Nomar Garciaparra, SS

At shortstop, Nomar Garciaparra ran away with the race, collecting 55 percent of the votes, leaving only 15 percent for the runner up, Rico Petrocelli. The beloved No. 5 stands alone in the hearts of Sox fans even after leaving the team in 2004. Other fan faves left off our list: Jackie Gutierrez, Spike Owen, and Glenn Hoffman.
(AP Photo)

