boston.com your connection to The Boston Globe

Britain's Parliament votes to renew nuclear defenses

Hundreds of protesters gathered outside in Parliament Square as lawmakers voted yesterday. (stephen hird/reuters)

LONDON -- Prime Minister Tony Blair survived a rebellion by 95 lawmakers in his party yesterday when Parliament approved his program to replace Britain's fleet of four nuclear-armed submarines.

Overwhelming support from Conservatives assured approval of Blair's plan , with the motion passing by a vote of 409 to 161. His Labor Party has a majority of 67 seats in the House of Commons.

Critics said the $40 billion program could harm efforts to stem the weapons ambitions of Iran and other countries. But before the vote, Blair told the House of Commons that the submarines -- due to be phased out starting in 2022 -- should be replaced to meet possible future threats from rogue regimes and state- sponsored terrorists.

"I think it's right we take the decision now to begin work on replacing the Trident submarines. I think it's essential for security in an uncertain world," Blair said. "Though it is impossible to predict the future, the one thing that is certain is the unpredictability of it."

The opposition Conservative Party supported the government. Former leader William Hague said that not renewing nuclear defenses would force Britain to depend on France and the United States.

"As far as we can see into the future nuclear weapons will remain part . . . of the global security setting. They will not be disinvented," he said. "This country has set a good example in the reduction of its nuclear arsenal. But we should not think for a moment that if we were to divest ourselves altogether of that arsenal, other nations would be likely to follow suit."

Lawmakers Stephen Pound and Chris Ruane announced their resignations from junior government jobs -- becoming the third and fourth members of Blair's government to quit over the proposal. The Labo r Party abandoned its long-held policy of unilateral nuclear disarmament in the late 1980s, but significant numbers of party members continue to press for Britain to scrap its nuclear arsenal.

As the debate began, Labo r lawmaker Jeremy Corbyn said the government's plan to replace the nuclear defense system is "contrary to the whole spirit of the nonproliferation treaty." Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett shot back: "That is complete and utter rubbish."

Nigel Griffiths, who resigned a government role as deputy Commons leader on Tuesday so that he could vote against the project, said he had concerns over both the price tag for the project and the message renewing Britain's nuclear commitment sends.

"We have led the world in decommissioning land mines, and nuclear warheads, and the world is watching us now," Griffiths said. "Let us lead the world for peace."

Protesters, including Bianca Jagger, singer Annie Lennox, and designer Vivienne Westwood, gathered near the Houses of Parliament ahead of the debate, and hundreds of protesters were outside in Parliament Square as lawmakers voted. Anti nuclear campaigners say the Trident system could cost three times as much as the government's estimate.

"They are just like little schoolboys that don't think," Westwood said.

Blair, who has announced he would step down by September, has said Britain's stock of nuclear warheads, made up exclusively of submarine-launched missiles, would be cut from 200 to 160.

But the issue of replacing current warheads, expected to remain in service until the 2020s, will be considered in a separate debate.

SEARCH THE ARCHIVES