomayor

Posted by Foon Rhee, deputy national political editor July 9, 2009 04:04 PM


On the eve of Sonia Sotomayor's confirmation hearings that begin Monday, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island delivered a steadfast defense of the Supreme Court nominee on the Senate floor today.

Whitehouse, a member of the Judiciary Committee that will hold the hearings, said he's impressed as a former prosecutor with her experience as a practicing attorney and prosecutor.

"Like millions of Americans, I have been inspired by her personal story. Frankly, it gives me goose bumps to think of that little girl growing up in the projects in the Bronx and growing into the woman we see before us now at the top of the legal profession, with a career of exemplary conduct, exemplary academic achievement, exemplary judicial experience already behind her. It is really a great story of American discipline and achievement," he told his colleagues.

"Unfortunately, critics of Judge Sotomayor’s confirmation have unleashed an avalanche of innuendo meant to weaken the case for her confirmation. These criticisms began among the right-wing talking heads, but unfortunately some of them are now voiced by my Republican colleagues here on the floor. Indeed, rather than waiting for the hearing to ask her about her record and her judicial philosophy, a number of my colleagues have come to the floor to attack her and her nomination."

To criticism of her judicial philosophy as outside the mainstream, Whitehouse argued that Sotomayor has stuck to precedent during her career on the bench. He also tried to turn the tables, arguing that Chief Justice John Roberts has not been a neutral "umpire" on the court, but has been a judicial activist.

And to criticism that her life experience -- she would be the first Hispanic on the high court -- would damage her ability to be fair and impartial, Whitehouse asserted that judicial discretion -- based partly on personal experience -- is part and parcel of American legal tradition.

"It is harsh, narrow-minded, and ahistoric to contend that a rich life experience and natural empathy are at odds with that judicial tradition," he said.

Meanwhile, both Democrats and Republicans today submitted their witness lists for the confirmation hearings.

Republicans plan to call Frank Ricci, the white firefighter in New Haven, Conn., whose reverse discrimination claim was rejected by Sotomayor. He was the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit challenging his city's decision to scrap the results of a promotion test because too few minorities scored highly enough to qualify. Sotomayor was part of an appellate court panel that rejected Ricci's claim. The Supreme Court reversed the ruling last week.

Republicans also plan to call Sandy Froman, a former president of the National Rifle Association, which has criticized Sotomayor on gun ownership rights, and Charmaine Yoest, president of Americans United for Life, a Washington-based group that opposes abortion.

Democrats' witnesses include New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, former FBI Director Louis Freeh, and former Major League Baseball pitcher David Cone. As a federal district court judge, Sotomayor ended a long baseball strike in 1995, ruling in favor of the players and against the owners.

  • CommentComment
  • EmailEmail
.

This is the highest court in our nation. It will take a little more than the story of her upbringing to convince me she should pass the confirmation hearings.

Is it too much to ask for a little substance every once in a while instead of this crap.

Posted by no July 9, 09 05:42 PM
.

Now we have the amazing irony of right-wing morons with IQs equivalent to their shoe size expressing concern about Sotomayer's intellectual capability...priceless, and hypocritical in the extreme.

Posted by nighthawk soars July 9, 09 05:44 PM
.

BOSTON GLOBE WROTE: ""Unfortunately, critics of Judge Sotomayor’s confirmation have unleashed an avalanche of innuendo meant to weaken the case for her confirmation."

Yes... it is called quoting her own words and decisions. That must be hate speech according to this Rhode Island "genius."

Posted by Oscarbozach July 9, 09 05:50 PM
.

Why doesn't the Globe tell us what party Mr. Outhouse is from? The state that elects Patches, as bad as ours.

Posted by fan66 July 9, 09 06:54 PM
.

Quotes largely taken out of context, Oscarbozach. And in spite of what many of the simpletons in this country would prefer to believe, context matters.

Posted by Andy Anonymous July 9, 09 06:56 PM
add your comment *(If you put a URL in your comment, it must be relevant )
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

About Political Intelligence

Reports from Boston Globe reporters and editors about the Obama administration, the Massachusetts congressional delegation, and other national political happenings.

News from the Washington Bureau

Beirut attack victims’ families face new hurdle

On Veterans Day, Christine Devlin stood in the cold in Westwood for the unveiling of a new memorial to local soldiers lost overseas, including her son Michael, one of the 241 servicemen killed in the bombing of the US Marine barracks in Lebanon in 1983. (Globe Staff, 12:43 a.m.)

FHA runs low on cash, fueling bailout concerns

The Federal Housing Administration, which propped up the collapsing housing market last year, acknowledged yesterday that it has drained its cash reserves to dangerously low levels, heightening concerns that it might need a taxpayer bailout. (Globe Staff, 11/13/09)

Powerful health care groups offer optimism on overhaul

Two leading health care interest groups, representing insurers and big business, struck a more conciliatory, even optimistic tone on the health care overhaul yesterday, emphasizing their support of the overall goal of increasing coverage and containing costs even as they warned that the wrong bill could cause great harm. (Globe Staff, 11/13/09)

Afghanistan wary of US plan to send more advisers

Afghan officials have begun to push back from the Obama administration's plans to send hundreds of advisers to the country, complaining the Americans are often overpaid, underqualified, and unfamiliar with the culture of the country. (Globe Staff, 11/12/09)

Earmarks’ cash flow lifts firms, lobbyists, lawmakers

16 defense-related firms in Massachusetts have secured nearly $30 million in federal funding in next year's defense appropriations bill pending in Congress. The tally offers a lesson in the practice known as congressional earmarking, in which lawmakers direct federal money to specific projects, usually in their districts. (Globe Staff, 11/12/09)

Mass. keeps an eye on US bill’s funding ban

Massachusetts officials are closely monitoring an abortion funding ban in the sweeping health care legislation before Congress to make sure that it does not restrict women’s access to abortion coverage in the state. (Globe Staff, 11/11/09)

Survey raises new doubts on military’s ‘don’t ask’ policy

WASHINGTON - The Obama administration received more research yesterday to help make its case for allowing gays and lesbians to serve openly in the armed forces. (Globe Staff, 11/10/09)

Lieberman’s threat of filibuster looms large

When a recent conversation among Senate centrists turned to insurance company antitrust concerns, Joe Lieberman boasted of his bona fides: As Connecticut attorney general in the 1980s, he sued the industry. (Globe Correspondent, 11/9/09)

Health care headache for House Democrats

WASHINGTON - Democratic House leaders scrambled to round up enough support yesterday for their sweeping health care overhaul, getting last-minute help from White House advisers on the eve of a historic vote scheduled for today. (Globe Staff, 11/7/09)

Health care opponents intensify late attack

WASHINGTON - The sweeping health care overhaul package before Congress is under an 11th-hour attack over a pair of emotional issues, abortion and immigration, that are complicating Democrats’ efforts to piece together the coalition they need to pass the bill. (Globe Staff, 11/6/09)
archives