Jan. 21, 2007: Colts 38, Patriots 34
In possibly the best game of the Peyton Mannng/Tom Brady rivalry, the Colts avenged a conference title game loss three years earlier. It remains New England's only loss in eight AFC finals. Manning would go on lead Indy to his only Super Bowl crown. After years of dominance by the Patriots, the Colts finally made it a real rivalry as Laurence Maroney (pictured) and his teammates walked off the field in defeat.