< Back to Front Page Text size +

Varitek, Henry meet for 90 minutes

Posted by Tony Massarotti, Globe Staff January 17, 2009 07:19 AM

Red Sox catcher Jason Varitek and owner John Henry met for approximately 90 minutes near the player's Atlanta-area home Friday night, but it remains unclear as to whether Varitek is any closer to returning to the team.

Communicating via text message after the meeting, Varitek would say only that the meeting
"went OK" and that there was "nothing to report." The Red Sox’ captain and longtime catcher said he met with Henry "to speak [about] how I feel" and answered "yes" when asked if his desire was to return to the team for the 2009 season.

Varitek declined comment when asked if the Red Sox similarly expressed a desire for him to return. He also declined to address any specifics as to why he remains unsigned less than four weeks before pitchers and catchers are due to report to spring training.

Late last night, Henry returned an e-mail declining comment.

"It wouldn't be appropriate,'' wrote the Red Sox owner.

According to a baseball source, it was Varitek who requested the meeting.

Earlier this offseason, Varitek filed for free agency for the second time in his career, with agent Scott Boras going so far as to suggest that the player might warrant a deal in the range of the four-year, $52 million package awarded catcher Jorge Posada by the New York Yankees following the 2007 campaign.

The market for Varitek has barely developed and the catcher might have forfeited an annual salary in the range of $10 million-$12 million when he turned down an arbitration offer from the Sox last month. He is coming off a four-year, $40 million deal he signed following the 2004 season.

By offering Varitek arbitration, the Sox also ensured that they would receive a compensatory first-round draft selection should he sign with another club. The existence of that pick, along with Boras's insistence on a multi-year deal, has resulted in a virtually nonexistent market for the player, who batted .220 last season and will turn 37 on April 11.

Red Sox general manager Theo Epstein said earlier this week that it is possible Varitek could return to Boston.

"There's still some unfinished business," Epstein said. "Jason's still out there. As I said at the beginning of the offseason, he has been a really important guy here, to this organization. By no means have we shut the door on him. There's still unfinished business there, and also in the pursuit of a younger catcher."

Josh Bard, who was signed to a one-year non-guaranteed deal with an option earlier this offseason, is the only catcher on the team's 40-man roster with significant major league experience. But the Sox view him as a backup. The other catchers are George Kottaras and Dusty Brown, neither of whom figures to be a major league starter this season.

Asked about Varitek's decision to decline arbitration earlier this week, Epstein said, "That's always the player's decision. The player and agent get together and decide what's in their best interest. But certainly it was something we were hoping he would have accepted and get him back under those terms. But that's behind us now and we'll see what happens next.

"We haven't ruled anything in or anything out at this point."

197 comments so far...
  1. GOOD! I hope this gets this done and over with. We need Tek' back and I don't care what anybody says! We can all postulate about what ifs but all I know is when Tek' went down in 2006 that pitching staff fell apart and with no viable replacement in place this close to Spring Training and with a team built this well with a real chance to return to the World Series I think it would be beyomd idiotic not to bring back the Capatain for another 2 years. I don't care about his .220 BA, lok at the RAYS they had a few guys with bad BA's and that really didn't hurt them in the AL East. REMEMBER; It's pitching & defense that wins championships not a number 9 hitter with a .290 batting average!!!

    Posted by Eric Bousquet January 16, 09 04:46 PM
  1. GOOD!!!! 'Tek needs to FIRE Boras........he hosed him BIG TIME!!!!!!

    Posted by Darrell, Wichita January 16, 09 04:52 PM
  1. No! Please just let this guy go, last year i wanted him ti strike out so he wouldnt hit into a double play, keep his bats though they are fairly new,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,he didnt use-em

    Posted by jimfitz January 16, 09 04:52 PM
  1. Let him go. He's done. Can't hit the fastball anymore.

    We can get another catcher.

    Posted by Bob Glavine January 16, 09 04:54 PM
  1. No Theo or Lucchino? This is odd.

    They're sending Henry either because the owner really wants him back and is willing to over pay to show respect

    Or, they're going in a different direction and John wants to personally say thanks for everything.

    I bet they get a deal done though.

    Posted by WTE January 16, 09 04:55 PM
  1. You know, with the incentive laden contracts to Smoltzy and Kotsay (big fan of both, btw) why not give Tek a chance to make some money if he can bring up that average. Let's face it, the pitching won't get worse with him on board, and we've wasted money on guys that brought less to the table. (Clement or Renteria ring a bell?)
    Still go after a young 'un, but bring Tek back to show him the way

    Posted by soxfanvann January 16, 09 04:57 PM
  1. Let him walk. The red sox should be done with Boras and his clients. Talk about overrated! No offer from other clubs should tell you that.

    Posted by Jim M January 16, 09 05:02 PM
  1. Hey. The Sox gave broken armed Curt schilling $8mil last year for no pitches thrown.....get Tek back here to work with what is potentially the best pitching staff in the world. He's worth a run per game just being here.

    Posted by Laurence January 16, 09 05:04 PM
  1. Do it without Boras.

    Posted by ChadProvidence January 16, 09 05:06 PM
  1. It looks like we're stuck with him.. Boo Boo Boo.

    Posted by esf January 16, 09 05:09 PM
  1. please do not taketek back .how arogant can you be to refuse arbitration and probably around more than 10 million dollars with his 220 batting average. he said the heck with you red sox i am worth much more than that. do not forget how he got mad at tito when he pinch hit for him in the playoffs. way to think of the team first mr. captain

    Posted by cup1938 January 16, 09 05:10 PM
  1. Enough with the standoff. Boston needs a catcher, the best one the team's ever had is sitting home in Georgia, with nothing to do and Spring Training starts sooner than one would think. Sign him up and bring 'Tek back.

    Posted by Editorialist January 16, 09 05:11 PM
  1. Why aren't Kottaras and Brown figured to be major league starters? What are they lacking that Tek has so much more of? Tek's lost much of his range and doesn't hit as well as he did. But his game calling skills are so important and so much better that these guys don't even get a chance? Why have AAA players unless you project them to eventually help the parent club? Go into spring training with these two and Bard and see how quickly Tek signs, but even if he does, give them the opportunity to compete to be the starter. Gotta find out what they can do sometime.

    Posted by danalogue January 16, 09 05:13 PM
  1. DO NOT OVERPAY!!!

    Posted by BORASS January 16, 09 05:14 PM
  1. Just get it done. Tek has ment too much to this team, and this city for his time here to end in a fight. Just do a deal that is fair for both sides (because they do need each other). And Tek can retire a Sox and we hang 33 on the right field wall in a few years, end of story.

    Posted by jason January 16, 09 05:16 PM
  1. Here's hoping that better heads (and not ego) will prevail. Tek is needed for at least one more year and maybe a second year to help teach Taylor Teagarden after we get him in a trade. Then maybe Tek can be a coach in the system for as long as he desires. Hope things work out for both sides.

    Posted by peperedick January 16, 09 05:24 PM
  1. Come to your senses 'Tek. You are happy here and still needed.

    Posted by Rhino January 16, 09 05:26 PM
  1. No! Please just let this guy go, last year i wanted him ti strike out so he wouldnt hit into a double play, keep his bats though they are fairly new,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,he didnt use-em

    Posted by jimfitz January 16, 09 05:26 PM
  1. A nice gesture by the Sox would be to offer Jason the 1 year at $10M he probably would have gotten in arbitration. Throw in a second year at the clubs option, and make it contingent upon him finding a new agent. Boras has done him no good at all, and deserves to be flushed. Jason Varitek should finish his career here, have his number up over the bleachers along with Joe, Jimmy, Teddy, Bobby, Johnny, Carl and Carleton, and be on the coaching staff when he hangs up the bat and glove.

    Posted by Ralph January 16, 09 05:27 PM
  1. What comes around seems to go around. I like Varitek I think his agent needs to see the light of day in a new economic time. The day of the big dollar deal is going so fast some players are getting burnt.

    Posted by Kevin January 16, 09 05:29 PM
  1. wish they would just let him go...a veteran pitching staff like ours doesnt need his help as much as we once did. it would be great to fill his spot in the lineup that wont fly out or ground to 2nd all day ong too..

    Posted by Jaybee January 16, 09 05:32 PM
  1. SEATTLE -- Seattle Mariners Executive Vice President & General Manager of How much is Tek reaklly worth it...

    Baseball Operations Jack Zduriencik today announced that the Mariners have re-signed catcher Jamie Burke. Burke, who became a free agent after he was not tendered a contract on Dec. 12, has agreed to terms on a 2009 Minor League contract.

    Burke, 37, appeared in 48 games with the Mariners last season, hitting .261 (24-for-92) with 3 doubles and 1 home run. He hit .341 (14-for-41) vs. left-handed pitching and threw out over 29% (5 of 17) of opponents attempting to steal a base. Burke hit .333 (12-for-36) in 22 games after the All-Star Break.

    Posted by Otis January 16, 09 05:34 PM
  1. Lets go Tek. SIgn on the line. Drop Boras as your agent and lets get the ship pointed at another penant.

    Posted by Duke Brother January 16, 09 05:34 PM
  1. It's about time!!!!

    Posted by Carl January 16, 09 05:35 PM
  1. I hope they don't re-sign him. It's time to move on.

    Posted by unhhockey January 16, 09 05:37 PM
  1. Ugh, go away, Varitek. Nobody wants you and your telephone pole swing, your nonexistent arm, and your elitist attitude. Enough of this "clinging to the past" with Varitek and Wakefield. They clog up roster spots and offer no value whatsoever. Varitek ends more rallies than he starts and Wakefield cost them the LCS game last year in Tampa.

    Posted by Ed January 16, 09 05:43 PM
  1. I'd be curious to know if Boras is participating or if this is Henry and Varitek hammering out a deal on their own (I hope). It'd be the second time in a year (A-Rod) that this would have happened to Boras.

    Boras has literally cost Varitek millions by electing to decline arbitration. If he strikes a deal with Henry directly he should fire Boras first and then sign the deal so he can save 5%!

    Posted by Steve January 16, 09 05:47 PM
  1. you got scooped again by Sons of Sam Horn. Please give credit where credit is due.

    Posted by Matt D January 16, 09 05:52 PM
  1. Scott Boras is in Atlanta today with Derek Lowe to sign with the Braves. Boras may not be "at the table" but don't assume he won't be at the meeting with you John Henry.
    One question, who asked for the meeting??

    Posted by Mike66 January 16, 09 05:53 PM
  1. I heard they are meeting at Wild Wings Cafe in Alpharetta, GA on Windward Parkway! Great wings!

    Posted by Jake January 16, 09 05:59 PM
  1. .......I'm not a Varitek fan...not at all......he can't hit at all.....he can't throw out base stealers.....he is not the type of a guy to be a Captain......cut him loose before he is worthless in all respects....players come and go.....he is no different.....final sayonara, lover boy!!

    Posted by GUNGHOGUY January 16, 09 06:08 PM
  1. Way cool. I say offer Tek 2 million to play for the sox this year and through in a 9 million dollar bonus if he fires his agent!!!

    Posted by profTom January 16, 09 06:09 PM
  1. Maybe John Henry wants to find out personally if there is any truth to the Heidi Watney rumors....

    Posted by gr8fuldave January 16, 09 06:13 PM
  1. We cannot afford a 2.20 hitter who failed miserably when the middle of the lineup was left hanging for most of the season... Let him go!!!!

    Posted by Vic in Houston January 16, 09 06:16 PM
  1. "You know, with the incentive laden contracts to Smoltzy and Kotsay (big fan of both, btw) why not give Tek a chance to make some money if he can bring up that average. Let's face it, the pitching won't get worse with him on board, and we've wasted money on guys that brought less to the table. (Clement or Renteria ring a bell?)
    Still go after a young 'un, but bring Tek back to show him the way"

    I'm sorry but there is something called learning from your mistakes. As good of a catcher as he may be at calling a game, that doesn't mean that there's not other good catchers out there. We need to get younger. We have to part with him sooner or later so if not now then won't we be in the same boat this time next year?

    Posted by Ben January 16, 09 06:17 PM
  1. Great news! Let's get the deal done!

    Posted by Marylin Jenkins January 16, 09 06:18 PM
  1. Hopefully Henry doesn`t offer more than 5 mil for 2 years.

    Posted by spij January 16, 09 06:20 PM
  1. ".he is not the type of a guy to be a Captain." That is crazy! His bat is too slow, he should NEVER hit left handed again, and he can't throw out runners consistently. He can, however, call a great game. And he CAN be the leader of this team. I like an incentive laden deal with a club option for 2010. And I really like throwing Boras under the bus being in the contract.

    Posted by B Clarke January 16, 09 06:25 PM
  1. This makes sense as Henry seems to be the one who can be the most cold business minded about this situation. Theo seeks to emotionally involved to not keep waiting. And it sounds like a meeting without Boras too, doesn't it? My concern would be, Boras is probably still in Georgia with Derek Lowe signing with the Braves.

    Posted by Kate January 16, 09 06:28 PM
  1. If Varitek looks like he walking funny next season, It's because he got the uncomfortable prison treatment from Boras in the offseason. Tek needs to take the one year deal the Sox offer him. He needs to groom his replacement and end his career on a high note. He is one of the best catchers of this generation. He has nothing to hang his head about, well maybe his choice of agents is questionable but, I think he should take the year offer and call it a successful career.

    Posted by RandyFloss January 16, 09 06:28 PM
  1. Remember, Varitek was in the middle of a nasty divorce last year. Hopefully, he has that BS put behind him and he rebounds from the stress of it all.

    Not making excuses, but I don't think the guy is done. I can remember a certain Sox pitcher that wore his emotions on his sleeve that had a down year during his divorce.

    Just because these guys have jobs where they perform in front of thousands and make millions for doing it doesn't mean that they are not human.

    Posted by SeeingIsBelieving January 16, 09 06:31 PM
  1. This is a great opportunity for the Red Sox to deal with Varitek on their terms. Spring training for pitchers and catchers is only four weeks away and no market whatsoever has developed for Varitek. No one is going to pay Boras money for Tek, who clearly is on the downslide, personal problems or not. Baseball is not going to be exempt from the economic downturn, unless you are the Yankees. How about a one year deal for Tek in the $4 million range with some incentives. How sweet to beat Boras.

    Posted by tnrglhcm January 16, 09 06:31 PM
  1. Editorialist,
    You said, "Boston needs a catcher, the best one the team's ever had is sitting home in Georgia, with nothing to do"

    What's Carlton Fisk doing down there? He can't help the Sox, he's 61 years old.

    Posted by KF January 16, 09 06:31 PM
  1. As the Country collapses and people lose their homes by the millions isn't it important that people worry about "Tek", "Youk", "C.C." and "Tex". Meanwhile, the Yankees add insult to injury by having the audacity to ask for more public funds...If only everyone would put this same energy into holding their elected officials accountable. Good luck to all these big contract holders collecting...with any luck the entire system will collapse and they'll be left with only their GREED.

    Posted by CL January 16, 09 06:32 PM
  1. Remember, Varitek was in the middle of a nasty divorce last year. Hopefully, he has that BS put behind him and he rebounds from the stress of it all.

    Not making excuses, but I don't think the guy is done. I can remember a certain Sox pitcher that wore his emotions on his sleeve that had a down year during his divorce.

    Just because these guys have jobs where they perform in front of thousands and make millions for doing it doesn't mean that they are not human.

    Posted by SeeingIsBelieving January 16, 09 06:32 PM
  1. Tek was worth the 10mill+, he probably would have gotten in arbitration, & still is in my mind. I haven't seen one name out there that is actually a #1 catcher. Furthermore, none of them have shown that they can consistently put up the offensive numbers that are that much better than Tek's. The guy has been a lunch pail type of player for Boston since coming from Seattle. I would love to see him finish his career here & eventually move into the coaching ranks for the Red Sox. I definitely don't want to see him parting with ill feelings, so I hope that this meeting tonight at least clears the air & recognizes Tek's accomplishments here in Boston, & leaves the door open for him here in Boston, whether or not they can agree to get a deal done.

    Posted by Dave Z January 16, 09 06:34 PM
  1. One of the two best catchers in my life time on the Sox, remember Fisk please. Last season he had a career ending output if no reason for it can be discovered. I would suspect his marital issues weighed heavily on his mind. Many people have off years when under personal tensions. Sign him short term for decent money with long term bonus possibilities and team options.

    Posted by Noel January 16, 09 06:35 PM
  1. Tek could have taken arbitration and made over 10M, but him and his greedy agent declined. I don't want him back at all but if the sox decide they need him then they should pay no more than 3million or I will be pissed.

    Posted by rick January 16, 09 06:37 PM
  1. Its time to move on?? We are not talking about a broken sexual relationship here! Its simple, in 09 the sox will be a better team with Tek than with whats available. Sign him, pitchers and catchers report in less than a month.

    Posted by PaulyMeadows January 16, 09 06:39 PM
  1. Can't help but think that if he signs, Boras wins. That flat-out makes me sick. The RS should walk away. Tek CHOSE not to take arbitration and it's his choice to hang onto Scott Boras. If one two or three year offer had come thru he would've been long gone by now. Tek's age, his .220 BA and the fact that the catching problem STILL won't be resolved tells me Henry should just say "thanks for everything" and move on. Most importantly, no way I want to see Boras claim victory, which he certainly will, when it should be a humbling defeat. There are no other offers. Boras completely misread the market with regard to Varitek and John Henry's gonna help him save face.

    Posted by Oscar Gamble-2 January 16, 09 06:42 PM
  1. I only want Tek back if it's going to be for 1 year and as a mentor to Salty or Montero or some other young guy.

    The guy hit .180 after May last year. Uh, that's not good.

    Posted by fillylabinga January 16, 09 06:44 PM
  1. I will be very happy if the Sox can make a deal with Tek. His knowledge and command of the staff is unrivaled, let's offer him one year, $8M with a second year team option.

    Posted by Matt January 16, 09 06:48 PM
  1. Thank god Boras is not there. Come back Tek!

    Posted by Doug January 16, 09 06:52 PM
  1. Type your comment here..

    A few things.....

    1.) While Boras is the devil, the player makes the final call, so it's Tek who tried to hold us up. Don't cave - cap the offer st $3 mil for 1 year with some performance incentives for good faith.

    2.) The one thing everyone refers to is Tek's "playcalling ability." He lost us the ALCS with that (in)ability by taking 4 games to figure out not to throw the ball hi and inside to Upton and Longoria and low and away to Pena. And it WAS Tek calling for the pitches most of the time, not missed location.

    3.). His bat and arm are shot.

    Make the trade for Salty. He's gonna be a stud and is young. Please don't tug at the heartstrings.....Wakefield already has cost us a useful body with that.

    Posted by Theo January 16, 09 06:58 PM
  1. No more than 2 years.He is the best around to work with pitchers.!0 million for 2 years and then go after Papelbon big time

    Posted by bram January 16, 09 06:59 PM
  1. Any Sox fan that has thrown Tek under the bus should stay out of Fenway. Go route for the yankees. This guy has helped us win two WS in a short span of time and has suffered with the rest of us while he played his heart out. He had a bad year at the plate last year- big deal! A guy with his pedigree will be back, simply put. In fact, ask the Sox pitchers who they want to throw to...you know who it is.

    Posted by DjM January 16, 09 07:03 PM
  1. Come on people! Work it out! We want Varitek to stay!!! We need your leadership! We need your heart!!! Don't go Jason!!!

    Posted by Jill January 16, 09 07:06 PM
  1. Come on people! Work it out! We want Varitek to stay!!! We need your leadership! We need your heart!!! Don't go Jason!!!

    Posted by Jill January 16, 09 07:06 PM
  1. Varitek has been a positive force in the clubhouse, and an excellent catcher for many seasons. He is a terrible batter, though, and is losing his throwing arm as well. He is a natural leader, and we don't have many good catchers to choose from -- those are the plusses for Tek. On the flip side, his time is past, and we need to find and develop some good young talent. I will miss him if he goes, but it is time to look to to the future, to keep the Red Sox a winning team.

    Posted by Kristin January 16, 09 07:09 PM
  1. These are the facts. Varitek's average was .220 last year. For the last three years combined, his average has been .238. A three year average is not a slump, it's a reality. Time to move on.

    Posted by Fav January 16, 09 07:11 PM
  1. regarding putting the screws to boras, doesn't he represent matsuzaka? and
    who else with the sox? a war of attrition won't be pretty. i would dearly love to see
    his whole stable fire him but as long as the nyy remain, he will have plenty of work
    and support ( "buzzards of a feather", as it were)

    Posted by roland cote January 16, 09 07:11 PM
  1. My guess is the Sox will give Tek a two year deal for $ 20 mil; and he's overpaid at that. There isn't a market, anymore, for a 37 year old catcher that hits .220. In the days of team loyalty, it would have made a difference however loyalty walked out the door when free agency and their high priced agents walked in.


    Posted by Papa Dan the Red Sox Fan January 16, 09 07:12 PM
  1. I agree with the other poster while watching many a Sox game last year I found myself doing the unthinkable, yes that's right wishing that my home town player would strike out, so that he didn't hit into double play, as jason had done so, so, so many times.

    Once again, I am finding myself doing the same thing cheering for Jason to strike out only this time I hope he strikes out on his negotiations and leaves Boston to his recent memories - Go now, in peace, just go...

    Posted by myname55 January 16, 09 07:15 PM
  1. Rule for the ages..."Don't get caught with a falling star. "

    Game calling is overrated. We've got some smart pitchers who know what to throw, and when to throw it. Let's let these veterans pitch what they want to pitch and lay them game on them, not the catcher.

    Having said that, I'm all for signing Varitek on a one year, short money deal with incentives and a team option for 2010. If the Sox want to play the low risk/high reward game with the Penny, Smoltz and Saito signings, which I agree with, then why not with an aging catcher too?

    Posted by The Cutoff Man January 16, 09 07:19 PM
  1. Dear Mr. Henry: Cap it it $2.5 million. If that doesn't get it done, pick up the check , thank Jason for a wonderful evening as well as a great career that he had with the Sox and walk away.

    Posted by Adios Boras guys January 16, 09 07:20 PM
  1. I don't think you can put the blame on Tek for the pitching errors in the ACLS...or he also gets all the credit for Game 1 with Dice-K which was one of the best performances I have seen from him. It wasn't the bad calls that made game 2 a loss...it was Beckett being hurt. And in Game 6, Beckett gave the performance of his life while pitching all beaten up...then Pap came in and closed the game with increased soreness and decreased velocity.

    I always go back to the incredible amount of loyalty from the pitching staff to Tek...it says a lot to me about his value behind the plate. I hope the deal gets made and Tek comes back to the team.

    P.S. And if Tek is meeting without Boras...it's about time! Maybe Manny will start meeting with teams on his own too. Boras is a cancer to all things baseball....are you listening Ells???

    Posted by Shelley January 16, 09 07:20 PM
  1. Sign him to a 2 year deal...deal with his offense...then get Joe Maurer as a free agent!

    Posted by Big Daddy Primetime January 16, 09 07:21 PM
  1. I sincerely hope Jasons Varitek tells Scott "Pit-bull" Boras to take a VERY LONG, COLD SWIM in the Charles River, and that he, and John Henry can reach an agreement on a contract, say for one-year plus an option for 2010. I think Dustin Pedroia put it best in his round-table discussion at Theo Epstein's and Peter Gammons' "Hot Stove, Cool Music" event last week, that "Your agent works FOR YOU," and that "you don't work for you agent." Sadly, the game needs more players like Pedroia, Tim Wakefield, and Kevin Youkilis, as well as more agents like Ron Shapiro, Jack Sands, and John Boggs,. Here's wishing Tek and Henry good luck.

    Posted by Ellen M. Hedderman January 16, 09 07:24 PM
  1. Will Manny request to meet with Mr. Henry next ?


    Posted by doraemon2112 January 16, 09 07:24 PM
  1. I'm very glad that they're meeting & hopefully going to make a deal...however, who does your editing?

    "Free-agent catcher and Jason Varitek confirmed that he is meeting with Sox owner John Henry"... The opening sentence of this article makes me wonder who the free agent catcher is...

    Posted by 'Tash1980 January 16, 09 07:25 PM
  1. A previous comment hit the nail on the head...why does Tek get so much credit for good pitching performances, yet when the pitchers get lit up ( see 2008 ALCS , Upton et.al.) , none of that is Tek's fault, it's all on the pitchers? Along with a .220 BA and the inability to throw anybody out anymore, it just might be time to say Thank you and Goodnight.

    Posted by Fenway Frank January 16, 09 07:26 PM
  1. stick a fork in em' he's DONE.....

    Posted by Sal Paradise January 16, 09 07:27 PM
  1. We need Tek. You think Smoltz, Penny, Beckett and Dice-K are gonna trust Bard or some untested AAA catcher. Whether or not he play 90% or 50% of the time Tek needs to be here for the pitchers. A small year or two year contact with lots of incentives is the way to go. Come on now...its not like we haven't had players here that struck out a lot....Belhorn, Lugo...etc. He is the Captain and has a jerk for an agent. he had a bad year...everyone is allowed a bad year...

    Posted by Ray January 16, 09 07:29 PM
  1. This is really simple. What are our options? We can't have Bard catching every day, right? The pitching staff would have to suffer if that was the case. Sign Varitek for 2/17-18 and let him groom some young'uns. Yeah, it's a spaghetti bat in the lineup but can he be any worse than last year? The guy went through a divorce, he's a proud dude, you'd have to think he's working his tail off to get ready. Also, consider this: would Varitek go to the Yankees like Damon did? Imagine the trade secrets he could share? But he won't go because he hates the Yankees. We can show him a little loyalty, can't we?

    Posted by Kampy1 January 16, 09 07:31 PM
  1. Why does anyone care what John Henry pays? It's not our money, and there is no salary cap in baseball. Bring him back already.

    Posted by Y8S January 16, 09 07:35 PM
  1. Get rid of him...and Twatney too. If you can run Wakefield out on a rail, that would work too.

    Posted by disko2k January 16, 09 07:37 PM
  1. There are not alot of catchers out there and Tek knows the Red Sox system. Bring him back for a year with incentives for a second.

    Posted by BZ January 16, 09 07:43 PM
  1. I think you give him a 3 year deal with a low base and tons of incentives. This should obviously be his last year as a starter, but he could be a very good back up for a few years... much better than Mirasmelli and Cash probably, plus it allows him to stick around for a few years to teach the new starter how to call a good game... right?

    Posted by MacPaddy January 16, 09 07:43 PM
  1. Reduce his workload let him guide and give his experience to our crop of good young pitchers.He helped carry the Sox for the last ten years give him the respect that is due him.Let the TEAM carry him for awhile he deserves it. He won't embarrass the TEAM.Good job 'Tek' and thanks.
    Bobby from Brockton

    Posted by Bob Solakoff January 16, 09 07:48 PM
  1. Offer him 5 Mil. Tell BorASS to make up the difference as to what HE thinks Tek is worth!

    Posted by P. Casey January 16, 09 07:49 PM
  1. "This guy has helped us win two WS in a short span of time"

    So you want Mark Bellhorn back at 2B too? Teams have to cut declining players at the right time, like the Patriots do.

    Posted by will January 16, 09 07:50 PM
  1. The people who want Varitek back clearly do not understand the dynamic business of baseball. He was offered arbitration at a ridiculously high salary that he doesn't deserve. I liked him as much as the next person, especially because he is such a good guy, but when he said no to arbitration it was like he was snubbing the Sox and the fans. I hope he gets no offers at all and is forced to retire dishonorably. I always thought he'd retire in Boston, but it was TEK who went looking for another deal in another city -- the SOX tried to retain him. Peace out Tek -- hope you have a good life bro -- you ripped out my heart and now I hope the same happens to you!!

    Posted by Bobby Bluefield January 16, 09 07:53 PM
  1. Don't let the door hit you on the way out, Tek.

    Posted by Salty in '09 January 16, 09 07:54 PM
  1. Hey Eric Pitching n defense wins? well btw Jason dosen't pitch and not the best @ defense (throwing runners out) he can't even catch Wake! guess he's to busy checking the past history of hitters.He call a great game, (ya right)if that is so important then it's not about the pitching.i'm surprised catchers don't have a era if this so true.OVER RATED it's not just about Money (greed) it's about production ,only his offense and defense are way below average.a great guy to have (teamate) he's like a Joey Corra was ,a smart backup to have ,around 2 mill

    Posted by Paul January 16, 09 07:59 PM
  1. I do think Tek made a mistake or two this off season, but I put most of the blame on Boras. And yes, he has lost his bat, but he does have a great relationship with all of the pitchers and seems to be able to bring out their confidence (2 no-nos in 2 years). No one could disagree that he is one of the most prepared catchers in baseball history, so why not bring him back, let him work with Bard, and the other young guys. Pay him like Smoltz... a reasonable base pay and bonuses upon reaching production goals. If he does well with the bat again, we all win, if he doesn't at least the young catchers will win by get the opportunity to learn from one of the smartest in the game.

    Posted by CPearson January 16, 09 08:00 PM
  1. Here's what I want. I want to see a press announcement that Tek is coming back and that as part of the deal he agreed to never associate with Boras again. Then, on a serious note, I want to see Tek end his career here and becoming a developing future coach.

    Posted by David Huber January 16, 09 08:01 PM
  1. Love to see Tek get a combination player / coach offer from the Sox. If his true value is everything that he has to offer working with the pitchers then let him catch another year or two and then make him an offer to work as pitching / catching coach of some sort. This would allow the Sox to offer him a multi year deal without being stuck with him at catcher forever. I can see him taking less $ per yr in a situation like that as well.

    Posted by nysoxfan January 16, 09 08:01 PM
  1. Varitek saves a run or two behind the plate, so anything offensive he adds is gravy. You can't honestly say he isn't one of the best pitch caller the game has ever seen.

    Posted by Jeff January 16, 09 08:05 PM
  1. what happened to the talk about joe mauer ? That would be something to drool about.........

    Posted by mark H January 16, 09 08:05 PM
  1. The man is a cheater and deserves nothing. He is over the hill and has been for at least 2 years now. He stole money from the sox for the last 2 years. Let him go already. You people think he is johhny bench.

    Posted by rickb101 January 16, 09 08:18 PM
  1. He made a big mistake passing on arbitration especially in this economy. What was he thinking? He's 37 and has had 3 bad years at the plate. When he got to the plate you were pretty sure nothing good was going to happen. This stuff doesnt get better with age.

    I say give him either a 1 year for 7 to 9 mil or multi year for 5 mil b/c he can call a good game.

    Posted by Jesse January 16, 09 08:23 PM
  1. Do not underestimate the leadership qualities that Jason Varitek brings to the table. He offers intangibles that have made him such a valued member of a team that won its first two World Series titles since 1918. He may not have the same stick that he had coming up through the organization after the steal of the 90’s that brought both him and Derek Lowe to Boston from Seattle, but he is amongst the best and the brightest we have seen play at Fenway Park in recent memory, if not team history. I hope to see him behind the plate on a part time basis next year, perhaps one-third to one-half of the games, preferably teaching the pitching staff ropes to a new catcher, while being groomed for a future managerial role in the organization. One way or the other, I wish him the best.

    Posted by JM January 16, 09 08:26 PM
  1. Tek invited the owner but did not invite the agent, Theo will be invovled in the mtg by phone and Tek will be signed within a few days. Sure he can't hit but he is the best catcher available to work with pitchers, especially young ones, sign him for one maybe two years.

    Posted by Dave January 16, 09 08:29 PM
  1. Five Million, one year contract with a team option for year two. That's it. Take it or leave it.

    Posted by Bill January 16, 09 08:29 PM
  1. Hey - all of you out there who want to bend for Varitek. I remember that 4 years ago, Varitek stepped up during the negotiations, and told Bor-ass that he wanted to stop at the $40 mil he got offered. That ended it !! HE DIDN'T DO THAT THIS TIME !! He's a grown dude !!...a selfish one...let's move on...... on top of that, I got no respect for a millionaire who trades in his wife and family for a newer model.

    Posted by tekasam January 16, 09 08:32 PM
  1. Hoping John Henry checks the closets and under the bed at Tek's place before they talk. Just a bit too coincidental to have Tek set up a meeting with John Henry on the very same day Scott Boras is in Atlanta. The timing of ths meeting doesn't quite smell right.

    Posted by Mike66 January 16, 09 08:33 PM
  1. glad to see mr. henry taking control of the situation. tek should come back while the sox also pursue the catcher of the future, no doubt. hes played his ass off here and has been a big part of a lot of big wins, including 2 rings. stats dont always tell the whole story. anyone that has played sports knows that certain players bring things to the table that dont show up on the stat sheet. hes one of those players.

    Posted by pj January 16, 09 08:34 PM
  1. Tek should stay in the organization. Whenever he moves from player to coach, and I'll leave the timing of that to wiser baseball minds, he should stay in the Sox family.

    Posted by pt January 16, 09 08:43 PM
  1. Henry flying out to meet a Boras client? Sounds like he'll be signing with the Yankees on Monday.

    Posted by Patrick January 16, 09 08:49 PM
  1. John Henry to Tek:

    'Thanks Tek for all the years of service but your arm is gone and you totally blew the calls in the ALCS. We are going younger but just to show you I'm not the bad guy in all of this I'll pick up the dinner tab".

    Oh, and John one more thing. If you do cave to his sobbing NO MORE THAN ONE YEAR AT 2 MILLION.

    Posted by MMole January 16, 09 08:49 PM
  1. Why would the Red Sox give him a two-year deal for $20 million? Arbitration would have been one year at $10 million; are they tipping 100% or something? I don't think they'd give him one year/$10 million now, because they don't need to in this market, and he's not worth it. And if the team gets a young catcher they only need Varitek for one year of mentoring. But if that's what they need, they should hire him as a special coach, and pay him something between a player and coach salary (I know, it won't happen).

    Posted by OCB January 16, 09 08:50 PM
  1. Of all the teams in MLB not 1 has shown any interest in Tek. Do you really think they're missing something? Bring him back and watch him achieve the lowest percentage throwing out base stealers. If he comes back and make him bunt w/ a runner on first. All this crap about calling a game. Veteran pitchers shake off what they don't want to throw anyway. The battery does their homework before a game and develop a pitch plan for each hitter in the line up. The veteran pitchers can teach young catchers almost as well as a veteran catcher. Get the young catchers in the game. Let them work out the butterflys, make their mistakes, and develop. Who knows they may hit .270 and throw out more than half the base stealers. wouldn't that be something.


    Posted by Hawaiiguy January 16, 09 08:53 PM
  1. "Remember, Varitek was in the middle of a nasty divorce last year. Hopefully, he has that BS put behind him and he rebounds from the stress of it all.
    Not making excuses, but I don't think the guy is done. I can remember a certain Sox pitcher that wore his emotions on his sleeve that had a down year during his divorce."

    This excuse is the lamest. A nasty divorce? OK, if you start an affair and an ensuing divorce causes you to under-perform at your job, try blaming the divorce to see if your employer is willing to accept that. That's not about player being a human; it's about doing your job and managing your own personal life. Why should we hold a millionaire player to a standard that's LOWER than average Joe's?

    As far as whether he is done, look at his stats for the past 3 years, as some one has pointed out. And don't give us game-calling BS. The Phillies pitching coach's comment prior to the World Series about Red Sox pitchers put the blame right on Varitek.

    What I see here is Jason and his agent are playing good cop bad cop, just like A-Rod did last year. Please don't fall for that.

    Posted by WAG January 16, 09 08:53 PM
  1. Good, I sincerely hope the Red Sox sign him, I want to see them with a starting catcher who bats 220. In fact, I hope they sign him to a multi-year deal because his hitting will get worse as he gets older and he is already 37.

    Posted by Louis January 16, 09 09:01 PM
  1. Tek had a horrible season. I remember Mike Lowell having such a bad year a while back that his team forced the Red Sox to accept him in trade, in order to complete a certain deal. Anyone recall what happened?

    Tek has been an invaluable part of two championship teams. He deserves better than what most so-called fans are giving him. Yet we wonder why players take the money and run. I'm ashamed of Red Sox Nation tonight reading most of the comments here. Sickening. I'm not saying to break the bank for him. He HAS been well compensated for the past 4 years. But to be so vicious about it...well those that take that attitude really disgust me as a fan.


    Posted by Dano50 January 16, 09 09:03 PM
  1. It is very very simple....Look at the track record the sox have had when he has gone down to injury. It is bad period. When he's around, the sox are the team that wins around 95 games/ year and gets into the tournament. He isn't an offensive force, never really was. I would love to see him just settle in to one side of the plate for the year and abandon switch hitting, but that is near irrelevant. His game prep is a real difference maker, and pitchers are comfortable with him. I would love to see him end his playing career in Boston and migrate to a coaching roll bullpen coach etc...

    Posted by Bob January 16, 09 09:04 PM
  1. Almost all of you Tek haters miss a very important point. You are worried about 4-5 at bats at the bottom of the batting order and forgetting that the catcher is involved with more defensive plays (every pitch) in every game than any other defensive player. Pitchers only pitch every 5 games. Tek catches almost every game. 95% of a catchers job is to catch, not hit. Calling a game is much more important than 5 at bats at the end of the order. I am happy they may get him back, especially with no replacement in sight less than 3 weeks before pitchers and catchers are to report to spring training.

    Posted by Scott January 16, 09 09:06 PM
  1. The only way we should take Tek back is in management ... he's done behind the plate ... he can't hit ... he needs to move on with the next stage of his career

    Posted by Indy January 16, 09 09:06 PM
  1. Varitek had a good run here, but it's over. His hitting ability is nil and he can't throw out baserunners. Time to bow out gracefully, Tek.

    Posted by RD January 16, 09 09:12 PM
  1. I don't care if he walks to home plate without a bat in his hands for the entire season!!! He is the heart and soul of the pitching staff. The pitchers, young and old have confidence in how he calls a game. There is no other catcher in MLB that calls a better game and prepares his staff for the same. I hope the sox sign him long enough for him to retire in Boston so they can make him part of the coaching staff.

    Oh yeah, somebody mentioned that Carlton Fisk was the best backstop in Sox history... Uh, how many rings does old Fiskie have? I'm sorry could you repeat that but say it a little louder.....

    Posted by BallsDeep January 16, 09 09:13 PM
  1. The .220 BA isn't as bad as some people make out. That's 93 hits over 423 at bats. Conversely, a .250 hitter would've hit 106 hits. That's 13 more hits over the course of a 131 games, or 1 more hit ever 10 games or so.

    Let's face it, it isn't likely we're going to do much better than a .250 hitter behind the plate next year anyway. Thus, I'd take good management of pitchers over 1 more hit every 10 games. Plus, while I don't expect Varitek to regain the form he had a few years ago, I wouldn't be shocked to see him put up .250 and 15 HR next season.

    Posted by Jon January 16, 09 09:18 PM
  1. Varitek is an important part of the Red Sox team. His skills in coaching pitchers, the institutional knowledge he carries, his leadership qualities, warrant another 1-2 yr contract. Especially as his valuable knowledge can be passed on to the new generation of Red Sox catchers, Bard, etc.
    Boras has not done 'Tek any favors by holding out.

    Posted by AnnetteRob13 January 16, 09 09:19 PM
  1. Great news now get it done !

    Posted by bosoxyaz8 January 16, 09 09:24 PM
  1. I have to go 50/50. I want him here because of what he brings to the club and to the pitchers.
    on the OTHER hand he needs a batting average to match what he does behind the plate. I want to say it was a bad year for him due to personal crap he had going on.
    It is hard to just say go; but like that pair of comfortable jeans that are no longer worthy of even your favorite sports bar, what is Theo to do? Josh bard isn't the answer, heck there isn't a good catcher out there at all.
    He is still one of my all-time favorite players of the sport not just of the Red Sox.
    If it is any indication that Bor-ASS isn't invited it could be that J-Tek is going to come back for two years for like maybe 'tween 14 - 18 mil.

    Posted by Steph#33 January 16, 09 09:29 PM
  1. I love how the Red Sox' pitching "fell apart" in 2006 due to Varitek's absence. It wouldn't have anything to do with ham and eggers like Kyle Snyder, Jason Johnson, Lenny DiNardo, or Kevin Jarvis starting games late in that season, would it? Nah, it had to be the Captain. Just look at the great season Clay Buchholz had with 'Tek behind the plate in '08. Oh, wait...

    Posted by Ed Sarkavakian January 16, 09 09:32 PM
  1. mauer and morneau, anyone?

    Posted by rlstewart January 16, 09 09:47 PM
  1. Who are these idiots saying give him $10 million? How about 3 million plua incentives with the Sox holding an option for 2010. Sorry Jason, your agent cost you millions. Time to say Bye Bye Boras.

    Posted by Bob Montgomery January 16, 09 09:50 PM
  1. It's no accident that JV has been such an able captain of this team. Few players prepare as hard as he does, few catchers can call a game as well as he does--he's a consummate professional. And I don't think that believing that 'Tek will have a better season at the plate this year makes me a hopeless optimist. Personally, I'm hoping that the parties can find common ground, and that 'Tek returns.

    Posted by deminimus January 16, 09 09:57 PM
  1. OH MY GOD, all you IDIOTS who want to let Tek go because he can't hit (it doesn't freakin MATTER if he can't hit, he is a catcher, his role is to work with the pitchers - he is a No. 9 hittier, WHAT team has a good No. 9 hitter??), who is going to replace him???? There is no one out there that is going to replace him, don't you all realize that? Sign him for one more year, overpay him, who cares. They overpaid for J.D. Drew and Lugo. NOW they have to get rid of Lugo and pay his salary. Don't you think that Tek is worth more to the Red Sox than freakin Lugo???? Tek can come back for the year and work with a younger catcher. By the way the Yankees don't know if Posada is going to be healthy. Do ANY OF YOU want to see Tek is a Yankee Uniform???

    Posted by suesunswim January 16, 09 10:03 PM
  1. Jason, thank you for holding this negotiation without Boras.
    I hope you and the Sox come to terms to keep you in the organization for now as a player and hopefully as part of the management staff in the future. You are a consumate professional and a great team captain.You have been been very patient throughout this rocky offseason negotiation which is due to Boras's demands . I hope you sign with the Sox and be named comeback player of the year . The Sox need you and I believe deep down you want to stay with the Sox.

    Posted by JMCG January 16, 09 10:08 PM
  1. Tek has been a big part of this team for many years.

    I say offer him a lower dollar contract with incentive clauses that only pay out if he delivers.

    But if he ain't hitting by May...

    Posted by guido January 16, 09 10:09 PM
  1. Just what I want to hear. Jason is his own man. He should tell Boras to let him negotiate on his own terms. Jason is too valuable to let go.

    Posted by Bob Wasserman January 16, 09 10:12 PM
  1. Papa DAN........
    "My guess is the Sox will give Tek a two year deal for $ 20 mil;"
    I can only hope you are joking. I like Varitek and I don't think bringing him back is the worst thing. Altho it's not the best thing either, but if Theo gave Varitek $20 million he would be unemployed and his saliva and blood tested. I am guessing they will give him one year at $5-7 million and they will be creative with a 2nd year.

    Posted by BobL January 16, 09 10:16 PM
  1. I agree with an earlier comment regarding 'divorce' . There's enough history to show that that can influence performance. Also, its , as stated, a good time for the Sox to make an offer, the same 10 mill offer, and throw in the post career coaching etc etc. while the Sox hold the hi ground. So, this situation should hopefully resolve with Tek being a better contributor this year, and have him positioned to add knowledge later.

    Posted by gravymanstan January 16, 09 10:26 PM
  1. Tek and the Sox both need to be reasonable. If the Sox can pay for others as they have, Tek deserves elite catcher cash...Boras is a jerk--yes--but recall, his last contract was not without drama that never should have been. They will get this done. The years may be short; the figure will be $10-12M annually!

    Posted by minnesoxfan January 16, 09 10:27 PM
  1. WE WANT TEK

    Posted by E January 16, 09 10:28 PM
  1. For those sox fans that think there is a better catcher to call games, get your head out of the sand. There are many average catchers in the league, but very few that are true leaders like Tek. Tek will be a great bridge for a young future catcher.

    Posted by Jeff Kalish January 16, 09 10:31 PM
  1. JV is a banjo hitter, and a benefactor of Red Sox media shill propaganda about how "he handles the pitching staff so well and is always prepared and works hard."

    Big deal doesn't he make ridiculous money to do this already.

    Posted by rob January 16, 09 10:32 PM
  1. He is washed up and needs to be replaced with someone who
    can hit and catch a knuckleball.Maybe he can join Manny and
    Andrew Jones on the umemployement line.

    Posted by Paul January 16, 09 10:34 PM
  1. All you people who are talkin trash about Varitek need to shut up. Obviously, you are not loyal Red Sox fans. He is a crucial part of this clubhouse and no one can match him there. So he had a bad year, BIG DEAL. His personal life was in the crapper. What do you expect? And where do you all get off anyway?! He has more talent in his pinky finger than you all have in your whole bodies. COME BACK VARITECK. WE NEED YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Posted by Cari January 16, 09 10:48 PM
  1. Having a pitching staff like the one the Sox have in place.......a Beckett who has won in 2 World Series, a Jon Lester who Varitek guided into the strategy of major league pitching........a John Smoltz as a starter around May, a guy that no young catcher will convince that he can choose pitch selection better than him, and who, as great as he's been, is facing all American League hitters.......ditto for Brad Penny.......and last but not least, all the work in being able to communicate with and gain the confidence of Daisuke etc etc etc, we NEED Tek. If he ups his average to .255 it will be nothing but gravy. A new guy back there can ruin it all.

    Posted by LEE G January 16, 09 11:04 PM
  1. I think it is great news that Tek and Mr. Henry are meeting without the man that has no regard for Tek's best interest or his legacy with the Sox. I see a 3 Yr 33million dollar deal if Tek fires scum bag Boras.

    Posted by jstet77 January 16, 09 11:15 PM
  1. i hope they sign him back.. they need him! bring TEK back to the redsox!

    Posted by kat_pittbull January 16, 09 11:20 PM
  1. Varitek can't hit anymore; he can't really throw anymore, and we have a number of key veteran pitchers who don't really need his expertise in order to succeed. He has become something of a sacred cow around here. Hell, we recovered from Petey leaving, recovered from Johnny leaving, and Bill and Kevin, and Trot, and Orlando. We need a catcher who can hit a little and one who can be pinched hit for. Francona didn't have the guts to pinch hit for him once during the regular season even though he was useless at the plate and killed one rally after another. When Terry finally did pinch hit for him in the playoffs he sulked and got angry. Some team player, some captain setting an example for the rest of the team.

    PUNCH HIS TICKET OUT OF TOWN ONCE AND FOR ALL and watch him out of baseball this year because no other team wants him. Henry should remember that if he is tempted to resign him.

    Posted by SeaBeach Fred January 16, 09 11:25 PM
  1. Maybe the Sox can use the DH in the catcher's slot and let the pitchers hit. I don't think the DH rules require that it be the pitcher who is replaced in the offensive lineup. I could be wrong about that. I'm obviously joking, but not by much.

    Posted by Jim Nagle January 16, 09 11:30 PM
  1. Yes, Varitek has declined a lot over the last few years but a big bat is not everything in baseball. This guys brings more "intangibles" than any other player on the team. Most importantly, he is the Captain and part of the core of the Boston Red Sox. For what he has brought to this team - his work ethic, guts and spirit - he does not deserve to be disrespected or treated like some disposable commodity as other posters have suggested. Boras should be thrown under the bus and ignored; Varitek should not be as long as he is talking to the Sox man to man with Bor-ass out of the picture. His bat sucks big time but I hope that we can get another year or two with him leading the team, grooming his replacement and moving on to a Sox coaching job for life. More importantly, he is the best catching option on the market right now.

    Posted by Dave January 16, 09 11:33 PM
  1. Jason is the best we have had in ages. Get real people everyone has a bad year - I predict this to be one of his best years.

    Posted by Pat January 16, 09 11:35 PM
  1. We have to keep Jason Varitek, so like Carton Fisk we won't be missing him play
    well for another 10-12 years on another team and land in the Hall of Fame. We were very lucky Carlton Went in the hall in a Red Sox uniform. Varitek's a great catcher AND A great leader and is happy here in Boston. Hopefully his numbers will go up. Love you Jason.

    Posted by Maggie1 January 16, 09 11:36 PM
  1. Why can't TEK dump Boras and sign for the 2 years with an option and save the money that Boris would get for representing him.

    Posted by yankeeshater January 16, 09 11:43 PM
  1. Whatever they do, I think they are handling this the right way. Theo holds all the cards right now. There's absolutely ZERO market for him right now. Depending on what else is going on with the catching market and if they decide to make the trade for Salty, I wouldn't offer much to Varitek at all right now and if they go in another direction so be it.

    I know he's a great game caller and the pitchers love him and all but we knew eventually the day would come where someone else would have to take over. You hoped Tek could break the new kid in but if he can't they'll make due without him. This team has enough talent to survive and they will survive.

    Posted by Aaron January 16, 09 11:45 PM
  1. What would Belichick do? Answer: Not get sentimental over a 37 year old catcher who has seen his best days.

    Posted by turflion January 16, 09 11:48 PM
  1. Veritek and Henry had a long talk, and Tek called it positive, and said he wants to return to the Sox. This could be great news. I hope the negotiations are short, that Tek returns with a generous but realistic contract, retires in a couple of years and stays in a Boston uniform as coach and then manager. RSN needs Tek to resign as captain of the Red Sox. But the decision seems to be up to Tek. Henry went to the meeting to invite Tek back, to discuss parameters, but not on Boras' obscene terms. The decision is Tek's to make.

    Posted by Giraud January 17, 09 12:06 AM
  1. Four no-hitters caught, major league record. Could have been five if Pedro wasn't so stubborn, six if Schilling had a little luck. 'Nuff said.

    Posted by MrTH January 17, 09 12:38 AM
  1. Look, I respect 'Tek for what he has done for the Sox. But the past is past, and his recent past points to "more of the same" as opposed to "he might get better". Look catchers generally don't age well, and father time hasn't skipped over 'Tek. If you are a real Sox fan, and want the team to win, having an automatic out like 'Tek in the lineup is not going to get us over the top in a strong AL East this year. The last I checked, the AL doesn't require the pitcher to bat, so why would we essentially put the equivalent out there? As many of you forgot, last year the bottom 3rd of our lineup were basically automatic outs(watch replay's of the play-offs if you think differently). Why would you want to bring them back?

    Posted by ScubaSteve January 17, 09 12:51 AM
  1. Ghee with Texeira at 1b, we could carry a Catcher who hits like a shortstop, and throws out nobody.

    Without, Tex., the lineup is too shallow for an automatic out.
    It is a god DAWG[georgia] shame.

    Offer him a 1-2m contract for 1 year. He rolled the dice. He lost.
    Do not let fondness, reward Boras.

    Posted by lavanny January 17, 09 12:54 AM
  1. Ha! People on this board are suggesting giving Varitek 2YR/$20M when there is NO MARKET for him? He ALREADY TURNED DOWN 1YR/$10M....why would you, after 3 months, offering him DOUBLE THAT AMOUNT???

    1YR/$5M and dont let the door hit you on the way out of 2009.

    Posted by Locke January 17, 09 12:58 AM
  1. Bring him back! I can't even believe it has taken this long to make him another offer or to see some progress. I read all of these posts about "get rid of him" "he can't hit a fastball." Well, Jason Bay has a hard time hitting curveballs. Does that mean we are trading him now too? Jed Lowrie couldn't swing anywhere near the ball the last month of the season and everyone wants him to be the starting shortstop. Just look around the league and you tell me how many catchers are hitting .290+. Or how about I just save you some time and tell you not very many are. You can probably count on two hands how many big league catchers have good averages. The guy calls a great game in my eyes; and leads this team like no one else could. Show some support

    Posted by JTuck January 17, 09 01:05 AM
  1. Varitek's strategy this offseason (and don't insult him with the Boras leading him around crap this isn't a simpleton like Manny) was the same as the last time he was a FA. No one even offerred him a contract yet the Sox paid him 10m a year and gave him a virtual no trade clause.

    He is probably genuinely stunned that the Sox don't want to pay him big $ for multiple years.

    Posted by marc January 17, 09 01:06 AM
  1. let me see if i have this right. You batted .220 last year, your old, and you could have made $10-12 Million dollars next year. Your agent told you to turn that down?

    OK - lets keep it simple and be real. That was bad advice. That was a bad mistake on your part Mr. Veritek. That and the fact that you're beyond clueless what your Japanese pitchers want to throw.

    Posted by John Panzer January 17, 09 01:08 AM
  1. Sign Varitek but on the Red Sox terms. Trade Bucholz, who is the second coming of Aaron Sele to Texas for Salty. Why the debate about keeping Bucholz? he was slammed by everybody last year, his fastball is toast. keep Varitek for one year with a team option and groom Salty. Not all of these young players you are anxious to hang on to will pan out. Bucholz will not, I promise you.

    Posted by Tom Konjoyan, fan since 1958 January 17, 09 01:11 AM
  1. Yawn. I wanted Teixeira.

    Posted by Cheap Sox? January 17, 09 01:22 AM
  1. A captain of your team rejects a $10mil per season offer says to me maybe his so called leadership is not what it is all cracked up to be.
    If you wear a Red Sox uniform and you have that C on your jersey you and you reject a $10mil a year offer then realize that you can get anywhere near that on the market and you come crawling back you can either accept a lot less or get lost. He certainly should not be the captain of this team. I think a guy with a heart bigger than Scott Boras check book in Dustin Pedroia should have that honor. Not a catcher who turned his back on $10mil only to come crawling back and asking for forgiveness.

    Posted by Badger January 17, 09 01:41 AM
  1. Oh, please, let him go! I really don't wanna see him in Red Sox anymore. He's an old dog that will never learn new tricks! He was one of the big reasons why the team didn't win last year.

    Posted by John Matsubara January 17, 09 01:45 AM
  1. Good, Tek wants to be here and he's man enough to go ahead and get it done without Boras. He's not the first person to do an end run after Boras embarassed him (A-rod, anyone?) He lost a lot of money by rejecting arbitration and now he'll lose a little pride...but he wants to be a Red Sox, he has more value to Boston than to any other team and they will probably pay him more than anyone else would. A deal with Tek also gives the Sox tons of leverage with Texas and Arizona in deal for a young catcher. All of a sudden those teams will be sitting on extra catching talent in a diminished market when they have much greater needs than an extra, inexpenisve catcher. . And for everyone who thinks there is no team who will sign Tek because of the draft pick...remember the Mets signed K-rod...Tek would not cost them a first-rounder. Don't you think they would like to upgrade over Brian Schneider...Tek could hep that staff...with Pelfry and at least one other young starter. So JH, Tek...glad you both swallowed a little pride...get it done. You need each other.

    Posted by AL January 17, 09 02:23 AM
  1. It was a completely tone deaf move by Varitek and his agent to turn down the arbitration offer.

    The Sox have been good to Jason. Very good. And, clearly, he's not as intelligent as the Sox have made him out to be. He should have signed the one year arbitration deal, got his raise, kept his job (in this economy), and then had a monster year and then gone for the multi-year contract after.

    Going for a multi-year deal now is negotiating from weakness, and begs many questions. Too bad Jason wasn't more secure in his furture prospects, and wants us to foot the bill for his uncertain future.

    Posted by JR January 17, 09 02:27 AM
  1. Get it done.
    2 years, 8 Million plus 3 million bonus incentives.

    Posted by Bl January 17, 09 02:27 AM
  1. Tek is an o.k. catcher and only worth 4 mil or so. 10 mil? He was never worth that much even in his prime. He should just suck it up and take 5 mil and be happy.
    and be glad a contending team would even want him.

    Posted by ac January 17, 09 02:34 AM
  1. Tek is an o.k. catcher and only worth 4 mil or so. 10 mil? He was never worth that much even in his prime. He should just suck it up and take 5 mil and be happy.
    and be glad a contending team would even want him.

    Posted by ac January 17, 09 02:34 AM
  1. Was Hotty Watney in Atlanta with him ? CANT HIT ---CANT THROW OUT RUNNERS... make him a coach and let him call games from thebench and prep pitchers in the locker room. He was overpaid at 10 per year for 4 years.... time to let go and move on.... he has lost his skills... he cannot catch up to the fastball... we do not have the hitting to be able to CARRY him !!!

    Posted by pj January 17, 09 04:00 AM
  1. Thanks for the memories, Tek - turn him over, he's all done.

    Posted by Soundslikefrank January 17, 09 04:30 AM
  1. If Tek takes a short contract overpay IF he cuts Boras out of it. Tek and Henry mano a mano. Weaselface be damned!

    Posted by F Manny January 17, 09 04:31 AM
  1. OK, I gave John Henry a pass on not signing Teixeira, the right move as it turns out, but, if we are not going to add offense, with him, we have to try to upgrade the catcher. .220 and no cannon will not get it done this year.

    Posted by Ira January 17, 09 04:57 AM
  1. If I were the Sox, I wouldn't sign Tek until he fired his agent....The Sox kill two birds with one stone; they get Tek back and make Boras look bad.

    Posted by Thomas January 17, 09 07:17 AM
  1. WTE: "they're sending Henry". John Henry is the PRINCIPAL OWNER of the Sox. "They" don't send him anywhere--he sends them.
    Yes, Tek is another player who got bad advice from Bora$. The Sox should sign him to a short, incentive laden deal to mentor the youner catchers, and then hire him as a pitching coach when Farrell leaves (as everyone says he will).

    Posted by Shelley January 17, 09 08:01 AM
  1. Let go of the past people. Tek is done. Move on. For those that want a 37 year old Catcher that hit .220 resigned, I'd bet you think we should try to sign Pedro for the pen, and see if we can get Jim Ed as a reserve Outfielder.

    Posted by Shades January 17, 09 09:40 AM
  1. I like baseball

    Posted by Rick January 17, 09 09:52 AM
  1. Lets face it, the man knows almost every al hitter and calls a game like no one else. Remeber what happens when our staff calls off a pitch? oops wish I did not throw that pitch. aka Curt schillings no hitter. REMEBER THAT IS WORTH HOW MANY RUNS? It is easy to point the finger when the soxs are not scoring runs, the 220 ba sticks out, But what is his real JOB! CALLING GAMES AND HAVING HIS STAFF THROW THE BEST POSSIBLE PITCH TO THAT PARTICULAR HITTER. Can a rookie do that? Why is he the capt.? HE controls the game! He will figure out his hitting with some help, you all know that!

    Posted by Florida impalnt from NE Red Sox fan January 17, 09 10:22 AM
  1. Varitek is 37
    Varitek's offense has been declining over the PAST 3 YEARS - .180 since May 2008
    Varitek cant throw out runners anymore
    Varitek's defense is slipping
    Varitek ALREADY REJECTED $10M from the Sox this year.

    The Red Sox can improve in every one of these factors with another catcher. Guys, when players decline, its time to move on. Why is it so hard to understand this? And why are people suggesting MULTIPLE YEARS and salary NORTH OF $5M. Ha!!

    Please - the same people on this board advocating for his return will be the same people whining about his performance come early May. Then they'll complain that Varitek has 2 years left on his contract.

    Posted by Locke January 17, 09 11:11 AM
  1. The RedSox have more options then v-tek. 1) let the young guys play who they have, 2) sign another old free agent catcher who hit better then jason did last year. 3) trade pitching for a catcher. 4) or combo of above.

    note to tek - the baseball economy is not what it was, teams are going to generate less revenue in 2009...that is a fact...you should have taken the 1yr 10M arb deal. now your up shits creek without much leverage. There is no team out there that is going to offer you a multi year deal at 37yrs of age. Most catchers are done at 35. You had a good run...time to either retire or come back on the RedSox terms and mentor the next guy,

    Posted by brad sandler January 17, 09 11:20 AM
  1. any of you people that want tek back are FANBOY FOOLS!! I REPEAT- FANBOYS! he is going to bring our team down BADLY, we need someone (new and young) that can swing the bat. especially after losing manny and not getting tex. do you people realize how bad his avg was last year? .220!!! I REPEAT .220!!! THAT IS AWFUL. PLEASE DO NOT RESIGN VARITEK!! NO NO NO!!! yes I know what he did for our team, but nostalgia will hurt us people. DO. NOT. WANT.

    Posted by PleaseDontSignVTek January 17, 09 12:03 PM
  1. This is a classic example of the New England sports fan. Like so many times before, they clutch onto their heroes long after they have passed their prime. Was 'Tek a major player in two World Series? Yes. But the true reason for the success Sox fans have been seeing is because of Henry and the other owners. They are running this team like a business(ala Kraft) and thinking with their brains instead of their hearts. Now if only the New England fans could figure this out...

    Posted by Woodstick January 17, 09 12:35 PM
  1. Tek had a number of personal and health problems last year. The Sox should be loyal to Tek. Even with how bad Tek was the Sox still won 95 games with him behind the plate. I highly doubt the Sox could have done that with Montero or Salty back there.

    Posted by Eric Ridder January 17, 09 12:56 PM
  1. If varitek hits like last year he desurves shit.

    Posted by barry bonds January 17, 09 01:27 PM
  1. If varitek hits like last year he desurves shit.

    Posted by barry bonds January 17, 09 01:29 PM
  1. TEK'S THE MAN!

    Posted by BOB WASSERMAN January 17, 09 03:20 PM
  1. With all the college catchers out there and a whole world to search why in God's name do we want a non-hitting, non-throwing catcher who loses more games than he wins by catching because he is a worse hitter than Ellsbury which is hard to do. Tek constantly strikes out swinging wildly at pitches 4 feet outside.

    Posted by mascmen7 January 17, 09 04:17 PM
  1. Varitek has been one of the best players in sox history. That being said he is just to old and the sox should not invest so much time and money into him anymore. If I could I would thank varitek daily for what he has done for the sox, but it just comes to the point where he needs to part ways and we need to get a young catcher.

    Posted by jwest1184 January 17, 09 06:42 PM
  1. I was expecting a different a different outcome from all this. I thought that after the meeting Henry would have emailed the press and said ''We will no longer be a factor in the bidding for Varitek''. Then the Yankees could have signed him for $50 the week after.
    Gee, Yankees must be nervous...

    Posted by den666 January 17, 09 09:36 PM
  1. Interest rates are down, the market is down and banks are being bailed out. Teks average is as bad as my 401k. Bail him out and base his salary on incentives. What would it cost Henry for a catching coach?

    Posted by donsmith January 17, 09 11:16 PM
  1. PleaseDontSignVtek: You are an idiot.

    Posted by Susan January 17, 09 11:19 PM
  1. "But what is his real JOB! CALLING GAMES AND HAVING HIS STAFF THROW THE BEST POSSIBLE PITCH TO THAT PARTICULAR HITTER. Can a rookie do that? Why is he the capt.? HE controls the game! He will figure out his hitting with some help, you all know that!"


    This is such BS conjecture. Can you come up with one tangible stat or figure to support this? All you're doing is rehashing the same crap you hear on message boards, radio call ins, and anecdotal broadcast comments. But basically it's "when the Red Sox win, it's because of Varitek"; "when the Red Sox lose it's because the pitchers shrugged off his holy grail of game calling"

    i love that his 2008 divorce problems only affected his offense but not his game calling or declining defensive skills. Way to cherry pick that one.

    Posted by Locke January 18, 09 03:10 AM
  1. 1 Year @ 8 mil to solidify the best pitching staff in the majors!! Enough said; he is owed this!!! 1 last World Series and retire!!!

    Posted by Craig January 18, 09 08:40 AM
  1. Heidi did a spot on NESN last night concerning John Henry's trip to Georgia. She reported that JV wants to retire as a Red Sox player because he is a very loyal person. IS THAT SO ??? Guess she forgot about Karen Varitek and the kids !!

    Posted by tekasam January 18, 09 10:25 AM
  1. Jason is only meeting with Henry because there are no other suitors. I guarantee Boras suggested Jason set up the meeting in hopes that Henry will have a soft-spot and give him the 10mil he would have gotten in arbitration. Trust me, Boras is sneaky. Does anyone actually believe an idiot like Arod is smart enough to add "historical" clauses (30mil) on his own?? Boras is involved here and knows this is the only way Jason gets close to 10mil for 2010.

    Posted by nysoxfan January 18, 09 12:52 PM
  1. Anyone remember this same saga happening with A-Rod and the Yankees? Same Boras tactic. The team gets pissed, tired of being jerked around. Boras tells the player to have a private metting to patch things up... only difference is the Red Sox don't overspend for has-beens.

    I think the Red Sox got it right when they found out Teixeira led them on... forget Boras and his overpriced clients. I'd rather lose than hire anymore of his people. Move on. I never liked Varitek anyway, even if he is the reason for the no-nos and whatever, I don't care. I'd rather have Mirabelli back for far less money.

    SAY NO TO VARITEK.

    Posted by David January 18, 09 01:47 PM
  1. Boras Is behind it, he was the one who told Varitek to request the meeting. It sounds the same as Arod did last year with the Yankees. Boras dosn't minds to bee looked as the bad guy. But he always achieves his goals.

    Posted by holysoxfan January 18, 09 02:27 PM
  1. These are grown men, why must these guys put their livelyhood in the hands of an agent. How many of you out there use an agent in any negotiations for your jobs. If you are in your 20s and 30s and dont know what your worth you got problems. BORAS is bad for the game.....he has his prints all over this debacle.....mark my words he will eventually screw something up good and be banned from baseball. Varitek is worth a base salary of 2 milliion with incentives to bring it to 7 million if he produces, than a club option for next year. Take it Tek, this is the price of doing business with BORAS.......

    Posted by Mike C January 18, 09 04:54 PM
  1. Can't hit, can't throw any runners out, old, slow. He's more than just an automatic out and an inning-killer, he had the lowest line-drive percentage in the AL last year. That means when he didn't get a hit, he was popping up, grounding out, or just missing. Great ride while it lasted but it's time to move on. Just go with a young guy to develop and call the game from the dugout. At his age, it's just going to get worse.

    Posted by Mike McCloskey January 18, 09 10:31 PM
  1. hey Susan: way to be a fanboy. yeah, you heard me- FANBOY. you provide no reason to keep him (not that there is one) and call me an "idiot" despite the fact that I provided a solid reason not to keep Jason "OVER THE HILL./ MR.220/ TAKE YOUR TEN MIL AND SHOVE IT BECAUSE IM WITH SCOTT BORAS" Varitek!

    SAY NO TO VARITEK! you nostalgic fans need to wake up!!! do you even realize how bad he is now? WAKE UP FANBOYS! it would be like if the yankees signed pudge rodriguez back- A TERRIBLE MOVE! If john henry approved taking v-tek back I would be much more pissed than I was about not getting texiera.
    I

    you dont like what im saying? go cry about it.

    Posted by PleaseDontSignVTek January 19, 09 12:44 AM
  1. So they had a meeting BFD!
    "nothing new to report"...
    "He WANTS to return to the team".....

    Apparently not that bad that he would dump the biggest impediment to his stated goals. "Squat Bore-ass " doesn't care about Tek and is perfectly willing to let him sit idle ...time to Dump Bore-ass and come home Tek. Even a dope like Arod had the smarts enough to do that. I like Tek, as He's a large part of the recent lore, but I dislike Bore-ass so that if I ran the team, I wouln't court ANY of his clients.

    Posted by ctsoxguy January 19, 09 08:22 AM
  1. Veritek had a rough year in all aspects of his life last year. I think we owe it to the guy to stage a comeback for the Red Sox. A nice incentive laden contract that benefit all parties involved.

    Posted by Chris January 19, 09 08:56 AM
  1. Time for Tek to man up and dump his agent and do this contrat by himself or get another agent. I hope the Sox never deal with that A-hole of an agent again. Maybe give him a 1 year 3 million salary with a bunch of incentives letting him earn up to 8 million. No more than 1 year though we need to get younger at catcher. I would love to see Joe Mauer come to the Sox via a trade.

    Posted by bryan January 19, 09 10:31 AM
  1. Pulled a Nomar, absolutely. Decline $10mil in arbitration? He "trusted" his agent. The AntiChrist wasn't dealing for Tek, he was dealing for himself. Played 1 player against another to land the big 1 - the Tex deal - not the Tek deal. You'd think Boras'd be happy with a fee from $10mil. He knew none'd pay more for Tek at his age and worst offensive season. Remember when catchers were not even considered for offense - it was a bonus. Anything from Tek's bat is gravy. The Sox need this guy to be solid up the middle defensively - the keystone to a great team. And his going to JH is a very humble sign, you don't see that these days from players anymore. Sign Tek to a heavy incentive laden deal. Please!

    Posted by dan January 20, 09 05:37 AM

  1. i have been a long time red sox fan, and i can't ever remeber not cheering for any of their players. But, i will never cheer for Varitek ever again. The way i see it ,he is suppose to be a captain and a leader. After his comments, about not knowing a team would have to give up a # 1 draft pick, he is either very stupid ,( along with his agent), or he is lieing!!!

    Posted by graeme harding January 20, 09 06:11 PM
  1. One last comment here... If Jason didn't know that the Sox would have had draft picks coming their way had he signed elsewhere; and said HE takes the blame for that...it leaves me with one question.

    If he doesn't think he's worth a couple of draft picks, why on earth does he and/or Boras think he's worth $10m+ over multiple years?

    Posted by Ytsejamer1 January 21, 09 10:06 AM
  1. I find it hilarious Tek says it's not Boras's fault that he chose not to take arbitration because Tek didn't know about the draft choice. Uh, that's why you have an agent, right? To know all the info and scenarios and provide them to your client so he can make an informed decision? So by stating he didn't know, Tek indirectly threw Boras under the bus anyways. It's a pretty fair assumption that - after firing Boras - Tek should sign a 2-year incentive-laden contract. But if the Red Sox do sign him, just remember: coming off such a crappy season and without much of a market for his services, you'd think Tek, the team captain, would show at least SOME loyalty and gratitude to the Red Sox organization and its fans by taking the absurd gift the Red Sox offered in arbitration, but NOOOO! By refusing that cake, Tek showed his true colors, which are green, green, greedy GREEN. No sense of responsibility for his poor performance, no desire to prove he deserves all that money he wants and he's been paid already, just greed, so Tek, you should go get more money somewhere else, you ingrate! Whoops, guess there's no money out there for an old catcher who's getting older and can't hit and has fielding and throwing issues, again, something your agent should've brought to your attention as a possible scenario.

    Posted by danalogue January 21, 09 04:50 PM
  1. I find it hilarious Tek says it's not Boras's fault that he chose not to take arbitration because Tek didn't know about the draft choice. Uh, that's why you have an agent, right? To know all the info and scenarios and provide them to your client so he can make an informed decision? So by stating he didn't know, Tek indirectly threw Boras under the bus anyways. It's a pretty fair assumption that - after firing Boras - Tek should sign a 2-year incentive-laden contract. But if the Red Sox do sign him, just remember: coming off such a crappy season and without much of a market for his services, you'd think Tek, the team captain, would show at least SOME loyalty and gratitude to the Red Sox organization and its fans by taking the absurd gift the Red Sox offered in arbitration, but NOOOO! By refusing that cake, Tek showed his true colors, which are green, green, greedy GREEN. No sense of responsibility for his poor performance, no desire to prove he deserves all that money he wants and he's been paid already, just greed, so Tek, you should go get more money somewhere else, you ingrate! Whoops, guess there's no money out there for an old catcher who's getting older and can't hit and has fielding and throwing issues, again, something your agent should've brought to your attention as a possible scenario.

    Posted by danalogue January 21, 09 04:52 PM
add your comment
Required
Required (will not be published)

This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.

The Boston Globe and Boston.com will keep you updated on the Red Sox all season long.
The Globe's Red Sox team
Meet the Globe's Red Sox team (left to right): Nick Cafardo, Amalie Benjamin, Adam Kilgore and Tony Massarotti

Red Sox Twitter

    Waiting for Twitter.com...
Extra Bases on your blog
An easy-to-install widget to get the list of our latest links on your blog (or your iGoogle page).

E-mail your question

Or if your comment or question is non-specific to a particular reporter, enter it in the form below:
Name:
E-mail:
Your question/comment:
archives

browse this blog

by category