Red Sox disappointed with Matsuzaka's criticism of training program
Less than a week after a meeting between the two sides, there's a war of words playing out publicly between the Red Sox and Daisuke Matsuzaka over whether the team's training regimen is responsible for the pitcher's struggles this season.
"If I'm forced to continue to train in this environment, I may no longer be able to pitch like I did in Japan," Matsuzaka is quoted as saying in the article, according to WEEI.com's translation. "The only reason why I managed to win games during the first and second years [in the United States] was because I used the savings of the shoulder I built up in Japan. Since I came to the Major Leagues, I couldn't train in my own way, so now I've lost all those savings."
Red Sox pitching coach John Farrell, in an interview on Boston sports radio station WEEI this afternoon (listen to it here, partial transcript here), defended the team's approach, saying the adjustment in Matsuzaka's regimen was in response to the fatigue that Matsuzaka -- currently on the disabled list with a mild shoulder strain -- experienced adjusting to the majors.
"We have the utmost respect for the baseball norms and cultures that the Japanese baseball league has," Farrell said. "We not only respect them but we acknowledged them at the time of signing Daisuke. When he came over, no changes were recommended. No changes were mandated by any means. The adjustments in throwing have been in response to the challenges that Daisuke's faced here. ...
"We know that there was a pretty substantial amount of fatigue in the second half of '07 that we had to give him a breather at the time, largely in part because of the differences in travel, differences in competition, differences in strike zone, a number of the on-field challenges that he faced. So any of the adjustments that we've encountered have been in response to how he's adapted to the rigors of the schedule and the competition here."
Farrell further defended the Red Sox program, saying it was the best way to protect their investment in Matsuzaka.
"We've got a $103 million investment in a guy that we've got to not only protect, but put him in a best situation to have that success we just outlined," Farrell said.
Matsuzaka has made eight starts in 2009 with a 1-5 record and 8.23 ERA, a horrid stat line that most blame on the effects of pitching for the Japanese team in the World Baseball Classic before the season.
While making sure not to direct the full blame for Matsuzaka's woes at the WBC, Farrell today did say the team was concerned that the pitcher would be spending his spring not under the direction of the Red Sox but rather with Team Japan.
In perhaps his strongest statement, Farrell also questioned whether Matsuzaka put in the offseason work that was necessary to both prepare him for the rigors of a major league season.
"In hindsight, there might not have been the work that he needed to put in on his own time during the offseason to build the foundation that every pitcher requires to withstand the workloads that a major league starting pitcher is going to go through here in the States," Farrell said.
According to one Japanese reporter covering Matsuzaka, the pitcher explained his dissatisfaction to the Red Sox during a 90-minute meeting with manager Terry Francona, general manager Theo Epstein, and Farrell at Fenway Park on July 24.
"We had made huge strides [in communicating] during our meetings," Francona said before tonight's Red Sox-Athletics game. "So to hear him say that -- to have him air it out publicly -- I'm disappointed."
Francona said that he had talked to Matsuzaka within the last two days and thought he and the pitcher had an agreement to follow the team's regimen. Matsuzaka's statements, made after the July 24 meeting, imply that he wants to be able to work his shoulder back into shape on his own training schedule.
"If [Red Sox owner John Henry] came down and asked, 'What's going on?' and we said, 'We're letting [Daisuke] do it his own way,' he probably wouldn't like that very much," said Francona.
"I know there's frustration, but it's unfortunate for [Matsuzaka] to say that," Francona said. "I thought everybody was on board with what we were doing."
Matsuzaka has recently been unhappy that the Red Sox are not allowing him to throw as often as he would like. When Matsuzaka first reported to Florida earlier this month to rehabilitate his shoulder after being put on the disabled list for the second time this season, he was throwing (not pitching off of a mound) for two days, then resting his arm on the third day, according to a Japanese reporter. Now, Matsuzaka is limited to throwing for one day (again, not from a mound) and resting the next day. So instead of throwing two of every three days, he is now throwing one of every two.
Matsuzaka has been additionally frustrated by the fact that the Red Sox do not have a timetable for his return to the rotation, according to the reporter. Farrell said this afternoon that the Sox hoping for a September return for Matsuzaka, and explained why the Red Sox did not outline any specifics.
"The thing that we have not done is put a target date as a marker in the near future to say this is the game that we're hoping you're back in Boston for, and being attached to the calendar," Farrell said on WEEI. "Sometimes it causes the pitcher or the player to neglect how his body's feeling and what his body is telling him. So in a sense, we're not letting Daisuke completely direct this, but he is certainly included in our planning and the progression of the throwing going forward."
After the 90-minute meeting at Fenway last week, Francona said Matsuzaka would continue to rehab in Fort Myers, Fla. and be examined by team doctors when the Red Sox are in Tampa Aug. 4-5. Francona gave no indication when Matsuzaka might begin throwing off a mound again.
"He looks great. It's obvious he's worked hard,'' Francona said at the time. "What we kind of arrived at is that rather than have a target date for a return -- I think that's what we've done in the past -- we're going to keep it to short goals.''
Francona indicated that Matsuzaka "looks a lot stronger'' and said the pitcher's shoulder strength had "vastly'' improved based on the team's testing methods.
In the Allatanys article, which was written by Taeko Yoshii, who has also penned at least two Matsuzaka-related books, Matsuzaka said he thinks the difference in training methods between the United States in Japan is the reason why Japanese pitchers tend to have a couple of good seasons before seeing a dropoff in performance.
"I know that there are Japanese starters who came to the United States before me only have two or three successful years," Matsuzka said, according to the Globe's translation. "I now believe that it is because of a difference in training and conditioning methods.
"If I don't act, people in the Major League Baseball will never change their attitude toward it. I need them to understand this. It is more than just about myself but future Japanese pitchers who come over to the United States."
The Globe's Daigo Fujiwara, Steve Silva, and Ben Collins contributed to this report. Background information from the Globe's Tony Massarotti was also used. Report last updated at 5:17 p.m.


This will go over well.
IF he cant handle US baseball mayve he should return his salary and go back to Japan
How can this idiot complain about the Red Sox throwing program when he sucked the moment he returned from the WBC? The madness never ends!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I want my 101 million back.....
Wow, DiceK, sounds like a trip back to Japan sounds great.
100 Million total for this clown? Bye bye. If he pitched for the Sox the way he pitched in the WBC, he'd be great. I"m pretty sure your "shoulder savings" didn't cause you to nibble around the plate all game, against the best hitters in the world. Then he blames it on the Sox training program. JOKKKKKKKKKE.
Time to send Lice K somewhere else...
Dead to me.
Wow, it must be the throwing program Dice-K. Its obvious by the struggles of the rest of the pitchers and all the injuries they've developed. Oh wait, its just you. Dice-K seems very stubborn and unwilling to change anything for the team thats paying him millions. If he thinks the Japanese way, and screwing himself up while pitching for Japan in the WBC, are so much better maybe he should never have come over here. Buy yourself out of your contract and get lost. And take Smoltz with you.
What a self-serving face saving move. Dice K the first season you struggled with your command, the second season you struggled with your command, the third season your arm gave out. You know what a bad carpenter does? Blames his tools.
As a former pitcher myself, I will say that "Dice-K" is right on. Today, many great pitchers are driven into a sort of atrophy with the "wussy" type of babying that their trainers think is getting the job done. First off, this "Pitch Count Curse" needs to be gotten rid of. Remember when starters finished most of the games that they started? They kept pitching as long as they were effective. How many games have the Red Sox, and other teams blown after removing the starter who was still going strong after 100 pitches, only to have the bull pen take over and lose the game? Just look at Boston this year. For example, look at the great game Smoltz had going when they took him out and the bull pen were like a bunch of little leaguers
r u serious?
Matsuzaka complaining about a throwing program is ridiculous! His power has always been consistent! It has been his location and unwillingness to challenge batters when he needs to that has been a problem! Walking batters and leaving it over the middle of the plate are his biggest problems this year! That doesn't speak of arm strength as much as mind strength and stubbornness!
This is why MLB's guaranteed contracts are a joke. You cant cut fools like this loose without being on the hook.
I think they should let him do whatever he wants. The Red Sox program clearly is not working and the guy clearly can be a dominant pitcher. Why not let him try it his way?
How can you argue with him. He may be onto something. If given his own free reign to train his way, how much worse can he pitch? He made an interesting point about changing attitudes. He must make a push to have the opportunity to prove he is right. Thus making him a pioneer in pitcher's training and conditioning programs. I think it may be time for Theo, Tito, and John Farrell to give him a listen.
Dice K has a point. If he's used to a particular training program, then he should train the same way he did in Japan. What's so difficult about that? People study differently for tests: some study before going to bed, some sleep right away and wake up earlier to study, etc. If the front office tries out his training regimen and he still sucks after, then maybe he should go back to Japan and return his salary.
Honestly, the dude can't be any worse than he has already been, so let him use his Japanese training methods and see where that goes.
That said, there was obviously a miss between the two sides when he was signed. He should have known before he signed the deal that the Red Sox would be the governing party. If someone invests that kinda money in you, they should be able to tell you when to eat, drink, sleep, and throw. But now that we're past that, let him go to town using his own devices and see if he improves.
I too think he should return his salary and return to Japan. He is of no benefit to the Red Sox anyway.
The salary isn't the issue. The $50 million fee they paid the team in Japan for his contract rights is the problem. His salary is less than what Lugo was making.
The salary isn't the issue. The $50 million fee they paid the team in Japan for his contract rights is the problem. His salary is less than what Lugo was making.
He's complaining because the Sox regimen includes throwing over the plate.
"I know that there are Japanese starters who came to the United States before me only have two or three successful years,” Matsuzka said, according to the Globe’s translation. “I now believe that it is because of a difference in training and conditioning methods.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Not for nothing, but maybe he is right? It is certainly not out of the question that the training method here wouldnt work for someone that comes from another culture.
Just my two cents.
If and when Daisuke cares half as much about pitching for the Boston Red Sox as he does pitching for Japan in the WBC, then - and only then - will he be a successful major league pitcher.
I didn't realize that Matsuzaka was this immature. He needs to take responsibility for his troubles this year. They are a result of him overthrowing for the WBC. He needs to learn humility, and he needs to have respect for his employer, the fans, and the game. He's making a lot of money- and he hasn't produced. As frustrated as he is, Boston fans are even more frustrated with Daisuke the Nibbler.
OMG he is an overpaid cry baby...he "used up his savings"...excuse me, WTF does that mean...did he use up any of it in the WBC...send him back and sue him for the money he stole from us...enough of these cry babies who make tons of money
If he's willing to blowout his own arm, why don't the Red Sox let him? I would think that he is doing it against their advice would protect them from lawsuits and what the hell, the team is wasting $8 million a year on him now already. Maybe it will work?
Wasn't the school of thought prior to this season that Dice-K did NOT stick to his prescribed training program this off-season? The WBC clearly accelerated his program to his detriment.
On the other hand, if says he's ready to go, why not throw him in a few Pawtucket games and see if he's got command of his pitches again. There's no hiding whether or not you can hit your spots. Either you do it consistently or you end up with an ERA over 8...
When I'm frustration I usually put on one of those movies and make sure I have fresh D batteries
I say we let him train the way he wants and in return, his contract is no longer guaranteed and specific "release" triggers are defined - I wonder what Boras would think of that?
I heard El Tiante comment one time that the reason these guys only throw 100 pitches in a game now, as opposed to the amount they threw when he was pitching, is because they just don't allow them to throw that much anymore. He said the only way to be able to throw 140 pitches in a game is to actually do it a bunch of times and build up the strength to do it. I've always said that was Dice-Ks game, throw a LOT of pitches, nibble nibble nibble, never give you anything to hit, and get you to swing at something you don't want to swing at. But you can't really do that in 100 pitches because you'll only get to the 4th inning. Let him throw!
Dice-K is right about not being successful in the Bigs...but it 's not because of the Sox' training program. It's because he can't pitch against Big League hitters. Just look at the WBC...he was lights out against the teams that were mostly non-MLB. When he faced teams with Big League hitters, he pitched like we see him in Fenway: LOUSY. They still gave him the MVP, but he didn't deserve it. He didn't win 18 games last year. The bullpen did. Trade him...trade him to a National League team where there is a pitcher hitting against him, and he can be #9 in the line-up. The silver lining in this is that we have Oki; fun to watch, and great results
That primadonna china doll better get with the program or he can forget about a pleasant working environment here in Boston. There are a multitude of factors which could have resulted in his performance decline. The greatest of which was his burnout as a result of the joke that is the WBC. Blaming it on Boston's pitching trainers is a real sleazy thing to do.
Add Dice K to the Julio Lugo bad signings by Theo list. Send him back to Japan if he thinks its better.
Hey Dice K , URUSAI
The situation looks pretty cut and dried. If his performance isn't going to improve with methods used in this country, then he will continue to be a liability to the team. Let him train his own way. Can't get any worse. At least his failure will then be on him, not us.
Not necessarily agreeing with him, but there always is the possibility that he is right!!??!!??
Excuses are like A-holes... everybody's got one...
I have a terrific solution for the Sox. Negotiate a new contract with Dicek which would create a deal to let him train and participate in Japan again. He is obviously unhappy in the US. Another alternative would be to trade him to a National League team. This guy is a big bust:; get rid of him.
yikes...ditto tinisoli. this will not go over well
I'm glad he's finally standing up for himself. If anyone has read up anything on his success in Japan you'll know that he pitches better on short rest and longer innings (ie. not every 5 days and more CG.) So what if he goes 100 pitches through 5 or 6? Keep him in there, he's more than proven in his career he can throw 130+ no problem. The Red Sox just need to back off a bit and let him do his thing. Yes, from a business standpoint its the organization's investment, but you can mingle too much with someone's routine. I don't see them messing with Beckett's "I need to pitch every 5 days" motto.
I say let the man train the way he wants. Different strokes for different folks.
Dice-K battles, he's a fighter and he drives. I think he'd prefer to power through the situation than preserve his arm.
Someone needs to explain to him what happened to Bobby Orr's knee when his love for his country and his stoic toughness made him ignore the severe pain when he was playing in an international hockey tournament. He really hurt his knee and was never the same.
In Boston we love the toughness, but it is a marathon not a sprint. I do, however think that the organization should be open to the idea that his regime may bear fruit for him and perhaps they could work with him to some degree. I'd rather have a Dice-K than someone who was a big wimp.
He's completely right. There was nothing wrong with the way he was training. You can see that by looking at his production in Japan.
Jozee, perhaps the reason he pitched so well in the WBC is because he went back to his old training regimen while he was with the Japan team.
I think the Sox should let him train the way he was used to training... their regimen obviously isn't a good fit for him.
Thanks, W.B.C.
1.I say we let him train the way he wants and in return, his contract is no longer guaranteed and specific "release" triggers are defined - I wonder what Boras would think of that?
The MLB Union would NEVER EVER permit that. Recall they wouldn't even let ARod restructure his then contract with Texas to back end payments.
Do we miss Julio Lugo already, or what?
Listen to you people talk about the money. Like any of it came out of your pocket. If you train a pitcher to throw every 4 days that is what he will grow accustomed to. This is what he was doing in Japan and it worked out well for him.
All this aside, WhenTF do we stop referring to him as "Dice-K"? I think we can all pronounce "Daiuske" by now... years of that bastardized nickname have at least given us that.
Let him train the way he wants to and hope he doesn't flame out. The Sox can't continue to do it their way since Dice K isn't on board. It's probably a dead loss at this point, and whether Mr. Matzusaka is correct or not his public pronouncements
reflect badly on him.
Hmmmm. Wasn't Ichiro making some similar criticisms of the way that the Sox handled Dice K recently?
Seems like the Sox regiment has worked pretty well for Okijima, granted he's a reliever.
Someone should tell Dice K that the reason the Sox don't wan't him on his own program is because they don't want him to plan on throwing 200 pitches per outing. His starts are plenty long enough already, and we can't play 8 hour games every 5 days.
I hear Nolan Ryan and Texas will let you throw till your arm falls off --
How about a trade ?
Maybe for Hank Blalock and Salty ?
If you trained Japanese style all winter and came from the WBC ready to go,, how did it hurt you to ease off for last 3 weeks of spring training ?
Yes maybe Scott will allow a renegotiation ?
Let him do what he wants. Just draw up an addendum to his contract that if he blows out his shoulder or can't get his ERA under 5.00 that his contract can be voided with no liability for the Red Sox.
Wambo, pitching in little league does not qualify you as an expert. The Sox bullpen is one of , if not the best in the league. There is too much money at stake for teams to let pitchers throw their arms out in 2 or 3 years. When you invest over 100 million on a guy like Sabathia GUARANTEED then you better make damn sure he is going to last. Look at the kid Stasburg who just got drafted by the Nationals. He is going to command a 50 miilion dollar signing bonus!! No team is going to let a guy throw 150 pitches anymore.
I do kind of agree with Dice and other posters on this board. Let me start by saying I'm not a Dice-K supporter in the least, but this is a very valid point. The guy learned how to pitch his way. He learned how to train his way. He was effective his way. Yes he nibbles at the plate and blah blah which leads to a high pitch count but he can handle it! Scenarios similar to this often present themselves in international business. A french conglomerate buys a Japanese company and forces the French way of business into the company and replaces the top Japanese executives with ex-pats. The company fails because the french culture doesn't translate to the japanese. Same thing with Dice.
The only shortcoming in Dice's analysis is that he pitched in a six man rotation in Japan. That allowed for the high pitch count and heavy throwing. Clearly that is not the case over here. An above poster stated it best: Let him do it. He can't get any worse...
As a Yankee Fan this makes me smile :)
I agree with those who say "let him do it his way, how much worse could he get?" I'm sure there is no medical, scientific evidence to support his theory, but 90% of this game is half mental. If he believes it enough, maybe he will pitch better?
Enough is enough with this guy. By the time Dice-K's ready to come back we'll have Junichi Tazawa, who's tearing it up in the minors, ready to make his major league debut with his 3.3 million dollar contract.
Maybe the reason Japanese pitchers only have 2 or 3 good years in the US is that they threw their arms out in Japan before they got here? Ever think of that, Daisuke?
Check who signs your paycheck, pal, and shut your mouth.
There's a lot of baseball experts on here today. Oh I mean, so many crybabies on the boards today. I love the lines that have been written so far. "Send him back to Japan, take back his salary, screw him, blah blah blah". The guy knows his body better than the staff, better than you, better than me, and better than anyone else here.
Let him switch to his preferred training method. See what happens. It can't be any worse than what's going on now currently?
Hello! Look at his stats. Do you want him to continue doing the same thing or try to change it up and make a positive change? Currently, the training schedule he's on has not been effective.
Maybe if Daisuke was something special his first year, I'd buy his excuse. Trade him for a bag of balls.
Dice K, Smoltz, Penny... maybe the Sox need a new pitching coach. No one seems to be listening to this guy anyway. Whoever said that this was a face saving commentary by Dice K is right on the money. The Japanese press is covering HIS REHAB for Pete's sake. He's got to explain why he has another month before he sees the Bigs again. If then!!!
I think it's time Dice-K took a little responsibility and stop blaming the Sox. He has never appeared to be in great shape and obviously the shoulder program has worked for others... Penny, Papelbon, Beckett and Lester. Even his first year here when he had done his own conditioning he struggled with his command and has never pitched deep into games!!
And I thought we were over this kind of garbage.
Dice-K being Dice-K...
Many of you are truly stuck in one way of thinking -- and most of you have never even played baseball. If this guy and his arm are used to thier own regimen, then he may very well be onto something. Just because US coaches have a certain method engrained in your head -- that doesn't mean it's correct. These guys have screwed up as many arms as they've protected. Everyone is different --- guess how often Tim Lincecum ices his arm? Try NEVER -- he doesn't believe in icing?! Works for him....
Ah, Boras - how long before he throws his two cents in here. I agree with the person that said pitch him in a couple of games at Pawtucket or Portland and see what he has - in a few weeks. How would he look in Yankee pinstrips if his relationship with the Red Sox (and their Nation as I sence from the above blogs) hits rock bottom. It will be soon that they will cut ties if he makes these feelings readily known to american audiences.
He's just not that good. His 18 wins last year were a high-wire act. It's only because the team scored runs behind him. How many does he walk in a game? How bad is his control? How much English has he taken the time to learn?
I say send him back, like a smelly piece of three day-old sushi.
i wonder if Boras was behind this outburst and whining?
Man, after moving away from the Northeast and coming back, it's really wierd how much Red Sox fans complain. Everyone complains about dice k, everyone complains about smoltz, ortiz, drew blah blah blah blah blah. The Red Sox are exciting and GOOD, baseball is a game of patience. Can you people be patient, and stop ripping dice k. It's amazing how quickly people turn on Red Sox players. And like 90% of public really doesn't know WHAT they are talking about, yet everyone thinks they are a know it all.
I am curious as to why many people, likely many on this board, talk about how pitchers of yore used to throw WAY more often, throw way more pitches (no pitch counts, three inning saves, etc.), yet had FEWER arm problems, more complete games, longer careers, and generally heathier arms. And yet when we get a guy who feels that his old way of training, IE throwing a lot and keeping the strength up, the way the likes of Bob Gibson et al used to do before the era of pampering pitchers began, that we claim he should go home and give his money back?! I think MORE pitchers should follow Dice-K's old program of developing and maintaining strength in their arm, as opposed to babying it and leading to injury, as we have seen so much more often in the modern era of micro-managing pitchers.
If you want a steer to pull a plow, you don't feed it beer and baby it like it's producing kobe beef - you make it work and build its strength. Same with pitchers - a frequently used arm, as we saw all through basebal history up unitl the LaRussa era, is a strong arm, is a healthy arm. Why take a pitcher who obviously has success with that program (2 lights-out WBCs) and change it to make it fit the current trend it pitcher management? Make more young pitchers throw more and let him do his thing. Otherwise you are all but ensuring failure. Ask Ichiro about how much success one can have with a "weird, Japanese approach" to the game.
The dude kind of sucks, but why not let him train his way. What do we got to loose.
We should've let the yankees pay him, he fits in perfectly for them, over payed crap with stupid issues
5 innings, 100 pitches and a burned bullpen pretty much every time out and he wants to complain? Before he complains about the Sox program, maybe he should think about throwing 100 pitches in the WBC in March when other MLB pitchers were throwing far fewer pitches in spring training.
Let's just hold off on our opinions until Curt Schilling touches on this. It's only a matter of minutes. He'll know what to do
THIS GUY IS CRAZY WHEN THESE GUYS START A SEASON THERE NOT QUITE UP TO SPEED AND FURTHER MORE TO BE IN PLAYOFF SHAPE HITTERS AS WELL A LOT ARENT READY NOW FOR THE PLAYOFFS THESE GUYS GO INTO THE WORLD HULLA BALLOU BARELY IN SHAPE SOX METHODS WHAT ABOUT HIS METHODS THIS GUYS EGO IS MORE IMPORTANT TO HIS JAP FANS THAN THE LEAGUE HE IS PAYED FOR TEAMS SHOULD BAN THESE CLOWNS FROM PLAYING IN THIS THING
I thought the recent report that Daisuke met with Francona for ninety-minutes before the game very curious.
It occurred to me then that, even setting aside time for translation, it was obvious they were not simply shooting the breeze.
"let him blow out his arm if he wants to". Really? Only if he's willing to sign a waiver indicating that if he does so, the Sox (i.e. fans) don't have to pay him. Include in the waiver that if his results do not improve significantly, he will quit the team without financial consequence. In other words, "put your money where your mouth is Dice K"! If you're as good as you think you are, you'll come out ahead in the end, right?
I love how it's the Red Sox's fault now that he's not where he should be. Nevermind his stint in the WBC to where he most likely pitched his heart out like it was our playoffs. Coming right off of that to the beginning of our season is most likely what threw him off. In this situation, the Red Sox are trying to protect his arm so he can be utilized towards the end of the season. I don't see what's so hard to understand. I love people who complain about getting MILLIONS of dollars for doing even less work than is expected of them....
Maybe he's right. If he's wrong then forcing him to train in a way he disagrees with won't work either. They need to let him do what he wants.
Let the baby have his way. If the sox try to stuff it down his throat he'll be no good to them anyway, it's the only solution.
Would the Sox tell one of their sluggers to lay off the weights? I say let the guy work out the way he wants to work out. The guy's been pitching his whole life, if he thinks that throwing more between starts will help, there's a good chance that he's right.
I wouldn't call this whining - he's saying that he wants to do more work in order to be prepared to do his job. The team is telling him to do less work.
I can understand eveyone's frustration with this idiot, but as of now he has it in his head that this is the reason that he sucks.
All professional baseball players have routines that they don't mess with.
Right now it is obvious that the Sox will get nothing from him until he feels he is training his way.
So let him do it and see what happens. If he still sucks then he can't say anything
I personally do not think that the Japanese players are very good, esp pichers
I can understand eveyone's frustration with this idiot, but as of now he has it in his head that this is the reason that he sucks.
All professional baseball players have routines that they don't mess with.
Right now it is obvious that the Sox will get nothing from him until he feels he is training his way.
So let him do it and see what happens. If he still sucks then he can't say anything
I personally do not think that the Japanese players are very good, esp pichers
Dice-k,
Maybe you pitched so great in Japan because you were facing sub-par hitters. Ever think of that? Matsui was a homerun-hitting god in Japan, but in the big leagues he is just a decent hitter. I have no doubt that you can dominate hitters in Pawtucket the way you did in Japan. Shut up and stop nibbling the corners of the strike zone.
I can understand eveyone's frustration with this idiot, but as of now he has it in his head that this is the reason that he sucks.
All professional baseball players have routines that they don't mess with.
Right now it is obvious that the Sox will get nothing from him until he feels he is training his way.
So let him do it and see what happens. If he still sucks then he can't say anything
I personally do not think that the Japanese players are very good, esp pichers
He seems to do well against batters that don't know him, and when he only has to perform for a short period of time (read WBC). Tell him the WBC got moved to September and October and the Sox are representing Japan. Let him train his way, gear himself up for the Fall, and hopefully he'll pitch like its March. Then shut him down for 6 months until its time to do it again.
Where is all this give your salary back crap coming from? Would you ask JD Drew for his $14M inapt bat? Or $12.5 for Lowell whose always on the DL? Dice K is making $8.3 and you need to stop factoring in the buyout portion because that money never went to him.
All we know the there could be lost in translation and/or taken out of context.
Just like Boston fans, always looking to find a scapegoat.
Daisuke!
Only 5 year olds need 'Dice-K' to achieve the proper pronunciation.
i'd have him sign a form that says this: I can train anyway i want to. if i do not perform better after that training period, i will allow the Sox to pull out of the original contract with no money owed to me.
what do they have to lose?
Number 57.. good comment..thats why I don't buy it either..plus he has looked like a tubby since being here..
Two thoughts:
Is it possible that the japanese leagues are just subpar to the Majors? Nomo fizzled. No japanese starters have come over and enjoyed consistent success in the majors. In the minor leagues, in college, in Japan, you can get away with bad pitches or just throwing fastballs. In the majors this doesn't work, therefore he struggles to find the strike zone.
Also, I think he has a little JD Drew in him. Pitches when he wants to. It baffles me when scouts drool over Japanese players (esp pitchers) and try to transfer their game to the pros. It almost never works out.
Dice was throwing 90-100 pitches and going 5 innings if he was not nibbling around the edges after getting batters 0-2 those 100 pitches might have gotten him to 7 inning and then they'd let him try and throw 120 for 9....
Watching this guy pitch on TV is like watching the paint dry on "Sell this House".
If they let him throw 120-130 pitches they'd hit midnight every time he pitches..
Hey wait that's extra beer sales... ownership might not mind that.
PS: This is the guy who recently revealed that he (apparently) believes there are physiological differences between the Japanese shoulder and the (American? European?) shoulder, so take whatever he says about his own training regimen with a grain of salt.
Hooray for malcontents.
bring him back, let him get a few wins under his belt (if possible) and trade him to the Dodgers in the offseason....
Did Daisuke ever consider the possibility that his lack of success here vs. Japan is due to the fact that in MLB he faces 9 professional hitters in every line-up. This isn't Japan where he faces two good hitters and 7 college kids.
i like the yankees fan chiming in. how did it work out with the guy from Japan that new york posted for, that same year? 20 or 30 million for a guy that i can't remember the name of. he had some sweet glasses, though. looked really good in triple A.
and i've been thinking for a while that it may not have been the best idea to radically change the training model of someone who had been doing things a certain way for 20 years, and had been successful. japan has a drastically different approach to things, i think, and it seems fairly narrow-minded to force a new system on someone, unless there had been issues resulting from the way they had been working. it could be like the bolted chair in the galaxy transport in Contact - trying to apply incongruant elements out of cultural bias.
Guess What? The Great Nolon Ryan HOFer agrees with Dice-K. I read where Nolon Ryan has said the exact same thing. Ryan has got all the pitchers in Texas and their AAA team strengthening their arms so that they can pitch a full 9 innings.
Like He used to do. Check Wambo's comment number 9 above. For all I know that is Nolon Ryan himself talking because that is exactly what Ryan has been preaching for years now. That's good enough for me. Let Dice-K do his own thing because he can't make things any worse. Can he?
Wow, a foreign player questions the difference in training methods and people act like he slept with their little sister. Bucholz has trouble after the Sox change his pitching mechanics, and everybody blames the Red Sox. Dice-K has trouble when the Red Sox change his training and it's Dice-K's fault. Hmmmm.
Dice-K was the best pitcher in Japan. Why wouldn't he want to continue to use the same methods of training here in the US that helped be the best pitcher in Japan? If he suceeds in the US, then it's on him. if he fails in the US, then it's on him. Wouldn't he want to suceed or fail on his own terms? Dice-K isn't a rookie right out of high school. He knows how to be successful. Dice-K is blaming his injury on the Red Sox. He's never had this problem in the past. If the only thing that is different is his training methods, then why wouldn't he think the training method caused the injury.
There's an old saying - if it aint broke, don't fix it.
Dice K should keep his trap shut, and take responsibility for his situation. He pitched way too much in the World Classic last spring, and that my friends is the problem here.
is he serious?... he calls his numbers a success?...wow.. well hes the only 18 game I have ever seen who averages 5 innings a start.. I think Dice K should be giving half his paycheck to the bullpen for saving him about 10 of those 18 wins last year.
Let him train the Japanese way and let the results speak for themselves. Anything would be an improvement over his performance to date.
Seems pretty simple. Dice K wants to build his arm and shoulder strength the old fashion way. By throwing a lot. Nolan Ryan is trying this in Texas with his staff. May not be a bad idea. I say let him throw.
The smart thing would be to let him train the way that works for him.
Japanese culture IS one of personal responsibility, rather than finger pointing. Japanese people do not like to make waves.
Those of you who think he's passing the buck (or yen) are wrong.
I can understand eveyone's frustration with this idiot, but as of now he has it in his head that this is the reason that he sucks.
All professional baseball players have routines that they don't mess with.
Right now it is obvious that the Sox will get nothing from him until he feels he is training his way.
So let him do it and see what happens. If he still sucks then he can't say anything
I personally do not think that the Japanese players are very good, esp pichers
Let him go back to his old training regimen which he is comfortable with. He may have a point as other pitchers from Japan fizzed out after their second to third year like Hideo Nomo, Hideki Irabu and Kazuhiro Sasaki to name a few. His salary is not the issue as he gets paid less than some Bosox players, i.e. Julio Lugo and J.D. Drew. We've won a championship with him is the past and he's won many games us. We need him to come back and win games here.
The WBC was important to him and his country since it represented something more than it does to many American players.
This is another example of the Theo trying to prove he's smarter than everyone else. Why not let Dice-K go back to doing what actually worked for him? Theo Epstein is an overrated joke. The guy's made more terrible moves than you can shake a stick at. The straw that broke the camel's back for me was when he blew off the troops at Walter Reed Medical Center. The Ivy league elitist couldn't bear the thought of meeting President Bush, so he took his ball and went home. They ought to send Theo to Japan with Dice-K.....Good riddance.
I was at Fenway the first game this guy pitched there. He lost control of the game and the Sox lost. Since then, he always seems to be on the edge and struggling, even when he wins. He not only costs $$, but he also costs the bullpen since he needs them for almost half a game each game to come in and cover for his inability to go longer.
He's got to be a man and admit he blew his arm pitching for Japan in the WBC. Just man-up Matsuzaka, or how much more does that cost? To blame it on the Red Sox is ludicrous. The Sox have been nothing but gracious publicly about this train wreck. If the Japanese system is so amazing, wouldn't that be incorporated here? And if so, why is considered such an honor for a Japanese player to come to the MLB and a demotion for an American player to go the Japanese league?
“If I don't act, people in the Major League Baseball will never change their attitude toward it. I need them to understand this. It is more than just about myself but future Japanese pitchers who come over to the United States." Yah, way to make this a political discussion. What a tool. What happened to sportsmanship and accountability? They built you up at home, because that is what salespeople do. Then, they sold you. Turns out, you can't live up to what they built. You have issues, you should go back to those jerks who built your image into something you just aren't.
I'm in the "let him do it his way" camp. But only because he can't suck any worse than continuing to follow the Sox' routine. However, they should add a clause in to his contract that stipulates that if he doesn't improve by "doing it his way" the 50 million $$$ signing fee comes back. And we buy Halladay with it.
Hard to get a timetable on your return when your line is a 1-5 record and 8.23 ERA. Maybe he should come to terms with the fact he pitched himself off the roster and there is no firm date for a reason.
Do agree though that pitchers are pampered with pitch counts, but then I haven't invested millions in their arm. Who cuts the check kinda decides when you pitch, no? His problems started from the get go, so according to his logic, why didn't he start fast after the all additional throwing he did in the off season and the WBC?
How can anyone say he's wrong. He trained a certain way in Japan and that is what made ML Teams (Red Sox) Go after him so strongly. Then he comes here and isnt allowed to do the same thing? Its a mind set thing with him, he thinks he is a better pitcher when he has his regime. Let him go do what hes used and if he fails then try it the sox way. The sox chose to pay him all that money based on what he did in Japan and the way he trained there.
I think he's probably right. Let him get going on his own program and see what happens. If he can't get back to what he was at one time, then that's that.
" I heard El Tiante comment one time that the reason these guys only throw 100 pitches in a game now, as opposed to the amount they threw when he was pitching, is because they just don't allow them to throw that much anymore. He said the only way to be able to throw 140 pitches in a game is to actually do it a bunch of times and build up the strength to do it. I've always said that was Dice-Ks game, throw a LOT of pitches, nibble nibble nibble, never give you anything to hit, and get you to swing at something you don't want to swing at. But you can't really do that in 100 pitches because you'll only get to the 4th inning. Let him throw! ""
This Bears repeating.
HE CANT TRAIN THE SAME BECUASE IT IS A DIFFERENT GAME> IN JAPAN HE PITCHED ONCE EVERY 7 DAYS. HERE IT IS ONCE EVERY 5
WOW! Ignorant comments and morons are abound on this blog today! He's a crybaby, send him back to Japan, trade him for a bag of balls, he can't pitch to major leage hitters...What?? This guy has won the Red Sox 24 games in 2 1/4 seasons and helped win us a World Series. He has pitched in Japan under the same training regimen for most of his professional career and wants to train the same way he used to because he feels he will be more effective. What's wrong with that? I think this guy probably knows a lot more about his own body and how he can pitch better than half of you armchair managers. The Red Sox didn't want him to train the old way in fear that he would develop shoulder strains and tired arm. Since he's changed to the Red Sox regimen, he's had tired arm twice and developed a shoulder strain this year.
In college when we used to warm up throwing before practice, I used to throw harder and longer than anyone else, then the outfielders did a bit of extra throwing, then we did outfield throwing drills. Then I would switch gloves and do infield drills with the infielders throwing more again. I personally threw longer and harder than anyone on the team and had the least amount of arm pain/trouble/fatigue out of anyone on the team for 2 years....You have to throw until your arm gets tired and sore and then throw past that point longer to really strengthen your arm, so I absolutely agree with what Dice K is saying. He had a routine and a program that worked for him and the red sox stopped that and now we are seeing the results of that
there should be stipulations in contracts if a player injures himself during or has an injury as a result of the WBC, they should not be paid for their time on the DL.
And the house came tumbling down. Brick by Brick. Its the curse of Mannywood
Dice-K knows what's best for Dice-K....and that's the bottom line... Let him train how he wants, although the last few years results were from RUN SUPPORT, not built up strength...
To be part of a team you've got to be part of the program the team puts together. But, there also has to be room for some differences. Let him train the way he wants...but make him sign a statement that the Sox won't pay the medical bills or the overtime, or the extra staff work or facilities use. Let him pay for the extras if he wants it (he can do so out of his $$$$$$$$$$$$). Then, play him. If it works, the organization needs to look at, and incorporate, special programs. We can always learn from each other. If he doesn't want to go along, cut the cord now.
Dice-K's training regimen will not work here. Sure he can throw all he wants between starts in Japan, but the Japanese season is 40 games shorter than the MLB season. That's 8 fewer starts in Japan. With fewer starts and a longer offseason, throwing more makes sense. He's just not at all grasping the difference between MLB and Japan.
And for those of you saying "He pitched well in japan, let him go back to that routine," you do realize that the quality of baseball in Japan is about AA level, right? For $101 million, he'd better look good against AA hitting!
Dice-K, In case you have not noticed, only YOU are having this trouble. The American pitchers, the Dominican pitchers, and most importantly, your fellow Japanese pitchers on the Red Sox staff are not having these problems. Just you buddy, just you.
Send him away to the place for untalented whiners- New York.
time to trade up !!!!!!!!
Wow what a stand up guy, standing up for all Japanese pitchers - not. Just another whiner looking for excuses. His speed hasnt been off - his control has - so who is to blame for that?
And no offense to Japan, but maybe the reason Dice-K was "so effective" over there was that their hitters just arent as good as American league hitters. Frankly if they were, there would be a ton of them over here. Same reason he was "so effective" in the WBC - inferior competition. Oh and the author has written 2 Dice-K books - real unbiased opinion....
sdf
And keep in